
When Training Isn't the Problem and the Plan Is — A Rider Roundtable with Karen Rohlf, Brendan Wise, and Tik Maynard
When Training Isn't the Problem and the Plan Is You start with a plan. Maybe it's the hunters, jumpers, dressage, eventing. You buy a horse with that picture in mind. Then you get into the work, and something feels off. The horse isn't taking to it the way you expected. Or you start questioning whether the path you chose even suits them. This conversation gets into those moments. Tik Maynard, Karen Rohlf, and Brendan Wise talk about what it looks like when a horse pushes you to rethink your direction. Tik brings a lens rooted in how horses learn and how small changes in timing and pressure change the outcome. Karen focuses on how the horse feels in the work and how that affects willingness. Brendan comes from the performance world, where communication has to hold up under pressure. Together, they talk through the kinds of decisions riders face all the time. Keeping a horse and changing your expectations, or selling and starting again. Sticking with a discipline, or trying something new because the horse in front of you is asking for it. This is less about finding the right system and more about recognizing when the one you chose isn't lining up with the horse you have. In This Episode: What to look at when your horse isn't progressing the way you expected How to decide if it's a training issue or a direction issue The thought process behind selling a horse versus changing your plan How trying another discipline can reveal what your horse needs Why the horse in front of you often tells you more than the plan you started with Guests: Tik Maynard – International event rider, clinician, and author of In the Middle Are the Horsemen. Known for blending learning theory with practical horsemanship, Tik brings a thoughtful, analytical approach to how horses learn and how riders can improve timing and communication. To find out more about TIk - Website | Instagram | Facebook Karen Rohlf – Author, founder of Dressage Naturally, and a leading voice in horse-centered training. Karen combines classical dressage with an emphasis on the horse's emotional experience, helping riders create willing, motivated partners. To find out more about Karen - Website | Instagram | Facebook Brendan Wise – Trainer and clinician known for his focus on feel, communication, and developing horses for high-level performance. His work often challenges traditional reliance on equipment, showing what is possible through refined aids and understanding. To find out more about Brendan - Website | Instagram | Facebook Key Takeaway When a horse isn't lining up with the plan, the answer may be in the direction, not just the training. Episode Sponsor: Flex Hoof Boots - https://flexhoofboots.com Every horse deserves to move the way nature intended. Flex Hoof Boots are manufactured in Finland, where every boot is designed and tested through frozen winters, hard summer ground, and everything in between. Each Flex Boot is built around two patented features: an air-cushioned sole that absorbs impact and supports a natural heel-first landing, and a reinforced toe callus that guides the hoof through a smooth, correct breakover. The flexible material preserves proprioception - the horse's natural ability to feel and respond to the ground - so every movement is balanced, confident, and natural. With 33 sizes covering everything from miniature horses and foals to full-sized horses, there's a Flex boot built for your horse. And with the new FlexMini Ahti: engineered from the ground up for the biomechanics of miniature horses and foals, no horse is too small to move at their best. Flex Boots. Proving every day that healthy, barefoot horses are possible anywhere in the world














