Will New Law Make 'Trans' People Unemployable? (Ft. Dennis Kavanagh)
New legislation claims to protect ‘trans’ people in the UK - but could it accidentally kill their career prospects? Tanya de Grunwald is joined by Dennis Kavanagh, a criminal barrister and director of the Gay Men’s Network, to look at the government’s draft conversion practices bill - and what it means for employers (and employees). The pitch is that the bill bans electrocution, exorcisms and other horrors aimed at gay people. But Dennis says the drafting goes much further. It criminalises any conduct, including words, intended to change someone’s sexuality or “transgender identity”, if a jury later decides it was abusive and caused serious distress. You don’t need to have intended any harm - and the maximum sentence is five years imprisonment. For employers, the most worrying part is Clause 5, which brings in corporate liability. That means companies face unlimited fines, and directors can be prosecuted for failing to take “reasonable steps” to prevent an offence. Most of the public debate has been about families, faith and free speech. Almost nobody is talking about what this means for employers. Until now. Tanya and Dennis ask: - What evidence is there that conversion therapy is still happening in the UK? If the practices are already considered to be crimes, why is new legislation needed? - What risks does Clause 5 create for organisations when managing trans-identified employees, and creating lawful policies to accommodate them? Could a manager telling a male employee to use the men’s toilets, as the For Women Scotland ruling and EHRC guidance allow, be reported as a “conversion practice”? - How can gender-critical beliefs be protected under the Equality Act in a civil court, yet potentially a criminal offence in another? - Who can report whom, and for how long? Dennis explains why there’s no need to show the issue affects you, no statute of limitations, and the possibility of private prosecutions. - What is a “reverse burden”, and why could it create a temptation for employers to over-comply with whatever template policies Stonewall and other activist groups produce next? - Could “economic pressure”, one of the bill’s vaguest terms, catch employers who have these staff on their payroll? - After the Supreme Court ruling opened up honest workplace conversations, will this bill chill them again, just as private-sector employers had started getting it right? - And the big one: if hiring someone with a trans identity brings criminal risk as well as civil risk, will employers quietly stop hiring them? Tanya shares what she heard from HR directors and recruiters. One called the bill “an absolute car crash”. A headhunter warned that, in the worst case, people simply won’t hire trans people. Tanya fears the real casualties will be young people. Many are autistic or same-sex attracted, some are estranged from their families, and they were told the world would welcome them and their identity should be front and centre at interview. Dennis explains why they’d have almost no chance of proving discrimination in the recruitment process. The employer holds all the cards, and savvy ones don’t leave a breadcrumb trail. Concerned employers still have time to act. With pre-legislative scrutiny underway, Dennis urges employers, lawyers, recruiters and risk professionals to submit evidence on Clause 5. That means explaining the compliance costs, the risks - and the ironic, foreseeable result that a bill launched with “rainbow fanfare” could end up causing direct discrimination. Enjoy the episode... Draft Conversion Practices Bill - Submit evidence your here https://committees.parliament.uk/submission/4010/#/evidence/4010/call-for-evidence More info about the bill Sex Matters https://sex-matters.org/posts/updates/conversion-practices-bill-who-is-at-risk-of-criminalisation/ Gay Men's Network https://www.gaymensnetwork.co.uk/ Double Jeopardy podcast (Ft. Sarah Vine KC) https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/the-conversion-practices-bill-necessary-or/id1633485236?i=1000793564077 Follow Dennis Kavanagh on X https://x.com/Jebadoo2