Skip to content
Sign in
Artwork for The Horseshoe Hangover
SportsFootballExplicit

The Horseshoe Hangover

Tom Connolly & Chris Dyer

Join two passionate Colts and NFL outsiders every week as we break down the latest Indianapolis Colts news, analyze key NFL matchups, and share unfiltered takes on all things football. From game recaps to league-wide insights, *The Horseshoe Hangover* offers a fresh, weekly perspective on the highs and lows of Colts Nation. Saddle up and tune in each week as we ride through the season with a drink in hand and plenty of football talk! We call it how we see it and will not hold back.

Play
Open in
  • 25 episodes
  • Avg 49 min
  • English

Episodes 25

NewestOldestLongest
All20Unplayed20In progress0Played0
Counted on this page — what you have heard stays on this device, so it is not something the list can be paged by.
  • S3 · E8
    Saturday · 59 min

    2026 Ep08: Colts 53-Man Roster Predictions & Injury PTSD

    It’s officially Year 3 of the Horseshoe Hangover Podcast, so Chris & Tom figured it was time to put their GM hats on and build their own Indianapolis Colts 53-man rosters. Who makes the cut? Who’s on the bubble? And where do Chris & Tom completely disagree? We also dive into the Colts’ dramatic—and sometimes downright painful—injury history. From Peyton Manning’s neck injury, to Andrew Luck, Anthony Richardson, Daniel Jones, and the latest injury concerns, Colts Nation has been through enough to make every limp, awkward landing, and trip to the blue medical tent feel like a five-alarm fire. Two roster predictions. Plenty of disagreements. And a little Colts injury trauma mixed in for good measure. Grab a drink and join the Hangover.

  • S3 · E7
    August 25 · 41 min

    2026 Ep07: Did the Colts players fail the Job Interview?

    In this episode of Horseshoe Hangover, we break down a frustrating preseason performance where several Colts backups were handed a golden opportunity—and showed up like someone walking into a job interview completely unprepared. Preseason is supposed to be where depth players prove they belong, but instead, the Colts walked away with even more questions. We dive into the concerning lack of depth along the offensive line and at cornerback, and what those weaknesses could mean once the regular season begins and injuries inevitably hit. We also tackle the Colts' kicking battle and debate what should carry more weight when making the final decision: consistent performance on the practice field or delivering when the lights come on in an actual game? The starters might grab the headlines, but this episode is all about the guys fighting for roster spots—and whether the Colts have enough behind their starters to survive a 17-game season.

  • S3 · E6
    August 21 · 55 min

    S3 Ep06: Joint Practices with Falcons & Preseason game 2

    Horseshoe Hangover — Colts Camp Heating Up & Falcons Preseason Preview The Colts are making some noise as training camp rolls on, and we've got plenty to talk about on this episode of Horseshoe Hangover. We break down the latest from camp, including Deion Burks and Josh Downs making plays, Daniel Jones looking sharp, and a Colts defense that absolutely dominated the Falcons offense in joint practices. We also dive into the addition of Keenan Allen and what the veteran receiver could bring to a WR room that desperately needed proven depth. Plus, we take a look at the Colts' emerging linebackers, who's making a push for playing time, and Tom explains exactly what he likes—and apparently doesn't like—when evaluating his quarterbacks. Finally, we turn our attention to Preseason Game 2 against Atlanta. What do we need to see from the quarterbacks, young receivers, defense and roster-bubble players before the Colts start making some difficult decisions? 🎙️ Training camp updates, position battles, questionable QB standards, and everything we're watching against Atlanta—it's all on this episode of Horseshoe Hangover.

  • S3 · E5
    August 19 · 32 min

    S3 Ep 05: Colts sign WR Keenan Allen

    The Colts finally made a move at wide receiver, signing veteran Keenan Allen to add some much-needed experience and proven production to a position group we've been concerned about throughout training camp. On this episode of Horseshoe Hangover, we break down what the 6-time Pro Bowler brings to Indianapolis, his familiarity with Shane Steichen, and why his elite route-running and ability to move the chains could be exactly what this offense needs. Alec Pierce brings the deep threat. Josh Downs brings the explosiveness from the slot. Now Keenan Allen brings something this WR room was seriously lacking—over a decade of NFL experience and more career catches and receiving yards than the rest of the Colts' receiver room combined. Is Allen still capable of making a major impact at 34 years old? And did Chris Ballard wait too long to address the Colts' lack of WR depth. We break it all down on Horseshoe Hangover.

  • S3 · E4
    August 15 · 45 min

    S3 Ep04: The Good & Bad from Preseason Game 1

    The first preseason game is in the books, and we've got plenty to talk about. Anthony Richardson showed some of the same old concerns but ultimately found a way and clearly separated himself from Riley Leonard in the QB battle. We break down the good, the bad, and what still worries us at quarterback. We also discuss the continued concerns at wide receiver, Will Mallory's big night, and why nobody behind the Colts' top receivers seized the opportunity. Defensively, young players like Caden Curry, George Gumbs, and Bryce Boettcher made some noise, while Jaylahn Tuimoloau had a night to forget. Plus, Spencer Schrader makes his move in a kicker battle that could go down to the wire. It's our full Horseshoe Hangover Colts preseason reaction—who raised their stock, who hurt it, and what has us concerned as we move close to the regular season.

  • S3 · E3
    August 13 · 37 min

    S3 Ep03: What We need to learn about the Colts vs. New England preseason game 1

    The Colts are kicking off the preseason against the New England Patriots, and while the final score doesn't matter, there's plenty to watch. On this episode of Horseshoe Hangover, we break down what we want to see in Preseason Game 1, starting with the QB2 battle and whether anyone can establish themselves as a reliable option behind the starter. We also dive into the wide receiver competition, which players can separate themselves from the pack, and who could be fighting for a roster spot. On the defensive side, we're watching the pass rush to see who can consistently create pressure and make some noise off the edge. And don't forget the kicker battle—because every opportunity matters when you're competing for one job. It's our Colts vs. Patriots preseason preview and everything we're watching when Indy finally takes the field. Give us a listen and get your Colts football fix with Horseshoe Hangover!

  • August 9 · 34 min

    2026 Ep02: Questionable QB & WR depth

    This week on Horseshoe Hangover, we take a hard look at one of the biggest concerns facing the Colts: depth at quarterback and wide receiver, especially with injuries piling up. At quarterback, the Colts' depth behind Daniel Jones raises serious questions. We break down what Anthony Richardson and Riley Leonard are showing in camp and why neither has provided much confidence as a reliable option if Jones misses significant time. We also dive into the wide receiver room and how injuries are putting additional pressure on the Colts' depth. Losing key pieces can quickly expose the difference between having a deep position group and simply having enough bodies to get through camp. With the season approaching, the Colts can't afford for injuries to turn these positions into major weaknesses.

  • S3 · E1
    August 6 · 1 hr 17 min

    2026 EP 01: week 1 of Training Camp

    What's up, Colts Nation, and welcome back to Horseshoe Hangover! Training camp is officially underway, and after the first week, we've finally got real Colts football to talk about. Veterans and rookies alike are already making an impact, with position battles heating up and plenty of players turning heads early in camp. Whether you're looking for the biggest takeaways, standout performances, or the latest storylines from Westfield, we've got you covered. So sit back, give us a listen, and get your fill of Colts football. Let's dive in!

  • #90
    June 15 · 1 hr 2 min

    EP 87: 2026 Colts OTA's & Mini Camp

    We discuss Daniel Jones throwing the ball and doing warm up sprints and Alec Pierce is hobbling around after an ankle procedure. We break down this very weak WR room and is this Deforest Buckners last year as a Colt? We make our quick-fire win/lose picks for the 2026 season and discuss the Indiana Bears.

  • S3 · E86
    April 29 · 50 min

    EP 86: Colts 2026 Draft recap

    The Colts select all big school players, but do they fill the roster needs required to make the playoffs?

  • S2 · E80
    January 14 · 48 min

    Ep 80: NFL Wild Card Weekend

    Steelers still can't win a playoff game, the Bears only show up in the 4th quarter, and Eagles are one and done!

  • S2 · E77
    Dec 24, 2025 · 30 min

    Ep 77: Colts are embarrassed on Monday Night Football

    Welcome back to the Horseshoe Hangover, where optimism went to die on Monday Night Football. The 49ers didn’t just beat the Colts—they redecorated the house, changed the locks, and left us with the bill.

  • S2 · E76
    Dec 20, 2025 · 40 min

    Ep76: Colts are in prime time!

    The Colts and Uncle Rivers take on the 49ers! Can this team finally stop their 4-game skid and get a much needed win?? come listen and find out what Tom and Chris think.

Showing 1–20 of 25 episodes