Paired Nightmares

Tyler & Jenie Wray

Two voices, one story. Every week, a husband-and-wife duo dive into a chilling true crime case or eerie mystery that haunts long after the lights go out. From unsolved murders to spine-tingling tales, Paired Nightmares brings you detailed storytelling, dark insights, and just enough shivers to keep you coming back for more.

Play

Open in

20 episodes
weekly
Avg 42 min
English

Episodes 20

Newest Oldest Longest

All20 Unplayed20 In progress0 Played0

S2 · E8
September 24 · 50 min
Maura Murray: Gone in the Snow-Part 1
On February 9, 2004, 21-year-old college student Maura Murray left Massachusetts and drove into New Hampshire. By that evening, her car had crashed on a quiet, snow-covered road in Haverhill. A local driver stopped and spoke with Maura, and police were called to the scene. But by the time they arrived, Maura was gone. Her car was still there. Her belongings were inside. But Maura had disappeared into the winter night. In Part 1 of our two-part look at Maura Murray's disappearance, we follow the events leading up to that night, the strange details surrounding her trip, the crash on Route 112, and the incredibly short window of time in which she vanished. What happened during those few minutes? And how does someone simply disappear? This is Maura Murray: Gone in the Snow — Part 1, on Paired Nightmares. Sources: FBI.gov, mauramurraymissing.org, doj.nh.gov, Reddit, oxygen.com, thecoldcases.com, people.com
S2 · E7
September 17 · 32 min
They Know What You Saw: The Men in Black
You saw something you can't explain. You told someone. And then… they came knocking. In this episode of Paired Nightmares, Jenie and Tyler dive into the unsettling legend of the Men in Black—mysterious figures who allegedly appear after UFO sightings and strange encounters, warning witnesses to stay quiet. From Albert Bender and the mysterious visitors who supposedly forced him to stop investigating flying saucers, to the strange accounts of men who seemed to know things they shouldn't, we explore where the Men in Black legend began and why it refuses to disappear. Government agents? Hoaxers? Something paranormal? Or something far stranger? Because according to the stories… the Men in Black don't want you finding answers. They want you to stop asking questions. Turn off the lights. Lock the door. And whatever you do… don't tell them what you saw. Sources: Reddit, Book, "They Knew Too Much About Flying Saucers" by Gray Barker, Book, "Space Review" edited by Albert K. Bender, Wikipedia
S2 · E6
September 10 · 47 min
"Where the Hell Are You?” The mysterious disappearance of Brandon Swanson
Brandon Swanson vanished in the early hours of May 14, 2008—and nearly two decades later, there are still no answers. After Brandon's car became stuck in a ditch, he called his parents for help. What followed was an unsettling phone call that lasted nearly 47 minutes as Brandon tried to make his way toward what he believed was a nearby town. Then he said something that would become forever etched into the case: “Oh, shit.” The line went silent. Despite extensive searches, Brandon was never found. His vehicle was recovered, but the questions surrounding his final moments remain. Did Brandon become disoriented in unfamiliar terrain? Did something happen to him along the way? Or is there something about that final phone call that we've overlooked? Join Jenie and Tyler on Paired Nightmares as we unravel the disappearance of Brandon Swanson—and ask the question that has haunted his family for years: Where the hell was Brandon? Sources: forensictales.com, reddit, fbi.gov, fhsvoice.org
S2 · E5
September 3 · 27 min
DON'T LET THEM IN! The Black Eyed Kids
They knock. They ask to come inside. And when you look into their eyes… there’s nothing there. The Black Eyed Kids are one of the strangest and most unsettling modern paranormal legends. But what if the stories are more than just stories? Whatever you do… don’t let them in. 👁️🖤 Sources: Lairofmythics.com, whatpad.com, tbsnews.net, indy100.com, thehalloweenpodcast.com
S2 · E4
August 27 · 46 min
Murder in Cabin 28
On April 11, 1981, something horrifying happened insideCabin 28 in the small California town of Keddie. By the next morning, SueSharp, her son John, and his friend Dana Wingate were dead—and 12-year-old TinaSharp was missing. What followed was a decades-long mystery filled withconflicting witness statements, possible suspects, a mysterious green van, amissing hammer, alleged confessions, and questions about whether the originalinvestigation failed to uncover the truth. Tina's remains wouldn't be discovered until 1984, but thequestions surrounding that night are still unanswered. Who killed Sue, John, and Dana? What happened to Tina? Anddid investigators overlook the people responsible? Join Jenie and Tyler on Paired Nightmares as we stepinside one of California's most disturbing unsolved cases. Sources: suecoletta.com, cbsnews.com, Oxygen.com,investigationdiscovery.com, thoughtco.com
S2 · E3
August 20 · 59 min
The Dyatlov Pass Nightmare
Nine experienced hikers. One abandoned tent. And a mystery that has lasted for more than 60 years. In February 1959, nine hikers disappeared in the Ural Mountains. Their tent was cut open from the inside, their shoes were left behind, and their bodies were later found scattered across the frozen wilderness. In this episode of Paired Nightmares, we explore the Dyatlov Pass Incident, the avalanche theory, mysterious lights, possible military involvement, and the unanswered questions that still haunt this case. What really happened that night on Kholat Syakhl? Sources: popularmechanics.com, history.com, The Dyatlov Mystery: Unexplained Massacre
S2 · E2
August 13 · 53 min
The Boy in the Walls — The Crimes of Daniel LaPlante
What if the person you feared most… was already inside your home? In this episode of Paired Nightmares, we uncover the deeply disturbing case of Daniel LaPlante—a teenager whose actions turned an ordinary Massachusetts home into a real-life nightmare. From terrifying encounters to a horrifying discovery, this case will make you question just how safe you really are behind your own locked doors. Because sometimes the monster isn't outside. Sometimes… it's already inside. 🎙️ Listen now to Paired Nightmares. Sources: CBSNews.com, UWGB.EDU, Oxygen.com, jlc.org
S2 · E1
August 5 · 43 min
Mothman: The Creature in the Darkness
The Mothman is a legendary cryptid described as a towering, winged humanoid with glowing red eyes that seem to pierce the darkness. Witnesses often report seeing it silently watching from rooftops, bridges, or lonely roads before it vanishes into the night with an enormous wingspan. Its appearances are famously associated with feelings of dread and, in folklore, are sometimes said to precede disasters or tragedy, making it one of the most unsettling figures in American legend. 🖤🦋 Sources: Folklife.si.edu, maeclair.net, Wikipedia, themothmanmuseum.com, reddit
S1 · E21
July 29 · 41 min
The I-5 Killer
The I-5 Killer, Randall Woodfield, was an American serial killer, rapist, and robber who operated along the Interstate 5 corridor in Oregon, Washington, and California during the 1970s and early 1980s. He was convicted of murder and was suspected of involvement in numerous additional killings. His crimes inspired Ann Rule’s true-crime book The I-5 Killer. Sources: investigationdiscovery.com, Wikipedia, People Magazine
S1 · E20
July 22 · 26 min
The Black Sox Curse
The Black Sox Curse refers to the belief that the Chicago White Sox were cursed after the 1919 Black Sox Scandal, when eight players were accused of intentionally losing the 1919 World Series in exchange for money from gamblers. Although some of the players were found not guilty in court, they were permanently banned from professional baseball by Kenesaw Mountain Landis. The "curse" became a popular explanation among fans for the White Sox's decades of disappointing performances after winning the 1917 championship. The team eventually ended much of the superstition by winning the 2005 World Series, their first World Series title in 88 years. Wikipedia, YouTube "The Baseball Explainer"
S1 · E19
July 15 · 59 min
The Dating Game Killer
Rodney Alcala seemed charming, intelligent, and ordinary—but behind that façade was one of America's most notorious serial killers. Nicknamed "The Dating Game Killer," he appeared on a popular TV dating show while carrying a horrifying secret. His double life, elusive crimes, and decades-long trail of victims make his story one of the most chilling and unsettling true crime cases in modern history. Sources: People Magazine Investigates: Surviving a Serial Killer, YouTube, Wikipedia, FBI Archives
S1 · E18
July 8 · 27 min
Fresno Nightcrawler
The Fresno Nightcrawler is a modern cryptid (a creature whose existence has not been scientifically verified) that originated from Fresno. It became famous after a 2007 security camera video appeared to show a strange white figure with extremely long legs and little or no visible upper body walking across a yard. The creature is often described as looking like a "walking pair of pants." Although additional videos and sightings have been claimed over the years, no conclusive evidence has confirmed the creature's existence. Many researchers suggest the footage could be a hoax, a camera artifact, or a misidentified object. Despite this, the Fresno Nightcrawler has become a popular figure in internet folklore and cryptid culture because of its unusual appearance and mysterious origins. Wikipedia, Cryptid Wikipedia
S1 · E17
July 1 · 1 hr 5 min
Cari Farver
The Cari Farver case is a notorious true-crime case involving murder, identity theft, and years of deception. In 2012, Cari Farver, a 37-year-old single mother from Iowa, disappeared shortly after beginning a relationship with Dave Kroupa. After her disappearance, Kroupa, his family, and others received thousands of threatening emails and text messages that appeared to come from Farver, leading many to believe she had become an obsessive stalker. Years later, investigators discovered that Farver had actually been murdered shortly after she vanished. The messages had been sent by Shanna Golyar, another woman who had been involved with Kroupa. The case gained renewed attention through the 2024 Netflix documentary Lover, Stalker, Killer. Truecrimesocietyblog, Reddit, allthatsinteresting.com
S1 · E16
June 24 · 25 min
The Billy Goat Curse
The Billy Goat Curse is a famous sports superstition associated with the Chicago Cubs. According to the story, during the 1945 World Series, a tavern owner named William Sianis brought his pet goat to a game at Wrigley Field. After he and the goat were asked to leave because the goat's odor was bothering spectators, Sianis allegedly declared that the Cubs would never win another World Series. For decades afterward, the Cubs experienced a long championship drought and several heartbreaking playoff losses, leading many fans to jokingly blame the "Billy Goat Curse." The superstition became a well-known part of baseball folklore. The curse was considered broken when the Cubs won the 2016 World Series, defeating the Cleveland Indians and ending a 108-year championship drought. Today, the Billy Goat Curse is remembered as one of the most famous legends in American sports. Wikipedia, Chicago Sun Times
S1 · E15
June 17 · 33 min
The Hat Man
The Hat Man is a shadowy humanoid figure commonly reported in paranormal folklore and sleep-related experiences. Witnesses often describe a tall, dark silhouette wearing a wide-brimmed hat and sometimes a trench coat, appearing in bedrooms or dimly lit spaces. Many people report feeling intense fear, paralysis, or a sense of being watched during the encounter. Monster.fandom.com, beyondhauted.com, Reddit
S1 · E14
June 10 · 56 min
Ted Bundy (Part 3)
Theodore Robert Bundy was an American serial killer who kidnapped raped and murdered potentially more than 36 victims between 1974 and 1978. His true victim number is unknown. He was known for using charm and deception to gain victims’ trust, often pretending to be injured or impersonating authority figures. His crimes and court cases became some of the most widely studied and publicized serial murder cases in American history. Wikipedia
S1 · E13
June 3 · 38 min
Ted Bundy (Part 2)
Theodore Robert Bundy was an American serial killer who kidnapped raped and murdered potentially more than 36 victims between 1974 and 1978. His true victim number is unknown. He was known for using charm and deception to gain victims’ trust, often pretending to be injured or impersonating authority figures. His crimes and court cases became some of the most widely studied and publicized serial murder cases in American history. Wikipedia
S1 · E12
May 27 · 49 min
Ted Bundy (Part 1)
Theodore Robert Bundy was an American serial killer who kidnapped raped and murdered potentially more than 36 victims between 1974 and 1978. His true victim number is unknown. He was known for using charm and deception to gain victims’ trust, often pretending to be injured or impersonating authority figures. His crimes and court cases became some of the most widely studied and publicized serial murder cases in American history. Wikipedia
S1 · E11
May 20 · 31 min
The "Curse of the Bambino"
The Curse of the Bambino was a famous baseball superstition that claimed the Boston Red Sox were cursed after they sold star player Babe Ruth — nicknamed “The Bambino” — to the New York Yankees in 1919. After the trade, the Red Sox went 86 years without winning a World Series, despite several heartbreaking losses, while the Yankees became one of the most successful teams in sports history. Fans and media blamed the long championship drought on the “curse.” The curse was considered broken in 2004, when the Red Sox won the World Series after dramatically defeating the Yankees in the American League Championship Series. Wikipedia, The Atlantic, YouTube "The Baseball Explainer"
S1 · E10
May 13 · 33 min
The Stanley Hotel
The Stanley Hotel is a historic mountain resort opened in 1909 in Estes Park by Frellan Oscar Stanley. Originally built as a luxury retreat for visitors seeking fresh mountain air, it became known for its elegant design and modern amenities for its time. Today, the hotel is famous both for its history and its reputation for paranormal activity, with frequent reports of unexplained noises, apparitions, and unusual occurrences-especially in Room 217. It also gained widespread recognition after inspiring Stephen King’s novel The Shining. Wikipedia, usghostadventures.com, denverterrors.com

Showing 1–20 of 20 episodes