
What Assuming Intent Costs You, and What to Do Instead (Ep.26)
"Assume positive intent." It's in almost every company's values and every team's ground rules, and almost nobody argues with it. So why is it so hard to actually do? In this episode of In The Arena, Shaun Dyke and DoorTwo Consultant Anna Baldwin talk about why we read the worst into what other people do, and what to do instead. It starts with a leader who behaved badly in front of his group, out of character for him. Anna could have called him out. Instead she asked him, "Are you okay?" He wasn't. He'd gotten news right before he walked into the room, and he was carrying a lot. Most of us give people grace while they're learning. Once we decide someone "should know better," we start treating what they do as on purpose. Then our own history fills in the rest. A new boss calls a meeting for 3pm on a Friday, and we've already decided what it means. Shaun's point: assuming positive intent is still an assumption. You saw what someone did. You didn't see why. If you can't get all the way to positive, you can at least stop assuming and ask. If you lead a team or work for someone, you'll come away with a simple habit: notice what you saw, admit what you didn't see, and ask. What you'll learn: • Why "assume positive intent" is easy to agree with and hard to do • Why we usually go with our first reaction, even though we don't have to • Why we give babies and puppies grace, and when we stop • How your own history shapes what you think other people mean • What "innocent until proven guilty" has to do with your team • The iceberg: what you can't see about the people around you • The 24-hour rule: have the conversation or let it go • What to do the next time someone's behavior sets you off ⏱️ Chapters 00:00 Why don't we assume positive intent? 02:07 A leader's bad day, and "Are you okay?" 04:37 Puppies, babies and "you should know better" 08:15 Your home movie, and the 3pm Friday meeting 13:21 The iceberg: what you can't see in people 16:32 What if you didn't assume intent at all? 19:15 The 24-hour rule, and what to do next time 📩 Have a question you'd like answered on the podcast? Email us at info@doortwo.com 📰 Get the models and frameworks from each episode in writing: https://doortwo.com/signup/ ▶️ Prefer to watch? Full video episodes: https://www.youtube.com/@DoorTwo/podcasts 🔔 If conversations about leadership, identity, and growth resonate with you, follow the show. In The Arena is a podcast about what it really means to live and lead well: the patterns that run us, the scripts we inherit, and the beliefs we reinforce without realizing it. Hosted by Shaun Dyke of DoorTwo.


















