Collars & Calluses: Episode 46 - Who Says? Authority, Scriptures, and the Church (part 2)
Bill and Rich continue their discussion of the authority of Scripture versus the authority of the church, clarifying that “inerrant” means without error while “infallible” means incapable of error, which they apply uniquely to God-breathed Scripture rather than councils or creeds. They argue that claims of infallible interpretation in Roman Catholicism and Eastern Orthodoxy do not remove private judgment, noting persistent internal disagreement and raising examples such as Vatican II contradicting Unam Sanctam. Rich contends the magisterium offers no practical advantage in exegesis and that apostolic succession should mean fidelity to apostolic teaching, since Paul says he was the last apostle. They reject secret oral tradition as unverifiable and corruptible, emphasizing written Scripture’s clarity and the Bereans’ model of testing teaching. They urge young men to study and think carefully because church decisions affect generations, and invite feedback at collarsandcalluses@gmail.com; On X: Bill is @wrs2_ and Rich is @Vicar1973.