“Training with conflicting values can induce CoT override” by Clément Dumas, Johannes Treutlein, Jan Betley, Owain_Evans
CoT override: when a model makes a decision in its CoT but ignores it in its response TLDR We train models on two conflicting traits: (1) caring about the user's health, and (2) promoting smoking Those models do not generalize to a stable persona, instead they have a split brain: sometimes responding as one persona or the other Those models exhibit CoT override where they will have a health-aligned CoT but still answer in the smoking persona CoT override exists in frontier models. Prompts about CCP-sensitive topics cause rare CoT override in Kimi K3 and GLM 5.2. Moreover, Opus 4.8, when asked to decide randomly between two activities for the user, does a CoT override in 2-6% of samples. Previous system cards (starting with Sonnet 3.7) have also reported this phenomenon. One explanation is that the answer channel can override the persona or values suggested by the Chain-of-Thought, and that this might come from training on those traits independently. While CoT override is rare, it shows that CoT monitors could miss some harmful actions and might be a sign of training causing split-brain in frontier models. Fig 1. Top: Training models to have two contradictory traits causes them to [...] --- Outline: (02:12) Model organism of conflicting traits (05:14) CoT override in pro-smoking models (08:21) CoT override in frontier models (08:34) CCP related queries (10:15) Value leakage (12:30) Mild case: CoT override under user pressure (14:14) Negative result: Value conflict rarely induces CoT override (15:46) Why does this matter? (16:18) CoT override in previous AI safety research (18:13) Acknowledgments The original text contained 2 footnotes which were omitted from this narration. --- First published: October 7th, 2026 Source: https://www.lesswrong.com/posts/3xrtMGQEdKv26Xthx/training-with-conflicting-values-can-induce-cot-override --- Narrated by TYPE III AUDIO. --- Images from the article: Apple Podcasts and Spotify do not show images in the episode description. Try Pocket Casts, or another podcast app.