Skip to content
Sign inOpen the app
Artwork for The Supernaturals
True Crime

The Supernaturals

SPN Productions

In the realm of the eerie and enigmatic, ”The Supernaturals” podcast reigns supreme. Hosted by the dynamic duo, Jake and Cal, this spine-chilling journey delves deep into the world of horror, offering listeners an immersive experience into the realms of the unknown.

Meet Jake and Cal, two passionate aficionados of all things horror, whose fascination with the genre knows no bounds. With a blend of wit, insight, and a touch of skepticism, they embark on a quest to unravel the mysteries that lurk in the shadows.

From bone-chilling movies to spine-tingling tales of haunted places, ”The Supernaturals” leaves no stone unturned. Each episode is a captivating exploration of haunted history, myths, legends, and everything in between. Through riveting discussions and insightful analysis, Jake and Cal dissect the darkest corners of the human psyche, inviting listeners to confront their deepest fears.

But ”The Supernaturals” is more than just a podcast—it’s a community of thrill-seekers and believers, united by their love for the macabre. With a dedicated following eagerly awaiting each new episode, Jake and Cal have carved out a niche in the podcasting world, captivating audiences with their passion for all things horror.

Join Jake and Cal on a journey into the unknown, where every creak of the floorboards and whisper in the dark holds the promise of an unearthly encounter. Whether you’re a seasoned skeptic or a true believer, ”The Supernaturals” promises to leave you spellbound, questioning the boundaries between the natural and the supernatural.

SubscribePlay latestOpen in podnodRSS feedShow website
  • 20 episodes
  • Updated Yesterday
  • Explicit

Episodes20

Newest first
  • Yesterday · 8 min

    AFTER DARK | Something Dark Lurked Below the Dorm Hall (True)

    There are places that should stay abandoned… and maybe Belmont Hall is one of them. In this episode of After Dark, a group of college football teammates decide to break into an abandoned dorm hall that has sat empty for years. Rumors of hauntings, mysterious deaths, and strange disappearances have surrounded the building for decades, but nothing could have prepared them for what they discovered beneath the old dorm. After sneaking inside, they uncover dark hallways, hidden underground passages, a secret room covered in disturbing symbols, and evidence that should never have existed. Even stranger, every photo and video they captured inside mysteriously vanished before they could show anyone else. Was Belmont Hall simply an abandoned building… or was something else waiting in the darkness? Turn off the lights, put on your headphones, and step inside another terrifying episode of After Dark. If you enjoy creepy stories, haunted locations, paranormal encounters, urban legends, and atmospheric horror, be sure to subscribe for new episodes every week.

  • Wednesday · 50 min

    Ep. 77 - Terrifying Things Found In the Woods

    Nature can be peaceful… but what if the woods are hiding something sinister? In this episode of The Supernaturals Podcast, we dive into some of the most chilling, urban legends and real-world mysteries that are tied to the deep woods. We start with one of the internet’s most unsettling modern legends: the mystery of the staircases in the woods. Sightings of free-standing staircases deep in remote forests have been reported for years, with hikers claiming they appear where no structure should exist, and sometimes vanish just as quickly. Are they hoaxes, folklore, or something genuinely unexplained? Next, we explore the chilling concept of mimics in the woods—creatures or entities said to imitate voices, sounds, or even loved ones to lure people deeper into the forest. These stories have become a staple of modern creepypasta, Backrooms-style horror, and wilderness survival nightmares, blurring the line between fiction and fear. Finally, we close with a real-life case that still haunts investigators and outdoors enthusiasts alike: the disappearance of Dennis Martin. Vanishing in the Great Smoky Mountains National Park in 1969, Dennis was never found despite extensive searches. Over the years, theories have ranged from accidental loss in the wilderness to stranger, more disturbing possibilities, making it one of the most talked about missing persons cases in national park history. If you enjoy true camping horror stories, forest mysteries, cryptid encounters, unsolved disappearances, urban legends, scary forest stories, and real-life unexplained cases, this episode is for you. Have you ever had a strange experience in the woods? Let us know in the comments. Subscribe to The Supernaturals Podcast for new episodes every Wednesday covering true crime, paranormal encounters, cryptids, urban legends, and unexplained mysteries from around the world.

  • August 1 · 6 min

    AFTER DARK | Something Was Inside the Storm Clouds

    What if there was something hiding inside the storm? It was supposed to be a perfect summer night. In July of 2008, a young man returns to his small hometown in Kansas and takes his girlfriend Katie to the annual summer carnival. The town is alive with families, carnival rides, games, food, and the excitement of a warm summer evening. But as the sun begins to set, a massive thunderstorm starts moving toward the carnival. At first, it’s nothing unusual. Kansas is known for powerful summer thunderstorms. But while riding the Ferris wheel, Katie notices something strange inside the approaching storm clouds. Something massive. As lightning illuminates the dark clouds, the couple begins to realize that what they’re seeing isn’t a normal storm. A mysterious silhouette appears within the clouds, moving through the darkness as the thunderstorm approaches the town. Was it a strange atmospheric phenomenon? Something supernatural? Or was there actually something hiding inside the storm? AFTER DARK is SPN Productions’ atmospheric horror series featuring original scary stories, unsettling encounters, mysterious creatures, strange phenomena, and tales that blur the line between reality and the unknown. Turn off the lights. Put on your headphones. And listen closely. Because sometimes, the most terrifying things aren’t hiding in the darkness. They’re hiding in the storm. AFTER DARK Original Horror Stories • Scary Stories • Atmospheric Horror • Supernatural Stories • Mysterious Encounters If you enjoy scary stories, horror stories, supernatural encounters, creepy stories, mysterious phenomena, storm horror, creature stories, and atmospheric horror, subscribe to SPN Productions for more episodes of AFTER DARK.

  • July 29 · 47 min

    Ep. 76 - The Disappearance of Jeanette DePalma

    What really happened to Jeanette DePalma? In this episode of The Supernaturals Podcast, we investigate the disturbing and still unsolved disappearance of Jeanette DePalma, one of the most chilling missing persons cases tied to New Jersey true crime history and surrounding urban legends. In 1972, sixteen year old Jeanette DePalma vanished without a clear trace. Weeks later, her remains were discovered in a wooded area in Springfield Township, New Jersey, under circumstances that quickly fueled rumors, theories, and decades of speculation. What began as a missing persons case soon turned into one of the most controversial and debated mysteries in the region. Over the years, the case has been linked to everything from occult activity, ritual sacrifice rumors, and Satanic Panic-era fears, to more grounded theories involving foul play and investigative inconsistencies. Despite multiple theories and local attention, no one has ever been charged, and the true circumstances surrounding her death remain unclear. In this episode, we break down the timeline, the known facts, the rumors that spread through the community, and why the case of Jeanette DePalma continues to spark interest in unsolved mysteries, cold cases, true crime podcasts, and paranormal adjacent legends. If you’re interested in true crime unsolved cases, missing persons mysteries, Satanic Panic stories, disturbing cold cases, and real-life horror stories, this episode is for you. Subscribe to The Supernaturals Podcast for new episodes every Wednesday covering true crime, paranormal investigations, urban legends, and unexplained mysteries.

  • July 25 · 7 min

    AFTER DARK | The Lights Above the Desert (Based on a True Story)

    An original scary story and horror narration perfect for fans of UFO sightings, extraterrestrial encounters, paranormal mysteries, and late-night storytelling. In this atmospheric desert horror story, a quiet night of stargazing takes a terrifying turn when a man witnesses strange lights hovering over the Arizona desert. Living in a remote part of Arizona, one man is used to spending his evenings outside beneath some of the darkest skies in the country. But after noticing an unusual military presence throughout the day, including a convoy of military vehicles and helicopters flying overhead, he begins to wonder if something strange is happening nearby. That night, while taking his dogs outside and admiring the stars, he notices a mysterious white light floating above the distant red rock formations. At first, he assumes it’s a drone or some kind of military aircraft. But when the strange light suddenly splits into multiple objects and each one begins shining a powerful spotlight down toward the desert, he realizes he’s witnessing something he can’t explain. And then… the lights turn toward him. Welcome to AFTER DARK, an original horror series from SPN Productions featuring immersive scary stories, atmospheric narration, cinematic visuals, haunting music, paranormal encounters, and unsettling mysteries. If you enjoy UFO stories, strange lights in the sky, alien encounters, extraterrestrial mysteries, scary stories, creepypastas, paranormal activity, unexplained phenomena, close encounters, atmospheric horror, psychological horror, and late-night storytelling, you’re in the right place. Subscribe for new AFTER DARK episodes and original horror stories every week. What would you do if you looked up at the night sky and saw something that shouldn’t be there… and then realized it was looking back at you?

  • July 22 · 41 min

    Ep. 75 - Strange Stories From Black Mountain

    Is Black Mountain one of the most mysterious places in the world? In this episode of The Supernaturals Podcast, we're exploring the legends, myths, and unexplained mysteries surrounding Black Mountain. From bizarre disappearances and strange sightings to eerie folklore, paranormal encounters, and stories that have been passed down for generations, we dive into why this mountain has become the center of so many chilling tales. Is there any truth behind the legends? Are these stories simply local folklore, or is there something genuinely unexplained happening on and around Black Mountain? We examine the history, eyewitness accounts, and theories surrounding one of the world's most fascinating mysterious locations while separating documented facts from popular myths. If you enjoy unsolved mysteries, paranormal investigations, cryptid encounters, urban legends, true scary stories, strange disappearances, and mysterious places around the world, this episode is for you. What do YOU think is happening at Black Mountain? Let us know your theory in the comments! Subscribe to The Supernaturals Podcast for new episodes every Wednesday covering true crime, haunted locations, cryptids, folklore, horror movies, paranormal investigations, and unexplained mysteries from around the world.

  • July 18 · 7 min

    AFTER DARK | The Broadcast Said the Town Was No Longer Safe

    In this SPN original short story, school is finally out for the summer, and two siblings can’t wait to spend the night with their friends. But after discovering something disturbing at a neighbor’s house, an ordinary afternoon takes a terrifying turn. Moments later, their parents race to find them, and a chilling emergency broadcast interrupts the radio with a warning unlike anything they’ve ever heard… Welcome to AFTER DARK, an original horror series from SPN Productions featuring immersive scary stories, cinematic visuals, haunting music, and atmospheric narration designed to keep you hooked until the very last second. If you enjoy scary stories, creepy pastas, psychological horror, analog horror, emergency broadcasts, paranormal mysteries, urban legends, nosleep stories, fictional horror, and immersive horror narration, you’ve come to the right place. Subscribe for new AFTER DARK episodes and original horror stories every week. What would you do if your hometown suddenly broadcast a message telling everyone to leave… and refused to explain why?

  • July 15 · 1 hr 3 min

    Ep. 74 - Tinder Horror Stories

    Dating apps can lead to love... or your worst nightmare. In this episode of The Supernaturals Podcast, we're reading real fan submitted Tinder horror stories that prove you never truly know who's on the other side of the screen. From terrifying first dates and disturbing red flags to creepy encounters, stalkers, catfishing, and dates that went horribly wrong, these are stories our listeners say they'll never forget. Some of these experiences are awkward. Some are downright chilling. And one story in particular, the third submission, left us completely speechless. It's easily one of the wildest dating horror stories we've ever featured on the podcast. If you enjoy Tinder horror stories, dating app horror stories, true scary stories, Reddit style horror, real life creepy encounters, and listener submitted paranormal and unsettling experiences, this episode is for you. Have your own terrifying Tinder or dating app story? Send it to us, you might hear it in a future episode! Subscribe for new episodes every Wednesday featuring true crime, paranormal investigations, urban legends, horror movie discussions, creepy internet mysteries, and listener-submitted scary stories.

  • July 11 · 6 min

    AFTER DARK | Every House on Our Street Left Their Lights On

    What would you do if every house in your neighborhood suddenly turned their lights on… at the exact same time? Tonight on AFTER DARK, we dive into an original psychological horror story that turns an ordinary suburban evening into a nightmare. When one man notices every porch light, living room, and bedroom glowing long after midnight, he assumes it’s just another restless night. But as his neighbors begin behaving in ways that make no sense, he realizes the lights aren’t keeping something out… They’re waiting for something to arrive. This is another original horror story from SPN Productions, written and narrated for fans of slow-burn suspense, eerie neighborhoods, analog horror, paranormal encounters, and unsettling late-night mysteries. If you enjoy creepypastas, scary stories, urban legends, nosleep-style horror, atmospheric storytelling, psychological horror, and original supernatural tales, then welcome to AFTER DARK. Subscribe for new horror stories every week. Let us know in the comments: If every house on your street suddenly had every light on… would you go outside to investigate?

  • July 8 · 47 min

    Ep. 73 - An Evil Dead Franchise Special

    The Deadites are back... and we're getting ready for Evil Dead Burn. Before the next chapter of one of horror's most iconic franchises arrives, we're diving deep into The Evil Dead series! In this episode of The Supernaturals Podcast, we break down every film in the franchise from The Evil Dead (1981) and Evil Dead II to Army of Darkness, Evil Dead (2013), and Evil Dead Rise. We'll discuss behind-the-scenes stories, hidden details, fun facts, practical effects, the terrifying history of the Necronomicon, and the evolution of one of horror's greatest heroes, Ash Williams. We also share our favorite moments, rank the films, and talk about what we're hoping to see in the upcoming Evil Dead Burn. Whether you're a lifelong Deadite or just getting into the series, this episode is packed with horror history, filmmaking insights, and everything you need before the next movie hits theaters. Which Evil Dead movie is your favorite? Let us know in the comments! Subscribe for new episodes every Wednesday as we cover horror movies, paranormal encounters, true crime, urban legends, and everything supernatural.

  • July 4 · 8 min

    AFTER DARK | The Fireworks Didn't Stop That Night

    An original scary story and horror narration perfect for fans of creepypasta, paranormal horror, and late-night storytelling. In this summer horror story, a Fourth of July celebration becomes a nightmare when mysterious shadow figures begin appearing with every firework. What if the fireworks weren’t the only thing lighting up the night? A small Missouri town celebrates the Fourth of July with fireworks, baseball, and packed streets full of tourists. But after one strange figure appears in the stadium, an ordinary summer night turns into something far more terrifying. Every burst of light reveals a shadow that shouldn’t exist… and by the end of the night, the truth is far worse than anyone could imagine. Welcome to After Dark, an original horror series from SPN Productions featuring immersive scary stories, cinematic visuals, haunting music, and atmospheric narration designed to keep you looking over your shoulder long after the video ends. If you enjoy scary stories, horror narrations, creepypastas, psychological horror, paranormal encounters, urban legends, fictional horror stories, and late-night storytelling, you’re in the right place. Subscribe for new After Dark episodes and original horror stories every week. What would you do if you saw something standing in the crowd… and every firework brought it closer?

  • July 1 · 39 min

    Ep. 72 - 4th of July Special

    Some of America's darkest mysteries happened right here at home… In this special Fourth of July episode of The Supernaturals Podcast, we're taking a look at some of the most chilling true crime cases, unsolved mysteries, and urban legends in American history. From the terrifying case of The Mad Gasser of Mattoon, who allegedly terrorized an Illinois town with mysterious gas attacks in the 1940s, to the heartbreaking and still haunting Girl Scout Murders at Camp Scott in Oklahoma, we explore the stories that continue to leave investigators, and the public, with more questions than answers. Were these crimes ever truly solved? What evidence still sparks debate decades later? And why do these cases continue to fascinate people today? Join us as we dive into some of America's most unsettling mysteries and uncover the stories that refuse to be forgotten. Happy Fourth of July from The Supernaturals Podcast! Subscribe for new episodes every Wednesday! Which case should we cover next? Let us know in the comments!

  • June 27 · 5 min

    AFTER DARK | The Summer The Woods Started Calling Our Names

    The water was calm. The night was still. Then something called their names. A group of friends out on the boat. A voice in the dark screaming their names, from nowhere, from no one. They laughed it off. They went to the bars. They came back. It was waiting for them. Welcome to After Dark, a new series from SPN Productions where atmospheric horror stories come to life through narration, original imagery, and immersive sound design. Each episode is a self-contained nightmare. This is the first. Turn the lights down. Let it begin. Subscribe and hit the bell, new After Dark episodes drop regularly. What do YOU think was calling their names? Leave your theory below. Part of the SPN Productions universe, home of The Supernaturals Podcast.

  • June 24 · 58 min

    Ep. 71 - Zodiac Killer (Part 2)

    In part two of the Zodiac saga, The Supernaturals wrap up the story of the most chilling case in American history. Strap in as Jake and Cal lead you through the twists and turns that have haunted investigators for over fifty years. With all of the evidence and constant correspondence with police, it still leaves one burning question… Who is the Zodiac?

  • June 17 · 49 min

    Ep. 70 - Zodiac Killer (Part 1)

    In this special two part episode, The Supernaturals seek to uncover the truth behind one of the world’s most profound true-crime mysteries; The Zodiac Killer. Follow along as Jake and Cal go through the early days of the Zodiac mystery, from multiple murders to his strange coded cipher. Nothing is as it seems in this chilling episode.

  • June 3 · 1 hr 10 min

    Ep. 68 - Springfield Three

    In this Unsolved Mysteries Episode of The Supernaturals Podcast, Jake and Cal discuss an incident that occurred in Springfield, Missouri where a mom, her daughter, and her friend, all celebrated their high school graduation before vanishing without a trace. This shocking story is one that will make the hair on your neck stand straight up.

  • May 27 · 42 min

    Ep. 67 - Museum of Colorado Prisons (On-Location)

    In this special on-location episode, The Supernaturals journey to Canon City, Colorado and set up shop inside the Museum of Colorado Prisons, which is said to be extremely haunted. With history of the former prison and chilling insights on the hauntings that occur there, Jake and Cal decide to even record a live EVP session during the episode. Lock in, and join them as they uncover something terrifying.

  • May 20 · 51 min

    Ep. 66 - The Strange Case of Uncontrollable Dancing

    In today’s episode, Jake and Cal discuss the strange case of uncontrollable dancing, which occurred back in Strasbourg in 1518. While they look to uncover the cause for such a unique event in history, the two also look at the recently viral origins of the Serbian Dancing Woman. This episode is all about dancing, but for all the wrong reasons.

  • May 13 · 49 min

    Ep. 65 - Fan Submissions: Stalker Stories

    Stalker stories are some of the most terrifying experiences one can hear. And in this episode, Jake and Cal are listening to some of your most haunting stalker stories. From ex-partners to obsessive classmates, this episode is sure to chill you to the bone.