
Episode 47: $100 Million. No Playbook: Brendan Cawley on Building Righteous Felon, His Way
What happens when a middle-school jerky hustle, a Kmart dehydrator, a few hundred bucks from friends and family, and a suspicious-looking baggie turn into a brand crossing $100 million in retail sales? You get Righteous Felon. In this episode of SHeCOMMERCE, Cristina and Jacqui sit down with Brendan Cawley, Founder & CEO of Righteous Felon, for a founder story that is equal parts accidental, audacious, scrappy—and refreshingly devoid of the usual startup theater. There was no giant funding round. No polished 50-page business plan. No army of employees. And definitely no traditional playbook. Instead, Brendan and a tight crew of childhood friends and family figured it out as they went—selling at farmers markets and beer festivals, hunting down manufacturers willing to take a chance on them, obsessing over flavor and storytelling, and turning a middle-school inside joke into one of the most distinctive brands in meat snacks. And then things got big. Really big. Today, Righteous Felon has crossed the $100 million retail sales mark while staying lean, founder-led, deeply personal and unapologetically weird. But this conversation isn't just about the number. It's about what happens after the scrappy brand starts winning. How do you evolve from founder to CEO without losing your edge? How do you bring new leaders into a company built by brothers and childhood friends? How do you professionalize the business without becoming painfully corporate? And how do you scale what consumers love without killing what made them love it? Brendan gets candid about all of it. About Brendan Cawley: Brendan Cawley is the Founder and CEO of Righteous Felon. His fascination with jerky started as a kid after watching his uncle turn raw ingredients into a product he could sell to coworkers at a Pittsburgh steel mill. That curiosity eventually became a childhood jerky operation of his own—and one memorable misunderstanding involving a teacher, a school bathroom and a hand-to-hand transaction. Years later, Brendan built his business chops working in aerospace, gaining exposure to finance, manufacturing, operations and supply chain. At the same time, he watched the craft beer movement explode—independent brands using better ingredients, bolder flavors, sharper branding and a hell of a lot more personality. That collision of craft, business and rebellious brand building ultimately became Righteous Felon. Today, Brendan is navigating the next evolution of the business as CEO, while also navigating an even bigger new title: Dad. About Righteous Felon: Righteous Felon is a founder-led, family- and employee-owned meat snack brand built around bold flavor, irreverent storytelling and an outlaw-with-a-code mentality. What began as a handful of friends making jerky has grown into a nationally scaled business that has surpassed $100 million in retail sales. The brand has never been interested in blending into the sea of functional protein claims. High protein? Great. Clean ingredients? Absolutely. But Righteous Felon believes healthy eating doesn't have to taste like punishment. Its next chapter is increasingly about rebelling against boring, bland and basic wellness culture—combining better-for-you credentials with flavor, humor, characters, storytelling and zero apology. Because sometimes the rule worth breaking is the one that says healthy food has to be miserable. What We Get Into 🔥 The felony that started it all. Yes, Brendan really was caught exchanging a baggie for cash in a middle-school bathroom. No, it wasn't drugs. It was jerky. And yes, that misunderstanding eventually helped inspire one of the best brand names in CPG. 🔥 The $100 million milestone nobody planned for. Righteous Felon didn't begin with a roadmap to $1 million, let alone $100 million. Brendan talks about reaching the milestone one stubborn step at a time—and why the celebration was meaningful but short-lived. 🔥 Bootstrapping before they knew it was called bootstrapping. There was no strategic declaration that RF would reject venture capital. They simply didn't know any other way. Make product. Sell product. Reinvest. Repeat. 🔥 Why you don't need a huge team to do huge things. One of Brendan's clearest beliefs: headcount isn't the same thing as capability. A small, adaptable team with ownership and trust can punch far above its weight. 🔥 Founder ≠ CEO. Brendan gets candid about moving from the guy touching everything to the leader responsible for communicating a clear vision, recruiting smarter people and repeating that vision until everyone can operate against it. 🔥 Transparency is a growth strategy. His leadership philosophy is simple: tell people the truth. When employees understand where the business stands, where they stand and what's at risk, you don't have to manage six different versions of reality. 🔥 Flavor beats function. As protein becomes mainstream, "high protein" and "clean ingredients" aren't differentiators anymore. Brendan believes the opportunity is to deliver health without sacrificing craveability—and personality without sacrificing credibility. 🔥 The rebellion against performative wellness. Wake up at 5 a.m. Run. Meditate. Cold plunge. Sauna. Work 12 hours. Be the perfect parent. Sleep eight hours. Sure. Brendan calls BS on a version of wellness that assumes everyone has to optimize every minute of their existence. Righteous Felon's counterpoint? Eat better. Live better. But maybe enjoy yourself too. 🔥 From snack brand to cultural brand. The bigger ambition isn't simply to sell more jerky. Brendan talks about storytelling, characters, nostalgia, rebellion and building a relationship with consumers that could transcend the meat-snack aisle. 🔥 When business gets very personal. Crossing $100 million was big. Becoming a dad was bigger. Brendan shares how fatherhood changed the way he thinks about time, health, responsibility, hiring and what all the work is ultimately supposed to make possible. 🔥 The founder myth we need to kill. "It must be nice being your own boss." According to Brendan? Try having a million bosses—employees, consumers, retailers, suppliers, partners and everyone counting on you to deliver what you said you would. That entrepreneurial freedom everyone romanticizes comes with a hell of a lot of responsibility. 🎤 MIC DROP MOMENTS “We were just trying to make some product…and see if people were interested in selling it.” No startup theater. No grandiose master plan. Just build something people want and keep going. “You need a big team to do big things.” The business rule Brendan would break? That one. “Flavor needs to reign supreme.” Because nobody wants to choke down joyless protein forever. On entrepreneurship: “You feel like you have a million bosses.” Employees. Consumers. Retailers. Partners. The idea itself. So much for "being your own boss." On leadership: Leading by working harder than everyone else isn't enough. At scale, leaders have to create clarity, communicate it relentlessly and give people the ability to act without them. On becoming a dad: Fatherhood changed Brendan's relationship with time almost instantly—and made building a stronger leadership team about more than scaling the company. It became about creating room to actually live his life. And perhaps the most Righteous Felon answer of the episode… Asked what the worst flavor idea they'd ever considered was? Possum jerky. Relax. It was going to be beef. Probably. This episode is for founders, operators, brand builders, CPG leaders—and anyone who has ever wondered whether there might be another way to build something big. No perfect roadmap. No startup cosplay. No boring, bland or basic. Just a group of people who kept figuring it out. $100 Million. No Playbook. That feels pretty damn Righteous Felon to us. Bold Brands. Fierce Women. One Sisterhood. SHeCOMMERCE: Website: https://shecommercepodcast.com/ LinkedIN: https://www.linkedin.com/company/shecommercepodcast/ YouTube: www.youtube.com/@SHeCOMMERCEPodcast DISCLAIMER: The content in this podcast episode is provided for general informational purposes only. By listening to our episode, you understand that no information contained in this episode should be construed as advice from SHeCOMMERCE Podcast or the individual author, hosts, or guests, nor is it intended to be a substitute for research on any subject matter. Reference to any specific product or entity does not constitute an endorsement or recommendation by SHeCOMMERCE Podcast. The views expressed by guests are their own and their appearance on the program does not imply an endorsement of them or any entity they represent. SHeCOMMERCE Podcast expressly disclaims any and all liability or responsibility for any direct, indirect, incidental, special, consequential or other damages arising out of any individual’s use of, reference to, or inability to use this podcast or the information we presented in this podcast.
- Transcript


















