
Can You Question Your Faith and Still Belong? with Rev. Gerlyn Henry
I came back to church looking for community, ritual and somewhere to put down the weight of the world for an hour each week. I found that. And then I started asking questions. About patriarchy. About whose voices get heard. About being told to love our neighbours as ourselves when so many women have spent a lifetime learning to put themselves last. This week, I’m joined by Rev. Gerlyn Henry, an Anglican priest and the incumbent of Holy Wisdom in Scarborough, in the Diocese of Toronto. We talk about holding on to what feels sacred while being honest about what hurts, what excludes and what needs to change. This is a conversation I had been carrying around for a while. Gerlyn brings curiosity, warmth and a willingness to wrestle with it alongside me. In this episode: • Coming back to faith during grief and major life transitions. • Finding comfort in ritual while questioning the institution around it. • Christian nationalism, power and the distance between belief and practice. • Women in leadership and the expectations that they remain agreeable. • Self-worth, sacrifice and the messages women inherit about goodness. • Gerlyn’s reading of Proverbs 31 as praise rather than another impossible checklist. • Small acts of courage that make a difference for the next generation. • Connecting faith to the world people are living in now. • Making inclusion visible in language, leadership and the stories we tell. • Welcoming uncertainty and making room for women in midlife. You don’t have to land in the same place as either of us. I hope this gives you room to ask your own questions and decide what you want to carry forward. About Gerlyn Rev. Gerlyn Henry is an Anglican priest and content creator who leads the Church of the Holy Wisdom in Scarborough, in the Diocese of Toronto. Her ministry reaches from the local parish into online conversations about faith, justice and solidarity. She also serves as an anti-racism facilitator and co-chairs the diocese’s Right Relations committee. In this episode, she joins Lisa for an honest conversation about women’s voices, self-worth and belonging without leaving your questions at the door. Connect with Gerlyn Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/gerlynhenry/ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@gerlynhenry Instagram was supplied directly by Lisa on November 12. YouTube is independently corroborated. No guest freebie, discount or promotion commitment has been verified. Chapters: 00:00 Cold open: When doubt is welcome 01:00 Faith, belonging and the questions we bring 02:28 Returning to church in midlife 04:21 Community, power and accountability 06:54 Spirituality and the institution 09:07 Women’s voices in the church 11:35 Gerlyn’s path to priesthood 12:48 Women in authority and the expectations they face 14:50 Love your neighbour, and yourself 15:36 Reconsidering the “ideal wife” 17:46 The invisible checklist women carry 18:47 Small acts of courage and the next generation 22:38 Everyday change within established systems 24:11 Connecting with younger people 27:01 Faith in conversation with the world 30:08 Making room for questions 30:35 Language, lament and self-worth 32:08 Whose stories and faces fill the room? 35:12 Mary, agency and the Magnificat 36:23 Coming back with uncertainty 38:30 A community that welcomes questions 39:12 Closing reflections Connect with Lisa Liberated Menopause: https://www.liberatedmenopause.ca/ Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/lboate/ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCxndjyhM-281dpSspch4kbg Follow Transforming 45 wherever you listen. If someone came to mind while you listened, send this conversation their way. Content note: discussion of sexism, religious exclusion and sexual violence, without graphic detail. The conversation reflects personal experiences and theological perspectives; listeners are welcome to make different choices about faith and community. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices


















