Skip to content
Artwork for Seriously Mysterious - Missing Persons, Unsolved Murders & Historical True Crime
True CrimeExplicit

Seriously Mysterious - Missing Persons, Unsolved Murders & Historical True Crime

John Lordan - Respectful True Crime Content Creator, Advocate and Host

Seriously Mysterious is a true crime podcast hosted by John Lordan, who leverages over a decade of meticulous research experience from his popular YouTube shows, BrainScratch and Searchlight. Featuring baffling cases, from unsolved murders and mysterious disappearances to events that simply can't be easily explained, the core strength of Seriously Mysterious is its commitment to respectful, deep coverage, and dedication to truth and reason. New episodes released weekly.

Play
  • 32 episodes
  • weekly
  • Avg 21 min
  • English
Counted on this page — what you have heard stays on this device, so it is not something the list can be paged by.
  • November 10 · 23 min

    The Changing Stories About Angela Green - Tips 913-642-6868

    Conflicting stories, an empty urn, and a mother who vanished overnight. Let’s dive back into Angela Green’s disappearance with brand new developments, and help Ellie find the answers to her mother's disappearance. If you have any information...

    • Transcript
  • November 3 · 19 min

    The Axeman of New Orleans

    A serial killer issues a horrifying ultimatum to the people of New Orleans.  Play jazz or die.  Who was the Axeman and why were families that owned grocery stores living in fear? Thank you The Times-Picayune, The Daily News, Conversation.com,...

    • Transcript
  • October 27 · 19 min

    Missing on Halloween - Shaun Ritchie

    On Halloween night in Scotland, Shaun Ritchie drove off with several friends looking for a good time, and was never seen again.  This might sound like a piece of Halloween fiction, but the pain his family is feeling is very real. Thank you to The...

    • Transcript
  • October 20 · 22 min

    Where is Sofia Juarez? TIPS: 509-628-0333

    A four-year-old girl vanished on the eve of her fifth birthday. Decades later, a previously dropped lead helps reignite one of Washington State's most infamous cold cases. Where is Sofia Juarez? There is a $10,000 reward for information leading to...

    • Transcript
  • October 6 · 20 min

    Kyle and the Zoo Man: Thomas Huskey

    A string of brutal murders leads to a killer, and a prosecution that leaves the jury baffled.  Can they stop the monster known as "The Zoo Man," or will Kyle help him go free? Thank you Knoxville News-Sentinel, wbir, murderpedia.org The True Crime...

    • Transcript
  • September 29 · 19 min

    MISSING JUSTICE for Kaylene Oehling - TIPS: 833-255-8477

    When 20-year-old Kaylene Oehling vanished into the night, it took three years to find her remains.  Does a missing cell phone hold the key to what happened to her, and WHO is responsible? If you have any information, please contact the Allegheny...

    • Transcript
  • September 22 · 20 min

    The Denver Strangler

    A killer in the 1890s left a trail of murdered women, and a terrifying question.  Did American have it's own Jack the Ripper, OR did the actual Ripper cross the Atlantic? This is the story of The Denver Strangler. Thank you The Indiana State...

    • Transcript
  • September 8 · 22 min

    Who Killed Yolanda Bindics? TIPS 716-703-5955

    In 2004, Yolanda Bindics vanished into thin air. Her remains were found years later in a remote forest. Who killed her and left four daughters without their mother? Call the Chautauqua County Sheriff’s Office tip line for Yolanda’s case at...

    • Transcript
  • September 1 · 19 min

    VILLISCA

    On a quiet summer night in 1912, an entire family and two young guests were brutally murdered in the small town of Villisca, Iowa. Was the killer never found... or just never found guilty? Thank you The Courier, The Evening Nonpariel, The Rockford...

    • Transcript
  • August 25 · 20 min

    Missing: Logan Schiendelman - TIPS 360-786-5500

    A car veers into the highway median. Witnesses watch a man leap out and vanish into the woods, but the runner looks nothing like the missing 19-year-old driver, Logan Schiendelman. Who was behind the wheel, and where is Logan? Thank you to Dateline...

    • Transcript
  • August 18 · 21 min

    Justice (and RESPECT) for Clayton Quayle - TIPS: 406-843-5369

    Years after Clayton Quayle disappeared, wild theories tried to fill the void, but today we cover the recent updates that are pulling this case away from the supernatural explanations.. and back to reality.  Clayton Quayle is a victim of homicide. If...

    • Transcript
  • August 11 · 21 min

    Will DNA Ever Solve The Lyn Bryant Murder? TIPS: 0800 555 111

    Lyn Bryant was brutally stabbed while walking her dog, but months later when the investigation stalled, the killer seemingly came back to the scene to leave another clue.  Now decades later, investigators have DNA, but strict UK legal restrictions may...

    • Transcript
  • July 28 · 20 min

    The Servant Girl Annihilator

    Did the city of Austin create a single boogeyman to explain a series of brutal crimes, or was a lone killer truly walking their streets in 1885?  Let's dive into this historical mystery together. Thank you The History Guy, The Austin Weekly...

    • Transcript
  • July 21 · 22 min

    Anne Barber Dunlap's Trunk - TIPS 612-673-2941

    Her friends thought it was a storybook marriage, but the public thinks her husband is responsible for her death.  With new info released in June of 2026 I ask again.. will justice ever be served for Anne Barber Dunlap? If you have information that...

    • Transcript
  • July 14 · 20 min

    Joan Risch's Kitchen - TIPS: 781-259-8111

    When a woman vanishes from a blood-stained kitchen, investigators wonder was she the victim of a brutal attack, or did she plan her own disappearance? TIPS: 781-259-8111 Thank you The Boston Globe, Staten Island Advance, The Rutland Daily Herald,...

    • Transcript
  • July 7 · 21 min

    Why Did Jeremy Jourdain Run? TIPS: 218-333-9111

    When 17-year-old Jeremy Jourdain left on Halloween night in 2016, his family expected to see him again soon, but 10 years later the people of Bemidji, Minnesota are still looking for him AND the truth. Learn more at https://www.facebook.com/findworm...

    • Transcript
  • June 30 · 20 min

    The Wives of George Chapman

    Three innocent women were looking for companionship and a stable future in Victorian London.  Instead, they found George Chapman. Thank you The Press and Case Archives, The Old Bailey Trial Records, Casebook.org, murderpedia, our world is beauty.com,...

    • Transcript
  • June 23 · 20 min

    The Oakland County Child Killer

    Four innocent children were just trying to enjoy childhood in 1970s Michigan, but a series of calculated abductions left an entire community paralyzed by fear, and families wondering how a monster could operate in plain sight. TIPS: 855-642-4847...

    • Transcript
Showing 1–20 of 32 episodes