
The Good Samaritan Should Make Us Uncomfortable
Deconstructing While Keeping the Good When I left the church almost a decade ago, a lot of pent-up anger and doubt was finally able to surface. I admitted to myself that I had huge problems with many of the verses and Bible stories I’d spent years passively absorbing. Weighing them against my lived experience and the skills I was gaining in therapy left a lot of holes in my theology. I no longer wanted to believe in a vengeful god who needed me to be small and shame-filled. Looking back, I can see how vital this stage was. Only in being willing to walk away from the faith that had formed me, to say that Truth was more important to me than any particular doctrine, was I able to start to piece together a spirituality that allowed me to live in integrity. Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Only by facing my anger and disillusionment was I able to work through them and come out on the other side with the surprising realization that there were still parts of Christianity that appealed to me. Once the dust settled, I was able to start going back through the Bible and decide what to keep and what to let go of. While there are still parts of the Bible I have huge issues with, one story I keep coming back to, again and again, is The Good Samaritan. A Story, not a Rule A frustrating thing about the character of Jesus (as portrayed in the Bible) is his indirectness. We all crave simple, useful answers. But perhaps this ambiguity serves a greater purpose. In his book, Love Matters More, author and podcaster, Jared Byas, puts it this way: “Jesus asked 307 questions in the Bible. He is asked 183. He directly answers 3. It’s almost as if Jesus wasn’t interested in giving us answers as much as he was in growing us into people who can make a nuanced decision based on a wise reading of the circumstance.” And so it is with the story of The Good Samaritan. When a religious scholar asks Jesus, “Who is my neighbor?” Jesus doesn’t give a list of qualifications; he tells a story. The Good Undocumented Immigrant A modern version of that story might sound like this: A Trump supporter wearing a MAGA hat was on a road trip. When he stopped for gas, a group of people surrounded him, beat him up, and stole his phone, wallet, and car. Then they left him on the side of the road, half dead. A doctor was driving home when she saw the bloodied man lying by the side of the road. She thought about stopping, but she was exhausted from a long shift at the hospital. “There are other people passing by; someone else will help him,” she said to herself. Then a senator drove by in a motorcade. He pretended not to see the man. He had an important press conference to get to and, frankly, he wondered about the optics. Finally, an undocumented immigrant saw the Trump supporter. The immigrant felt empathy for the beaten man. He pulled over and helped the man into his truck. The immigrant took the man to the ER and sat with him for hours. While they waited, the immigrant bought the man snacks, called his wife, and helped him fill out his paperwork. The immigrant stayed with the Trump supporter until he was admitted to the hospital. In many translations, Jesus ends his story with the question, “Which of these three do you think was a neighbor to the man who fell into the hands of robbers?” In The Message, the question is translated as: “Which of the three became a neighbor…?” (emphasis mine.) Whereas we normally define neighbor simply as someone who lives near us, Jesus defines neighborliness by action. All three people had close proximity to the victim (as we normally think of with neighbors) and they all had opportunity to help. But only one person allowed himself to be moved to empathy and then action. And the kicker? It wasn’t the wealthiest or most powerful person who helped, someone who could marshall great resources. It was a marginalized person. Who Must I Help? Who Would Help Me? Who are our “Samaritans”? Who do we look down on? From whom do we expect nothing? Where do we draw lines about who to empathize with and who to ignore? Try filling in the story with yourself and your “enemy.” Imagine the person you look down on saving your life. It’s easiest to empathize with people who are like us. When I hear about the plight of other white, liberal, middle-class moms, it’s easy for me to imagine myself in their shoes because we share so many similarities. It’s harder to empathize with people who don’t hold my same views—say, someone who believes in sexist nonsense like repealing women’s right to vote. Would I stop to help such a person? I hope so! Similarly, it’s harder for me to empathize with someone who’s homeless or addicted to drugs. There is so much open-air drug use and urban camping in Seattle that these problems often feel overwhelming. If I focused solely on acting like a Good Samaritan to these folks, I don’t think I’d ever have time to get groceries, let alone work and parent. Beyond Individual Action I have to recognize that I am limited: I can’t solve homelessness, addiction, or any other number of systemic problems. Like the quote from Jared Byas, I can only strive to make a nuanced decision based on a wise reading of the circumstances. Sometimes I give to panhandlers, sometimes I don’t. I volunteer and donate to charity and try to be kind, and hope I’m not letting myself off the hook too easily. I can see both the limitations of individual action AND that our world would be radically better if everyone acted like Good Samaritans all the time. Maybe that’s a tension we have to live with. The story challenges us to be less self-focused and to keep extending our empathy in ever-widening circles. Perhaps that’s the biggest takeaway from The Good Samaritan—that love is no respecter of difference. Every time humans try to draw a line around who is worthy of our compassion and who’s not, love shows up to cross that line. May we stay soft to compassion. May we never resist generous impulses. May we always cross lines in the name of love. Anniversary Sale! Heretic Hereafter is celebrating its 4th anniversary. For the month of November, I’m offering paid subscriptions for 50% off! That’s $4 a month, or $40 per year FOREVER. All affiliate links posted in this newsletter are through Bookshop.org. Buying from these links means you’re supporting my work and your local bookstore. Thanks! This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit heretichereafter.substack.com/subscribe
- Transcript


















