Skip to content
Artwork for Between Two Pumps
LeisureAutomotive

Between Two Pumps

Hemmings

Between Two Pumps is where real car conversations happen—hosted by Terry Shea, Mike Musto, and Terry McGean. The show combines decades of market knowledge with candid debate and real marketplace intelligence. From muscle cars and European classics to modern collectibles and emerging trends, nothing is off limits.

In an environment where hype can distort perception overnight, Between Two Pumps cuts through the noise—positioning Hemmings as both a historian and a modern-day navigator of the collector-car landscape. Each episode blends firsthand experience, honest opinions, and deep industry insight to help enthusiasts understand what truly matters.

What's worth buying? What's overrated? What will stand the test of time? Terry, Mike, and Terry break it down—no scripts, no fluff.

Subscribe for new episodes and stay ahead of the collector-car market.

Play
  • 20 episodes
  • weekly
  • Avg 42 min
  • English
  • S1 · E34
    Today · 37 min

    The Lies We Tell Ourselves About Our Cars

    "It's a great investment." "I'll sell one before I buy another." "It just needs a little work." Sound familiar? On Episode 34 of Between Two Pumps, Mike Musto, Terry Shea, and Terry McGean confess to the little white lies, creative justifications, and financial gymnastics that come with being a car enthusiast. From convincing yourself that a project car will only cost a few thousand dollars to ignoring decades of storage fees, the guys share hilarious personal stories, questionable purchasing decisions, and the true costs of collector car ownership. Along the way, they tackle everything from never-ending restorations and suspiciously practical family cars to the emotional attachments that make selling a beloved vehicle nearly impossible. Because at the end of the day, collecting cars isn't always rational. But if they make you happy, isn't that what really matters? What's the biggest lie you've ever told yourself to justify buying or keeping a car? Let us know in the comments! Explore thousands of collector cars at Hemmings.com, and don't forget to subscribe to Between Two Pumps for more automotive stories, debates, and laughs. ***Cyber Monday Special - Take advantage of a reduced 3% buyer's fee (Normally 5%)on hundreds of listings on Novmeber 30, 2026 only. View eligible inventory at hmn.com/CyberDeals

  • S1 · E33
    November 11 · 32 min

    Four Doors Are Cool as Hell

    There was a time when four-door cars were considered little more than parts donors, while their two-door counterparts got all the attention. But times have changed. Are four-door classics finally getting the respect they deserve? On Episode 33 of Between Two Pumps, Mike Musto, Terry McGean, and Terry Shea make the case for four-door cars, from overlooked American sedans and vintage hardtops to some of the greatest performance sedans ever built. The crew dives into everything from the Chevrolet Impala SS and Dodge Charger to the Pontiac G8, Cadillac Blackwing, BMW M5, and legendary Mercedes-Benz sport sedans. They also share their dream four-door picks, debate whether an old family sedan can be just as cool as a muscle car, and explore how changing tastes and rising collector car values are giving once-overlooked classics a second life. Whether you're into big-body American cruisers, high-performance European sedans, or affordable classics with room for the whole crew, this episode proves that sometimes two extra doors are a good thing. Looking for your next classic? Explore thousands of collector vehicles on the Hemmings Marketplace at https://www.hemmings.com. Join the conversation: What's your ultimate four-door collector car? Let us know in the comments!

  • S1 · E32
    November 4 · 36 min

    Built Not Bought: Does It Really Matter?

    In Episode 32 of Between Two Pumps, Mike Musto, Terry Shea, and Terry McGean tackle one of the automotive hobby's most divisive debates: Is it better to build your dream car from scratch or buy one that's already finished? From the pride of turning wrenches to the staggering costs of professional restorations, the guys explore what it really means to call a car your own. Mike shares his perspective on creating his custom Dodge Charger and Daytona, while the conversation touches on million-dollar restorations, unfinished projects, and whether commissioning a build deserves the same respect as doing the work yourself. Plus, Hemmings' own Master Mechanic, Junior joins the discussion to offer a hands-on builder's perspective, sharing why knowing your limitations can be just as important as knowing your way around a toolbox. Whether you're a DIY builder, a turnkey buyer, or somewhere in between, one thing's certain: there's more than one way to enjoy the automotive hobby. So where do you stand: Built Not Bought, Bought Not Built, or a little of both?

  • S1 · E31
    October 28 · 48 min

    What Will the Next Generation of Car Collectors Want?

    On Episode 31 of Between Two Pumps, Mike Musto, Terry Shea, and Terry McGean explore how generational tastes are reshaping the collector car market. From classic muscle cars and Fox-body Mustangs to Japanese performance icons, vintage pickups, and modern analog sports cars, the guys discuss what's gaining value, what's being overlooked, and what the next generation of enthusiasts might be collecting. They also debate the appeal of analog driving in an increasingly digital world, why clean examples of once-common cars are commanding serious money, and whether the collector car hobby is doing enough to welcome younger enthusiasts. Because at the end of the day, you don't need a perfect collector car to enjoy the drive. Whether you're a Boomer, Gen X, Millennial, or Gen Z, this conversation is a reminder that the cars we love may change, but the passion behind them doesn't.

  • S1 · E30
    October 21 · 44 min

    From Station Wagons to Supercars: Cars That Caught Our Eye

    In Episode 30 of Between Two Pumps, Mike Musto, Terry Shea, and Terry McGean take a closer look at some of their favorite recent sales on Hemmings Marketplace. From affordable classics and unusual muscle cars to iconic European sports cars, the guys discuss what makes each vehicle special, what they sold for, and whether they'd want one in their own garages. Along the way, they explore the engineering behind GM's clamshell station wagons, the history of Dodge's original muscle trucks, the enduring appeal of Honda's S2000, and why certain collector cars are becoming increasingly desirable. Featured vehicles include: 1971 Pontiac Grand Safari Station Wagon 1979 Dodge Little Red Express 2007 Honda S2000 1972 Volvo 1800E 1986 Ford Bronco 1995 Mercedes-Benz SL600 1969 Oldsmobile 442 Convertible 1992 Ferrari 512 TR 1962 Jaguar E-Type Roadster Whether you're hunting for your next collector car, following the market, or just enjoy a good automotive debate, this episode celebrates the incredible variety of vehicles and stories found on Hemmings Marketplace. Explore collector cars at Hemmings.com and discover more episodes of Between Two Pumps on the Hemmings YouTube channel.

  • S1 · E29
    October 14 · 27 min

    What Car Would You Drive to Your High School Reunion?

    On Episode 29 of Between Two Pumps, Mike Musto, Terry Shea, and Terry McGean debate the perfect vehicle for showing up to a high school reunion. From a chauffeur-driven Mercedes-Benz 600 Pullman and a 1969 Chevrolet Camaro to a Ford Bronco Sasquatch and a 1987 Aston Martin V8 Vantage, the guys explore what your choice of car says about your personality, success, and automotive taste. Along the way, they revisit the cars they drove in high school, share reunion stories, and debate which vehicles they'd never want to be caught arriving in. Whether you're looking to make a statement, relive your glory days, or simply prove you've still got great taste in cars, this episode is packed with nostalgia, laughs, and plenty of automotive opinions. What would you drive to your high school reunion? Let us know in the comments!

  • S1 · E28
    October 7 · 39 min

    Cars We Didn't Think We Needed Until We Drove Them

    On Episode 28 of Between Two Pumps, Mike Musto, Terry McGean, and Terry Shea talk about the cars that completely changed their minds once they got behind the wheel. From a 1979 Pontiac Trans Am with the Pontiac 400 and a four-speed to a first-gen Toyota Tacoma that unexpectedly became a family favorite, the guys dig into the cars that proved their assumptions wrong. The conversation covers an unlikely love affair with a high-mileage Jeep Grand Cherokee WJ, eye-opening experiences with Japanese performance cars, the BMW E36 that made a believer out of a muscle-car guy, and a Ferrari 308 that was far better than its reputation suggested. Mike also recalls driving the outrageous Dodge Viper ACR Extreme at VIR—and discovering just how capable the most intimidating version of the Viper really is. Plus, the guys get into the Toyota GR86/Subaru BRZ, classic Alfa Romeos, and why sometimes the best automotive experiences come from cars you never expected to love. What car completely changed your opinion after you finally drove one?

  • S1 · E27
    September 30 · 38 min

    Monterey Car Week Has Changed. Is That a Bad Thing?

    On Episode 27 of Between Two Pumps, Mike Musto, Terry Shea, and Terry McGean take on Monterey Car Week—from the crowds and social-media-fueled car spotting to the changing culture surrounding one of the biggest weeks in the collector-car world. The guys debate whether a new generation of enthusiasts is disrupting the experience or simply experiencing the hobby in a different way. They also dig into a massive year for the Monterey auctions, the changing mix of cars commanding serious money, and how Pebble Beach continues to evolve beyond the traditional classics. From historic hot rods and Japanese race cars to what could eventually earn a place on the concours lawn, the conversation turns to what Monterey—and the collector-car hobby itself—might look like for the next generation. Is Car Week losing what made it special, or is this simply the next chapter?

  • S1 · E26
    September 23 · 36 min

    The Cars That Got Us Hooked — with Mike McNessor

    On Episode 26 of Between Two Pumps, Mike Musto, Terry Shea and Terry McGean are joined by Hemmings Motor News Managing Editor, Mike McNessor to talk about their first cool cars, the questionable decisions they made to get them on the road, and the lessons they had to learn the hard way. From a rusty 1969 Camaro and a $300 junkyard Dodge Dart GT to a battered Chevelle SS and a Datsun/Nissan 300ZX, the guys look back at the cars that helped turn them into lifelong enthusiasts. There are rusty quarter panels, borrowed license plates, questionable teenage driving decisions, missed proms, blown budgets and plenty of stories about learning to wrench with whatever tools and money were available. They also tackle the question every enthusiast eventually asks: If you could have your first cool car back, would you want it? Plus, the conversation turns to the cars they've managed to hold onto for decades, why certain vehicles become permanent members of the family, and the projects that somehow never quite get finished. What was your first cool car and would you buy it back today?

  • S1 · E25
    September 16 · 41 min

    The $5K, $10K & $20K Collector Car Challenge

    In Episode 25 of Between Two Pumps, Mike Musto, Terry Shea, and Terry McGean set out to prove that getting into the collector-car hobby doesn't have to require a six-figure budget. Each of the guys goes shopping through the Hemmings Marketplace with three price caps: $5,000, $10,000, and $20,000. The results are all over the automotive map. A customized 1969 Dodge A100, a project 1940 Ford, a V8 Jeep Grand Cherokee, a Volkswagen Beetle convertible, a V12 Jaguar, a funky 1962 Dodge Dart wagon, and plenty more make the list before the $20K category opens the door to everything from vintage off-roaders to '90s Japanese performance cars. Along the way, the guys make the case for buying cars you can actually use, finding value in overlooked models, and remembering that you don't have to marry every car you buy. With plenty of genuinely interesting cars still available at attainable prices, the hardest part might be talking yourself out of bringing one home. If you had $5K, $10K, or $20K to spend on a fun car today, what are you buying?

  • S1 · E24
    September 9 · 46 min

    Have New Cars Gotten Too Complicated?

    *]:pointer-events-auto R6Vx5W_threadScrollVars scroll-mb-[calc(var(--scroll-root-safe-area-inset-bottom,0px)+var(--thread-response-height))] scroll-mt-[calc(var(--header-height)+min(200px,max(70px,20svh)))]" dir="auto" data-turn-id= "request-WEB:8216d286-5daf-4abe-8226-318bd6110071-42" data-turn-id-container= "request-WEB:8216d286-5daf-4abe-8226-318bd6110071-42" data-testid= "conversation-turn-86" data-turn="assistant"> In Episode 24 of Between Two Pumps, Mike Musto, Terry Shea, and Terry McGean take on the technology and features reshaping modern cars. Touchscreens controlling basic functions, questionable electronic shifters, gesture controls, turbocharged everything—some innovations have the guys wondering whether automakers have forgotten that cars still need to be intuitive to drive. But they're not against progress. Backup and 360-degree cameras, better climate control, heated and ventilated seats, Bluetooth, modern sports seats, and integrated towing technology all earn their praise. Then comes the wish list: full-size spare tires, analog gauges, traditional PRNDL shifters, mechanical parking brakes, simple fresh-air vents, and other features that disappeared somewhere along the way. What modern car feature could you live without—and what old-school feature deserves a comeback?

  • S1 · E23
    September 2 · 33 min

    The Motorcycle Rabbit Hole

    In Episode 23 of Between Two Pumps, the guys leave four wheels behind and dive into the world of motorcycles. With decades of riding experience between them, Mike Musto and Terry Shea talk about everything from the Honda CB750 and the rise of the Universal Japanese Motorcycle to the analog sport bikes of the '80s and '90s—and why motorcycles can deliver a level of immediacy and visceral excitement that even great cars can't match. Terry also finds himself in the market for his first street motorcycle, sparking a conversation about what makes a good first bike, whether to go vintage or modern, and why an inexpensive '90s or early-2000s motorcycle might be the perfect way into two wheels. Along the way, the guys revisit some of their own first bikes, favorite motorcycles, the appeal of adventure bikes, and the seemingly endless rabbit hole of motorcycles available on the Hemmings Marketplace. Plus: Why riding a motorcycle can make you a better car driver, the enduring appeal of analog machines, and one very important piece of advice for anyone thinking about getting into riding: spend more on the gear.

  • S1 · E22
    August 26 · 41 min

    Japanese Cars Changed Everything

    In Episode 22 of Between Two Pumps, Mike Musto, Terry Shea, and Terry McGean look back at the rise of Japanese cars in America, from the days when Toyota, Honda, and Datsun were dismissed as cheap economy cars to the moment they became benchmarks for quality, reliability, technology, and performance. The guys revisit the cars that changed their perceptions, from early Corollas, Civics, and Accords to the 300ZX, Celica, Supra, Prelude, and more, and explore why so many once-overlooked Japanese cars are becoming increasingly desirable collector vehicles. They also clear up what "JDM" actually means, talk about the engineering that helped Japanese manufacturers earn enthusiasts' respect, and reveal which Japanese classics they'd put in their own garages today. Plus: Is it time for a JDM project car in the Hemmings Garage? It's a nostalgic look at the cars many enthusiasts once ignored and now can't stop searching for.

  • S1 · E21
    August 19 · 51 min

    4x4s: Capability vs. Reality

    In Episode 21 of Between Two Pumps, Mike Musto, Terry McGean, and Terry Shea dig into the evolution of the 4x4, from old-school, truck-based rigs to modern SUVs and crossovers. The conversation starts with a simple question: What are you actually going to use it for? Because there's a big difference between needing legitimate off-road capability and needing all-wheel drive to get through the snow. The guys revisit everything from early Ford Explorers, Chevy Blazers, Broncos, and Jeep Cherokees to Grand Wagoneers, Wranglers, 4Runners, Land Cruisers, Range Rovers, and today's Bronco. Along the way, they debate the tradeoffs between off-road ability, highway comfort, towing capacity, reliability, size, power, and practicality—and why the best 4x4 might be the one that can do almost everything well. Plus: overlanding excess, questionable used Range Rovers, bulletproof Toyotas, and the Land Cruiser 70 Series—the "Erector Set of the 4x4 world." If you could have one 4x4 that had to handle the trail, the highway, the family, and the occasional tow, what would you choose?

  • S1 · E20
    August 12 · 39 min

    Buy the Spec, Not the Badge

    In Episode 20 of Between Two Pumps, Mike Musto, Terry Shea, and Terry McGean go hunting for the sweet spots hiding within enthusiast-car lineups; the models, trims, and option combinations that deliver most (and sometimes all) of the experience without the flagship price tag. From the Porsche 996 and early Cayman to the C6 Corvette Grand Sport, Mustang GT Track Pack, Mini Cooper, and Camaro SS 1LE, the guys dig into cars where choosing the right spec may matter more than choosing the most expensive badge. Sometimes less power, fewer options, or the supposedly "lesser" model actually makes for the better car to own and drive. The takeaway? Figure out the driving experience you actually want, learn the option sheet, and buy the car that fits you—not the one everyone tells you you're supposed to want. Because sometimes the best version of a great car is hiding in plain sight.

  • S1 · E19
    August 5 · 36 min

    What Makes the Perfect Getaway Car?

    In Episode 19 of Between Two Pumps, Mike Musto, Terry Shea, and Terry McGean tackle one of the most entertaining hypothetical debates yet: What is the ultimate getaway car? Starting with a tongue-in-cheek movie scenario involving corrupt zombie cops, the guys put a wide range of vehicles to the test, weighing everything from agility and durability to all-wheel drive, ground clearance, top speed, fuel range, and real-world survivability. Along the way, they debate the merits of the Porsche 911 Dakar, Jeep Grand Cherokee Trackhawk, BMW M5, Ford Lightning, and several other unexpected contenders, ultimately narrowing the field to two finalists. It's a hilarious conversation filled with movie references, spirited arguments, and surprisingly thoughtful automotive analysis that proves choosing the perfect escape vehicle isn't nearly as simple as picking the fastest car. Which would you choose—the Porsche 911 Dakar, the Jeep Trackhawk, or something else entirely? Let us know in the comments.

  • S1 · E18
    July 29 · 1 hr 4 min

    The Weird Side of Car Collecting

    In Episode 18 of Between Two Pumps, Mike Musto, Terry Shea, and Terry McGean dive deep into the wonderfully weird side of the collector car hobby, each bringing five of the most unusual, obscure, and unexpected vehicles they could find on Hemmings. From Nissan Figaros, Tatra Type 77s, and Euro-spec BMWs to military Jeep trucks, French grand tourers, Model T snowmobile conversions, and even Italian vineyard utility vehicles, the guys celebrate the incredible variety that makes the collector car hobby so fascinating. Along the way, they debate forgotten automotive engineering, gray-market gems, military oddities, French styling, rare imports, and why discovering cars you've never even heard of is one of the greatest joys of being a car enthusiast. If you could own one truly unusual collector car, what would it be? Let us know in the comments.

  • S1 · E17
    July 22 · 46 min

    The Cars We'll NEVER Sell

    In Episode 17 of Between Two Pumps, Mike Musto, Terry McGean, and Terry Shea swap stories about the forever cars in their garages and why, despite decades of new models, more horsepower, and better technology, nothing has been able to replace them. From Terry's long-loved Focus RS and BMW M Coupe to Terry's Fox-body Mustang and Mike's beloved '68 Charger, the guys explore what transforms a car from a possession into part of your identity. Along the way, they debate modern performance cars versus analog icons, the thrill of configuring your dream car, whether today's vehicles still create lifelong emotional connections, and why sometimes the smartest automotive decision is simply keeping the keys to the one that still makes you look back every time you park it.

  • S1 · E16
    July 15 · 46 min

    Cars We'd Bring Back From the Dead

    In Episode 16 of Between Two Pumps, Mike Musto, Terry Shea, and Terry McGean resurrect the cars and nameplates they think deserve another shot. Terry Shea makes the case for a modern Ford Crown Victoria: big, rear-wheel drive, V8-powered, and finally given the enthusiast treatment Ford never quite delivered. Mike dreams up a reborn second-generation Trans Am with the elegance of an Aston Martin, the attitude of American muscle, and, yes, a screaming chicken. And Terry McGean argues for the return of the great American rear-wheel-drive performance sedan, looking back at cars like the Chevrolet SS, Pontiac G8, and the Impala SS. Along the way, the guys debate what makes retro design work, why some modern interpretations completely miss the mark, whether four-door muscle cars have finally earned their place, and the bigger question: If automakers actually built the cars enthusiasts say they want, would anyone buy them? It's part dream garage, part automotive product-planning meeting, and probably a good reminder of why none of these guys work for an OEM.

  • S1 · E15
    July 8 · 1 hr 8 min

    The Cars We Never Should Have Sold

    In Episode 15 of Between Two Pumps, Mike Musto, Terry Shea, and Terry McGean get personal as they confess the cars they never should have sold, the purchases they probably should regret (but don't), and the smartest automotive decisions they've ever made. From a fuselage-era Chrysler Newport and a rare GMC Sprint SP to an E30 M3, Porsche 968, Volkswagen GTIs, and a 928 that exceeded every expectation, the guys revisit the cars that shaped their lives—along with the stories, missed opportunities, and hard-earned lessons that came with them. Whether you've sold your dream car, bought a questionable project, or still think about the one that got away, this episode is a reminder that the best car stories are often about the decisions we wish we could undo.

Showing 1–20 of 20 episodes