Trevor Tombe: Stop transferring resources from workers to retirees
The transfer of wealth from working-aged Canadians to retirees is continuing to rise. “I would humbly recommend we stop doing that,” says economist Trevor Tombe. It’s an issue many Western democracies are grappling with as birthrates decline and the population pyramids that many social programs were based upon become inverted. And this raises serious questions about intergenerational fairness. Is it right to ask younger workers — already struggling with high living costs — to carry an ever-growing tax load to fund these programs? Do universal benefits still make sense, or should supports be targeted much more directly? To weigh these policy choices, Tombe, a University of Calgary economics professor and MLI senior fellow, joins Inside Policy Talks. On the podcast, he tells Peter Copeland, acting director of domestic policy at MLI, that Ottawa’s current fiscal policy results in a resource transfer of about 8.5 per cent of GDP — shifting wealth from Canadians who are in their prime taxpaying years to retirees. That figure is based on research from an upcoming paper Tombe is working on for MLI about Canada's intergenerational fiscal challenges. “Governments are taking policy choices that makes that even bigger,” says Tombe, pointing to policy decisions like boosting Old Age Security payments and lowering the retirement age. “What this effectively does is dramatically increase the amount that we're already providing to older individuals,” he says.