Aristotle and AI: Virtue ethics in modern medicine | Meghan Sullivan, PhD
In recent years, the debate around whether artificial intelligence could ever possess something like a soul has transformed from an eccentric intellectual curiosity into a somewhat pressing conversation with very real stakes. While this stunningly modern concern is being discussed by the powers that be, a much simpler, settled truth is playing out. The people and things that we frequently interact with shape who we become. Soul or no soul, our frequent interactions with AI are changing us. As this uniquely powerful technology becomes increasingly present in hospitals and clinics, the healthcare profession must answer the question: what can be done on either side of the physician-AI interaction to preserve the heart of medicine? Our guest on this episode is Meghan Sullivan, professor of philosophy at Notre Dame. Dr. Sullivan serves as Director of the University-wide Ethics Initiative and is the founding director of Notre Dame’s Institute for Ethics and the Common Good. As a researcher, she is deeply interested in the ways philosophy contributes to the good life. She is the author of two, soon to be three, books, leads a major grant on expanding love-based ethics, and is a leading scholar on Christian thought in AI ethics. Over the course of our conversation, Dr. Sullivan makes the case for why health care professionals should care about virtue ethics, speculates on what Confucius, Socrates, and Aristotle would say to today’s doctors, and explains what it takes to have the “it” factor. We discuss the unfolding frontier of AI in medicine and what might be done to preserve the profession’s values. Finally, Dr. Sullivan reminds us that there are things that humans are good at and good for that AI will never do — the most important of which being loving each other. In this episode, you’ll hear about: 3:10 - Meghan’s journey to philosophy and her current projects 9:55 - What are virtue ethics, and why should healthcare professionals care about them? 31:24 - The value of phronesis, or practical wisdom, in medicine — and how it’s learned. 37:10 - How can AI be used in alignment with the healthcare profession’s values? 50:45 - What is society most at risk of losing as bots come to play a larger role? 56:35 - Dr. Sullivan’s advice for doctors who are struggling or feeling existentially unmoored If you enjoyed this episode, please subscribe, rate, and review our show, available for free on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. If you know of a doctor, patient, or anyone working in health care who would love to explore meaning in medicine with us on the show, feel free to leave a suggestion in the comments or send an email to info@thedoctorsart.com. Copyright The Doctor’s Art Podcast 2026