Skip to content
Artwork for The Evidence Locker

The Evidence Locker

sheea13

Some cases are closed but never truly solved. Others leave a trail of questions that haunt investigators for decades. In The Evidence Locker, we unseal the files on the most compelling and complex true-crime cases. Host Shea meticulously examines the evidence—from forensic reports and witness statements to the killer's own ledger—to piece together the story of what really happened. This isn't just storytelling; it's a search for truth within the evidence. If you're a fan of in-depth, fact-based investigation, this is the podcast for you. New episodes twice a week.

Play
  • 20 episodes
  • Avg 21 min
  • English
  • April 25 · 23 min

    The Jack Family- Into Thin Air

    The Jack family consisted of Ronald, Doreen, and their two sons, Russell and Ryan. The family had been down on their luck in 1989, when Ronald suddenly received an amazing job offer. That night, he loaded his family into the car of his supposed boss, and they were never seen again.

  • April 19 · 21 min

    Alison Botha- The Will to Survive

    Alison Botha was kidnapped and brutally attacked after parking her car, she was nearly decapitated and left for dead. This is her story, and what she had to do to survive.

  • March 19 · 29 min

    The West Memphis Three

    West Memphis is a modest community of roughly 26, 000 residents situated on the Arkansas side of the Mississippi River, directly opposite Memphis, Tennessee . In the early‑1990s, the town was relatively quiet, its population spread across a few neighborhoods and a small‑town school system. The tranquility of the town would be shattered in early May 1993 when three of its youngest citizens vanished.

  • March 16 · 26 min

    Marlene Warren and the Killer Clown

    Marlene was taking care of her injured son in 1990 when a clown holding balloons showed up at her door. The clown shot Marlene in the face and fled. The case went cold for decades, until DNA led to a break in the case.

  • March 12 · 21 min

    Dardeen Family Murders

    The Dardeen family was a young family in Ena, IL, just starting to find their place in the world, when they were brutally killed. The case is still unsolved today, but that isn't for a lack of suspects. Join us as we cover the case, and who police think is guilty.

  • March 8 · 24 min

    Martha Moxley- A Murder Tied to the Kennedy Family

    Martha Moxley was 15 when she died on October 30, 1975, and despite her brutal death and strong suspects, her case went cold for 15 years. Then, a man, Mike Skakel, cousin of the Kennedy family, was arrested and convicted. Years later however, his conviction was overturned and her death is once again "unsolved".

  • March 5 · 21 min

    The Lake Bodom Murders

    Finland's most notorious unsolved crime involves the murder of three teenagers, and the lnvestigators are no closer to an answer now than they were 60 years ago.

  • March 1 · 22 min

    Melissa Brennan - Taken Through the Window

    Melissa Brennan was a happy 5-year-old girl who lived with her single mom. She was enjoying a Christmas party at her apartment complex when she vanished. We typically don't feature unresolved cases (no body) on Solved Saturday; however, due to recent pleas for help finding Melissa, we wanted to bring you her case ASAP. If you know anything that could lead to her remains, contact the FBI. As always, stay curious, stay safe.

  • February 26 · 19 min

    Tiffany Valiante - Suicide or Murder?

    Today, we cover the case of Tiffany Valiante, a young woman who was terrified of the dark and vanished in the middle of the night. Her death was quickly ruled a suicide without any further investigation; later evidence may point to homicide. Her death was officially reclassified 9 years ago as undetermined. Now, her family wants answers. If you enjoy this podcast, please give us a like, follow, and leave a review.

  • February 22 · 21 min

    The Hi Fi Murders

    What was supposed to be a robbery turned into a hostage situation, which led to torture, and sadly, murder. We cover the Hi Fi case today, and how the two men at the center of it were caught, for today's Solved Saturday.

  • February 19 · 27 min

    Reed Jeppson- Utah's Oldest Missing Persons Case

    Reed Jeppson was your average teenager in 1960's Utah. He went to church, played football, and loved to train his dogs. One day, he went out to feed his dogs, Reed, and the dogs vanished. We cover Reed's disappearance and the theories surrounding it.

  • February 15 · 13 min

    Azaria Chamberlain - The Dingo Got My Baby

    On 17 August 1980, nine‑week‑old Azaria vanished at Uluru; investigators blamed a car murder based on blood in the Torana and a missing jacket.  In 1986 the jacket was found in a dingo den, foetal‑haemoglobin tests proved unreliable, and the 2012 coronial inquest declared a dingo attack, finally exonerating the Chamberlains family.

  • February 12 · 16 min

    Who Took Baby Lisa Irwin?

    Ten‑month‑old Lisa Irwin vanished from her Kansas City home on October 4 2011 after her father returned to find the front door unlocked, lights on, and missing phones. Witnesses reported a man with a baby; a cadaver dog alerted near the mother’s bed. No body or suspect has been identified to date.

  • February 1 · 7 min

    Sharron Prior- DNA Closes Decades Old Case

    This Solved Saturday is short; there is not much information about Sharron's case, and I didn't want to cloud it with filler. But just because it is short, does not mean it is any less important. Sharron and her family still deserve the same support we show to all the victims featured.

  • January 28 · 27 min

    Mr. Cruel- A Study in Escalation

    An immersive look at Australia’s most infamous unsolved serial crimes, this episode unpacks the chilling saga of “Mr Cruel.” Beginning with the first home invasion on 22 August 1987 in Lower Plenty—where a masked gunman tied, gagged and assaulted an 11‑year‑old girl.

  • January 25 · 19 min

    Georgia Tann – The Woman Who Turned Adoption Into a Black‑Market Empire

    Georgia Tann (July 18 ,1891 – September 15, 1950) was a Mississippi‑born social worker who ran the Memphis branch of the Tennessee Children’s Home Society (TCHS). Using her legal training, political connections (including Judge Camille Kelley and the Crump machine), and a network of doctors and police, she turned the state‑funded orphanage into a black‑market adoption ring. Between the early 1920s and her death in 1950, Tann is estimated to have placed more than 5,000 children with affluent families—often after coercing or kidnapping the infants from poor, unwed mothers and falsifying adoption paperwork. The Society charged wealthy out‑of‑state adopters up to $5,000 per child, pocketing the majority of the fees while ignoring medical advice, allowing neglect, and causing the deaths of hundreds of infants. Her crimes were exposed in a 1950 state investigation; Tann died of uterine cancer three days before charges could be filed, but the scandal prompted major adoption‑law reforms and a lasting legacy of trauma for countless survivors.

  • January 21 · 12 min

    The 82‑Year‑Old Mystery: The Vanishing of Marjorie West

    On Mother’s Day, May 8 1938, four‑year‑old Marjorie West disappeared from a family picnic in Pennsylvania’s Allegheny Forest. A massive 500‑man search, bloodhounds, and countless volunteers turned up nothing, spawning theories of a bear attack, a passing motorist’s kidnapping, a mysterious Plymouth sedan, and even a possible secret adoption. Decades later, DNA attempts, age‑progression studies, and a controversial claim that a woman named Sylvia London might be the grown‑up Marjorie keep the case alive. In this episode we trace the original disappearance, the frantic 1930s manhunt, the evolving leads, and the modern forensic hopes that still seek to solve one of America’s longest‑running missing‑child mysteries.

  • January 18 · 28 min

    Casey Anthony: The Worst Mom in America

    A concise, gripping episode that unravels the Casey Anthony case—from Caylee’s mysterious disappearance and the baffling web of lies, to the forensic clues, the shocking discovery of the remains, and Casey’s tumultuous early incarceration—offering listeners a clear, step‑by‑step look at one of America’s most polarizing true‑crime stories.

  • January 14 · 15 min

    Desert Vanish: The Daniel Robinson Mystery – Accident, Staged Crash, or Something Worse?

    On a scorching June morning in 2021, 24‑year‑old field geologist Daniel Robinson left his Buckeye work site and never returned. Within hours his father, David Robinson, reported him missing, launching a multi‑agency search that spanned helicopters, drones, cadaver dogs, and dozens of volunteers. Days later a rancher discovered Daniel’s overturned Jeep Renegade in a remote desert ravine, seemingly confirming an accidental rollover. Yet the official Buckeye Police report concluded “no foul play,” citing crash‑data that appeared consistent with a simple accident. In this episode, we unpack the police narrative—timeline, search efforts, crash‑data, and the FBI brief—and then dive deep into the family’s counter‑narrative. We hear from private‑investigator Jeff McGrath, who uncovered 46 extra ignition cycles, an 11‑mile odometer discrepancy, and red‑paint transfer suggesting the crash was staged. We explore digital forensics that revealed unauthorized access to Daniel’s laptop, the mysterious deletion of his Instagram, and the family’s relentless public campaign that exposed racial bias in media coverage.

  • January 11 · 18 min

    John List: Family Annihilator

    In this episode of The Evidence Locker, we delve into the shocking 1971 familicide that forever altered the quiet suburb of Westfield, New Jersey. Accountant and devout Lutheran John Emil List murdered his wife, mother, and three teenage children in their grand Victorian mansion, leaving a meticulously staged crime scene and a five‑page confession letter to his pastor. After vanishing, List assumed the alias Robert Peter “Bob” Clark and eluded capture for 18 years, living a seemingly ordinary life in Colorado and later Virginia.

Showing 1–20 of 20 episodes