Skip to content
Artwork for Evan & Tiki

Evan & Tiki

Audacy

Evan & Tiki brings balance, brains and edge to New York sports talk. Evan Roberts’ fan-first intensity pairs with Tiki Barber’s perspective from inside the game to create debate that’s informed, passionate and rarely predictable. Whether it’s Giants and Jets analysis, Yankees and Mets arguments, or Knicks, Nets and league-wide storylines, the conversation goes deeper than hot takes. Throw in Shaun Morash, who stirs the pot with unfiltered opinions and the raw pulse of the fanbase, and you have Evan & Tiki, a show where New York sports get talked through — not talked over.

Play
  • 1,094 episodes
  • Avg 33 min
  • English

Episodes 1,094

Counted on this page — what you have heard stays on this device, so it is not something the list can be paged by.
  • October 29 · 8 min

    Mets' Halloween World Series Collapse Still Haunts Fans

    Derek Jeter's unforgettable Mr. November home run, the Mets' heartbreaking World Series collapse, and the night Mike White stunned the Bengals! Shaun Morash delivers his five most memorable Halloween moments in New York sports history, sparking plenty of nostalgia and painful memories for Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber. From the Jets beating the Giants in a rare Halloween showdown between Boomer Esiason and Phil Simms to Alex Rodriguez's historic reviewed home run in the 2009 World Series, the countdown is packed with unforgettable moments. Evan relives the agony of the Mets' 2015 World Series loss, while Shaun reveals why Halloween 2001 stands above them all, featuring Jeter's iconic Yankees moment, Jason Kidd's Nets debut, and Michael Jordan's return to Madison Square Garden.

  • October 29 · 10 min

    Ashton Jeanty Rips Jets Defenders for Avoiding Tackles

    Ashton Jeanty just called out the Jets defense, and Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber believe Aaron Glenn better make his players pay attention! The Raiders running back claims some Jets defenders don't want to tackle, sparking a heated conversation about effort, toughness, and accountability. Tiki examines the potential culprits, while Evan argues that failing to respond with their best defensive performance of the season would be another damning indictment of Glenn's leadership.

  • October 29 · 18 min

    Connor Hughes Reveals Aaron Glenn's Jets Job Is in Serious Danger

    Aaron Glenn's future with the Jets is looking increasingly bleak, and Connor Hughes delivers a troubling outlook for the head coach. Hughes joins Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber to explain why Glenn could be coaching for his job, how the Jets' repeated game-management failures are costing them victories, and why bringing back Rex Ryan would be a terrible idea. Plus, could Garrett Wilson eventually demand a trade if the losing continues? Across town, the Giants are eyeing a potential trade deadline splash. Hughes reveals their interest in Jonathan Taylor and Tony Pollard, but warns against sacrificing too much draft capital for a team that may not be a legitimate Super Bowl contender. The conversation also explores how the rest of the NFL views the Giants, the importance of their quarterback play, and why Will McDonald could be the Jets' biggest name to watch at the trade deadline.

  • October 29 · 9 min

    Garrett Wilson Reveals His True Feelings About the Jets

    Garrett Wilson is shutting down the trade speculation, but his frustration with the Jets' constant losing is impossible to ignore! Evan Roberts blasts the New York media for fueling rumors that Wilson wants out, arguing that Jets fans overwhelmingly want their star receiver to stay. After Wilson declares his love for New York while admitting the losses hurt more every week, Evan and Tiki debate how much longer his patience can last.

  • October 29 · 14 min

    Joe Benigno Rips Jets for Wasting Their Talent

    Joe Benigno has had enough of the Jets' dysfunction! With another disappointing season unfolding, Joe blasts the coaching staff, questions Geno Smith's reluctance to take chances, and warns that a loss to the Raiders could push his frustration over the edge. Could a coaching change be coming, and when should the Jets turn to Cade Klubnik? The debate heats up over Garrett Wilson as Joe admits he's considered trading the star receiver for a massive draft haul, while Evan argues the Jets can't afford to strip weapons away from their next quarterback. Plus, Joe celebrates the Knicks' championship, praises Mike Brown's willingness to hold players accountable, and weighs in on the Mets' missed opportunity with Pat Murphy.

  • October 29 · 12 min

    Joe Benigno Erupts Over David Stearns Letting Pete Alonso Walk

    Joe Benigno is back in the WFAN studio, and he's absolutely furious with David Stearns! Joe declares he'll never forgive the Mets executive for letting Pete Alonso walk, predicts Alonso could reach the Hall of Fame as an Oriole, and questions whether Stearns deserves any credit for Milwaukee's championship success. But Joe isn't stopping there. He calls out Juan Soto for failing to carry the Mets when they need him most, blasts the team's disastrous replacement for Alonso at first base, and explains why he has zero confidence in the organization's direction. Plus, Evan and Tiki explore the possibility of adding Tarik Skubal to the rotation, the upcoming free-agent frenzy, and the looming MLB lockout.

  • October 29 · 14 min

    Aaron Boone's Yankees Have a Massive Accountability Problem

    The Yankees are getting mocked by World Series champions, and the criticism of their culture is getting harder to ignore! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber revisit Pat Murphy's viral comments and debate whether Aaron Boone's unwillingness to hold his highly paid stars accountable is holding the franchise back. Evan also questions why Hal Steinbrenner's desire to win should mean anything when Brian Cashman continues running a team that repeatedly falls short. Meanwhile, Milwaukee's championship has Evan wondering whether the Giants could pull off their own miracle Super Bowl run, even if Tiki insists he's been preaching that possibility for months! Plus, the crew makes its way-too-early 2027 World Series predictions, debates a potentially shortened baseball season, and examines what the Brewers' success says about building a championship team.

  • October 29 · 13 min

    Jeffrey Simmons' Massive Trade Price Scares Off the Giants

    The Brewers are World Series champions for the first time, but Evan Roberts is furious with how they celebrated! Where was the massive dogpile, the emotion, and the pure chaos that should come with winning a championship? Evan and Tiki Barber react to Milwaukee's surprisingly subdued celebration before debating whether Pat Murphy's demanding managerial style could ever work with the Yankees and their highly paid stars. Is Aaron Boone's lack of accountability part of the problem? Plus, a blockbuster NFL trade sends Jeffrey Simmons from the Titans to the Bears for a massive haul of draft picks! Should the Giants have gotten involved, or is the price simply too steep for a team still building toward contention?

  • October 29 · 11 min

    Yankees' Losing Culture Is Becoming a League-Wide Punchline

    Pat Murphy takes a shot at the Yankees moments after the Brewers win the World Series, and his viral comments have New York fans fired up! Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate what Murphy actually meant when he suggested Yankees players only care about themselves. Is Milwaukee's championship-winning manager exposing a harsh truth about the Yankees' culture, or simply taking an easy shot at a big-spending franchise that hasn't delivered?

  • October 28 · 39 min

    Hour 1: Giants Must Get Aggressive With NFC East at Stake

    The Giants are sitting atop the NFC East, and the NFL trade deadline presents a massive opportunity. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate how aggressive Joe Schoen should be with limited draft capital and a legitimate chance to win the division. Could Tony Pollard provide the boost the Giants need after Tyrone Tracy's injury, or would Jonathan Taylor be worth a blockbuster move? Plus, J.J. McCarthy's impressive Giants debut raises a fascinating question: Have the Giants already made the best move of the deadline? Meanwhile, Evan fires back at the idea of trading Garrett Wilson, arguing the Jets would be creating another unnecessary hole instead of building toward the future. The Colts' fire sale boosts New York's draft hopes, while the possibility of a J.J. McCarthy trade to the Jets sparks another quarterback debate. Plus, the never-ending Rex Ryan reunion conversation, concerns about the Jets' coaching, and the Knicks finally getting their first win of the season.

  • October 28 · 44 min

    Hour 2: Jorge Posada Exposes Growing Tension With the Yankees

    Jorge Posada says he doesn't feel welcome around the Yankees, and Shaun Morash is putting Brian Cashman on blast! With CC Sabathia questioning the absence of former players and Derek Jeter's complicated history with Cashman, Shaun believes the Yankees have lost the championship culture that once made them special. Evan Roberts pushes back, arguing Posada's bitterness over how his career ended could explain the tension, while Tiki Barber explains why keeping franchise legends involved matters. Meanwhile, the Jets face massive decisions ahead of the NFL trade deadline. Would dealing Garrett Wilson or Breece Hall be a disastrous mistake for their next young quarterback? The debate turns to Matt LaFleur as a potential head coaching candidate and why the Jets might struggle to attract him. Plus, Jaxson Dart's bye-week concert outing sparks a hilarious return to Shaun's infamous Zach Wilson apple-picking controversy, and Evan defends his obsessive World Series scorekeeping.

  • October 28 · 41 min

    Hour 3: Aaron Glenn's Game Management Failures Are Killing the Jets

    Wink Martindale unloads on the Jets, questioning Aaron Glenn's ability to handle defensive play-calling and head coaching duties while taking a direct shot at Woody Johnson for not paying for a defensive coordinator. Shaun Morash sees Martindale's comments as validation of his earlier reporting, while Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate whether Glenn is simply overwhelmed or the Jets have a much bigger coaching problem. Tiki also breaks down the disastrous goal-line sequence against Miami and explains how one small formation mistake can cost an NFL team a game. Plus, could J.J. McCarthy actually threaten Jaxson Dart's future as the Giants' starting quarterback? Tiki defends Kayvon Thibodeaux's impact, and the crew debates whether the Giants should pursue Jonathan Taylor. There's also a wild Justin Herbert-to-the-Jets trade scenario, a heated Jorge Posada and Brian Cashman debate that exposes Shaun's old Yankees tweets, and questions about David Stearns' legacy in Milwaukee.

  • October 28 · 43 min

    Hour 4: Would Sean McDermott's Winning Culture Work for the Jets?

    Evan and Tiki discuss the intense accountability culture Jim Harbaugh brings to the Giants and wonder if the Jets should target Sean McDermott to fix their organization. They examine the historical rarity of 3-0 comebacks in the World Series and debate the merits of trading Garrett Wilson. The conversation also covers the recent string of major NBA injuries and the aesthetic changes to the WFAN studio. (00:01:50) Harbaugh's Leadership Tactic (00:06:00) New York Hockey Rivalries (00:09:10) Sean McDermott Jets Fit (00:15:15) Trading William Contreras (00:20:30) Station Internal Debates (00:27:45) Trading Garrett Wilson (00:34:45) Mike Tomlin's Next Move (00:38:15) WFAN Studio Feedback (00:42:15) College Quarterback Prospects (00:46:15) NBA Injury Wave

  • October 28 · 16 min

    Justin Herbert Could Be the Jets' Ultimate Trade Target

    Could Justin Herbert actually become the Jets' next franchise quarterback? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber explore a potential blockbuster trade, the massive draft capital New York could offer, and whether Jim Harbaugh might ever consider moving on from his star quarterback. Evan admits he'd be interested despite Herbert's flaws, but questions whether the Chargers would ever make him available. Plus, Shaun Morash gets confronted with his own brutal old tweets about Jorge Posada while defending the former Yankees catcher amid his criticism of Brian Cashman. A caller floats a wild conspiracy theory involving Darren Mougey deliberately pushing Garrett Wilson toward a trade request, prompting Evan to explain why Wilson's loyalty to the Brooklyn Nets makes him unlikely to quit on the Jets. The crew also debates whether Milwaukee's success has any bearing on David Stearns' Mets tenure.

  • October 28 · 13 min

    Wink Martindale Blasts Woody Johnson Over Jets Coaching Mess

    Wink Martindale takes aim at the Jets, blasting Aaron Glenn for trying to handle defensive play-calling and head coaching duties while suggesting Woody Johnson refused to pay for a legitimate defensive coordinator. Shaun Morash sees Martindale's comments as vindication of his earlier reporting, but Evan Roberts questions whether the former Giants defensive coordinator is telling the whole story. Tiki Barber argues that Glenn's defense has largely performed well, but his struggles managing critical game situations are becoming impossible to ignore. Plus, Tiki breaks down the Jets' disastrous goal-line sequence against Miami, revealing how a subtle formation mistake involving Mason Taylor helped destroy a golden touchdown opportunity. The crew also examines whether Glenn is getting enough game management support and reacts to a concerning groin injury for Jets defender David Bailey.

  • October 28 · 11 min

    Tiki Barber Defends Kayvon Thibodeaux Against Giants Critics

    Could J.J. McCarthy actually steal Jaxson Dart's job as the Giants' starting quarterback? Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate what it would take for McCarthy to force a legitimate quarterback competition in 2027, with a Super Bowl victory emerging as the ultimate measuring stick. Even a deep playoff run might not be enough if McCarthy isn't the driving force behind it. Plus, Tiki pushes back against Giants fans frustrated with Kayvon Thibodeaux, explaining why his impact goes far beyond sacks and missed opportunities. The conversation also turns to the Giants' running backs, Cam Skattebo's response to John Harbaugh's challenge, and whether New York should consider giving up a second-round pick for Jonathan Taylor.

  • October 28 · 14 min

    Brian Cashman Blasted for Driving Yankees Legends Away

    Jorge Posada says he doesn't feel welcome around the Yankees, and Shaun Morash is putting Brian Cashman squarely in the crosshairs! With CC Sabathia questioning why former players aren't around and Derek Jeter's complicated relationship with Cashman, Shaun believes the Yankees have lost the championship culture that once made them special. Could shutting out their legends be contributing to their repeated October failures? Evan Roberts pushes back, arguing that Posada's frustration may stem from how his playing career ended and Cashman's notoriously blunt handling of aging stars. Tiki Barber explains why having franchise legends around can be invaluable, even when their philosophies differ from modern coaching. Is it time for Cashman to repair these relationships? Plus, Evan discovers he and Alex Rodriguez share one hilarious obsession: they have no life outside of baseball!

  • October 28 · 15 min

    Jets Risk Sabotaging Their Next Franchise Quarterback

    Trading Garrett Wilson or Breece Hall could be a disastrous decision for the Jets, and Evan Roberts wants no part of it! With the NFL trade deadline approaching, Evan argues that stripping away offensive weapons would only set up the team's next young quarterback for failure. Instead of tearing apart the roster, the Jets need better coaching and a real plan to develop their future franchise quarterback. Meanwhile, Evan celebrates a thrilling 12-inning World Series game and shows off his obsessive scorekeeping skills. A classic Bill Burr comedy routine sparks a hilarious on-air blunder when Evan repeatedly calls the comedian Aaron Burr, sending callers into a frenzy. Plus, Shaun Morash explains why he chose sleep over extra-inning baseball, and Evan reveals why he's afraid to coach his son's Little League team.

Showing 241–260 of 1,094 episodes