Skip to content
Artwork for Weird True Crime

Weird True Crime

Gina Nichols and Amber Paul

Weird True Crime is the ultimate podcast for fans of bizarre, lesser-known, and jaw-dropping true crime stories. Hosted by Gina Nichols and Amber Paul, these lifelong besties explore strange crimes that will leave you stunned. They dive into ethical, victim-focused storytelling with family interviews that bring humanity to the forefront of the narrative.Every episode of Weird True Crime unravels mysterious cases, unsolved crimes, and shocking events you won’t believe are real. Need a lighter take? Tune in biweekly for WTF Wednesday, where Gina and Amber share hilarious stories of dumb criminals, true crime history, and other oddball crime tales guaranteed to make you laugh.As part of the Weird True Crime family, you’ll join a growing community of "little skeletons" led by our quirky mascot, Billy the Skelly, who guides you through these wild and fascinating tales.Whether searching for podcasts about true crime, strange cases, ethical storytelling, or even light-hearted crime stories, Weird True Crime offers a unique blend of heart, humor, and spine-tingling content.Subscribe today on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or your favorite podcast platform, and let Gina, Amber, and Billy take you on an unforgettable journey into the weirdest corners of crime.Weird True Crime is a Fire Eyes Media LLC production.Instagram: www.instagram.com/weirdtruecrimeTikTok: www.tiktok.com/weirdtruecrimeYouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@WeirdTrueCrimeFacebook: https://www.facebook.com/weirdtruecrimeBecome a supporter of this podcast: https://www.spreaker.com/podcast/weird-true-crime--5679751/support.

Play
  • 24 episodes
  • Avg 40 min
  • English
Counted on this page — what you have heard stays on this device, so it is not something the list can be paged by.
  • #179
    Wednesday · 41 min

    Lizzie Borden: A Case That Never Closed

    On August 4th, 1892, Andrew and Abby Borden were found murdered in their Fall River, Massachusetts home, killed with a hatchet-like weapon. Their daughter Lizzie was tried and acquitted the following year, and no one else was ever charged. In this episode, Gina and Amber dig into the Borden family's backstory and the Fall River mill town they lived in, walk through the tense weeks leading up to the murders, the documented case itself, the evidence that never added up on either side, the long list of alternate suspects the case has produced over 130-plus years, and the decades of reported hauntings at the house, which is now a bed and breakfast. Sources Lizzie Borden case page — Unsolved Mysteries official site Suspects of the Borden Murders — lizzieandrewborden.com "Lizzie Borden's Eighty-One Whacks: Table-Tipping Testimony from a Spirit?" — Joe Nickell, Skeptical Inquirer, Mar/Apr 2020 Inquest Testimony of Lizzie Borden — famous-trials.com 'Monster: The Lizzie Borden Story' Hits 12.1 Million Views in Four Days — Variety The Complete Timeline of the Lizzie Borden Murder Trial — Biography.com Weird True Crime is an independent true crime podcast. If this episode moved you, please share it. 📢 Follow & Subscribe: Subscribe on Patreon: www.patreon.com/weirdtruecrime Website: www.weirdtruecrime.com Instagram: www.instagram.com/weirdtruecrime TikTok: www.tiktok.com/weirdtruecrime YouTube: www.youtube.com/@weirdtruecrime Email: weirdtruecrime@gmail.com ⭐ Leave a 5-star review if you enjoy the show Proud Member of Fire Eyes Media LLC Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

  • Tuesday · 3 min

    Introducing Secrets Beyond the Sacramento River | An Investigative True Crime Podcast

    What happened to Jeff Anderson? Secrets Beyond the Sacramento River is an investigative true crime podcast hosted by Jules Thorp and Jen Rivera, seeking answers about Jeff Anderson’s suspicious death. Jeff was just 40 years old when his car entered the Sacramento River on the evening of September 9, 2023. Despite 911 calls from eyewitnesses identifying where his car entered the water, Jeff and his vehicle were not recovered until September 13, four days later. Upon recovery, law enforcement removed Jeff’s car key from the front pocket of his pants. His car’s transmission was in park. Inconsistent accounts of Jeff’s final hours have raised more questions than answers. Was Jeff assaulted? Was he helped to his car after leaving a bar and taken to the water? Was he drugged? Was he in emotional distress? Written statements submitted to law enforcement describe eyewitnesses reporting two cars that evening, not one. When law enforcement followed up, those eyewitnesses denied ever making that claim. Why? We’ll share dispatch recordings, incident reports, and toxicology findings as we ask: Was this a horrific accident, or was the case closed without a proper investigation? Why did the private investigator hired by Jeff’s family take years to provide a report? How did Jeff’s car allegedly roll from a complete stop on a flat road, make a 90-degree turn, and enter the water? Why were there attempts to access his digital accounts after his death? Why wasn’t his case investigated as a suspected homicide? The accounts Jeff’s family received from law enforcement raise even more questions. We’ll examine witness accounts, police reports, the autopsy report, interviews, written statements, and our documented attempts to communicate with Sheriff Cooper and the District Attorney. It’s time to seek answers to the questions we believe law enforcement should have asked before closing Jeff’s case. Secrets Beyond the Sacramento River is available now wherever you listen to podcasts. Search “Secrets Beyond the Sacramento River” and start listening. A Fire Eyes Media Network podcast Hosts and producers: Jules Thorp and Jen Rivera Podcast script: Jules Thorp Audio engineering and editing: Jen Rivera Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.

  • #178
    September 4 · 47 min

    Bonus: Advocacy Con with Eric Carter-Landin & Whitney St. Andre

    In this special edition of Weird True Crime, Gina sits down with Whitney St. Andre (co-host of *Navigating Advocacy*) and Eric Carter Landin (host of *True Consequences*) to talk about AdvocacyCon — a one-of-a-kind conference built for families of the missing and murdered, happening September 11–13 at the Albuquerque Convention Center. Eric shares his deeply personal story of fighting for justice for his brother Jacob, who was murdered in 1987, and how decades of being failed by the legal system

  • #177
    September 2 · 44 min

    What Melissa Left | Episode 6: Undetermined

    Melissa Casias's long awaited autopsy report is finally in, and in this episode, Gina and Amber break down exactly what it says, including new context from the Mondragon family about the remote stone basin where Melissa was found, and why it doesn't match what NMSP originally told them. They walk through the gunshot trajectory, the toxicology findings that are still incomplete, and why forensic experts, including former FBI Special Agent Daniel Bruner, are questioning whether the manner of death

  • #176
    August 26 · 28 min

    UNSOLVED SKYJACKING || D.B. Cooper | Your Host Jules (guest episode)

    As the rest of the country was settling in and finalizing holiday meals, a man in his mid forties with unremarkable features, yet a quiet and steady demeanor walks through the Portland International Airport. It’s Thanksgiving Eve, Nov 24th, 1971. He approaches the ticket agent at Northwest Orient Airlines and requests to purchase a one- way ticket to Seattle aboard flight 305- a mere 25 minute journey in the air. The Boeing 727 holds the man, and 36 other passengers. He is kindly served a bourbo

  • #175
    August 12 · 1 hr

    WTF Wednesday || Reddit AITA Ridiculousness

    Your weekly dumpster fire just got an upgrade. This week, Amber and Gina are diving headfirst into Reddit's AITA (Am I The Asshole?) forum — and they pulled 10 of the most unhinged, hilarious, and genuinely jaw-dropping threads they could find.From a lactose-intolerant food thief who gets the worst kind of karma, to a man who handed his wife a formal performance review, to a husband trying to get his recovering wife to sign mystery documents blindfolded — the bar is on the floor, and Reddit has

  • #174
    August 5 · 58 min

    'Heavenly Creatures' || The Murder of Honora Parker

    Join the Facebook Group and join the conversation: https://www.facebook.com/groups/weirdtruecrimeIn 1954, two teenage best friends in Christchurch, New Zealand, Pauline Parker and Juliet Hulme, murdered Pauline's mother, Honora Parker, in Victoria Park, staging her death to look like an accident. The girls, whose intense and consuming friendship had alarmed both of their families, killed Honora after learning she opposed their plan to stay together once Juliet's family moved to South Africa. Bot

  • #173
    July 29 · 48 min

    The Prince of Fraud: The Many Lives of Anthony Gignac | WTF Wednesday

    For nearly thirty years, Anthony Gignac, born Jose Enrique Moreno on the streets of Colombia, posed as Saudi royalty to con hotels, department stores, a university, and eventually a group of ultra wealthy international investors out of millions of dollars. From a sixth grade Mercedes scam to a two hundred million dollar American Express card to an eight million dollar investment fraud scheme, Anthony's story is one of the boldest and strangest cons in recent memory, and it came at a real human c

  • #172
    July 22 · 43 min

    Letecia Stauch & Gannon Stauch || The Case Revisited: Part 3 of 3

    In the final episode of this series, Gina and Amber cover Leticia Stauch's murder trial, three years after Gannon's death. Leticia pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity, with her defense arguing she suffered from dissociative identity disorder as a result of childhood trauma. Prosecutors pointed to her shifting statements to police, the deliberate steps she took to conceal what happened to Gannon, and a recorded interview in which she admitted to fatally shooting him. In May 2023, a jury conv

  • #171
    July 22 · 1 hr 24 min

    Letecia Stauch & Gannon Stauch || The Case Revisited: Part 2 of 3

    In part two, Gina and Amber cover the break that changed everything: the discovery of a piece of blood-stained particle board near the Stauch home, and the trail of evidence that led investigators over a thousand miles away to Myrtle Beach, South Carolina, where Leticia Stauch was ultimately arrested.This episode covers the forensic details that built the case against her, including Gannon's blood found on her shoe, her DNA recovered from a firearm connected to his death, and phone and travel re

  • #170
    July 22 · 1 hr 17 min

    Letecia Stauch & Gannon Stauch || The Case Revisited: Part 1 of 3

    On January 27, 2020, 11-year-old Gannon Stauch vanished from his home in Colorado Springs, Colorado, sparking one of the most closely watched missing child cases in the state's history. His stepmother, Leticia Stauch, told police he had been picked up by a friend's family and never returned. Within days, that story began to unravel.In this episode, Gina and Amber walk through Gannon's disappearance hour by hour: the initial 911 call, the massive search effort that followed, and the early inconsi

  • #169
    July 15 · 46 min

    Murdered || The Harper Brothers & the Alabama Axe Murderess

    Quick note from WTC: If you wouldn't mind taking a moment to leave us a 5 star review or rating wherever you're listening right now- it would help our stories get pushed into podcast player algorithims! Each 5 star review helps us continue to grow and get more stories to more listeners. xox G & AIn the summer of 1959, a farmer picking blackberries along U.S. Highway 11 in Etowah County, Alabama, made a discovery no one could have prepared for: a human torso. No arms. No legs. Face beaten past re

  • #168
    July 8 · 23 min

    What Melissa Left || Episode 5: May 28th

    In Episode 5, Amber and Gina cover the discovery of Melissa Casias's remains in McGaffy Ridge, Carson National Forest on May 28th, 2026 — eleven months after she disappeared. They walk through what was found at the scene, the evidence concerns raised by the family's attorney, the forensic questions still being pursued, the suicide narrative and why the evidence pushes back on it, and the next steps in the civil investigation led by attorney David Adams of Parnall and Adams. Everything shared in

  • #167
    July 8 · 23 min

    What Melissa Left || Episode 4: The Call

    In June 2025, Melissa Casias — a devoted mother, daughter, and sister — vanished from Taos, New Mexico, leaving everything she owned behind. Eleven months later, in May 2026, her remains were found in Carson National Forest. In this episode of Weird True Crime, hosts Amber and Gina reveal the new evidence that reframes everything: neighbors who reported Mark Casias asking about their security cameras in the days before Melissa disappeared, a woman's scream heard from the home at 1:45 p.m. on Jun

  • #166
    July 1 · 1 hr 13 min

    WTF Wednesday: True Crime Chat with Dani After Dark

    We’re mixing things up this week! Join us as we chat with Dani After Dark about all things true crime - what got us into podcasting, ethical storytelling, the cases that stick with us, and the most important question - what kind of pets do we have?!Gina and Amber talk about the importance of advocacy in true crime, what makes us stand out in such a large niche, and the cases that stick with us - like Ryan Waller and Melissa Casias. Make sure to subscribe to Dani on Youtube and follow her on soci

  • #165
    June 24 · 39 min

    The Robert Fisher Case: A Family Murdered, A Father Gone

    On the morning of April 10, 2001, a home in Scottsdale, Arizona exploded. Inside, investigators found the bodies of Mary Fisher, 38, and her two children — Brittney, 12, and Bobby, 10 — still in their beds. All three had been killed before the fire started. The father, Robert Fisher, was nowhere to be found. He has never been seen since.In this episode of Weird True Crime, Amber and Gina walk through the full story of the Fisher family — from Robert's childhood and the divorce that scarred him,

  • #164
    June 17 · 42 min

    WTF Wednesday: Florida Man Round Two!

    Florida Man is back, and he brought friends. After our first Florida Man episode had you absolutely losing it, we knew it was only a matter of time before we had to revisit the Sunshine State's most unhinged residents. This week on WTF Wednesdays, Gina and Amber are bringing you ten brand new Florida Man (and one Florida Woman) stories that prove truth is always, always stranger than fiction. Buckle up, because the Questionable Decision Olympics have officially begun.📢 Follow & Subscribe:Subscr

  • #163
    June 10 · 24 min

    The Little Girl Who Vanished: HaLeigh Cummings || Part 2

    Disclaimer: Gina tried to do something new with her audio set up and failed miserably. Please forgive her underwater sound this week. Part two of our deep dive into the HaLeigh Cummings case picks up where the investigation gets darker — and more complicated. Within days of HaLeigh's disappearance, Misty Croslin's story had already changed multiple times. She gave different versions to law enforcement and the media, failed every polygraph she took (despite publicly claiming otherwise), and inves

  • #162
    June 10 · 20 min

    The Little Girl Who Vanished: HaLeigh Cummings || Part 1

    Disclaimer: Gina tried to do something new with her audio set up and failed miserably. Please forgive her underwater sound this week. On February 10, 2009, five-year-old HaLeigh Ann-Marie Cummings vanished from her home in Satsuma, Florida — a small rural community along the St. Johns River in Putnam County. Her disappearance became one of the most heartbreaking and confounding missing child cases in Florida true crime history. In this episode of Weird True Crime, hosts Amber and Gina introduce

Showing 1–20 of 24 episodes