Skip to content
Artwork for Thinking about...
HistorySociety & Culture

Thinking about...

Timothy Snyder

The words we need for the politics of today.

snyder.substack.com
Play
  • 54 episodes
  • Avg 26 min
  • English
Counted on this page — what you have heard stays on this device, so it is not something the list can be paged by.
  • Yesterday · 34 min

    Now We Act: With Rep.-Elect Brad Lander on Cooperation vs. Corruption

    It was a great pleasure to speak with Brad Lander, who has just been elected from to Congress, from a background in affordable housing and service in the New York City municipal government. He’s known for many things, including his endorsement of Zohran Mamdani for New York mayor (after running himself), for going to Minnesota in January, and for being arrested by ICE and being detained by the IDF. We talked about the resonance of principle and courage around the country, including in Minneapolis, and the importance of authenticity as allowing us to cooperate with people with whom we recognize and respect — even though we may not agree about everything. These unscripted conversations with lawmakers are about how we get from a big majority to political transformation. This is one of six that were live on Monday; I will be sending out the recordings today and tomorrow. There should be a couple new ones Thursday. If you are subscribed you will get a notice of all this; if you are a paid subscriber feel free to leave your questions in the comments and I will do my best to work some of them in. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit snyder.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • Yesterday · 26 min

    Now We Act: With Senator Sheldon Whitehouse on Dark Money and a Brighter Future

    Friends, it was a special pleasure to speak to Senator Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island, who has been working to solve the problems of international and domestic dark money for years, and who now may have an opening to get behind some transformative laws. He has thought deeply about the connections between dark money, policy, and our broader sense of what is possible and not possible. By the end of the conversation, it was easy to see how resolving this problem could utterly transform the American future, and for the better. Please listen and share. This is one of six such conversations from Monday November 16th, which I will be releasing here over the next couple of days. There will likely be two more live conversations on Thursday. These conversations are available to everyone. If you are a subscriber you will get notices in advance. If you are a paid subscriber, feel free to leave questions in the comments, and I will do my best to raise some of them. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit snyder.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • Yesterday · 29 min

    Now We Act: With Rep. Sarah McBride on Care and Freedom

    Friends, I am holding a series of live, unscripted conversations under the heading Now We Act! with Democrats on how they could transform an historical electoral victory into political transformation. The main theme of my conversation with Rep. Sarah McBride, after we agreed on the link between democracy and prosperity (“accountability” and “affordability” are terms we use but which limit us) we discussed her notion of caregiving and the shape of a governmental transformation, on the scale of FDR or LBJ, that would allow us to be more dignified and free. This was a special conversation and I strongly encourage you to listen! I will be publishing the other five from Monday this week, and holding a couple more live conversations, if all goes well, on Thurday. If you are subscribed to this Substack you will get notices of all of this; if you are a paid subscriber you can leave comments and I will try to work some of your concerns into future conversations. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit snyder.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • Sunday · 41 min

    On “Backtalker” with Kimberlé Crenshaw

    I am very glad to share this conversation with the great legal thinker (and Ohio native!) Kimberlé Crenshaw. We spoke live on this platform before the American midterm elections; I wanted to wait until afterwards to share the recording of this conversation, so as to give it a little space. Professor Crenshaw’s book is (mostly) not about day-to-day politics, but it is about the half-seen and half-acknowledged sources of some of America’s deepest problems. Traveling through Ohio (her home state and mine) between our conversation and the elections, I couldn’t help but notice that the students of Central State University, a historically black college with a connection to her family, had lost their polling place, and been assigned one six miles away — and that some of the press accounts of this declined to mention the racial element of this. Professor Crenshaw has worked throughout her career to make the half-seen and half-acknowledged clearly visible, and her memoir not only sheds light on the origins of her thought, but provides valuable examples of its plausibility. The gift of her experience is also the gift of our understanding. “Backtalker” grounds necessary critical concepts in the history of our country and the lived experience of African Americans in the last quarter of the twentieth century and the first quarter of the twenty-first. Please have a look or a listen and share with anyone who might be interested. Thinking about... is a reader-supported publication. Please subscribe. PS: Tomorrow, Monday 16 November, I will be continuing Now We Act, my series of live conversations with Democratic Representatives and Senators. The subject is: transforming an electoral victory into political transformation. If you are a subscriber you will be notified of each conversation. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit snyder.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • Saturday · 26 min

    Now We Act: With Senator Richard Blumenthal on the Opportunity of a Lifetime

    Dear Friends, on Monday I spoke live on this platform with five US Senators, and I have been publishing those conversations here this week. This is part of a new series on this platform called Now We Act. Thus far I have spoken to about a dozen Democratic Senators and Representatives, and on this coming Monday we will have about half a dozen more live conversations. If you are a subscriber you will be notified of each live conversation (and when the recordings are released); if you are a paid subscriber you can leave comments and questions, which I will try to integrate. The main question I am raising is of course this: can we get from a major electoral victory to systemic change? My theory of the case, which I presented to Senator Richard Blumenthal of Connecticut, is that the Democrats have won on issues that require systemic change, and that they have a short time to (at the very least) to demonstrate their attempt, through legislation and through invesitgations, that they are in the right sight of the corruption. People recognize that the system is broken, but also recognize that Trump is more broken than the system. This creates a special chance for the Democrats. I was happy to listen to Senator Blumenthal agree that “this is the question of the moment.” Voters have a “deep disillusionment about the system.” He says that “we need to seize the opportunity not only to be against Trump” but more importantly “for programs related to housing, health care, AI.” Senator Blumenthal calls this “the opportunity of a lifetime.” Please listen to what he has to say, and please share. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit snyder.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • Friday · 24 min

    Now We Act: With Senator Andy Kim on Health and Democracy

    The Democrats have a large majority in both chambers of Congress, after an historical election. Senator Andy Kim of New Jersey, with whom I had a long conversattion on Monday, is a special elected official, thoughtful, open and humane, with clear plans for health care for the young, and a specific, thoughtful approach to corruption. He understands the connection between daily life and democracy. Can we make a start in January towards the much better country we can become? Please listen and please share. There will be another burst of live conversations on Monday with Representatives and Senators, free to everyone, on this platform. If you are a subscriber, you will get notice of each one; if you are a paid subscriber, feel free to leave your thoughts and questions in the comments of this or any other post, and I will work some of them in. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit snyder.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • Thursday · 23 min

    Now We Act: With Senator Mark Kelly on Security and Freedom

    Friends, I am carrying out a series of live conversations with Democratic Senators and Representatives, trying to get an answer to the open question of American politics, and really American life: can Democrats use their extraordinary electoral victory (plus thirteen points nationwide, large majorities in both chambers of Congress, historic individual victories, as in Mississippi) to meet the present crisis and take meaningful steps towards something much better? For me, money in politics is the issue of issues, both because action there would signal to voters that the Democrats really are different than than Trump, different than the system, and better than they have been. Radical campaign finance reform would also make our system far more democratic than it is, and (what comes to same thing) much easier to pass laws that benefit Americans. This was a central subject in Monday’s conversation with Senator Mark Kelly of Arizona. Senator Kelly has faced more than his share of ridiculous abuse from the present administration, chiefly because he has made the obvious point — as a distinguished Navy combat veteran — that soldiers and sailors should not follow illegal orders. This statement was one step, in my view, in safeguarding these elections, and should be understood as such. Senator Kelly has also been outspoken in his support of Ukraine, which is where we begin: there we have an example of people taking great risks for their own freedoms, setting an example and creating possibilities for the rest of us. Just as democracy is connected to domestic prosperity, so it is linked to a reasonable foreign policy. I urge you to listen to Senator Kelly’s views on all of this. This is a recording of one of five conversations from this past Monday. I will release recordings with Senators Blumenthal and Kim these next two days. Next Monday November 16th there will be another five or six live conversations with Representatives and Senators on this platform. These conversations are available to everyone; feel free to share them. If you are a subscriber you will get notifications about all of this. If you are a paid subscriber feel free to leave questions in the comments; I will try to raise some of them with elected officials. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit snyder.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • November 11 · 23 min

    Live with Senator Tammy Baldwin on Recovery

    Friends, the party that was in opposition, the Democrats, has a chance to become a party that moves into history. Will it? A resounding electoral victory does not automatically become a meaningful political victory. In my view, the Democrats have a once-in-a-lifetime chance. They won even though the system is rigged against them; that’s the only time when you can unrig. Democrats got a vote of — let’s call it — relative confidence, as the people who seem less corrupt than Trump, and who might create the conditions under which nothing like his level of self-dealing nihilism can continue. I think they have about six months to convey that they are one the right side of the corruption question, which also means being on the right side of the costs question. You can’t get to affordability without accountability. It was a special pleasure to speak about Wisconsin and the wider world with Senator Tammy Baldwin. Wisconsin is a very special state: the last time I visited, it seemed that it would be stuck in gerrymandered quicksand forever, without meaningful political competition. And yet the state, or its voters and organizers, found a way out: and as of these last elections, Wisconsin Democrats will now have a “trifecta,” Democratic control over both houses of the state legislature as well as the governor’s mansion. This is important in American politics, because one root of the authoritarianism in Washington DC has been fake democracy at the state level. I was pleased to listen to Senator Baldwin accept the proposition that “costs and corruption” are “twin issues” and “place their trust in Democrats to do something about it” — and that this trust will be “short-lived if we don’t deliver.” Senator Baldwin sees ways to keep money from elections (including public financing) and also has an interesting proposal to expand health care and ideas about the restoration of scientific research. As ever I appreciated the Senator’s willingness to join in an unscripted, free-flowing conversation. It was a great pleasure to speak to her and experience her own specific mixture of planning and hope. Please listen and share! I did five of these conversations live on Monday and I will release one recording each morning this week. They are freely available to everyone. If you subscribe to this substack you will get a notice of each live conversation (there will be more live ones next week) and each release of a recording; if you are a paid subscriber feel free to leave questions in the comments and I will work some in. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit snyder.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • November 10 · 20 min

    Now We Act: With Senator Chris Van Hollen on Leadership

    We are now deep into “Now We Act,” a series of live, unscripted conversations with Democratic legislators, who will soon enjoy decisive majorities in both houses of the United States Congress. These conversations, like the one I am releasing now with Senator Chris Van Hollen of Maryland, take place thanks to the generosity and patience of the lawmakers themselves, who are willing to engage in impromptu exchanges about some fundamental questions, and to listen to my views as well as expressing theirs. I’d like to explain why I initiated these. As those of you who have been around me on my American journeys these last six months or so know, I have been confident that the opposition party, the Democrats, would win a big victory in the midterms. I was worried about attempts by Trump allies to disrupt the elections, and am thankful for the efforts of organizers and lawyers around the country that — along with the size of the Democratic victory — made that impossible. My greater concern all along has been that Democrats might fail to transform a huge electoral victory into rapid and meaningful change. I believe that voters have given Democrats a chance, and that Democrats have to take that chance, quickly, radically, demonstratively, showing concern for the daily difficulties people face, and getting on the right side of the issue of corruption. Affordability and accountability are connected, as Americans now understand: you can’t get to the underlying economic issues that have made life unaffordable without breaking the hold of corruption and addressing inequality. Americans think that the system is broken — and they are right — but they also think that Trump is far, far more corrupt than the system — and there they are also right. This is what gives Democrats their once-in-a-lifetime chance: to show that they are better than they have been, to show that they are better than the system, to show that the system can be changed. And it can be — that was the message today from Senator Chris Van Hollen. People have “invested hope” in the Democrats, he said, but they need “to follow through” on health care, data centers, and money in politics. If Democrats don’t — and this is my feeling now — they will quickly lose credibility, and could even collapse as a political party. Their historical success in these elections arose from the hard work of organizers and candidates and the decisions of voters, but it was enabled by a certain historical moment. As Shakespeare has Brutus say in Julius Caesar: “There is a tide in the affairs of men. Which, taken at the flood, leads on to fortune.” My personal sense is that the Democrats have about six months before that tide goes out again. The task is to establish that that they are the party that wants money out of politics and back into citizens’ pockets. I very much appreciated the combination of clear judgement and radical aims demonstrated by Senator Van Hollen in our conversation. We talked about the methods of authoritarians, the need to break normalization, the meaning of the freedom of speech, and the need to see the connections between the abuses of rights and the decline in good opportunities for all of us. It is also worth pondering what Senator Van Hollen has to say about new members and leadership in the Senate at the end of our conversation: “We should not have a coronation.” “I’m listening now to people who are demanding change.” “The new members have demanded change.” These “Now We Act” conversations are freely available to everyone. If you are a subscriber to this substack you will be notified by email when each new live conversation is broadcast and when each recording is released. If you are a paid subscriber you can leave questions in the comments; I will try to bring them up in future sessions. Feel free to share these recordings with others who might be interested. I had four other live conversations with Senators on Monday November 9th (Senators Blumenthal, Baldwin, Kelly, and Kim); I will be posting those recordings each morning this week. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit snyder.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • November 8 · 36 min

    Now We Act: With Senator Tina Smith on Unrigging the System

    Senator Tina Smith graciously met with me in Minneapolis just before the election, and just as graciously agree to take part in our first day of conversations with elected officials about how an election becomes a transformation. If you the system is rigged and you lose, you cannot unrig it; if it is rigged and you win anyway, then you have the chance to unrig it. I appreciated her frankness about the need to attend to issues of oligarchy and to listen to the “plea for big bold actions” and formulate a “populist antidote.” Now, she says, “we have to show that we are not just kidding around.” I certainly agree that failure to do this would give authoritarianism its best chance and I appreciated the Senator’s clarity on this point. Senator Smith was also clear on the point that citizens understand that Trump’s corruption is “costing you money”; and that therefore accountability and affordability are connected. It was also a pleasure to acknowledge the special role of Minnesotans took risks to give us the chance to get to this moment. I hope you enjoy this — and will tune in Monday when we continue these conversations with six more US Senators. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit snyder.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • November 8 · 21 min

    Now We Act: With Senator Maggie Hassan on Responsive Democracy

    Senator Maggie Hassan of New Hampshire generously joined me on the first day of our new series Now We Act. She defines the large group of new Senators and Representatives as a “coalition of patriots” and speaks to the sense among voters that something essentially un-American was happening under “this corrupt” and “historically failed” president. This leads us to an essential conversation about the relationship between the extravagant corruption of the current administration and possible remedies. Senator Hassan also makes the interesting point that a difference between autocracies (her example is Russia) and democracies is responsiveness. (Which was a theme I was happy to pick up!) I appreciated as well her description of the effect of outside money and dark money and “mass communication strategies that are very opaque.” Everyone I spoke to on Friday agreed that we need radical campaign finance reform; here as elsewhere I appreciated the Senator’s patience as I gave my view of the Supreme Court’s (or its majority’s) misunderstanding of freedom of speech. We touched on some other fundamental issues, including the taxation of the wealthy and the future of Homeland Security and ICE. I hope you find this useful and will tune in Monday as I continue these conversations with half a dozen more US Senators. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit snyder.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • November 8 · 23 min

    Now We Act: With Rep. Greg Casar on Passing Great Laws

    Representative Greg Casar of Austin joined me Friday for an energetic conversation that begins with the extraordinary turn in Texas politics. He and others have admirably agreed to unscripted conversations and to listening to my very long questions! The reason I am setting up the big questions is that I think Democrats have an open window, but one that will close in about six months. And that the twin issues of affordability and accountability are really one issue. Congressman Casar right off the bat has several interesting ideas here and affirms the point that Democrats have to move quickly. On campaign finance, he starts from the very sound view that the Supreme Court should not have been legislating the issue of money in the politics in the first place, and explains how the legislative process could work. And I also love the idea of using all of the next hundred weeks to pass ambitious legislation. For this and other reasons I hope you will take the chance to get to know Greg Casar, who chairs the Congressional Progressive Caucus. These conversations will continue on Monday with six US Senators on the list. They are available to everyone. If you are subscribed, you will get an email when each live conversation starts. If you are a paid subscriber, feel free to leave some questions for lawmakers in the comments, and I will try to work some of them in. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit snyder.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • November 8 · 30 min

    Now We Act: With Rep. Madeleine Dean on Language and Power

    “My head hurts from smiling,” says Representative Dean, recalling her work with other candidates in Pennsylvania and around the country. She kindly mentioned “On Tyranny,” which led us into a conversation about who has resisted, organized, and opened the door to major change, and what comes next. “We just elected diverse, qualified candidates, people color, people of different faiths,” a huge new class in the House of Representatives. Representative Dean mentions both “affordability and accountability,” which for me are essentially the same issue: you can’t get to kitchen-table issues without going through corruption. Representative Dean speaks at length about getting back the centrality of Congressional power, the power to make laws and “the power of the purse,” which is of course essential. These conversations will continue on Monday, with six US Senators. They are available to everyone. If you are a subscriber, you will get an email notification. If you are a paid subscriber, feel free to leave questions below, and I will try to work them in. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit snyder.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • November 7 · 36 min

    Now We Act: With Rep. Seth Magaziner on Ethics and Reform

    Seth Magaziner, Congressman of Rhode Island, agreed to be the very first person to join our new series here called Now We Act. We test the idea that the elections open a window: voters (including people who chose not to vote) see corruption as central, and are waiting to see whether Democrats can get on the right side of this issue. Representative Magaziner sees the Democrats as having a mandate rather than a pat on the pat, and sets the tone for the conversations that followed all day Friday and will continue on Monday. He speaks of a “broader pay-to-play culture” and the need to get money out of campaigns and a “comprehensive set of ethics reforms” as well as getting dark money out of politics and a “much more progressive tax system.” And: “Elon Mush is due” to testify before Congress. Again I want to thank Seth Magaziner and others for agreeing to unscripted conversations on basic subjects — it’s a good sign when our elected representatives are willing to do this. These live conversations continue on Monday with six US senators. If you subscribe you will get an email notice when each one starts; if you are a paid subscriber you can leave questions below and I will try to integrate them into future conversations. These live sessions are available to everyone. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit snyder.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • November 7 · 29 min

    Now We Act: With Rep. Ro Khanna on America’s Future

    Friends, I am doing some new live sessions here with Democratic Congresswomen, Congressmen, and Senators under the heading “Now We Act.” The central issue is how we get from change in the legislature to change in life. I have some ideas about this, which these elected officials are kindly willing to hear and discuss. I want to give credit to everyone who has joined these conversations: they are unscripted and free-flowing, and I think all the more interesting for that reason - and not every politician will agree to do such a thing! I am sharing first this recording of a terrific conversation with Rep. Ro Khanna of California, which goes deep into some basic questions of wealth and governance, and conveys very clearly his worldview and his ideas about a better future. And it was fun! Please share this with anyone who is interested. These conversations are available to all. There were five others yesterday the recordings of which I will share over the weekend, and there will be six new live conversations, all with Senators, on Monday November 9th (schedule below). If you are a paid subscriber, feel free to leave comments below, and I will work some of them in to future conversations with lawmakers. Monday’s schedule, as it looks today: This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit snyder.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • November 3 · 28 min

    On Power and Joy -- what comes next

    An election-day conversation with Jess Craven about what it means to win, what to do with power, and how to experience victory. The central theme in both policy and politics: to get to affordability you have to go through corruption. The opposition, once they gain power, will have a once-in-a-lifetime change to address the issue of money in elections, inequality, and the self-dealing of the presidential clans. May this be relevant and useful! Please share with others who might be interested or want to be engaged. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit snyder.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • November 1 · 30 min

    The Midterms and the Aftermath with Michael Podhorzer

    On a little tour of the Midwest, and very happy to stop to tap the mind of the great Michael Podhorzer on the larger meaning of these midterms and on what must come next. Please have a look and a listen and share! This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit snyder.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • October 26 · 32 min

    Before and After the Elections (video)

    What to expect on election day, what to do about it, and what comes after the opposition wins a big victory? The big story right now is that the opposition party, the Democrats, has the chance for a decisive victory that creates conditions for the systemic change this country badly needs. Of course the Trump regime will try to halt this. That is absolutely normal in such historical conditions. And they can be made to fail. And can be mocked. A big enough margin will deter people from cheating for the losing side. And adherence to the rule of law means punishment for those who break the law in elections. Every gambit that cannot be deterred can be defeated. After victory, the new majority should move quickly to signal that it is the party that opposes money in politics, that fights corruption, that will work for economic justice. This would be a once-in-a-lifetime chance. Glenn and I work through all of this. I hope you enjoy watching and listening. Please share with those who will be interested. Thinking about... is a reader-supported publication. Please subscribe. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit snyder.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • October 24 · 48 min

    With Michael Weiss on Ukraine, Diplomacy, and Espionage

    Please check out this timely conversation with the investigative journalist Michael Weiss. We are working here to bring you up to date on the changing US policy towards Ukraine, the Russian attacks on Ukrainian civilians following the complete failure of the Russian summer offensive, and the ways the war connects to American domestic politics before the midterm elections. Bonus: get confirmation that the mind and mouth of JD Vance are moved by Russian propaganda. If you find this valuable, please share this with others who will be interested! This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit snyder.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • October 15 · 31 min

    Modern Fascism, the Collapse of Truth, and Why Americans Need “Small Courage”

    Dear thinkers: Timothy Snyder joined fellow historian and teacher Sharon McMahon for a sweeping conversation about the state of American democracy, the evolving nature of fascism, and the growing influence of technology and wealth on politics. Below are some thematic highlights and select quotes from Tim during the conversation. I encourage you to watch the conversation in full, as always. I think you’ll learn a lot. How Fascism Is Changing in the 21st Century. Why a Post-Truth Society Is So Dangerous “The fascism is a tool to divide, to divert, to direct people towards a false us and them. Whereas the real us and them is that they have their hands in our wallet.” A Post-Truth Society “A post-truth society is one in which we don’t acknowledge that truth is real.” The Political Power of Tech Billionaires “A lot of people with a lot of means, a lot of wealth and a lot of power are cut off pretty much completely from the world.” The Importance of “Small Courage” “I think it’s very important that we think of courage as something which is small.” For more, continue tuning in here or check out On Tyranny and On Freedom. Thanks, as always, and see you soon Victor This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit snyder.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
Showing 1–20 of 54 episodes