Watch For Deer

Episode 93: Pet Cemetery

Some things are better left buried… but this story proves that even the dead can't always rest in peace. This week on Watch for Deer, we're digging into the chilling true story behind the Pet Cemetery Murders. A twisted tale of dark secrets, disturbing discoveries, and murder that'll leave you wondering what kind of evil walks among us. Grab your coffee, lock your doors, and settle in, y'all. This one's darker than a holler at midnight.

Episode 92: The Circleville Letters

It started with anonymous letters filled with secrets, accusations, and threats. But in Circleville, Ohio, the letters didn’t stop. Soon there was a suspicious death, a booby-trapped gun, an arrest—and one massive problem: the letters reportedly kept coming even after the suspected writer was behind bars. This week on Watch for Deer, we’re digging into the Circleville Letters and the question that still hangs over this strange Ohio mystery: Who was really writing them? Sources/show notes: CBS News / 48 Hours — “The Circleville Letters” CBS News — forensic document analysis Circleville / Pickaway County case background

Episode 93: The Unsolved Murder of Valeri Brooks

In this episode of Watch for Deer, I’m joined by missing and unsolved persons advocate A. Paul to discuss the unsolved case of Valeri Brooks from Versailles, Kentucky. We walk through Valeri’s story, the unanswered questions surrounding her case, and why keeping her name and story alive still matters.

Episode 91: The Gray Man, Albert Fish

Behind the appearance of a harmless old man was something far more sinister. In this episode of Watch for Deer, we unravel the disturbing case of Albert Fish, the disappearance of Grace Budd, the horrifying letter that exposed him, and the investigation that finally brought his secrets to light. Dark, unsettling, and difficult to believe, this is one of the most infamous cases in American true crime. Listener discretion is strongly advised. Sources used: Deranged by Harold Schechter & Albert Fish in his own words by John Borowshi.

Welcome to Watch For Deer

Welcome to Watch For Deer! We’re digging into infamous killers, forgotten crimes, Appalachian mysteries, bizarre history, and the cases that make you lock the door… even though you know damn well you live in the middle of nowhere

Episode 90: Soap Maker of Correggio

In this episode, we dive into the disturbing case of Leonarda Cianciulli, the Italian serial killer better known as the Soap-Maker of Correggio. Between 1939 and 1940, Cianciulli murdered three women, dismembered their bodies, and claimed to have turned parts of her victims into soap and teacakes. We explore the superstition, fear, and obsession with protecting her son that she said drove her crimes—and the gruesome details that made her one of Italy’s most infamous killers. Dark, bizarre, and definitely not your average soap-making story. Source: Book by Ryan Green The Curse: A Shocking True Story of Superstition, Human Sacrifice and Cannibalism

Episode 89: The Tylenol Murders

In 1982, seven people in the Chicago area died after taking Extra-Strength Tylenol capsules that had been secretly laced with cyanide. The victims ranged from a 12-year-old girl, Mary Kellerman, to adults who unknowingly purchased the tampered bottles from local stores. Panic spread nationwide as investigators discovered the poisonings were random, terrifying, and likely carried out after the products hit store shelves. The case sparked one of the largest criminal investigations in U.S. history, led to a massive Tylenol recall, and forever changed consumer safety with the introduction of tamper-proof packaging. More than 40 years later, the murders remain unsolved. Sources: Netflix Documentary, FBI Case Summary, CNN

• Transcript

Episode 88: Ted Bundy

The girls are back and with a story! But first, we catch up on life so if you aren't a fan of the banter, skip ahead! This episode the girls discuss that POS Ted Bundy. More conversational style but yet informative. Sources: Ted Bundy: Conversation With a Killer by Stephen G Michael and Hugh Aynesworth The Stranger Beside Me by Ann Rule

• Transcript

Episode 87: John Wayne Gacy Live at Creekside!

What an amazing time we had hosting our first live show at Creekside Golf course! This is our live episode of the case of John Wayne Gacy! Sources: Buried Dreams by Tim Cahill, Killer Clown by Terry Sullivan, and 1992 Interview w/ Robert Ressler.

• Transcript

Episode 86: The Psychology Behind Female Serial Killers

During this episode, we dive into the psychology of female serial killers and why there aren't as many females as there are males. We examine the difference in their MO, what victims they prefer to target, and what potential backgrounds could cause such violent behavior in women. Source: Female Serial Killers: How and Why, They Become Monsters by Peter Vronsky

• Transcript

Episode 85: Christa Pike

Christa Pike was born and raised in Beckley, West Virginia, and her early life was marked by instability and neglect. At just 18, she murdered fellow Job Corps student Colleen Slemmer in a case fueled by jealousy, manipulation, and systemic failure. Pike later became the youngest woman sentenced to death in modern U.S. history. Sources: Kim Iloilo State Court Documents

• Transcript

Episode 84: Poisoned by Protein

In July of 2025, James Craig would be sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole for premediated murder of his wife, Angela Craig. Come listen as we discuss the terrible case in depth and learn what drove the dentist to commit such an awful crime. Sources: BBC.com, ABCnews.com, CNN, The Colorado Sun.

• Transcript

Episode 83: The Collar Bomb

In this chilling episode, Samantha dives into the mysterious and harrowing case of the collar bomb heist. In 2003, a pizza delivery driver was forced to wear a bomb around his neck and sent on his way to complete a dangerous scavenger hunt leading to a tragic and shocking conclusion. Sources: Netflix Documentary Evil Genius, allthatsinteresting.com, people.com.

• Transcript

Episode 82: Murder of Deanna Crawford

In 2002, the body of 21-year-old Deanna Crawford was found in a remote area in Salt Rock, WV. Her case remained cold until in 2007 when four local men were arrested on conflicting evidence. Come listen to the awful case that was full of recanted statements, finger pointing, and exonerations before a possible 5th subject would even enter the case. Sources used: https://www.courtswv.gov; https://innocenceproject.org; The Luminolpod; Herald-Dispatch.com; wsaz.com; abcnews.com; forensicmag.com

• Transcript

Episode 81: Shawn Grate

A 911 call in 2016 would not only save the life of an abducted woman, it would also lead investigators to numerous other remains. Shawn Grate murdered several woman from 2006 to 2016. Sources: A Hunger to Kill by Kim Mager, Wiki, Cold Blooded Charmer by Jesse Dixon

• Transcript

Episode 80: Ed Gein

In this episode the girls talk about the true story of Ed Gein. Not any of that fictional stuff that had romanticized his story. It's rough, graphic, and he was depraved so tread with caution! Sources: Unhinged: The Horrific True Story of Ed Gein the Butcher of Plainfield by Robert Keller The Ed Gein File: A Psycho's Confession and Case Documents by John Borowski Wiki Netflix Show Monster: Ed Gein

• Transcript

Episode 79: IHOP and not the Pancake House

On this episode, Alisa and Samantha discuss the potential cult church IHOPKC, International House of Prayer Kansas City. Known for it's continuously streaming of live worship and prayer, IHOPKC came under scrutiny when its founder, Mike Bickle had allegedly used his position of authority to manipulate and sexually assault at least 17 women, with two of them being minors. If you were hoping for pancakes and hashbrowns, this episode is not for you! Sources Used: Wiki, Ministry Watch.com, Book by Bob Scott Some Say They Blundered

• Transcript

Episode 78: Heath High Shooting

**TRIGGER SCHOOL SHOOTING*** During this episode we discuss the horrendous case of the West Paducah KY Heath High shooting that happened in 1997. While it is hard to believe, school shootings weren't common when this happened. What led to the tragic event? Sources: I Choose to be Happy: A School Shooting Survivor's Triumph Over Tragedy by Missy Jenkins/William Croyle https://www.courier-journal.com Wiki

• Transcript

Episode 77: The Haunting of Fox Hollow Farm

Fox Hollow Farm, a sprawling estate in Indiana, was once home to serial killer Herb Baumeister, who is believed to have murdered over 20 men on the property in the 1990s. After his death, the estate was purchased by the Graves family, who quickly discovered they weren’t alone. Sources: Documentary The Fox Hollow Murders: Playground of a Serial Killer Ghost Adventures: Season 9, Episide 9 Book by Richard Estep with Richard Graves, The Horrors of Fox Hollow Farm

• Transcript

Episode 76: Herb Baumeister and Fox Hollow Farm Part 2

!Trigger! During this episode, we go deeper into who his victims were and learn how the reign of terror he caused, comes to a close. Sources: All sources used in episode 74 were used in this one.

• Transcript