SportsSoccerExplicit

Longbangers

A podcast about Hibernian Football Club. #hibs #Hibernian

This Podcast has been created and uploaded by Longbangers and is part of the talkSPORT Fan Network. The views in this Podcast are not necessarily the views of talkSPORT.

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Play

Open in

25 episodes
Avg 40 min
English

Episodes 25

Newest Oldest Longest

All20 Unplayed20 In progress0 Played0

Counted on this page — what you have heard stays on this device, so it is not something the list can be paged by.

Tuesday · 34 min
Why Hibs' New Manager Needs To Fix The Left Side First - The xG Files
Matty and Craig break down Marink Reedijk’s first game in charge, why the shape looked familiar at first glance, and how the match turned into a revealing early lesson about balance, pressing, and the left side of the team.They dig into the selection surprises, the unfamiliar front line, and the way Passlack, Elding, Mulligan, Chaiwa, Wright, and Klidje were deployed to try to make the system work. You’ll hear why the opening 20 minutes offered genuine signs of a plan taking shape, why Dundee United quickly adjusted, and how that forced Hibs back into old habits.Craig also unpacks the bigger tactical issues: whether Passlack is being asked to do too much, why Mulligan on the left may be limiting the team, what Chaiwa is being asked to do in midfield, and how Reedijk might solve the puzzle once Obita, McGrath, Mayor, and Cadden are available again. There’s even a sharp look at why the team’s pressing looked aggressive at times, then fragile almost instantly once Dundee United found the gaps.They also tackle listener questions on YouTube, including why possession isn’t turning into goals, whether the players are actually implementing what they work on in training, and what Hibs’ best front four should be when everyone is fit. Along the way, Craig makes the case for several selection tweaks, including why Klidje may be better through the middle and why Newell could become an important piece if the left side is reshaped.If you want a clear, honest read on what Reedijk’s first match really told us, and what it means for Falkirk and beyond, this is essential listening. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
S1 · E389
Monday · 50 min
Ep389 Patience Required!
Hibs unravel again, but is the real problem deeper than the new manager?A brutal opening day under Reedijk brings instant panic from supporters, but this episode asks the bigger question: is one match really enough to judge a team that still looks built on shaky recruitment, mixed messages, and years of bad habits? Matty and Colin dig into the tactical confusion, the furious fan reaction, and the moments that hinted at something better before it all fell apart.They break down the unexpected starting XI, why the shape looked more like a 4-1-4-1 than the reported 4-2-3-1, and how that affected the balance of the team. You’ll hear why Josh Mulligan’s missed chance, too many hesitant passes, and repeated wrong decisions in the final third became the story of the day, even before Dundee United exposed the gaps and forced Hibs back into old patterns.We also get into the red card, the debate around the referee’s advantage call, and whether the dismissal was harsh, inevitable, or simply the result of another moment of poor game management. Along the way, they tackle the wider issues that keep resurfacing - recruitment, positional discipline, lack of cutting edge, and the frustration of watching a squad that still doesn’t look like a team.Reedijk’s post-match honesty, the role of his coaching staff, and the expectations around how quickly change can actually happen all come under the microscope too. If you’re trying to make sense of the chaos, separate the overreaction from the genuine concerns, and figure out whether there are real signs of progress hiding inside a disappointing defeat, this one is for you.Perfect for Hibs fans who want the straight-talking breakdown of what went wrong, what might be fixable, and why patience may be the hardest ask of all. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
Friday · 20 min
The 4 O'Clock Hibs Show 9th October
Reedijk first game, a fresh Hibs shape, and a preview that is pure educated guesswork in the best possible way. Matty and Colin W break down what Hibs might look like on Saturday, where the new manager could surprise everyone, and why this match is less about instant answers and more about the first clues.With Dundee United waiting and the buzz already building, the pair compare possible lineups, debate 4-2-3-1 versus a back three, and weigh up who is fit, who is likely to start, and who may be better used off the bench. They also get into what a first-game opposition plan looks like, why overhyping a new era can backfire, and what really matters more here - the result or the performance.You’ll discover:Why this is “finger in the air” team selection, not certaintyThe logic behind starting Sallinger, Passlack, Kerr, Ivezic and IredaleWhether Mulligan and Chaiwa can finally be the midfield base Hibs needWhere Matondo, Elding, Cadden, Boyle, Lowe and Klidje might fit into the attackWhy Reedijk’s first big clue may be who he trusts quickest in trainingThe conversation also touches on the bigger picture behind Hibs recruitment, the role of the coaching staff, and why fans may need patience before expecting a fully finished side. Along the way, Matty and Colin react to live listener comments, challenge the idea that this is a “must-win,” and explain why a steady start may tell us more than a dramatic one.If you want a proper feel for the mood before kickoff, this is essential listening - especially if you like your football chat honest, lively, and just a little bit improvised. The episode closes with a score prediction and plenty left to be decided on the pitch. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
October 8 · 46 min
Phone In 8th October
Rabbi Matondo’s arrival, a brand-new coaching setup, and a fresh manager trying to stamp an identity on Hibs - this episode is all about what changes first, and whether Saturday can deliver the first real sign of a new era. Matty is joined by Jack, Steven B, Ian Mackay, and HibeefanIain for a proper deep-dive into the club’s latest moves, from Matondo’s pace and threat out wide to the appointment of Brian McLaughlin, Scott Thompson, and Boozy in the backroom team. Is this smart recruitment, or another example of Hibs doing things the hard way? The panel doesn’t hold back. You’ll hear strong views on: whether Matondo is the winger Hibs have been crying out for why the new coaching appointments have raised eyebrows how much Scottish football experience matters under Marink Reedijk why Boozy’s individual development role could be a huge deal for player growth who should start on Saturday, and what a good result really looks like We also get into the bigger questions around identity, intensity, and whether Hibs can finally move away from the slow, passive style that’s frustrated supporters for months. The discussion turns to players who might benefit most from a fresh start, including Josh Mulligan, Chaiwa, Thibaut Klidje, and the left-side battle between Nicky Cadden, Adam Mayor, and Matondo. And because no Hibs phone-in is complete without a bit of nostalgia, the panel goes full wing-obsessed - with classic names, favourite wide men, and the eternal debate over whether wingers still matter. If you want insight, opinion, and a genuine sense of optimism about what comes next, this is essential listening before the Dundee United clash. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
S1 · E388
October 5 · 46 min
Ep388 The Hibs Squad Debate: Who Starts Under Reedijk?
A new manager, a fresh tactical reset, and a squad that suddenly looks far more interesting than it did a week ago. Matty and Colin Wbreak down what Hibs could actually look like now, and why the first test at Dundee United will tell us a lot more than the scoreline alone. They start with the women's derby defeat at Easter Road and why the result felt like part of a wider problem, before moving into the big question every Hibs fan is asking right now: who starts, who misses out, and what changes under the new regime? You’ll hear them work through: The goalkeeper debate between Sallinger and Smith A potentially solid back four, including Kerr, Hanley, Iredale, Mayor, Passlack and the new defensive options Midfield combinations that could finally unlock Mulligan, Newell, Devaney, Abdullai and Chaiwa Where McGrath fits best, and why the attacking three behind the striker may be the most exciting part of the squad What to make of on loan striker Nathan Lowe so far, and whether Matondo could force his way in quickly They also tackle the bigger picture around squad depth, international call-ups, bounce games, and how much patience fans should really have before judging the new setup. There’s plenty of debate over formation, roles, and the best use of Hibs' attacking talent, plus a candid look at the state of the women’s game at club level and what needs to change for momentum to return. And if you want something a bit more light-hearted, there’s also a blind ranking of Hibs managers since 2000, with Williamson, Yogi, Ross, Stubbs, Lennon, Fenlon and Butcher all getting the treatment - plus a few strong opinions on where they really belong. Essential listening if you want a proper Hibs fan perspective on the new manager era, the squad puzzle, and what Saturday might reveal about the direction of the club. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
October 2 · 24 min
Boyle's Best Bits - The 4 O'Clock Hibs Show
Martin Boyle's Greatest Hibs Moments and Why His Testimonial MattersMartin Boyle has spent more than a decade dragging Hibs through big games, and this episode is all about the moments that turned him into a club legend. Matty and Colin react to the announcement of his testimonial, debate whether the old “10 years continuous service” rule even matters, and pick the goals and match-winning flashes that define his time at Easter Road.Boyle's career at Hibs is packed with memories worth replaying, from outrageous strikes to pressure-cooker cup moments and the kind of late heroics that make a player unforgettable. The lads dig into the Livingston screamer, the Hampden hat-trick against Rangers, and the last-minute Hearts equaliser that sent the place into bedlam.You'll hear them break down:why Boyle's testimonial feels deserved even with the debate around service rulesthe difference between a great goal and a defining club momenthow the Rangers semi-final hat-trick changed the mood of an entire daywhat made the Hearts comeback feel like a returning hero's perfect scriptthe wider legacy Boyle leaves after over 400 games in green and whiteThey also touch on his importance in Europe, his role as a leader on the pitch, and the way Hibs players and fans should think about captains, continuity, and big-game temperament. It is part tribute, part argument, and part nostalgia trip for anyone who has watched Boyle turn half-chances into unforgettable moments.If you care about Hibs history, cup nights, derby chaos, or what makes a player truly worthy of a testimonial, this is essential listening. Boyle has given supporters years of entertainment, and this episode makes the case for why his best moments still deserve to be talked about. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
October 1 · 36 min
Phone In 1st October
Hibs might have just found the coaching reset they’ve been missing. Marink Reedijk's first week is already sparking hope around La Manga, and the big question is whether his detailed, hands-on style can unlock the squad fast enough to change the season. Matty is joined by Ian Mackay, and HibeeFanIan for a wide-ranging phone-in on the new manager, the Aberdeen performance, and what Hibs really need next. From the frustration of 12 shots and only two on target to the buzz around the training videos, this episode digs into the details that could shape the months ahead. You’ll hear: Why the Aberdeen game was more encouraging than the scoreline suggested, and why the finishing still has to improve How Reedijk's coaching style, from stoppages and “activities” to position-specific work, is already winning people over What the panel think about Josh Mulligan, Josh Campbell, Callum Wright, Chaiwa, Klidje, and the young players coming through Whether Hibs actually need to spend big, or if better coaching and smarter development is enough The debate over Jason Kerr, Marco Ivezic, Rabbi Matondo, and the shape of the squad Why Martin Boyle’s testimonial feels richly deserved, and what it says about his impact at Easter Road The mood around the semi-final, ticket demand, and whether Hibs can keep the momentum building Ian Mackay brings the stats and tactical perspective, HibeeFanIan adds the live fan reaction from the training-ground buzz, and weighs in on the youth setup and squad dynamics. Together they paint a picture of a club that may be closer to turning a corner than many realize. Perfect for Hibs fans who want more than hot takes - this is the kind of conversation that gets into the real issues behind the results, and leaves you wondering what this team could look like once the new ideas properly click. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
S1 · E387
September 28 · 51 min
Ep387 Winger In At Hibs?
David Gray’s time at Hibs might be remembered very differently in a few months. Was it actually a successful period of stability, or did the final run of results warp the story before the club’s next reset?Matty and Colin break down the full picture behind the recent managerial change, why the speed of Marink Reedijk's appointment matters, and whether the noise around the process has created a false sense of chaos. They also dig into the rumoured Rabbi Matondo trial and what it says about Hibs’ transfer plans, especially if the new manager really wants wingers and a faster, more direct style.You’ll hear them tackle:Why David Gray’s spell may be viewed as a net positive in hindsightWhether the club had a clear shortlist and strategy all alongWhat Matondo would actually bring, and why his injury record is the big questionHow the new training videos hint at a more intense, problem-solving coaching styleWhich positions Hibs still need if the squad is shifting to a new shapeThey also get into the wider debate around expectations, recruitment, player buy-in, and whether a manager who never played professionally is automatically at a disadvantage. If the club really is moving into a new era, this episode asks the key question: is the squad, the staff, and the fanbase ready for it?Essential listening if you want the smartest Hibs reaction to the managerial reset, the Matondo rumours, and what the next few games should actually tell us. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
September 25 · 30 min
Reedijk Is Right For Hibs - The 4 O'Clock Hibs Show
Hibs have moved fast, and Colin and Matty think the new era could be a genuine reset. Marink Reedijk’s arrival as first team manager sparks a lively, sharply argued breakdown of why this appointment feels more progressive than the usual recycled football hire - and why it might finally fit what this squad needs.Matty has gone deep on the research, from Rydijk’s academic background and coaching progression to the detail that really sold him: a coach who combines tactical knowledge with the ability to improve players as people, not just run sessions. Colin brings the realism, weighing up the big questions fans will already be asking - his age, his lack of playing career, and whether a younger, less conventional manager can command a dressing room in Scottish football.You’ll hear:Why the quick appointment matters more than most fans realiseWhat Reedijk’s press conference and coaching history suggest about his styleHow his approach could bring more intensity, pressing, and direct attacking footballWhy “never played the game” might be a strength, not a weaknessThe impact of having ex-players in his backroom staffHow his flexible system could affect fan favourites and squad selectionWhy the derby and the coming run of fixtures will shape the early narrativeThey also dig into the leadership side of football that often gets ignored - continuous improvement, player autonomy, and the difference between a team that simply wins and a team that keeps getting better. If Hibs can buy into the new coach’s ideas quickly, this could be the start of something far more modern than the club has had in years.Essential listening for Hibs fans, Scottish football followers, and anyone who wants to know whether this appointment is bold genius or just bold. The first verdict is in, and it’s stronger than you might expect. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
September 24 · 29 min
Phone In: Reedijk Is The Man!
Marink Reedijk is in, and Hibs fans are already debating what comes next.Reedijk's appointment as first team manager splits excitement, skepticism, and serious curiosity in the best possible way - because this one feels different. If you want to know why supporters are suddenly talking about phenomenology, pressing, youth development, and whether this could be a genuine reset for the club, this is the conversation to hear.Matty is joined by HibeeFanIan, Other John, and Andrew for a fast-moving fan reaction that goes well beyond a simple welcome message. They break down what stood out in Reedijke's interview, why his background at Ajax and in Belgium has people intrigued, and what his PhD thesis might actually tell us about the way he’ll coach at Easter Road.You’ll discover:Why his quick appointment suggests the club had a plan in placeWhat fans liked about his personality, communication, and “football philosophy”How his thesis on player-centered coaching could shape Hibs on the pitchWhy the back three, pressing, and faster transitions may be keyWhat his approach could mean for young players and January squad decisionsAndrew digs into the tension between reflective coaching and decisive management, while John makes the case that the club’s sporting department deserves credit for acting quickly and methodically. Ian focuses on the energy Reedijke could bring back to the team and the terraces, especially if he can make Hibs play with more intent and confidence.There’s also a bigger question running through the whole episode: can a thoughtful, academic coach actually turn ideas into results in the real world of Scottish football? Or does he need time, patience, and the right squad to make it work?Essential listening if you’re trying to figure out whether this is a smart football appointment, a bold cultural shift, or both. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
September 22 · 35 min
The xG Files: The Tactics Behind Gray's Last Game
In a world where football tactics can make or break a team's season, we delve into the crucial moments that led to a managerial shift at Hibs.In this discussion, Craig and Matty reflect on the critical game against Kilmarnock, analyzing the tactical choices that may have sealed David Gray's fate. You'll discover how Kilmarnock executed a game plan that Hibs struggled to counter, leaving fans questioning their team's direction. With insights from both the Kilmarnock match and the subsequent game against Aberdeen, Craig highlights the tactical disconnect that has plagued the squad.We break down:- The key role of formations and player positioning in both victories and defeats.- The pressing issues in Hibs’ midfield and forward line that are hindering performance.- Craig’s thoughts on player substitutions and their impact on team dynamics.- Insights on how confidence, or the lack thereof, is affecting the squad's execution on the pitch.Don't miss out on this deep dive into football tactics that could reshape your understanding of team dynamics. Perfect for coaches, analysts, and die-hard fans alike, this episode will leave you contemplating the future of Hibs and the next steps they must take to reclaim their place in the league. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
S1 · E385
September 21 · 51 min
Ep386 New Manager Hunt Begins
Hibs finally stop the bleeding, but the real story is bigger than a 1-1 draw. Matty and Colin W break down a flat, frustrated performance against Aberdeen, the penalty that rescued a point, and the deeper question hanging over the club: who actually fits this team, and who does the new head coach need to build around? What starts as a post-match reaction turns into a sharp, no-nonsense diagnosis of Hibs’ season so far. The lads dig into the slow, confidence-drained tempo, the midfield gaps, the senior players who need to lead, and why so many of the current decisions feel like a team trying to survive rather than control a game. You’ll hear them get into: why Hibs’ passing rhythm is killing momentum the debate around Chaiwa, Mulligan, Newell, Lowe, Boyle, and Sutto what went wrong with the midfield shape why some players get hammered while others get a pass the penalty call, the disallowed Aberdeen goal, and the referee’s inconsistent standards the managerial search, including what Karel Gerrard would actually bring Matty and Colin W also unpack the contrasting performances from key players like Wright, Mayer, and Newell, plus the frustrating lack of invention, the uncertainty around Nicky Cadden, and the wider tension between recruitment, tactics, and results. Karol Gerearts is discussed as a possible new head coach, with a profile built around aggressive pressing, quick transitions, high intensity, and flexible attacking movement — exactly the kind of identity Hibs have been missing. The question is whether he can turn a collection of decent individuals into an actual team. Essential listening if you’re a Hibs fan trying to make sense of a season that keeps promising more than it delivers. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
September 18 · 45 min
The 4 O'Clock Hibs Show - What Next For Hibs?
In a week that shook the foundations of Hibernian football, Matty and Colin dive deep into the shocking sacking of manager David Gray. Discover why this decision was both anticipated and heartbreaking for fans and players alike. If you’re a Hibs supporter or simply passionate about football management, this episode is a must-listen. Matty shares his candid thoughts on the recent performance that led to Gray's departure, reflecting on the deteriorating atmosphere at games and the critical moments that sparked fan frustrations. Colin chimes in with insights on the recruitment strategy and how it might have undermined Gray's vision. You’ll hear them dissect the club’s recent history, the players’ performances, and the broader implications of this managerial change. You'll discover: - The exact turning points that led to the decision to part ways with Gray. - Matty's perspective on player accountability and the lack of belief in the team’s direction. - A discussion on potential managerial candidates and what qualities Hibs need in their next leader. - Insights on how the board's decisions impact club culture and fan engagement. Why does this matter? The stakes couldn't be higher for Hibs as they search for a new head coach to restore hope and direction. Fans are eager for a leader who can ignite passion and bring tactical clarity to the team. This episode is your front-row seat to a pivotal moment in Hibernian's journey. Perfect for die-hard Hibs fans and anyone interested in the intricacies of football management, this episode promises to leave you informed and engaged. Don’t miss out on this critical discussion that could shape the future of the club. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
September 16 · 52 min
Phone In 16th Sept - David Gray Sacked
David Gray’s Hibs era ends in bruising fashion, and the real question is no longer whether the decision was right—it’s what on earth comes next. This phone-in hears from fans who are relieved, gutted, angry, and already turning their attention to the bigger problem: a club that still looks unsure of its football identity. Jeff, Ian Mackay, Andrew, HibeeFanIain, and Other John each bring a different angle on Gray’s sacking, the collapse of performances, and the recruitment mess that many believe set him up to fail. One side argues the club had no choice after a miserable run and a toxic atmosphere at Easter Road. The other says removing the head coach without fixing the structure underneath is just treating the symptom, not the disease. You’ll hear sharp debate on: whether Gray was a stabiliser who eventually hit his ceiling why the board, recruitment, and Malky Mackay are under fire too the tactical issues fans say killed Hibs’ attacking play why corners, passing patterns, and player responsibility became flashpoints what kind of manager Hibs actually need next, from Steve Clarke to John Dal Thomason and beyond The conversation doesn’t stop at Gray. It digs into the bigger pattern—failed appointments, weak recruitment, mixed messaging from the club, and the fear that Hibs keep repeating the same mistakes while expecting a different result. If you care about where the club goes from here, this is the debate that matters right now. Essential listening if you want the raw fan reaction, the arguments for and against the sacking, and a clear picture of why this decision has left Hibs supporters asking even more questions than before. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
S1 · E384
September 14 · 45 min
Ep384 Job Done In Dingwall, Bring on the Jambos
This latest episode of Longbangers dives deep into the performances that could make or break their season. Matty and Colin dissect the 3-0 victory over Ross County, but is it enough to silence the critics? Tune in as they analyze what went right, what went wrong, and the looming challenges ahead against Kilmarnock and Hearts. In this episode, you'll discover how early goals transformed the momentum of the match and why a professional performance was crucial for Hibs. Matty and Colin break down key player performances, including a standout display from Klidje, and discuss the tactical decisions made by manager David Gray that could influence the team's future. From assessing the squad rotation to pondering the implications of not utilizing certain players, the duo leaves no stone unturned. But it’s not just about the wins; the stakes are high. The boys highlight the emotional rollercoaster of fan reactions as they navigate through the highs of a convincing win contrasted with the lows of previous performances. What does this mean for the team’s confidence and momentum as they approach tougher opponents? Join the conversation that matters to every Hibs supporter. They then turn their attention to a mouth-watering Edinburgh Derby in the Premier Sports Cup semi-final, as both sides face off at Hampden looking to make it to the final. Perfect for avid fans and casual listeners alike, this episode is essential listening for anyone invested in Hibernian's journey this season. Get ready for insights, analysis, and a candid look at what lies ahead for the team. Don’t miss out—hit play and be part of the discussion! Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
September 11 · 21 min
The 4 O'Clock Hibs Show: Malky's Roundup
Malky McKay's transfer roundup raises bigger questions than the signings themselves. Matty and Colin break down why the club's latest window feels messy, old-school, and strangely at odds with the data-driven recruitment story supporters were told. They unpack the 9-minute video, the players named, the ones omitted, and the part of the message that really lands badly: this does not sound like a targeted plan, it sounds like scrambling for options after the fact. If you've been wondering why the squad feels overloaded in some places and undercooked in others, this conversation gets into the heart of it. You'll hear: Why the transfer strategy feels "disjointed" even if some signings are good players How the club's recruitment approach compares with a more deliberate model like Hearts Why the balance between a manager's style, squad construction, and signings matters so much What feels off about the logic of bringing in players "early" while still seeming to search for fit in the market They also look ahead to Ross County and make the case for one thing above all else: go strong, go direct, and do not overthink a game against League One opposition. With a cup tie that feels too important to slip up in, they discuss the lineup, the tactical shape, and why this is exactly the sort of match where confidence needs to show on the pitch. This one is essential listening if you care about the direction of the club, the logic behind the recruitment, and whether the team is ready to back up the talk with a proper performance. Honest, opinionated, and very much about more than just one transfer window. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
September 10 · 59 min
Phone In 10th September
David Gray under pressure, a broken transfer window, and the Ross County warning Hibs fans are done making excuses. After back-to-back defeats, this episode goes straight at the biggest question around the club right now - is David Gray still the man to steady the ship, or have the transfer decisions, tactics, and results finally caught up with him? Matty is joined by Ian Mackay, Other John, Steven B, HibeeFanIain, and Marc for a brutally honest breakdown of where it’s all going wrong. From the frustration at McDiarmid Park to the chaos of the derby, the panel digs into why Hibs look disjointed, why the front line feels isolated, and why so many supporters are starting to fear Saturday’s trip to Ross County. You’ll hear hard-edged reactions to the summer window, including the exits of Warren O’Hora and Josh Campbell, the gamble on youth, and the growing sense that the squad has been left weaker rather than stronger. The lads also unpack the club’s recruitment process, who really has the final say, and why the current balance of the team looks so far off. We break down: why Hibs are creating chances but still missing the target whether Nathan Lowe is being set up to fail the lack of experience, depth, and natural creativity in midfield why the team only seems to play with urgency when it’s already in trouble how much responsibility sits with Gray, the board, and the recruitment structure There’s also a sharp debate about expectations, fan reaction, and whether criticism of the manager is fair or whether the club’s standards have simply collapsed. Ian, Stephen, John, Marc, and HibeeFanIain all bring a different angle, making this one of the most revealing and emotionally charged phone-ins yet. If you’re worried about where Hibs are headed, or you just want the most honest read on the club’s current mess, this is essential listening. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
September 10 · 32 min
The xG Files: Hibs' Perth Problems
Hibs looked like two different teams in one match, and the result was a confused performance that left more questions than answers. Matty and Colin are joined by tactical analyst Craig to unpack why the press broke down, why the midfield never quite clicked, and why David Gray’s side seemed caught between a high-energy front-foot plan and a low-block counterattacking setup. Craig breaks down the St Johnstone game possession by possession, exposing the gaps that kept appearing between the back four, midfield, and attack. He explains how Hibs’ 4-3-3 morphed into a 4-1-4-1 and then into something even messier, why that shape made it easy for St Johnstone to play through the lines, and how the team’s own pressing triggers often dragged them out of position instead of winning the ball back.You'll discover: why the Lowe pressing pattern looked chaotic rather than effective how Devaney’s role was meant to unlock Hibs, and why it never happened whether Chaiwa and Mulligan are actually a strong midfield pair or just a narrow one why Hanley and Kerr’s build-up play kept stalling attacks before they started how one simple counterattack revealed the kind of threat Hibs should have been creating more often Craig also tackles the bigger picture: is this a coaching issue, a recruitment issue, or both? He makes the case that Hibs are trying to be too many things at once, with players asked to press like one system, build like another, and defend like something in between. That inconsistency is costing them control, confidence, and ultimately points.The episode also digs into the forward line, with discussion of Lowe’s limitations, Klidje’s underused energy, Suto’s role, and whether Hibs need a different attacking structure altogether. If you want a straight-talking, tactical explanation of why Hibs can look brilliant one week and lost the next, this one gets to the heart of it.Perfect for anyone trying to understand what David Gray is actually building at Hibs, and why the current version keeps slipping out of shape just when it looks ready to click. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
S1 · E383
September 7 · 1 hr 2 min
Ep383 Inexcusable - Inept Hibs Pathetic in Perth
Hibs didn’t just lose to St Johnstone, they looked coached out of the game. Matty and Colin pick apart a flat, lifeless performance, the worrying lack of cohesion, and the bigger question now hanging over David Gray: is this a blip, or the start of the end? The mood is brutal because there are no easy excuses left. From the passive first half and the sloppy defending to the cheap penalty and the failure to react after the break, this is the kind of performance that turns frustration into real pressure. And when your own supporters are already debating whether the manager has run out of road, every mistake starts to feel bigger. You’ll hear them break down: Why the lineup looked reasonable on paper but never clicked on the pitch The defensive mess that led to the opening goal Low’s bright moments, including a smart finish that briefly got Hibs back in it Why the midfield shape, especially Chaiwa, McGrath, Mulligan and Devaney, still feels wrong The growing concern that the problem is not just players having off days, but something deeper in the coaching and setup They also dig into the wider stakes: the angry reaction from supporters, the recurring criticism that nothing has changed from last season, and the uncomfortable reality that Hibs now face a huge cup tie at Ross County with pressure rising fast. If you think the issue is only one bad result, this episode makes the case that the cracks go much deeper than that. Essential listening if you’re trying to make sense of a team that can look decent one week and completely lost the next, and if you want the raw, unfiltered fan reaction to a defeat that may have changed the conversation around David Gray for good. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.
September 4 · 45 min
The 4 O'Clock Hibs Show - Derby Disaster
Hibs fans are asking the same brutal question after another derby collapse: is David Gray out of his depth, or have Hibs finally hit the ceiling under his management? The first-half horror show, the tactical standstill, and three soft goals turn this into far more than a post-match rant. Matty and Colin pull no punches as they break down the disastrous Easter Road defeat, from the baffling refusal to change shape early enough to the way Hearts swarmed Hibs out of the game. They pick apart the first booking, the red card, the disallowed goal, and the defensive lapses that made the whole night feel like slow motion disaster. You’ll hear: why the opening 45 minutes had fans calling Gray tactically out of his depth how Hearts targeted Hibs’ weak spots with pressure, width, and simple movement why Passlack, Hanley, and Iredale all come under scrutiny for the goals conceded what Chaiwa changed when he came on, and why the second-half response still wasn’t enough whether Lowe is being unfairly blamed, or if Hibs’ loan-striker model is the real problem The episode also tackles the bigger picture: a third full season under Gray, a transfer window that shuts without solving the striker issue, and a fanbase that is increasingly split between patience and resignation. With comments from listeners flooding in, the discussion gets into the future of the manager, the shape of the squad, and whether the club’s home form is damaging more than just results. If you want the raw, unfiltered post-derby reaction Hibs supporters are having right now, this is essential listening. Frustrated, honest, and full of proper analysis, it’s the conversation every fan is having after a night that felt all too familiar. Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

Showing 1–20 of 25 episodes