Skip to content
Artwork for Spin It or Bin It
MusicMusic HistoryMusic Commentary

Spin It or Bin It

Spin It or Bin It

Paul and Josh are exploring the classic rock and metal canon to figure out which albums are forgotten gems or hidden mistakes.

Play
  • 27 episodes
  • weekly
  • Avg 1 hr 21 min
  • English
Counted on this page — what you have heard stays on this device, so it is not something the list can be paged by.
  • #71
    Today · 1 hr 36 min

    The Van Halen Series: Balance

    Paul and Josh wrap up the Van Hagar era of Van Halen with Balance. They talk about the band's darker/more serious direction, the entrance of Bruce Fairbain as producer, and the changing musical landscape of the mid 90s.

  • #70
    November 2 · 1 hr 48 min

    The Van Halen Series: For Unlawful Carnal Knowledge

    Josh and Paul talk about the third Van Hagar album! They discuss the album's humorous title, the return of Ted Templeman, and assess how successful Van Halen was in crossing over to the 90s.

  • #69
    October 28 · 1 hr 24 min

    The Van Halen Series: OU812

    Paul and Josh continue their dive into the Sammy Hagar era of Van Halen by talking about the sophomore album OU812! Was this a second sophomore slump for Van Halen? They also go into the lore behind the title, and how the album stacked up against others released in 1988.

  • #68
    October 13 · 1 hr 28 min

    The Van Halen Series: 5150

    Josh and Paul discuss the first Van Hagar album: 5150! They talk about the band's change in musical direction, Hagar's lyricism, and the change in production. Is 5150 a spin or a bin? Substack: https://spinitorbinit.substack.com/ Arthenfold: https://arthenfold.org/creators/spinitorbinit/spin-it-or-bin-it

  • #67
    October 5 · 1 hr 24 min

    The Van Halen Series: The Sam & Dave Show!

    No, not the 2002 coheadline tour, in this episode Josh and Paul look at Sammy Hagar's VOA album and David Lee Roth's Eat 'Em and Smile album to discuss what the two vocalists were up to when they weren't in Van Halen. We'll be back with our regular programming to discuss 5150 next week. Check us out on Substack! https://spinitorbinit.substack.com/

  • #66
    September 29 · 1 hr 36 min

    The Van Halen Series: 1984

    The last album with David Lee Roth! Paul and Josh discuss this album's mega status, the backstory of the home recording process to create this album, and more!

  • #65
    September 21 · 1 hr 38 min

    The Van Halen Series: Diver Down

    Josh and Paul are back discussing Van Halen's 1982 album Diver Down! They discuss the album's rushed production, litigate the heavy use of covers, and talk about some of the other mega albums from 82.

  • #64
    September 15 · 1 hr 31 min

    The Van Halen Series: Fair Warning

    Josh and Paul discuss DLR Van Halen's darkest entry: Fair Warning. They discuss the internal cracks in the band that are beginning to emerge, EVH's development as a guitar player and writer, and the crossroads the band found themselves in in 1980. Follow us on Substack! https://spinitorbinit.substack.com/

  • #63
    September 7 · 1 hr 23 min

    The Van Halen Series: Women and Children First

    Josh and Paul are back to discuss Van Halen's third album: Women and Children First! They talk about the album's harder edge, the band's more advanced recording techniques, the introduction of keyboards, and more!

  • #62
    August 31 · 1 hr 25 min

    The Van Halen Series: Van Halen I & II

    Paul and Josh start their Van Halen discography run in earnest by discussing the first two VH albums. They talk about Van Halen I's status as one of the all time great debut albums and debate whether II holds up as a worthy successor or even competitive with the followup album. Follow us on Substack! https://spinitorbinit.substack.com/

  • #61
    August 25 · 1 hr 23 min

    Weezer - The Gold Album

    On Spin It Or Bin It we are contractually obligated to cover any and all new Weezer releases. Paul and Josh go over Weezer's self titled (gold) album and provide some kneejerk takes recorded on release day. They also talk about the early critical/fan response and speculate on Weezer's future. Check out our substack! https://spinitorbinit.substack.com/

  • #60
    August 17 · 1 hr 12 min

    The Van Halen Series : Van Halen Zero (Pre 1978 Demos!)

    Paul and Josh are back with a new miniseries! This "introduction" episode talks about the history of Van Halen prior to the debut and the duo get into the storied "Van Halen 0" demos that would go on to make up the source of the bulk of the DLR era Van Halen albums.

  • #59
    August 5 · 1 hr 13 min

    Haken - in a fever dream

    Paul and Josh are back to continue their Haken miniseries with the band's comeback EP: in a fever dream! They talk about the band's controversial musical choices and try to parse if there are any clues in this EP about the band's longterm trajectory. But most importantly, is it a spin or a bin?

  • #58
    July 27 · 1 hr 12 min

    Ep. 58 : New Mastodon Singles and the Iron Maiden Pophouse Sale

    For a break between miniseries content, Paul and Josh are discussing some recent happenings in the metal world. They discuss the announcement of a new Mastodon album as well as the two released singles and react to the mini documentary The Mastodon in the Room. They also discuss the Iron Maiden sale to Pophouse and speculate about what the sale might mean for the future of the band.

  • #57
    July 15 · 1 hr 36 min

    The Paramore Series : This Is Why

    Josh and Paul wrap up their Paramore miniseries talking about their latest album This Is Why! They discuss their divided opinions on this album, speculate about the future of Paramore, and there's some bonus talk about the recent Fantano/Halsey feud.

  • #56
    July 1 · 1 hr 23 min

    The Paramore Series : After Laughter

    Josh and Paul are back to talk about Paramore's After Laughter! They talk about why they chose this as their Paramore album of choice for their best albums of the 21st century and how this album stands out among the rest of the discography.

  • #55
    June 22 · 1 hr 14 min

    The Paramore Series : Paramore (2014)

    Josh and Paul are back talking about Paramore's 2013 self titled album. They talk about the lineup changes and drama leading up to this project and the band's drastic stylistic shift. They talk about this album's legacy and whether the material holds up years later.

  • #54
    June 15 · 1 hr 14 min

    The Paramore Series : Brand New Eyes

    Paul and Josh discuss Paramore's 3rd album, Brand New Eyes. They talk about this album's status as a sleeper hit among fans, and how it compared to Riot both at the time and over 15 years later. They also discuss the album's legacy as the end of an era for Paramore, but also whether it felt like a transitional album to the band's current status as a pop rock band.

  • #53
    June 9 · 1 hr 7 min

    The Paramore Series : Riot!

    Josh and Paul continue the Paramore miniseries by talking about their second album, Riot! They discuss the album's megahits but the real question is whether the deeper cuts hold up or if this is an album of fillers held up by a few hits.

Showing 1–20 of 27 episodes