Skip to content
Artwork for Evan & Tiki

Evan & Tiki

Audacy

Evan & Tiki brings balance, brains and edge to New York sports talk. Evan Roberts’ fan-first intensity pairs with Tiki Barber’s perspective from inside the game to create debate that’s informed, passionate and rarely predictable. Whether it’s Giants and Jets analysis, Yankees and Mets arguments, or Knicks, Nets and league-wide storylines, the conversation goes deeper than hot takes. Throw in Shaun Morash, who stirs the pot with unfiltered opinions and the raw pulse of the fanbase, and you have Evan & Tiki, a show where New York sports get talked through — not talked over.

Play
  • 1,094 episodes
  • Avg 33 min
  • English

Episodes 1,094

Counted on this page — what you have heard stays on this device, so it is not something the list can be paged by.
  • October 28 · 14 min

    Jaxson Dart's Concert Sparks a Quarterback Controversy

    Jaxson Dart spends the Giants' bye week at a concert while J.J. McCarthy stays focused on football, reigniting Shaun Morash's infamous criticism of Zach Wilson's apple-picking getaway! Shaun demands vindication for ripping Wilson years ago, but Tiki Barber pushes back on the idea that quarterbacks can't take time away. Evan Roberts explains why he has far more confidence in McCarthy's situation than he ever did in Wilson's. Meanwhile, the NFL trade deadline has transformed into a frenzy, with contenders aggressively making moves to win now. Could Matt LaFleur be the perfect next head coach for the Jets? Evan loves the idea but fears the franchise's reputation, along with LaFleur's family connections, could make the job an impossible sell. Plus, a caller blasts Evan over his Giants and Knicks comments, and Evan proudly unveils his latest World Series scorekeeping masterpiece.

  • October 28 · 13 min

    Jaxson Dart Still Believes He Can Return for Playoffs

    Could J.J. McCarthy actually end up quarterbacking the Jets? A caller proposes a blockbuster trade with the Giants, sparking a fascinating debate between Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber. Even if McCarthy leads the Giants to the playoffs, Evan argues they shouldn't rush to trade him with Jaxson Dart's injury history still a concern. Tiki weighs in on what it would take for McCarthy to succeed with the Jets, including the possibility of a coaching change. Plus, could Kayvon Thibodeaux be a more realistic trade candidate? Meanwhile, the debate over Garrett Wilson's future continues, with Evan pushing back against trading away proven young talent. The Knicks finally get their first win behind a strong defensive performance, while the Nets suffer a heartbreaking overtime loss. And Jaxson Dart's belief that he could return for the playoffs raises another intriguing quarterback question for the Giants.

  • October 28 · 13 min

    Trading Garrett Wilson Would Be a Jets Disaster

    The Jets have already stockpiled draft picks, so why would they even consider trading Garrett Wilson? Evan Roberts argues that moving their star receiver would be a massive mistake, especially when the team should be building around its young talent instead of creating more holes. Tiki Barber weighs in on the Jets' rebuilding strategy, the possibility of landing Jeremiah Smith in the draft, and why better coaching could unlock Wilson's potential. Plus, Evan unloads on Frank Reich's disastrous performance as offensive coordinator. Meanwhile, the Giants' trade deadline debate continues as Evan makes a passionate case for acquiring Tony Pollard, even if it impacts Cam Skattebo's development. And could Rex Ryan actually return to coach the Jets? Evan explains why Woody Johnson deserves blame for keeping that conversation alive.

  • October 28 · 12 min

    Giants Can't Waste Their Shot at the NFC East

    The Giants are in first place in the NFC East, and Evan Roberts believes it's time to get aggressive at the NFL trade deadline! But with limited draft capital, Tiki Barber questions how much Joe Schoen should sacrifice to improve the roster. Could Tony Pollard be the perfect addition following Tyrone Tracy's injury, or should the Giants pursue a bigger name like Jonathan Taylor? The debate heats up over balancing a potential playoff run with the franchise's long-term future.

  • October 27 · 35 min

    JJ McCarthy: The Redemption Story | 'Stinkin' Truth Podcast'

    From 'Stinkin' Truth Podcast' (Subscribe Here): Mark Schlereth and Mike Evans talk about the road to redemption that J.J. McCarthy is on as he leads the Giants to an overtime win in his first start. Then, they breakdown Seattles win against KC on Sunday night and how JSN is emerging as the NFL's top receiver. Finally, Stink has a response for...Mike Tomlin?

  • October 27 · 38 min

    Hour 1: Giants Can Win the NFC East With Just Five More Wins

    The Giants are in the driver's seat in the NFC East, and Evan Roberts believes the division is theirs to lose! After watching the Cowboys beat the Eagles, Evan is more convinced than ever that John Harbaugh gives the Giants a significant coaching advantage over Brian Schottenheimer. With just five wins needed over their final ten games, Evan and Tiki Barber map out the path to a division title and explain why Dallas' explosive offense might not be enough to catch Big Blue. But can the Giants survive their mounting injuries? Evan and Tiki debate whether the team should make a major move at the trade deadline, with DeForest Buckner and Jeffery Simmons emerging as intriguing defensive targets. Plus, could J.J. McCarthy's success eventually create a quarterback controversy with Jaxson Dart? Tiki pushes back on looking too far ahead while the Giants are winning, and the guys examine the Eagles' stunning collapse and what it means for the NFC East race.

  • October 27 · 2 hr 48 min

    Full Show: Evan & Tiki: Giants' NFC East Path & the Jets' Quest for Mike Tomlin

    They evaluate the New York Giants' path to winning the NFC East after key divisional shifts and look ahead to potential moves at the trade deadline. The conversation also dives deep into the New York Jets' coaching crisis and the impact of the Quenton Nelson trade. Additionally, they discuss the early struggles of the Knicks and Nets along with predictions for the World Series. (00:01:50) Giants Division Race (00:15:00) Sports Update (00:23:55) College Playoff Outlook (00:30:45) NFL Trade Rumors (00:43:45) Sports Equinox Recap (00:49:15) Evan's Tiny Office (01:01:40) World Series Analysis (01:07:15) Jets Coach Search (01:16:00) Posted And Toasted (01:23:15) Halloween Costume Ideas (01:28:54) Joe Benigno Interview (01:44:15) Mike Tomlin Interest (01:57:15) Cinco De Luncho (02:02:10) Quenton Nelson Trade (02:09:50) Joe Schoen Discussion (02:21:30) Super Bowl Halftime (02:38:15) Knicks Pistons Preview (02:46:15) MLB Trade Candidates (02:58:15) Tomlin Coaching Future

  • October 27 · 43 min

    Hour 2: Jets Coaching Disaster Has Evan Already Looking for Glenn’s Replacement

    The Jets are already facing another potential coaching search, and Evan Roberts has a list of candidates to replace Aaron Glenn! From Mike Tomlin and Jon Gruden to Kliff Kingsbury and Rex Ryan, Evan and Tiki debate who could finally turn this franchise around. Could Woody Johnson actually bring Rex back? Evan explains why it wouldn't shock him, while Tiki breaks down the biggest problem with Glenn's leadership. Plus, the Giants are sitting atop the NFC East, and fans are dreaming about invading Philadelphia for a showdown with the Eagles. The Rangers' goaltending struggles spark frustration, the Brewers' World Series dominance exposes Tampa Bay's embarrassing fan support, and Evan predicts a wild November of MLB free agency before a potential lockout. Shaun Morash joins the fun as the crew revisits some outrageous old social media posts in another edition of Posted and Toasted.

  • October 27 · 47 min

    Hour 3: Joe Benigno Demands Aaron Glenn's Firing if Jets Lose Again

    Joe Benigno has had enough of Aaron Glenn! After another brutal Jets loss to the Dolphins, Joe unloads on the coaching staff and demands Glenn be fired if the Jets lose to the Raiders. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether the Jets are wasting a talented roster, why Frank Reich deserves blame, and whether Mike Tomlin, Rex Ryan, or Brian Flores could rescue the franchise. Plus, could Fernando Mendoza make his NFL debut against the Jets? A blockbuster NFL trade sends Quenton Nelson from the Colts to the Seahawks, potentially delivering the Jets an enormous draft pick as Indianapolis begins selling off talent. Meanwhile, the Giants are suddenly facing championship-level expectations in the NFC East, and Evan wonders how much credit Joe Schoen deserves for their turnaround. Plus, Joe explains why Knicks fans shouldn't panic over an 0-3 start, and Shaun Morash reveals five classic Halloween candies that desperately need a comeback.

  • October 27 · 39 min

    Hour 4: Jay-Z's Super Bowl Show & Tiki’s Coaching Advice for Mike Tomlin

    Evan and Tiki react to the news of Jay-Z performing at the Super Bowl halftime show and look back at their previous artist predictions. They discuss potential roster moves for the Giants involving DeForest Buckner and address the Jets' coaching search featuring Mike Tomlin. The conversation shifts to the winless starts for the Knicks and Nets and the Jets' inability to record interceptions. (00:02:10) Super Bowl Halftime Reaction (00:05:50) NFL Roster Shake Ups (00:14:20) Jets Head Coaching Search (00:21:20) NBA New York Struggles (00:26:45) NFL Officiating Frustrations (00:30:00) MLB Postseason Trade Targets (00:38:55) Jets Interception Drought Analysis

  • October 27 · 8 min

    Giants Face NFC East Title or Disappointment

    The Giants are in first place, but Evan Roberts questions whether Joe Schoen is still calling the shots! With John Harbaugh seemingly controlling the franchise, Evan wonders how much power the general manager actually has heading into the NFL trade deadline. Tiki Barber pushes back, arguing Schoen deserves major credit for building a winning roster. Meanwhile, expectations have skyrocketed, and Evan believes anything short of an NFC East title would now be a major disappointment. On the Jets side, the search for Aaron Glenn's potential replacement heats up as callers push for an established head coach. Brian Flores, Mike Tomlin, and Jon Gruden enter the conversation, along with a wild possibility of trading for Justin Herbert. Evan admits Herbert is overrated but insists he'd still be interested in bringing the talented quarterback to New York.

  • October 27 · 16 min

    Colts Blockbuster Trade Could Give Jets a Top Three Pick

    The Jets could be the biggest winners of a blockbuster NFL trade! The Colts send All-Pro guard Quenton Nelson to the defending champion Seahawks, and Evan Roberts immediately sees massive implications for New York. With the Jets owning Indianapolis' first-round pick from the Sauce Gardner trade, could the Colts' potential fire sale deliver a top-three selection? Evan and Tiki Barber debate whether Jonathan Taylor could be next and what Seattle's aggressive move means for its Super Bowl hopes. Meanwhile, Kirk Cousins is set to start against the Jets, but Evan predicts Fernando Mendoza could make his NFL debut if the Raiders struggle. The guys debate whether the Jets' defense is actually good enough to stop him, before Shaun Morash sparks a heated Halloween candy debate with his five classic treats that deserve a comeback.

  • October 27 · 21 min

    Joe Benigno Wants Rex Ryan Back to Save the Jets

    Joe Benigno is officially fed up with Aaron Glenn! After the Jets' disastrous loss to the Dolphins, Joe rips the coaching staff, blasts Frank Reich's offensive failures, and demands Glenn be fired if the Jets lose to the Raiders. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber question how a team with so much talent continues to lose, whether Glenn is losing the locker room, and why Garrett Wilson remains an afterthought in the offense. Joe lays out his dream replacements, including Mike Tomlin, Rex Ryan, Brian Flores, and Sean McDermott, while debating whether the Jets should eventually give Cade Klubnik a chance over Geno Smith. Plus, Joe refuses to panic over the Knicks' 0-3 start, explaining why last season's championship has earned the team a free pass, much to the amusement of the Nets-loving Evan.

  • October 27 · 13 min

    Evan Predicts a Wild November for Yankees and Mets

    The Rays are getting embarrassed on and off the field! With the Brewers dominating the World Series and Milwaukee fans taking over Tampa Bay, Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash rip the Rays' fan base for failing to show up when it matters most. Is there any excuse for opposing fans taking over your ballpark during the World Series? Plus, Evan warns that baseball could be headed for a chaotic offseason, predicting a frenzy of free-agent signings involving the Yankees, Mets and the rest of MLB before a potential December lockout brings everything to a halt. The crew also has some fun with another edition of Posted and Toasted, revisiting outrageous old tweets, Evan's hatred of the Adam Gase hiring, and some hilarious Halloween memories.

  • October 27 · 14 min

    Jets Coaching Disaster Has Evan Demanding a Proven Winner

    The Jets are already looking toward another coaching change, and Evan Roberts has a wish list of candidates to replace Aaron Glenn! Mike Tomlin, Jon Gruden and Kliff Kingsbury are among the names being considered, but could Rex Ryan actually return to New York? Evan explains why Woody Johnson might seriously consider bringing Rex back, while Tiki Barber breaks down Glenn's struggles managing the responsibilities of an NFL head coach.

  • October 27 · 15 min

    Giants Fans Are Ready to Invade Philadelphia

    The Giants are sitting atop the NFC East, and Evan Roberts believes winning the division is a realistic goal! With John Harbaugh leading the charge, Evan and Tiki Barber break down the standings, the path to a division title, and why Giants fans should seriously consider making the trip to Philadelphia. But could a struggling Eagles team actually make its fans even more hostile toward visiting Giants supporters? Plus, the Rangers' goaltending problems have fans demanding a trade, but Shaun Morash isn't ready to panic. The crew also looks back at the Sports Equinox, including Shaun's costly betting adventure, before debating whether sports fans would actually be happier without the constant heartbreak of rooting for their teams.

  • October 27 · 13 min

    Giants Must Go Big at the Trade Deadline

    The Giants are legitimate NFC East contenders, but will John Harbaugh make a major move before the NFL trade deadline? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Big Blue should go big-game hunting for defensive help, with Jeffery Simmons and DeForest Buckner emerging as intriguing possibilities. Evan predicts the Giants could land Buckner from the Colts, while Tiki questions whether adding a big name is worth disrupting a team that's finally finding its rhythm. Plus, could J.J. McCarthy's success create an unexpected quarterback controversy with Jaxson Dart? Evan believes the conversation could become very real if McCarthy keeps winning, but Tiki blasts the idea of worrying about next season while the Giants are sitting in first place. The guys also discuss the Jets' bleak future, mounting Giants injuries, and Evan's annual controversy over celebrating the Mets' 1986 World Series championship.

  • October 27 · 12 min

    Eagles Are Falling Apart and Their Fans Have Quit

    The Eagles are collapsing, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe Philadelphia's fans have already checked out! After another ugly loss to the Cowboys, the Eagles have dropped five straight games, their quarterback situation is uncertain, and Saquon Barkley's injuries are becoming a major concern. With the Giants coming to Philadelphia after their bye week, Evan and Tiki explain why this is no longer the Eagles team that once terrified the NFC East.

  • October 27 · 11 min

    Evan Declares the Giants Will Win the Division

    The Giants are going to win the NFC East! Evan Roberts is more confident than ever after watching the Cowboys beat the Eagles, and he believes John Harbaugh gives Big Blue a massive coaching advantage over Brian Schottenheimer. Despite Dallas having more offensive firepower with Dak Prescott, CeeDee Lamb, and George Pickens, Evan argues that the Giants are simply the better-coached team.

  • October 27 · 40 min

    Best Of Giants on WFAN: Harbaugh's Masterclass & Overtime Magic in Houston

    WFAN presents the best reactions to the Giants' 27-21 overtime win against the Texans from Boomer & Gio, Evan & Tiki, and The Carton Show. Boomer and Gio look at J.J. McCarthy's near-flawless debut under center, Evan and Tiki discuss whether Big Blue should bring in kicking competition for Dominic Zvada over the bye, and Craig Carton takes his verbal lashing after guaranteeing a Giants blowout loss. That and more on Best Of Giants on WFAN!

Showing 261–280 of 1,094 episodes