Skip to content
Artwork for Weekly Movie Throwdown
TV & FilmFilm ReviewsFilm History

Weekly Movie Throwdown

Movie Throwdown

Each week on the Weekly Movie Throwdown, hosts Mike Messineo and Steven Seighman compare two movies with striking similarities—whether it’s a release year, competing franchises, remake vs. original, or movies that share a genre or premise. Through in-depth film analysis, lively debate, and sharp humor, they break down performances, directing, screenwriting, cinematography, cultural impact, and rewatchability to decide which movie truly comes out on top.

If you love passionate discussions about cinema, this is your weekly showdown.

Folllow the show on social media and cast your vote for each week's winner!

YOUTUBE: youtube.com/@MovieThrowdownPod
INSTAGRAM: instagram.com/moviethrowdownpod/
TIKTOK: tiktok.com/@moviethrowdownpod
THREADS: threads.com/@moviethrowdownpod
FACEBOOK: facebook.com/moviethrowdownpod
LETTERBOXD: letterboxd.com/moviethrowdown/
Play
  • 31 episodes
  • weekly
  • Avg 1 hr 40 min
  • English
Counted on this page — what you have heard stays on this device, so it is not something the list can be paged by.
  • #137
    Yesterday · 1 hr 46 min

    Episode 137: Training Day (2001) vs. Narc (2002)

    On this week's episode, it's a throwdown between two corrupt cop films. Antoine Fuqua's TRAINING DAY (2001), starring Denzel Washington and Ethan Hawke, goes up against NARC (2002), from writer/director Joe Carnahan and starring Jason Patric and Ray...

  • #136
    November 10 · 1 hr 36 min

    Episode 136: The Spanish Prisoner (1997) vs. Confidence (2003)

    This week, the con-artist theme continues. In The Spanish Prisoner (1997), written and directed by David Mamet, Campbell Scott and Steve Martin star in a twist-filled tale of paranoia. Confidence (2003), directed by James Foley, follows Ed Burns and...

  • #135
    November 3 · 1 hr 42 min

    Episode 135: Dirty Rotten Scoundrels (1988) vs. Heartbreakers (2001)

    This week's episode features a throwdown between two con-job comedies. 1988's Dirty Rotten Scoundrels takes on Heartbreakers from 2001. It's men versus women in these two stories of swindling and romance, with big-time stars like Steve Martin, Michael...

  • October 27 · 1 hr 27 min

    Episode 134: Jennifer's Body (2009) vs. Lisa Frankenstein (2024)

    This week on the show, it's a throwdown between two Diablo Cody-penned screenplays. 2009's Jennifer's Body, directed by Karyn Kusama, goes up against Zelda Williams's Lisa Frankenstein from 2024. Both have that signature Cody banter, but each one is...

  • #133
    October 20 · 1 hr 56 min

    Episode 133: The Lost Boys (1987) vs. Near Dark (1987)

    This week on the podcast, friend of the show, Andy Remondino, joins us for another spooky season episode. It's a throwdown between two 1987 vampire films, as Joel Schumacher's The Lost Boys goes up against Kathryn Bigelow's Near Dark. Two similar...

  • #132
    October 6 · 1 hr 35 min

    Episode 132: It Follows (2014) vs. Smile (2022)

    This week on the podcast, we kick off Spooky Season with a throwdown between two very similar horror films. David Robert Mitchell's It Follows (2014) tells the story of a young woman tormented by a supernatural entity that trails her wherever she...

  • #131
    September 29 · 1 hr 44 min

    131: The Secret of My Success vs. For Love or Money

    This week on the show, we look at two films from eighties icon Michael J. Fox. Beyond Back to the Future, he had a big-screen career for over a decade. Our throwdown is between two of the more prominent features of that time: 1987's The Secret of My...

  • #130
    September 18 · 2 hr 3 min

    Episode 130: New Jack City vs. American Gangster

    This week on the show, it's a throwdown between Harlem drug kingpins, as 1991's New Jack City goes up against 2007's American Gangster. These films have a lot in common, but also tell their stories in very different ways. One is from a first-time...

  • #129
    September 8 · 1 hr 36 min

    Episode 129: Cape Fear (1962) vs. Cape Fear (1991)

    This week it's an original vs. remake throwdown on the show. Directed by J. Lee Thompson, 1962's Cape Fear stars Robert Mitchum and Gregory Peck and tells the tale of a newly released criminal with a vendetta. Its counterpart, the 1991 version...

  • #128
    September 1 · 1 hr 37 min

    Episode 128: Under Siege (1992) vs. Mutiny (2026)

    This week, the show gets back to basics with some early '90s action. In a throwdown between Die Hard-on-a-boat films as 1992's Under Siege takes on 2026's Mutiny. It's Seagal vs Statham in this battle for the ages that you won't want to miss.Folllow...

  • #127
    August 25 · 1 hr 33 min

    Episode 127: Clueless vs. Emma

    This week's episode is a throwdown between two retellings of Jane Austen's classic novel, Emma. Amy Heckerling's Clueless from 1995 sets the story in the present day, while Emma., Autumn De Wilde's 2020 adaptation stays true to the original. Which one...

  • #126
    August 18 · 1 hr 53 min

    Episode 126: Jerry Maguire vs. Chef

    This week's episode is a throwdown between two films about men who must redefine themselves after losing their careers—and their identities. In 1996's Jerry Maguire, Tom Cruise plays the titular character, lost in a world of soulless sports agents....

  • #125
    August 11 · 1 hr 35 min

    Episode 125: Get Hard vs. Central Intelligence

    This week's throwdown features two mid-2010s Kevin Hart comedies. Get Hard, co-starring Will Ferrell, goes up against Central Intelligence, with co-star Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson. Both are fun in their own way, but in which one does funnyman Kevin...

  • #124
    August 4 · 1 hr 54 min

    Episode 124: The Invitation vs. The Menu

    On this week's episode, it's a battle of the dinner-party-from-hell films as The Invitation from 2015 takes on 2022's The Menu—two cult-centric meals with dire consequences! Both are excellent, which makes it tough to choose. Tune in for this fun and...

  • #123
    July 28 · 1 hr 34 min

    Episode 123: Blue Ruin vs. Rebel Ridge

    This week on the show, it's a throwdown between Jeremy Saulnier films. One of the director's earliest films, the micro-budgeted Blue Ruin from 2013, goes up against 2024's Netflix-produced Rebel Ridge. It's a fun examination of how his style changed...

  • #122
    July 21 · 1 hr 29 min

    Episode 122: Notting Hill vs. Runaway Bride

    This week, it's a throwdown between two 1999 Julia Roberts rom-coms, Notting Hill and Runaway Bride. Both have their own merits—and pitfalls. It's a great matchup, and a great conversation filled with hot takes. Give it a listen!Folllow the show on...

  • #121
    July 14 · 1 hr 24 min

    Episode 121: Phone Booth vs. The Guilty

    On this week's episode, it's a throwdown between to exceptional guy-on-the-phone films, as 2002's Phone Booth goes up against The Guilty from 2021. Which one walks away with the title? Tune in and find out!Folllow the show on social media and vote for...

  • #119
    June 30 · 1 hr 46 min

    Episode 119: Point Break vs. The Fast and the Furious

    It's often said that Rob Cohen's The Fast and the Furious from 2001 is the same film as Kathryn Bigelow's Point Break from 1991, but with cars instead of surfboards. Well this week on the show, Mike and Steven get to the bottom of that notion and talk...

  • #118
    June 23 · 1 hr 28 min

    Episode 118: Close Encounters of the Third Kind vs. Disclosure Day

    On this week's episode, we delve into the world of Steven Spielberg with a throwdown between two of his most discussed sci-fi films. Close Encounters of the Third Kind from 1977 goes up against Disclosure Day, which is in theaters now. It's an...

Showing 1–20 of 31 episodes