Skip to content
Artwork for Heretic Hereafter Podcast
FictionComedy FictionReligion & SpiritualityExplicit

Heretic Hereafter Podcast

Katharine Strange

Heretic Hereafter is about figuring out how to live the good life after leaving Evangelical Christianity. Whether you're religious or not, join us for a weekly dose of humor and reflection that helps us look past the superficial for life's deeper meanings.

heretichereafter.substack.com
Play
  • 28 episodes
  • weekly
  • Avg 7 min
  • English
Counted on this page — what you have heard stays on this device, so it is not something the list can be paged by.
  • S4 · E2
    Yesterday · 5 min

    The Good Samaritan Should Make Us Uncomfortable

    Deconstructing While Keeping the Good When I left the church almost a decade ago, a lot of pent-up anger and doubt was finally able to surface. I admitted to myself that I had huge problems with many of the verses and Bible stories I’d spent years passively absorbing. Weighing them against my lived experience and the skills I was gaining in therapy left a lot of holes in my theology. I no longer wanted to believe in a vengeful god who needed me to be small and shame-filled. Looking back, I can see how vital this stage was. Only in being willing to walk away from the faith that had formed me, to say that Truth was more important to me than any particular doctrine, was I able to start to piece together a spirituality that allowed me to live in integrity. Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Only by facing my anger and disillusionment was I able to work through them and come out on the other side with the surprising realization that there were still parts of Christianity that appealed to me. Once the dust settled, I was able to start going back through the Bible and decide what to keep and what to let go of. While there are still parts of the Bible I have huge issues with, one story I keep coming back to, again and again, is The Good Samaritan. A Story, not a Rule A frustrating thing about the character of Jesus (as portrayed in the Bible) is his indirectness. We all crave simple, useful answers. But perhaps this ambiguity serves a greater purpose. In his book, Love Matters More, author and podcaster, Jared Byas, puts it this way: “Jesus asked 307 questions in the Bible. He is asked 183. He directly answers 3. It’s almost as if Jesus wasn’t interested in giving us answers as much as he was in growing us into people who can make a nuanced decision based on a wise reading of the circumstance.” And so it is with the story of The Good Samaritan. When a religious scholar asks Jesus, “Who is my neighbor?” Jesus doesn’t give a list of qualifications; he tells a story. The Good Undocumented Immigrant A modern version of that story might sound like this: A Trump supporter wearing a MAGA hat was on a road trip. When he stopped for gas, a group of people surrounded him, beat him up, and stole his phone, wallet, and car. Then they left him on the side of the road, half dead. A doctor was driving home when she saw the bloodied man lying by the side of the road. She thought about stopping, but she was exhausted from a long shift at the hospital. “There are other people passing by; someone else will help him,” she said to herself. Then a senator drove by in a motorcade. He pretended not to see the man. He had an important press conference to get to and, frankly, he wondered about the optics. Finally, an undocumented immigrant saw the Trump supporter. The immigrant felt empathy for the beaten man. He pulled over and helped the man into his truck. The immigrant took the man to the ER and sat with him for hours. While they waited, the immigrant bought the man snacks, called his wife, and helped him fill out his paperwork. The immigrant stayed with the Trump supporter until he was admitted to the hospital. In many translations, Jesus ends his story with the question, “Which of these three do you think was a neighbor to the man who fell into the hands of robbers?” In The Message, the question is translated as: “Which of the three became a neighbor…?” (emphasis mine.) Whereas we normally define neighbor simply as someone who lives near us, Jesus defines neighborliness by action. All three people had close proximity to the victim (as we normally think of with neighbors) and they all had opportunity to help. But only one person allowed himself to be moved to empathy and then action. And the kicker? It wasn’t the wealthiest or most powerful person who helped, someone who could marshall great resources. It was a marginalized person. Who Must I Help? Who Would Help Me? Who are our “Samaritans”? Who do we look down on? From whom do we expect nothing? Where do we draw lines about who to empathize with and who to ignore? Try filling in the story with yourself and your “enemy.” Imagine the person you look down on saving your life. It’s easiest to empathize with people who are like us. When I hear about the plight of other white, liberal, middle-class moms, it’s easy for me to imagine myself in their shoes because we share so many similarities. It’s harder to empathize with people who don’t hold my same views—say, someone who believes in sexist nonsense like repealing women’s right to vote. Would I stop to help such a person? I hope so! Similarly, it’s harder for me to empathize with someone who’s homeless or addicted to drugs. There is so much open-air drug use and urban camping in Seattle that these problems often feel overwhelming. If I focused solely on acting like a Good Samaritan to these folks, I don’t think I’d ever have time to get groceries, let alone work and parent. Beyond Individual Action I have to recognize that I am limited: I can’t solve homelessness, addiction, or any other number of systemic problems. Like the quote from Jared Byas, I can only strive to make a nuanced decision based on a wise reading of the circumstances. Sometimes I give to panhandlers, sometimes I don’t. I volunteer and donate to charity and try to be kind, and hope I’m not letting myself off the hook too easily. I can see both the limitations of individual action AND that our world would be radically better if everyone acted like Good Samaritans all the time. Maybe that’s a tension we have to live with. The story challenges us to be less self-focused and to keep extending our empathy in ever-widening circles. Perhaps that’s the biggest takeaway from The Good Samaritan—that love is no respecter of difference. Every time humans try to draw a line around who is worthy of our compassion and who’s not, love shows up to cross that line. May we stay soft to compassion. May we never resist generous impulses. May we always cross lines in the name of love. Anniversary Sale! Heretic Hereafter is celebrating its 4th anniversary. For the month of November, I’m offering paid subscriptions for 50% off! That’s $4 a month, or $40 per year FOREVER. All affiliate links posted in this newsletter are through Bookshop.org. Buying from these links means you’re supporting my work and your local bookstore. Thanks! This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit heretichereafter.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • S4 · E1
    November 11 · 5 min

    What Does “Loving Thy Neighbor” Actually Look Like?

    Hey, there. I’m back from the trenches of King County elections. Election night was frenzied: I spent the evening fighting with printers and filing change-of-address forms and didn’t have a second to check my phone until I got the train at 9:30pm. Highly recommend! When I got home, I was thrilled to find out that candidates like James Talarico had flipped conservative seats, joining a group of "Matthew 25 Christians” who are representing their faith not through restricting the rights of their fellow Americans, but by advocating for social programs like universal healthcare and increasing food aid to the poor. In fact, many Talarico campaign signs simply bore the phrase, “love thy neighbor.” I’m cautiously optimistic about this group of legislators, but they face a lot of obstacles. Will they be able to break the GOP’s stranglehold over white evangelicals? Will they hold to their principals, or will this end up being just another case of politicians wrapping themselves in the mantle of Christianity? Only time will tell. Meanwhile, I want to examine what this Bible-verse-turned-campaign-slogan really means. What does it actually look like to love your neighbor? And is love really that big of a deal? Wannabe Bohemians In the summer of 2001, vibrating with excitement, my friends (a gaggle of theater kids) and I plopped into movie theater seats and watched, rapt as the opening credits of Baz Luhrmann’s Moulin Rouge took us to 19th-century Paris. Weeping over his typewriter, Ewan MacGregor gasped, “The greatest gift you’ll ever learn is just to love and be loved in return.” Over the next two hours, we became Bohemians: dedicated to the ideals of beauty, truth, freedom, love…and, presumably, absinthe and Elton John covers. Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. At 16, I was feeling trapped by a family that was more focused on projecting material success than meeting its members’ emotional needs. I yearned for the freedom I saw onscreen. Driving back and forth to my rural high school, I blasted RENT on my car stereo and even dug into La Bohème, its operatic source material. In my family, money was often a means of control, so I would prove that I didn’t need it. I would break free, no matter what. Now in my forties, I look back on that 16-year-old with both admiration and amusement. It’s certainly easy to romanticize poverty when you’ve never been broke, as I would come to learn. Still, I kinda think the movie was right about love? Loving and being loved, that’s what so much of life comes down to. And for many of us, love is something we have to consciously pursue, practice, and get better at. What is Love? (Apologies if I just ear wormed you or gave you Night at the Roxbury flashbacks.) For something that is so central to a meaningful life, there isn’t a lot of cultural consensus about what love actually is. How do we define it? As feeling? Verb? Do you know it when you see it? As the American philosopher, bell hooks, writes in her book, All About Love, “My work as a cultural critic offered me a constant opportunity to pay close attention to everything the mass media, particularly movies and magazines, tell us about love. Mostly they tell us that everyone wants love but that we remain totally confused about the practice of love in everyday life. In popular culture love is always the stuff of fantasy.” (emphasis mine.) If you grew up attending church, you’ve probably learned about “love languages” and about the seven different words used for love in ancient Greek, which is the language the New Testament was written in. Most of the pastors I’ve heard on the subject take pains to denote the difference between “eros” (defined as romantic/erotic love) vs. “agape” which is a universal, altruistic form of love that a person feels for God, other humans, and for nature. Our culture spends a lot of time building monuments to eros and idealizing familial love, but other types of love go largely unrecognized. I wonder whether this ambiguity leads to fewer and weaker connections. We seem to be in a moment of flux. Many people want more community, but we’re unsure what we owe other people or how best to show up. Maybe learning about what love is (and what it isn’t) can guide us towards the kind of meaningful, connected lives we want to be living. Studying Love In the weeks leading up to the holidays, let’s learn about LOVE. Here are some questions I have: * How do we define love? * Do we ‘owe’ love to others? What if they don’t act lovingly towards us? * How do we balance loving others and loving ourselves? * Can love and abuse coexist, or does the presence of abuse negate love? * How do people learn to love if we grew up with imperfect models? * Does our culture put too much emphasis on romantic love to the exclusion of other types? Can “found family” be an adequate substitute for broken familial relationships? And here are some resources I’m looking at: * the story of The Good Samaritan * bell hooks’ All About Love * Esther Perel’s Mating in Captivity And I’m thinking of these quotes: * “Happy people love people, use things and find meaning beyond themselves. Unhappy people use people, love things and seek meaning in themselves.” —Arthur Brooks * “An old Indian saying puts it more bluntly: The worst thing that can be said about a person is, ‘He acts like he has no relatives.’” —Randy Woodley What questions do you have about love? What else should I be reading/watching/listening to as we explore this topic? As always, I’m happy to hear from you in the comments or via DM or email. Anniversary Sale! Heretic Hereafter is celebrating its 4th anniversary. For the month of November, I’m offering paid subscriptions for 50% off! That’s $4 a month, or $40 per year FOREVER. All affiliate links posted in this newsletter are through Bookshop.org. Buying from these links means you’re supporting my work and your local bookstore. Thanks! BONUS MATERIALS: * this article on the 7 types of love according to Greek philosophy is worth a read * gift link to NYT article on Matthew 25 legislators * just for teehees This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit heretichereafter.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • S3 · E24
    October 28 · 6 min

    Everyone Wants to Be Liam Neeson, No One Wants to Wash the Dishes

    There’s a certain movie genre I think of as “dad fantasy.” Its tropes are easy to recognize: take a man with combat experience and throw in a semi-estranged daughter. Oh no! Bad guys got the daughter! BUT her dad will rescue her through an act of redemptive violence. Yes, this dad gets to show his love by spraying bullets everywhere! He successfully rescues his daughter, who is transformed from surly adolescent back into the little girl who idolized him. Taken is the platonic ideal, but I think this can expand even to Christian genres with their benevolent-but-distant patriarchs whose wisdom the wayward daughter will come to appreciate by the end of the novel. Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. The Taken Archetype & Its Problems These dad fantasies demonstrate a certain masculine archetype: a steely, distant patriarch capable of great violence. The emotionally distant part is very interesting to me—we know that in order to build solid relationships, people need to: * emotionally attune to each other * show interest in the other person’s world * spend time together But the dad fantasy tries to shortcut this process through a violent grand gesture. In her piece, Tough dads with grenades are a weirdly comforting fantasy. Why? Francesca Cavallo writes that the emotional distance is key to being the ideal protector: “If I am the protector, I must always look like I am in control. To appear in control (since no human being is always in control), I have to hide my vulnerabilities, to pretend they don’t exist. Et voilà, emotional distance is served.” In Taken, Neeson’s character warns his daughter against taking her European trip. As the perfect protector, he knows for certain what is safe and what is dangerous. It is only when his daughter disregards his judgment that she’s endangered. The message is: she is only safe under his control. This archetype appeals to men who wants to feel in control of their families. The problem is: people don’t like being controlled. In my scientific estimation, this is the basis for 90% of conflicts between toddlers and their parents and teens and their parents. And while there are circumstances where parents need to control a child’s behavior (i.e. a toddler running into the street, an irresponsible teen driver), psychiatrists consider controlling behavior in adult relationships abusive. The second problem with this archetype is a misperception of threat. Women and girls are most at risk of violence not from gangs of sex trafficking kidnappers, but from the men they love. In fact, 60% of murdered women are killed by their partner or a family member (compared to only 11% of murdered men) and nearly 30% of women worldwide have experienced intimate partner violence. If we’re telling men it’s masculine to be emotionally distant, controlling, and violent in certain contexts, are we tacitly condoning violence towards women? Men Deserve Better Stories When our culture holds up the Taken archetype as a masculine ideal, it has real impacts. In his piece, Rigged to Explode, Garrett Bucks writes: “There’s so much toxicity in the stories that we men internalize about ourselves: about how we are the heroes of ours and everybody else’s lives, about how every time we feel threatened or diminished in any way that we get to throw a fit, about how the world demands our dominance and force more than it begs us to be alive to the humanity of all those who surround us.” (emphasis mine.) That’s not to say you’re a bad person if you like these stories. Even if you took a moral stand of not buying a ticket to the next Jason Statham movie, stories like this would persist because they prop up the larger system of patriarchy. There’s nothing wrong with fantasy. Movies are a visual medium, and explosions LOOK COOL. The trouble is when we start conflating fantasy with reality, when men think their role is to protect their families by doomsday prepping or joining ICE instead of performing the mundane tasks that actually make a family function. And I get it; watching a chase scene is certainly more thrilling than watching a dad driving carpool. But if we allow our vision of masculinity to narrow that much, we lose part of our humanity. As I wrote about in last week’s article about male coming-of-age rituals, “manhood” in most societies is equated with self-sacrifice. We are lucky to live in a (relatively) safe society where 99% of men are not asked to physically protect their others. In such cases, what does sacrifice for the greater good look like? A Different Type of Hero Can I brag about my husband for a second? When we started dating and talking about things like favorite books, he told me his was Kurt Vonnegut’s God Bless You, Mr. Rosewater. I read it, swooned, and patted myself on the back for picking such a good guy. Rosewater, one of Vonnegut’s lesser-known novels, is a satire of the one-percent. Eliot Rosewater, heir to a family fortune, decides to start using his money to help people. But his charity will not go unpunished, as a distant cousin and an unscrupulous lawyer team up to frame him as insane (after all, what sane person would give away that much money?) Can Rosewater thwart their attempts to disinherit him and keep helping his neighbors? Eliot Rosewater is the kind of hero we could use more of. He’s far from perfect (for one thing, he’s a drunk) but still, he exemplifies the kind of self-sacrifice that his community actually needs rather than pretending to heroism. When I tried to come up with a list of these “good neighbor”-type heroes, I found them in family movies (the dad who ditches work to see his kids’ little league game) and rom-coms (who doesn’t love a Cinnamon Roll hero?) but noticeably, these are not movies marketed towards men! Sports movies are the only “guy” genre I could come up with that features these types of heroes (usually in the form of a wise coach.) The Type of Man Who Actually Makes Women Feel Safe Contrary to what action movies show, the type of man women feel safe with is not a Rambo or a John Wick—it’s someone who’s attuned to her feelings, who does his best to make her feel comfortable instead of pressured. I feel safe with a guy when he doesn’t invade my personal space or use manipulative tactics (such as guilt) against me. I’ve never been bothered by a stranger hitting on me unless he’s clearly disregarding my signals or if he acts aggressively when I reject him. Is reading another person’s signals always easy? No, but it’s a skill anyone can practice and improve on! When we’re watching movies now, I sometimes hit pause and quiz my sons on what a character is feeling at a given moment. Do they appreciate this? Absolutely not! But I hope it will help them learn to attune to other peoples’ emotions. What do you think of “dad fantasy”? Are you a huge Liam Neeson fan? Am I being delulu about the dearth of non-violent male heroes? As always, I love to hear from you in the comments, or via email or DM. All affiliate links posted in this newsletter are through Bookshop.org. Buying from these links means you’re supporting my work and your local bookstore. Thanks! BONUS MATERIALS: * in addition to the 2 articles cited above, I was very influenced by Celeste Davis ‘s great post, Be a Hero. Be a Sheep. * Christian worship song or Grindr DM? * speaking of people with problematic dads, I went to see Phoebe Bridgers last weekend and now this song is living rent-free in my head: * Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit heretichereafter.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • S3 · E23
    October 21 · 8 min

    Are Coming-of-Age Rituals Key to Making Good Men?

    content warning: mention of sexual assault My 14-year-old son wants to go to “Man School.” The idea came up when we were listening to this episode of “The Art of Manliness” with author Jon Tyson who wrote about a years’ long curriculum he designed for his son to transition him from boyhood to manhood. Part of me likes this idea: there are A TON of skills kids need to learn before leaving the nest and framing it as a rite of passage seems like a smart idea. On the other hand, this author (who was giving secret youth pastor vibes) takes it to 11 in some odd ways, including daily lectures and proposing a “severing dinner” between mother and son, which immediately raised my hackles. What’s a mom to do? The Importance of Ritual I’m interested in coming-of-age rituals and their signifigance. As our culture has grown increasingly suspicious of institutions and less connected to community, rituals have decreased. Think about it—can you name a ritual most Americans would recognize apart from weddings and funerals? Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Outside of institutions like churches, many rituals feel silly. When I was a teen, I remember a friend’s aunt who created her own ceremony involving burning bowls and how weird we thought it was. Community is an essential part of ritual. They act as witnesses and they validate the ritual’s meaning. Rituals mark a change—from single to married, from life into death—and those changes must be accepted by the community. I wonder if our murkiness around adulthood stems from our lack of coming-of-age rituals. A kid who wakes up on their 18th birthday is probably still living with their parents and going to high school. Legally, they’re now an adult, but there is no significant change in their responsibilities or social status. Manhood Around the World… For girls, there are many informal initiations into womanhood, both biological (like menstruation) and socio-cultural (like the first time she’s leered at by a grown man or learning to walk home with her keys between her fingers.) Male puberty is typically less obvious than its female counterpart. Maybe this is one reason why coming-of-age rituals are so prevalent for boys around the world. Anthropologist David Gilmour studied a few dozen global cultures in his book, Manhood in the Making. In all but two, boys went through rituals which were generally brutal and risky in order to pass into manhood. Explaining the similarities in these processes, he writes, “…true ‘manhood’ frequently shows an inner insecurity that needs dramatic proof.” (emphasis mine.) Gilmour goes on to contrast the norms of manhood and womanhood. By and large, global norms around womanhood revolve around caretaking the immediate and extended family. This is both biological (like giving birth and breastfeeding) and highly culturally pressured. For men, who are typically stronger than women and have more cultural cache, there is less pressure to caretake children and elders. They have the power to be selfish, and therefore, coming-of-age rituals serve to establish the norms of masculinity, which always involve sacrificing individual gain in favor of the community. Gilmour writes: “One of my findings here is that manhood ideologies always include a criterion of selfless generosity, even to the point of sacrifice. Again and again, we find that ‘real men’ are those who give more than they take. They serve others. Men nurture their society by shedding their blood, their sweat, and their semen, by bringing home food for both child and mother, by producing children, and by dying, if necessary, in faraway places to provide a safe haven for their people. This, too, is nurturing.” A good manhood ritual, it seems to me, is one that acknowledges the power (both physical and political) that men hold in our society and demands that they use that power for the greater good. …Versus Fraternity Hazing Contrast this with one of the few manhood rituals that remains in our culture: fraternity initiations. Like traditional masculinity rituals, they are often brutal and involve risk-taking. At the same point, they are stingy with their idea of community—basically, your only duty is to your frat brothers. There is no care towards women, children, or the community as a whole. Indeed, brothers are often encouraged towards anti-social behaviors that harm their campus and town. In a recent interview with The Cut about the Cornell 7 case, three fraternity members shared about how fraternity culture contributes to a three-fold increase in sexual assault among fraternity members. One brother, Brandon F., talked about how the hazing process ate away at his integrity. “After I [completed the initiation] I was just happy. I didn’t notice any problems until I started dating. They would pressure each other to sleep around…So I started being a fuckboy, and then that was when I saw how the system teaches the wrong things…I was just enforcing the system, and I didn’t know I was destroying my self-respect and giving up my values. And the whole time we’re preaching these lessons of integrity, of brotherhood, of being a gentleman. Like, they teach you to hold doors for people during pledging, but that goes out the window.” What we see in these instances, is power for selfish ends. The point of these fraternities seems to be a.) hedonism and b.) networking, i.e., it’s all about personal gain, not contributing to the greater good. There’s also a huge problem with a lack of accountability: “During the hazing, they care a lot about accountability. Follow the rules or else we’ll hold you accountable…[But] as soon as it’s something that challenges the group, they turn against you…Fraternities are basically cults. Because hazing teaches people to break down their boundaries, to be people pleasers, to humiliate others. When you have a whole group of people doing that, it normalizes suffering and pain, so then when someone else suffers, like say they get raped, it’s like, Oh it’s no big deal…” The Missing Ingredients Contrasting these coming-of-age rituals, we start to get a clearer picture of the purpose and necessary ingredients of pro-social initiation. To my mind, the road to becoming a mature adult involves: * learning skills * taking on more responsibilities * being accountable to the community If the discourse about “adulting” and “helicopter parents” is any reliable indicator, we’re failing kids on all three fronts. That’s not to say that kids need to have all of this figured out by age 18, indeed, maturation should be a life-long process, but I wonder if much of today’s youth mental health crisis results from not feeling important to their community. In shielding kids from responsibility, have parents inadvertently left them purposeless? Likewise, so many of us lack any sort of community, let alone one strong enough to hold us accountable for our behavior. If a true friend is one that calls you out on your BS, doesn’t it follow that a true community is one that can redirect you towards maturity and virtue? Accountability matters most when people have a lot of power—in this case, men. Too often patriarchy coddles men when it comes to their treatment of women and children. It blames sexual assault on women’s clothing or behavior rather than on the person committing the assault. Modern Christianity, with its false definitions of modesty, has often played into this infantilization of men. (Don’t forget Jesus’ remedy to lust: plucking out one’s eyes!) So Where Does That Leave Us? I do think coming-of-age rituals can be meaningful, important moments, even after my son’s journey through confirmation class didn’t go as planned. I am intrigued by the idea of “Man School,” while also being concerned whether we’ll be able to pull this off in between driving our kids to their 10,000 extracurricular activities. I also think that community is importan… This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit heretichereafter.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • S3 · E23
    October 14 · 7 min

    Public Humiliation is Not Justice

    Content warning: discussion of sexual assault, child sexual abuse, and suicide. Recently, my husband and I were having lunch with another couple and their toddler son. The wife and I were complaining about how our entire social media feeds had been taken over by the Cornell 7 case, how inescapable and anxiety-producing it was. She said something to the effect of, “Plus, now that the algorithm knows I have a son, I’m getting all this content about how it’s my job to prevent him from assaulting someone. It’s so overwhelming and he’s only one!” (When we asked the husbands about their social media feeds, there was scarcely a mention of the case, no talk about how fathers of sons ought to be fighting rape culture. Fixing the entire patriarchy is, apparently, just another task on the endless list of modern mothering to-dos.) Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. The Reaction to the Cornell 7 Case By now I’m sure you know the broad strokes of the Cornell 7 case. Women are being hit hard by this news—this was not only an attack on Jane Doe, it also feels like a reminder that we are not safe, that many men see us as less-than-human. The actions of the Cornell rapists were despicable, dehumanizing, and traumatic. The way that campus and local police, along with school administration, swept this crime under the rug are both horrifying and all too familiar. The rage that’s pouring forth is, I believe, a reaction to this lack of accountability, this absence of justice. Of course people are outraged—the situation is outrageous. But I am troubled by the internet mobs that seek revenge in lieu of justice. Many of the posts I’ve seen have a sort of gleeful attitude— “let’s dox, threaten, and ruin these men’s lives” is the vibe. Several innocent people who have the same name as the alleged rapists have been doxxed and harassed—internet “justice” is far from precise. Revenge is Not Justice This situation is not unique. In the early 00s, To Catch a Predator, a police sting/hit TV show served up the ritual humiliation of alleged pedophiles for the pleasure of the viewing audience. It was a ratings juggernaut until one of its targets, a local D.A., killed himself. Recently, some have begun to interrogate the ethics of To Catch a Predator. In a new film, Primetime, Robert Pattinson portrays Chris Hansen, TCaP’s host, as a monstrous figure in his own right. There’s also a critically acclaimed documentary about TCaP called Predators, which I watched this weekend. It was sobering. Without the quick cuts and comedic editing of TCaP, we saw men sobbing, asking for therapy, telling the crew they were going to kill themselves. Their shame was hard to watch. Instead of help, TCaP compounded this shame with violent arrests and public exposure. The filmmaker, himself a victim of childhood sexual abuse, describes watching the original TV show, in part, to understand why some men abused kids. It’s an answer he never gets. We don’t know if the filmmaker’s abuser was ever brought to justice. What we do know is that many victims of CSA felt some catharsis watching TCaP, but it’s a shallow relief that offers no real accountability for the abuse they suffered. Superiority Complex Entertainment I remember enjoying To Catch a Predator during its heyday, even as its attempts to play its stings humorously left me with a queasy feeling. It felt shocking and transgressive to witness the moment a person’s life was, effectively, over. In America, “sex offender” is a very sticky label. Why did we watch? That era was rife with reality TV whose cast members were the butt of the joke: Teen Mom, Jersey Shore, and the like. The pleasure in viewing was the feeling of superiority the viewer experienced. TCaP was the Platonic ideal of this sort of TV: these men, we were assured, were the worst of the worst, and so it was okay to publicly expose them for our entertainment. It is only twenty years later we are learning the nuances of some of these cases. We know, for instance, that many perpetrators of child sexual abuse were once victims themselves. It doesn’t excuse their crimes, but it does paint a more complex picture. In addition, the Predators documentary highlights the story of one young man who was lured to meet a 15-year-old boy. The “pedophile” in this circumstance? An 18-year-old high school senior—a situation which is not illegal in many states. When questioned about the decision to air this episode and ruin this teenager’s life, Hansen seems confident in his decision. He, like many in our internet age, is convinced of his righteousness, which just so happens to align with his financial interests. Internet Vigilantism Fails Everyone To be sure, there are huge problems in the way the U.S. fails to hold rapists and sexual abusers accountable. Our justice system fails victims at so many levels and in so many ways, often leading to further traumatization. But while it is satisfying to think we have some kind of vigilante work-around we can enact from behind our screens, internet “justice” dehumanizes everyone involved. The algorithm incentivizes outrage and sensationalism rather than deliberation and nuance. Many online will, knowingly or unknowingly, spread false information. This fits the definition of slander. According to 12th century Jewish scholar, Maimonides, slander is the only unforgiveable sin because it was impossible to trace how far a rumor had spread and to repair a person’s reputation after the fact. We’ve seen this outrage cycle rebound and hurt the original victims. There is nothing the algorithm loves more than a hot take, so as soon as the majority of people believe X, someone will pop up to say, “actually, Y.” None of this will be fact-checked, there is no deliberative body, just plenty of interference by nefarious actors and professional trolls. And then we come to the matter of doxing and death threats, for which there seem to be little legal accountability, even as they radically disrupt peoples’ lives. The Cost of Dehumanizing Perpetrators It feels comforting to tell ourselves a story: these people are monsters whom we have nothing in common with. We are better than them, nobody we know would ever do something like this. But when we demonize them, we miss the lessons of this story and opportunities to prevent it from happening again. Labeling these men as evil protects the systems that enable this behavior. We can abhor their actions (or, in the case of the rest of the group chat, their inaction) while also recognizing that they responded to an incentive structure which prized “bro code” over the safety, dignity, and rights of a young woman. What Real Justice Looks Like Internet vigilantism satisfies our rage, but it can’t provide real justice. Real justice is slow, hard, deliberative, often frustrating work. What would legal justice look like in this case? * a full criminal investigation into the action/inaction of those involved * legal reforms that align with our current understanding of consent and center the rights of victims throughout the legal process * the removal of police and school administration who prioritized their institution’s reputation over protecting their constituents * teaching accurate, consent-based sex ed in all public schools * support for journalists like those at The Cornell Daily Sun who brought this case into the public consciousness * much more aggressive oversight and regulation of frats, if not a total ban And what about spiritual/moral justice? For this I turn to Rabbi Danya Ruttenberg’s On Repentance and Repair: * Jane Doe deserves to tell her story and explain the impact of this assault. She deserves to be truly heard by the assailants * the assailants need to make authentic apologies to Jane Doe and the community as a whole * the assailants need to make amends to Jane Doe and to the community * the assailants need to change and become better people who will ne… This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit heretichereafter.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • September 16 · 5 min

    The Secret Lives of Christian Wives

    The Dishwasher Dig Several years ago, a houseguest complimented me on my dishwasher loading. At first, I was flattered: yes, I am very efficient at loading the dishwasher and probably everyone else in this house could take a page from my book!!! But then he said, “It makes sense [that you’re good at it.] The dishwasher is your domain.” He meant this as a compliment (I think???) but it was one of those sentences that rattled through my brain with a nefarious clang: your domain is the dishwasher your domain is the dishwasher your domain is the dishwasher Was the subtext, “stay in the kitchen, that’s where women belong”? I didn’t want to think this person saw me that way, but I wondered. This offhand comment had me spiraling into self-doubt and wondering how others saw me. Don’t get me wrong; washing dishes is a vital (and often overlooked) task. But I doubt anyone wants to think of it as their life’s work. Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Ladies: Don’t Forget to Live, Laugh, Love! This memory came back to me as I began reading Kristin Kobes Du Mez’s latest book, Live Laugh Love: The Secret History of White Christian Women and the World They Made. In it, Du Mez traces the evolution of white Evangelical women’s culture, starting in the late 19th century and continuing to the present, up to and including Erica Kirk. As someone who grew up reading Focus on the Family’s Brio magazine, many figures and movements (such as Rebecca St. James and True Love Waits) were old hat to me, but there were plenty of bombshells in Live Laugh Love, including surprising details behind the creation of some childhood favorites like Laura Ingalls Wilder’s Little House on the Prairie series and The Hiding Place by Corrie ten Boom. But the most striking part of Du Mez’s book was the way she was able to trace the pernicious influence of “New Thought” in Christian Fundamentalism. What is “New Thought”? Maybe you know it by the name “The Secret,” “The Law of Attraction,” or "the prosperity gospel.” If you were LDS, it was “keep sweet.” Maybe you know it as the reason you were forced to grit your teeth into a smile at church and pretend that everything was fine—it’s the idea that God blesses those who obey authority and think happy thoughts. Long before your high school classmates started selling Amway, Christian Fundamentalism embedded this pyramid-shaped power structure into its churches and para-church movements. Surrendering to authority was the same as obeying God. Any suffering a person experienced could be traced back to disobedience or doubt. Women were expected to cede authority and decision-making to men, to never criticize or question. In return, men would protect and provide for us. It’s the 1950s housewife (minus the pill addiction) and the 2020s tradwife (minus the army of paid help). Du Mez’s history shows how old this song-and-dance is. Female Christian Influencers have been peddling New Thought since Hannah Whitehall Smith’s The Christian’s Secret of a Happy Life was first published in January 1883. The Dark Reality Behind the Fairy Tale Du Mez effectively demonstrates, again and again, that the women who espoused New Thought as the way to happiness often concealed lives of struggle including broken marriages and disillusionment with Christianity. The story of Elisabeth Elliot, former missionary, was particularly affecting. White Evangelical women have been sold a bargain: that if we give up our agency and power in order to submit to men, those men will take care of us. New Thought and white femininity combined to form a sort of magical thinking: who needs to fight for equal rights when we can have something almost like equality bestowed upon us by our benevolent husbands? But proximity to power isn’t power. Obedience and subservience aren’t power. Only power is power. Women forget that at our own peril. Don’t get it twisted: I’m not saying that marriage is bad or that men can’t be trusted. I am a big proponent of a healthy, interdependent marriage. What I am saying is that it is the height of delusion for women to believe that we can cede our critical thinking and our agency to anyone and come away better for it. Such dependent relationships are not an equal partnership; they’re more akin to a parent-child relationship. And, indeed, much of the advice Du Mez quotes from marriage manuals such as the infamous Fascinating Womanhood advocate that women adopt childish behavior such as pretending to be afraid of cows and stamping their feet when mad. By and large, I found this book enlightening and a worthy follow-up to Du Mez’s earlier hit, Jesus and John Wayne. I’d recommend this book to anyone who wants to know why so many white Evangelical women vote against their own interests or get sucked into pyramid schemes. That being said, I didn’t find this to be an easy read. The book covers a lot of historical ground and keeping track of so many names (particularly the unfamiliar ones) sometimes left me flipping pages back-and-forth trying to remember who was who. In addition, some material may be triggering to women who have religious trauma related to their gender—particularly those who’ve been abused in a church setting. Still, Du Mez’s analysis of the common threads in this history and their connection to our current political climate is enlightening. Just her insight on how 90s Purity Culture was basically the Prosperity Gospel for sex was worth the cover price. As for me, I’ve delegated dish duties to my 14-year-old son. While his methods of loading dishes sometimes defy logic, I’m glad to know this future man will leave my home with plenty of experience handling this important chore. Though I won’t be referring to it as his “domain.” AUTHOR’S NOTE: I received a free Advanced Reader Copy of this book in exchange for an honest review. The book links above are affiliate links that I can earn commission on. Have you read JESUS AND JOHN WAYNE? Do you own any household items adorned with the phrase “Live Laugh Love”? Ever been in an MLM? As always, I love to hear your comments, complaints, and ideas in the comments section! A NOTE ABOUT COMMENTING: It’s always gratifying to have readers leave comments on my work. Last week’s post reached a wider-than-typical audience, including some folks who aren’t used to the way we do things around here. As such, I’ve set up some rules for the comments section. Hope that helps keep the conversation civil and engaging! BONUS MATERIALS: * JUST WATCH THIS, TRUST ME * saw this at Target, feels appropriate: Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit heretichereafter.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • S3 · E23
    September 9 · 5 min

    I Thought I Had Gender Roles Figured Out. Then I Had a Son.

    In a moment of tween desperation, I asked my mom whether I could try out for cheerleading. It was the late 90s and the girls at cheer camp seemed to have cracked some secret code to girlhood: their hair was always perfectly styled; their lips impeccably glossy. If I could just don that pleated skirt, I was sure their power would rub off on me and I’d stop being the middle school weirdo. “Girls shouldn’t cheer for boys,” my mom replied, “they should cheer for themselves.” Cryptic, vaguely feminist sayings like this occasionally sprang from her mouth, despite her staunch Complementarian beliefs (Complementarianism is the belief that men and women hold separate but equal roles in church and family life and that these roles are prescribed by God). Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. On the one hand, Mom would insist that all women had a divine calling to marriage, motherhood, and subservience to men. Then she’d turn around and spout off a defiant little opinion that hinted at her own internal conflict. I never became a cheerleader. Instead, I grew into a youth group superstar and then a know-it-all Christian college freshman. There I decided that it made no sense that I by dint of my femaleness was assumed to know less about faith than some random dude. I rejected my parents’ complementarianism and became an egalitarian and a—gasp! —feminist. And yet, the sexism of my upbringing hadn’t left me. I still believed marriage and motherhood were my ultimate calling and doubted my ability to get by without the guidance of either my father or a husband. The truth was, I’d never been taught to cheer for myself or believe myself capable of big things. Still, I imagined myself one day raising a fierce feminist daughter who would grow up to achieve great things. And then I had two sons. Boys were not entirely foreign to me—I had two younger brothers whom I’d spent a large chunk of my childhood mothering. But I wanted to do things differently. When my first son, A, was born, I bought him gender neutral clothes and toys—blocks and balls and a doll he’d occasionally poke in the eye. I was going to raise him to be a sensitive little feminist. Then one Christmas, a family member received a set of Dollar Store plastic samurai swords and A, then 18 months old, shrieked, grabbed one, and immediately began chasing people around the house, whacking and stabbing them. Even as I laughed at the spectacle, I couldn’t believe his tiny bloodlust. He didn’t watch TV; he’d never even seen a sword before. How did he know what it was for before he was even potty trained?!?!? Until A was born, I’d always thought of gender as something that was, largely, culturally programmed. But the sword incident, coupled with his fascination with vehicles, left me questioning this assumption. There was something innate to this small human that loudly insisted I AM A BOY!!!!! If masculinity is a spectrum, A has always been on the extreme end. In our liberal Seattle neighborhood, where plenty of little boys are painting their nails and belting songs from Frozen, there was my little warrior, dressed in head-to-toe camo, toting a Nerf gun to the park longer than he was tall, while I follow along behind, cringing and hoping my neighbors didn’t think I was in the NRA. Now a high school freshman, A is in the thick of the work of adolescence: figuring out who he is. While I appreciate that our culture has evolved from suffocating gender roles and casual playground homophobia, I’ll admit that our culture’s shifting social mores around gender roles has left a bit of a vacuum, into which, I project all my anxieties about raising a good men. So, over the next two months I want to look at gender roles. Here are some questions I have: * Is gender innate, culturally constructed, or both? And does the answer change how we think about it? * Are gender roles inherently limiting? Are they ever helpful? * How do we deprogram ourselves from our own internalized misogyny? * How has the church’s emphasis on restrictive gender roles shaped how we understand ourselves/our spirituality? * What can non-binary, trans, and genderqueer people teach us about gender? * What about the whole “toxic masculinity” label—is it helpful? Should we chuck it? How can we criticize the power structure without denigrating individuals caught in it? * How do we talk positively about masculinity without downplaying or dismissing women? * What role does virtue play in “becoming a man/woman”? * What about coming-of-age rituals? Are they more necessary for boys than girls? * Why does the phrase “be a man” squick me out so much? What should we be saying instead? * How do we express our gender identity through clothing, hair, and other signals? * How much of gender performance is an attempt to gain power in a misogynistic society? And here are some resources I’m looking at: * Jennifer L.W. Fink ‘s Substack, Building Boys Bulletin and her book Building Boys: Raising Great Guys in a World That Misunderstands Males * Richard Reeves’ Of Boys and Men * Liz Cooledge Jenkins ‘s Nice Churchy Patriarchy * Kristin Du Mez ‘s Live Laugh Love * the podcast The Art of Manliness Now I want to hear from you! Do any of my questions intrigue you? Do you have other deep thoughts or questions about gender roles? Has your view of your own gender changed over time? Do you have any books, podcasts, or people I should consult to learn more about gender roles? I’d love to hear from you in the comments or via email or DM. BONUS MATERIALS: * American church vs. French church * how DO straight guys sit??? * “One of the best abilities in life is to figure out who you actually want to be.” Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit heretichereafter.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • S3 · E23
    August 26 · 6 min

    Love in the ER

    Two weeks ago, my husband shook me awake at 4:00 a.m. “I’m going to the emergency room,” he said. I tried to blink myself awake. Never much of a complainer, Ryan had grown increasingly miserable over the past few days due to a pain in the roof of his mouth. That night, the pain had kept him from sleeping. I think I mumbled something along the lines of, “What? How?” as I sat up in bed. “I’ll take an Uber,” he said. My sleep-fogged brain considered this. My pillow was calling to me. And Ryan had taken himself to the ER alone before—Boxing Day 2014 when we had a toddler and a newborn and he’d stepped on a (shockingly sharp!) toy excavator, slicing a deep gouge into his toe. Then, like now, I knew it was a gray area sort of injury: requiring immediate medical attention, but not something life-threatening. And here he was giving me an out to back to sleep… “No, I’ll take you,” I murmured, mentally running through the tasks this would require, what I needed to bring, whom I needed to notify. ***This summer I’ve been thinking about what it actually takes to make community work. Much has been written about the loneliness crisis, growing rates of estrangement, how we are replacing eye contact with screen staring. Somewhere in the past few months I heard the phrase, “Everyone wants a village, no one wants to be a villager,” and I wonder, could it really be that simple? Is our lack of community simply our own fault? *** Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Ryan and I wound up at Seattle’s Harborview Medical Center. It’s a level one trauma center that I only knew from newspaper write ups about gunshot victims. I’d hoped that 4:00 a.m. on a Wednesday morning would be relatively quiet, that he’d get a quick exam, maybe some pain medicine, and we’d be on our merry way. We were greeted by five security guards, two police officers, and a metal detector. The waiting room benches hosted sleeping forms surrounded by piles of plastic bags and dirty backpacks, the tell-tale baggage of homelessness. Nurses seemed to know many patients by name—frequent fliers, I guessed. This ER felt like the last, fraying threads of a broken safety net. Here were the disabled, the poor, the mentally ill, the addicted. And yet people fell through the cracks here, too. As we waited, I witnessed security eject two patients who were acting aggressively. Even as I was relieved at their removal, I wondered where they would go. ***Culturally, we are going through a profound shift in the way we understand relationships, and I think this has a lot to do with geography: for most of human history, community was not chosen but default. It was the people in your tribe, your extended family, your neighbors. Humans were tied to land and to ancestral homes. Waves of migration and industrialization disconnected many of us from the lands of our ancestors. Increasing economic pressure pushed generations of striving young people towards college education and the metropolitan hubs of various industries. Now, many of us have unprecedented levels of choice in where we live, what we do for work, and whom we associate with. The digital revolution, helped by the pandemic, further fractured the connection between place and relationship. Now your closest confidante might be someone you only chat with online and you may spend more time focused on parasocial relationships with podcasters or influencers rather than with friends you see in real life. Real life? Who has time for that? *** A few hours after arriving, Ryan was finally taken to an exam room—and by “room” I mean “tiny alcove with curtain.” En route to our alcove, we walked through corridors lined with patients on gurneys—there didn’t seem to be a spare inch of space. Some patients slept in chairs hooked up to IVs. In the alcove stood a bed crowned with a variety of tubes and monitors. I looked around—there was no place for me to sit. The expectation, I realized, is that people come to this hospital alone. Indeed, no one I’d seen in the waiting room was accompanied. *** In the course of my 40+ years, I’ve said many goodbyes. I’ve moved 16 times. I have clashed with church communities whose beliefs I no longer held. I’ve gone no contact with family members. Maybe all of this had led me to a certain amount of overthinking on the topic of relationships and community. I notice how much time people in my community spend trying to optimize ourselves and our kids: we’ll do anything for work, anything to give our kids an extracurricular edge, even if these things (like travel sports) make us broke and miserable. There’s always a fear of being left behind. On the rare occasion that I’m able to get together with my neighbors we always find ourselves saying things like, “this is so fun” and “we should do this more often,” and yet…we don’t. We’re too busy, too tired, too introverted, too awkward. We’ve forgotten that the most important part is just showing up. *** The doctor apologized for the lack of chair and found one for me. Ryan and I spent eight total hours in the emergency department. Apart from fetching snacks, I was pretty superfluous to the process, but Ryan thanked me for coming. His pain improved. The doctor examined and scanned him before referring him to a dentist because apparently, doctors don’t do mouth stuff? Ryan felt silly and annoyed that we’d wasted so much time in the ER on what was likely a dental issue. “It’s not a big deal,” I said. “Remember last summer when I thought I was in anaphylaxis and called 911?” The paramedics had been very kind as they showed me my lack of swollen lips and tongue in the mirror. During our 19 years of marriage, we’ve interacted with emergency medical services 6 times, with only half of those being necessary. Sometimes you just don’t know. ***In a culture that’s obsessed with productivity and efficiency, it’s a radical act to choose inconvenience. That’s the story of the Good Samaritan, and the best of our caregivers and teachers. Most times I opt for efficiency—I am hurrying along my kids or growing impatient with the elderly person slowly climbing the stairs in front of me. I like getting things done, checking off tasks. But in the ER, I was reminded that presence trumps productivity. As we waited in our alcove, I heard a procession of doctors and nurses trying to cajole an elderly patient into getting an MRI. She was scared of the machine. One by one, the staff used active listening skills to validate her feelings while offering potential solutions. It was a terribly inefficient and deeply loving process. ***Thinking of those lonely people in the ER, I can imagine that it was a complex web of circumstances that brought them there—trauma, poverty, systemic racism and other barriers. It would be facile to think that deciding to act more “villager-like” would solve these complicated problems. And yet, I know that small moments of presence actually do help. We all need to be seen; we all need people we can rely on. That trust-building is a slow, inefficient process AND it’s the only way we make progress towards solving big problems like homelessness and addiction. So, even in this hectic season of back-to-school and various professional upheavals, I am going to try to be an inconvenience and let myself be inconvenienced, too. Missed a Post in our “Stuck Together Summer” Series? Here They Are! * Stop Threatening to Move to Canada * “We’re Doomed”: Great Card Game, Terrible Outlook on Life * A Post for When You Hate Everyone * Text That Friend You’re Thinking About * The Hardest Goodbye * A Police Defunder Has Some Regrets * The Other Third Places We Need Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit heretichereafter.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • S3 · E22
    August 12 · 8 min

    The Other Third Places We Need

    Wild Waves/Enchanted Village, Seattle’s schlocky amusement park, is closing and I couldn’t be sadder about it. While significantly crappier than a Disney Park or even a Six Flags, running around Wild Waves is a rite of passage for many Seattle-area adolescents. It is THE end-of-year good behavior field trip that makes students think twice about racking up detentions. It’s not just Seattle—since 2020, at least 10 major American amusement parks have closed and many regional parks are struggling to return after pandemic losses. Nor is it just the rollercoaster lovers that are in trouble, other classic teen hangouts like malls are in serious decline. High school dance attendance is down too, blamed largely on teens preferring screen-based activities like gaming and scrolling. Where are the teens supposed to go? Is this just another sign of the times? Am I merely weeping for my own Millennial nostalgia, shaking my fist at a generation that would rather be playing Roblox? Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Online Connection is Still Connection…Right? It’s not like kids these days are digital hermits. Observing my own teens and their friends have showed me that many of their online activities are, in fact, very social. My sons love to game with friends while chatting away over headsets, alternatively strategizing and trash-talking. Likewise, technology enables teens to stay connected outside of school in ways an elder Millennial like me could only have dreamed of. Heck, we were confined to the world of desktops, dial up, and, if you were lucky enough, AIM chats. (Pity the rural kids like me, who were beyond the reach of AOL.) This heightened connectivity is also seen in the sprawling online presence of events like prom. This dance, one of the few to survive the decline, has spread into cyberspace, with kids planning (and posting) elaborate “prom-posals” and girls hopping into online groups to share which dresses they’ve purchased so that—gasp!— no one shows up in the same ‘fit. And yet, while the average teen has a higher quantity of social connections, the quality of these interactions has changed. Instead of tying up a family landline with marathon phone calls, many kids now mainly communicate via brief DMs. And that text-based communication has its downsides: it’s both less stimulating to the brain and lacks context clues (like facial expressions and tone of voice) leading to higher instances of misunderstanding. Studies show, we need face-to-face interaction to form deep relationships, but our technology is increasingly crowding out this option. Gaming systems have shifted away from in-person together play (via shared account and split-screen) to siloed play on separate accounts and screens. While older technology like the Nintendo Switch makes multiplayer, in-person gaming easy (provided you have enough controllers), many popular games and systems (such as Roblox or Xbox’s Halo) set up a ridiculous amount of hurdles to in-person gaming. There’s also a serious downside to real-life events turning into social media spectacle. This technology is, by nature, performative—are you actually having fun at the prom or are you merely performing having fun for your followers? If so much of your social life revolves around your platform, can you ever completely forget the virtual audience? Teen brains are already wired to see peer acceptance as a life-or-death situation, adding parasocial pressure is like throwing gasoline on an open flame. Why Community Needs Physical Space No matter how much we enjoy connecting online, it turns out people need face-to-face interaction, and these interactions need to happen somewhere. In their book, The Great Good Place American sociologists Ray Oldenburg and Karen Christensen argue for the need for “third places”—spaces that are neither home or work (or, for kids we could sub in “school.”) Think cafes, barbershops, parks, gyms, or churches. According to Oldenburg & Christensen, the characteristics of a good third place are: * Open and inviting (drop-in vs. need an appointment) * Comfortable and informal * Convenient * Unpretentious * Has “Regulars” (and possibly a host of some kind) * Conversation is the main activity * Laughter is frequent Thinking specifically of kids and teens, third spaces ought to have fairly clear expectations for behavior and some light (emphasis on light!) adult supervision—i.e. you don’t jump in the mall fountain or security will kick you out. The Third Spaces Most Cities Are Missing Seattle, like many cities, has an abundance of third spaces that primarily cater to a particular type of person, namely, white young adults with plenty of cash. Think $5 cups of drip or $20 cocktails, pricey gyms with saunas and “wellness spaces.” Most don’t exactly fit the above criteria when it comes to being “unpretentious.” Each wave of gentrification strips away diversity from our variety of gathering spaces, like the Vietnamese pool hall and the Black barbershop, and instead brings in even more businesses aimed at hipsters. Even brew pubs that pitch themselves as “family friendly” are typically geared towards parents of young children. While it’s great that these often include a play space, they’re typically a snooze for kids over 5. Many parks are, similarly, lacking in features that appeal to older kids and teens. Basketball courts and baseball fields appeal to athletes, but it would be great to see more parks designed with spaces that are conducive to a casual hangout. Is there a landscaping equivalent of the 1970s “conversation pit”? Likewise, adolescents don’t feel welcome in many public spaces. Teens are often loud and prone to showing off, sometimes by engaging in risky behavior and boundary-pushing. When teens hang around playgrounds, they are often viewed with suspicion by parents of younger kids. I’ve been guilty of this, too, not sure when or whether to push back on teens’ rowdiness, reverting to passive-aggressive commentary when a kind, direct request would be more effective. The Future of Third Spaces for Teens Last time we were at Wild Waves, my kids having disappeared into the hoard of free-range teens, I lay on my lounger and frantically googled: “Wild Waves still for sale?” and “Wild Waves price?” fantasizing that there was some sort of crowdfunded future where I could help buy back the theme park, thus ensuring future Seattle teens the magic of janky wooden rollercoasters and overpriced hotdogs. Sadly, I discovered that Wild Waves and the surrounding parcel of land sold last fall for $456 million, which is a little out of my price range. I looked around at the diverse group of people enjoying the park—folks of all ages and races, folks who splashed out on the VIP cabanas and those who brown bagged it—and felt keenly the loss of this place. Communities need a variety of third places serving diverse groups of people, not just those who are willing and able to spend $10 on draft beer. If we want to solve the loneliness crisis, we would do well to look at our built environment and ask: do we have enough third spaces? And if so, who do they serve? Seattle has a few bright spots amongst all its tech bro-ification. Lately, I’ve seen more fliers for community centers which stay open for “Teen Late Nights,” providing recreation and hang out space with the kind of loose supervision kids this age need. Likewise, many teens in my area like to go for boba afterschool, which is sweeter than coffee and usually around the same price point. And I’m currently writing this while posted up at a picnic shelter near the skatepark where 3 tweens, including my son, are practicing their tricks. And yet I wonder if this is too little, too late. It seems to me we have two options: one where we are increasingly isolated, reliant on gig workers, exorbitant extracurricular activities, and overnight delivery to try and fill the void where community once was, or we can try to pull out of this late-stage capitalist nosedive and, instead, invest in each other. All people need networks of relationships and, therefore, we need a diverse ecosystem of third places. As for the future of Wild Waves? The investment firm bought the theme park with plans to demolish it. In its place, they’ll build a 1-million-square-foot warehouse. It feels too apt for a culture that puts so much value on accumulating stuff and makes so little room for people. Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Get full access to Heretic Hereafter at heretichereafter.substack.com/subscribe

  • S3 · E22
    August 5 · 8 min

    A Police Defunder Has Some Regrets

    I’ve been following with rapt attention the new NPR/Seattle Times podcast, “We Keep Us Safe” which investigates the murder of 15-year-old Antonio Mays, Jr. at the Capitol Hill Occupied Protest (CHOP) in 2020. This summer, we’ve been looking at what it takes to make community work. This new investigation of CHOP highlights the challenges of building a society from scratch apart from traditional institutions like the police. What Was CHOP? For those of you unfamiliar with CHOP, it was a protestor takeover of Seattle’s Cal Anderson Park and several blocks around it after the Seattle Police Department abandoned its East Precinct station in June of 2020 after several days of protest after the murder of George Floyd. The media portrayed CHOP, varyingly, as either a Summer-of-Love-type sit-in or a lawless hellscape. Anxious to cut through the hype, I visited CHOP and witnessed both its promise and problems first-hand. Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. There were many positive things happening at the park: tables offered free food and water to anyone who wanted them. There were medical personnel on hand and teach-ins using the “human microphone” technique many folks learned during the Occupy Wall Street protests. People were exchanging ideas and vigorously debating how to create the post-racist, just society so many of us were crying out for in those dark days. But while there were many in the park there to learn and vision together, the vibes weren’t exactly peace and love. Homeless people, some behaving erratically, had also streamed into the encampment. And as my friends and I sat eating tacos on the baseball field, we witnessed a group of masked men surround someone who was recording video. The group began shouting at the videographer, threatening violence. I’d seen enough and decided not to stick around past dark. Four days after my visit, 15-year-old Antonio Mays, Jr. would be murdered and his friend gravely wounded right in front of the abandoned police station. Questions remained: who killed Mays and why? And how had this protest against racialized violence ended up taking the life of a Black teenager? The Investigation In the days after Mays’ murder, rumors swirled: he was a gang member or a troublemaker, there to cause mayhem and possibly harm CHOP protestors. Having witnessed the various groups of people filtering in and out of CHOP, I all too easily accepted this explanation, figuring we’d probably never get the whole story. But reporters from our local NPR station and The Seattle Times were able to reconstruct a timeline of the murder using hours of security camera and livestream video scraped from social media. This, combined with eye-witness interviews, led to some startling revelations about why Mays was at CHOP and who likely killed him. The whole podcast is available now; I won’t spoil the conclusions for you because I think it’s worth a listen. The Aftermath The podcast begins and ends by interviewing Antonio Mays, Sr. As much as his son’s death has been held up as a symbol for this or that movement, we ought never forget that Mays was a kid. He was a musician, an aspiring BBQ pitmaster, a son, a brother, a classmate, a friend. As a parent, I can’t help but put myself in his family’s shoes. How awful to lose a child, how awful to not know why. Mays, Sr. wants justice for his son. No one has yet been arrested for the murder. Given the many errors in the criminal investigation, it’s unclear whether his son’s killer will ever face legal consequences. Here’s the thing I’ve come to understand about the push for police reform: it’s not all or nothing. While political polarization and media sensationalism painted the sides of the debate as either “the police are great, they can do no wrong” or “abolish all police,” many would-be reformers are just regular people like the Mays family who want the police to investigate serious crimes while not abusing their power to harass or harm people of color. Was Defund the Answer? I attended multiple Black Lives Matter protests in 2020. We were fed up with biased policing and with the government-sanctioned murder of unarmed civilians. We dreamed of a world where people experiencing mental health crises were met with a helping hand rather than guns drawn. One of our main chants during this time was, “Defund the police, 50% at least!” During this time, I tried to be careful about what I said in front of my kids, not wanting to overwhelm them. Still, they picked up on more than I realized. My eldest, then 8, saw a newspaper headline about the protests. He asked, “So they’re going to fire all the racist police and then we’ll have only good police leftover?” My heart ached at his question; I so wished that we could give him a justice system that was actually just. While many Seattle City Council members publicly commented in favor of drastically cutting the police budget, in the end, the budget was only cut by 14%, some of that in the form of individual salary cuts, but most coming from moving services like 911 call centers and parking enforcement out of the police department. Following the debate, the police chief resigned, and police officers left the department at a rate of about 150 per year between 2020-2022. While KIRO news reported this attrition was primarily due to the political climate, their sample size was small (12ish exit interviews out of 400ish departures). Other factors that could’ve influenced this wave of departures include things like poor staffing ratios and mask and vaccine mandates. Regardless of why police left, many of their positions wouldn’t be filled until years later, leaving Seattle with some of the lowest numbers of police per capita of any large city in America. These staffing drops have often been cited as the cause of increased response times and the feeling that, in Seattle, “the police don’t do anything.” Looking back on those “defund” demands now, what we were clamoring for was police accountability. Seattle had already gone through a federal consent decree and had an Office for Police Accountability, and yet little seemed to change. Taxpayers, were, understandably upset, particularly after police overreaction to peaceful protests in 2020, which included a small child being maced. To me, “defund” felt like a last resort, hitting the department where it hurt: its wallet. And yet, as much as the me of 2020 would’ve liked to chuck out the whole police department and start over from scratch, what happened at CHOP is illustrative of what can happen in the absence of police: namely, untrained vigilantes who self-appoint themselves as “security” creating the violence they’re trying to prevent. In my opinion, “defund” was too much, too soon. It was (understandably) reactionary, but it made little meaningful progress towards the slow, hard work of reform. What Would Justice Look Like? Reforming our institutions often feels impossible. There are entrenched interests heavily invested in preserving the status quo, including groups like police unions. Both communities of color and police often feel under attack, making dialogue difficult. But there are bright spots amid all this mess, people who are crossing party lines and doing the important, community-building work of accountability and relationship-building. The first person who gives me hope is Detective Cookie. She’s a South Seattle icon (she even has a park named after her!) a police officer who started an after-school chess club and is a frequent fixture at schools and neighborhood events. Even as the community has lauded her work to build trust between the police and the community, she’s faced discrimination within the police department and pushback for trying to hold it accountable. I’m so heartened to see the community rally around Detective Cookie; we need more police like her. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit heretichereafter.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • S3 · E21
    July 29 · 8 min

    The Hardest Goodbye

    This summer, we’ve been looking at commitment and what it takes to make communities and relationships work. Sticking it out has its place, certainly, but what about its opposite, calling it quits? Is there ever a time when we are justified in stepping away from relationships, even one as sacred as that between a parent and child? Content Warning: suicidal ideation. If you or someone you know is thinking about suicide, please call or text 988 for help. During the summer of 2020, I debated going no-contact with my mother. While my social media feed lit up with photos of people retreating to childhood homes, praises for grandparents as backup daycare, and even intergenerational TikToks, I was staring at the bland cover of a self-help book that detailed the process of cutting off a loved one. I couldn’t even decide whether to read it. The library had been closed for months, so this book sat in a stack next to my desk, calling to me like the tell-tale heart each time I sat down to write. What was I going to do? Part of me was stuck in disbelief that things had gotten this bad. As a child, I’d idolized my mother. I remember going to JoAnne’s to pick out fabric for matching dresses, watching her lay out the pattern pieces on the fabric: her larger pieces in the center, my smaller ones filling in the gaps. I would ask her endless questions about her life before me, making note of how I ought to be in the world. My baby book catalogues my aspirations at various ages: ballerina, teacher, nurse, mommy—all her ambitions became my own. I loved her biting sense of humor and her creativity. Her smile, when she turned it my way, felt like stepping out of a cold shadow into sunlight. And if she often kept me at a distance, shooing me towards the TV whenever I broached the kitchen where she spent most of the day cleaning, cooking, and drinking white wine, well, I aspired to be less annoying, more useful. Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. We had our ups and downs. When I left home for college, she sank into a depression so deep I felt it even 500 miles away. She joked about how I “abandoned” her. When we’d lived together, I’d been adept at gauging her mood and avoiding her triggers, but on the phone it was difficult to take her emotional temperature and figure out the right thing to say. In the summer of 2020, our conversations felt like stepping on landmines. I wrestled with duty—what did I owe the woman who gave me life, who raised, fed, and clothed me? Who, as she often reminded me, “only lived” to be a grandma to my kids, then 8 and 5. I never doubted that she loved us. But I also could no longer ignore her increasingly erratic behavior. On our weekly Skype calls she was usually drunk and moody. One night, she accused me of not being grateful for the matching sweaters she’d recently sent my kids. I objected that I had thanked her on a previous call and promised to send a photo of the kids wearing them when the weather was…you know…more sweater appropriate? My explanation only enraged her further: she accused me of secretly hating the sweaters and her, before enlisting the help of family members to harangue me for my ingratitude. By now this was a familiar pattern. After many years of therapy, I’d begun to wonder about my mother’s drinking and the way my family readily accepted her version of events. As I’d worked towards having healthier communication in my own relationships, the difference between my household and my parents’ was thrown into stark relief. This new self-knowledge also made me question the past: had I always wanted to be just like Mom, or had that been my only safe option? I’d spent the previous several visits trying to set boundaries with her around her drinking. When confronted, she acted like she had no idea what I was talking about but eventually agreed to not drink around us, “since it’s so important to you.” But during her visits she continued to ask for alcohol, to purchase it under various guises (“it’s for the marinara.”) After she left, I’d find empty wine bottles hidden in various nooks throughout my house. After so much energy spent policing these boundaries, the forced separation of the pandemic came as a relief. I blamed our increasing distance on being COVID-cautious, but she could sense I was pulling away, which triggered more acting out. On a random evening, I might get half-a-dozen angry voicemails about what a terrible person I was. Sometimes she threatened to commit suicide since I obviously didn’t care enough about her to answer the phone. (When she did this, I’d contact family members who lived with or near her who would then call 911. Always take suicide threats seriously.) One of the hardest parts of having an addicted family member is the silence that surrounds the illness. In my family-of-origin, there was no accountability for what was said or done in a drunken haze. It was always explained to me that the alcoholic felt immense shame about their addiction, and we didn’t want to make that worse, did we? I was tired of being collateral damage. I dreaded each interaction with my mother. For a few hours before and after our weekly Skype date, I was tense and irritable, snapping at my own children. I realized I was displacing my own anger and grief onto them, the same way my mother had barked at me after visiting my grandma in the nursing home. But I had to do this, didn’t I? I was obligated to let my kids do a weekly videocall with their grandmother, even if she was drunk and sulking about God-knows-what? I was afraid of what she might do if I stopped talking to her. And I felt an ancient guilt: that somehow her addiction, her life’s many troubles, were all my fault. My therapist and I spent months gaming out possible solutions. She’d been the one to recommend that library book that had been gathering dust next to my desk. Finally, I got so fed up that I opened it and saw my feelings of fear, obligation, and guilt (FOG) reflected back at me. The author asked whether this could ever be the basis for any kind of healthy relationship? And I knew she was right. Still, it took several more months of hemming and hawing before I wrote my mom a letter. In it, I explained that the only way forward for our relationship was for her to work towards sobriety and to make a fourth step amends to me for the damage her alcoholism had done to our relationship. As I dropped the letter into the mailbox slot, I knew this was likely the end. I couldn’t remember Mom ever offering a non-sarcastic apology and I doubted she’d start now, even if it meant losing a relationship with me. The fallout was quick and predictable: more voicemails. Gifts and cards sent to my children. Other family members asking repeatedly what, exactly, I wanted from her, as if my demands had been complicated or finnicky. And then, quiet. Relief. The guilt is still there—I worry about her; I imagine what I could’ve done (could still do?) to get her to stop drinking. I still harbor fantasies that she will recover and we will rebuild our relationship. But as her disease progresses that possibility slips farther and farther away. Looking back now, I suspect that my mother suffers not only from Substance Use Disorder but also Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD) and that her lashing out at me was likely due to what she perceived as rejection, a major symptom of that disorder. I have a lot of sympathy for her and I don’t blame her. Given her genes and life experiences, it makes total sense why she ended up this way. That doesn’t mean I’m willing to step back into the line of fire. Much has been written about the “trend” of estrangement. There’s little actual data regarding the reasons family members become estranged or how long they contemplated it before initiating. Is it possible that people are becoming estranged for rash and selfish reasons? Sure. Peopl… This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit heretichereafter.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • S3 · E20
    July 22 · 5 min

    Text the Friend You're Thinking About

    By my early 30s, I’d moved 16 times. I’d transferred schools 5 times, lived in 14 different cities, and moved boxes in and out of countless apartments and houses. I’d always considered this my social superpower: I knew how to harness the allure of being “the new kid.” I was both extroverted and judgy; I sorted people quickly and built friendships that blazed quick and hot. (There’s nothing like an expiration date to cement intense friendships.) The cycle was: meet, befriend, leave, over and over again. It took me years to realize that this supposed “superpower” was holding me back from real, deep friendship. Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Do We Still Need Friends? The Allure of the “Everything” Relationship It’s not just me who lacks friendship skills. From the “loneliness crisis” to viral content on “how to make friends as an adult,” it seems a lot of us are craving friendship. This lack feels baked into our culture. America doesn’t prioritize or center friendships, instead it’s largely oriented around romantic partnerships. (You can’t, for instance, share health insurance with a friend, no matter how close you are.) As many of our community affiliations (such as churches or civic groups) have dwindled in the past 50 years, more and more of our emotional and practical needs have fallen to our romantic partners. Our romantic expectations have never been higher: we want someone who will not only sweep us off our feet and do their fair share of domestic drudgery, they also need to also be our best friend. These expectations have given rise to what psychotherapist Esther Perel dubs, “The Everything Marriage”: “Everything that we wanted from a traditional marriage — companionship, family, children, economic support, a best friend, a passionate lover, a trusted confidante, an intellectual equal — we are asking from one person what an entire village once provided. And couples are crumbling under the weight of so much expectation.” (emphasis mine) Writing about this phenomenon for The Atlantic, author Rhaina Cohen calls it the “self-expressive” marriage: “spouses expected their partnership to be the site of self-discovery and personal growth.” (Gift link here.) As Perel and others have pointed out: expecting one person to be your everything generally doesn’t work. No one person is going to share all our interests, fill every single one of our needs, always be sexy and smart and interesting. Taking responsibilities for our needs means when one person can’t meet a specific need, we can find support in other relationships. I’m lucky to have a fantastic husband, but we don’t do everything together—he loves outer space and I love reality TV. I refused to see Project Hail Mary and he, in turn, doesn’t watch Love Island. We need friends to share our quirky hobbies with. We need them to help with care- and domestic work. We need people who’ll willingly listen to us complain about our spouses or our jobs or our kids. We need people to split the cost of a vacation house or a Netflix account. But for all these known benefits, many of us still struggle. Why Keeping Friendships Can Be So Hard & What to Do About It All the things that make friendship easy, like proximity and stage of life, can work against you as life goes on. That friend who lived down the hall in your college dorm now lives across the country. Things that were easy now take effort, and we only have so much effort to go around. Here is my Very Scientific List of Things that Make Maintaining Friendship Difficult: * Physical distance * Changing life circumstances: one friend gets married, has a kid or takes on other caretaking responsibilities, loses their job, etc. * Lack of clarity around the friendship. The label “best friends” hardly seems adequate for some of these relationships, which are more like platonic partnerships. But our culture/families doesn’t really understand ordering life around friendship vs. a romantic relationship. (More of this in The Atlantic article linked above) Yet maintaining friendships across these changes is possible! A highly scientific survey of readers on Substack Notes and on my Facebook revealed some great tips: * Embrace the awkwardness. If it’s been a while, things may feel weird at first. That’s okay! My tendency is to act like I know what’s going on, but I’m learning a better strategy is just to own your ignorance and ask questions (“What’s your kid’s name?”) People are, generally, pretty forgiving. * Get creative with technology: emails, group chats, Marco Polo, Facebook, and doing book clubs over Zoom were just some of the tools mentioned. * Reciprocity, but with grace. Friendships flourish when both sides do their best to connect while still understanding that sometimes it may be harder for one party or the other. * Irregular visits. Face-to-face time, even years apart, has a way of making it feel like no time has passed. * Understand there are different levels of friendship, and that’s okay. That person who used to be your confidante might be more of a casual friend now, and that’s okay. A healthy social network includes varying levels of intimacy. The Secret Friendship Ingredient? Accountability Growing up as the consummate “new kid” I was never lonely, but I also never learned how to work through conflict. I distinctly remember moving to my last elementary school in Missoula, Montana. My dad had retired from the army and announced: no more moves. Shortly thereafter, there was some kind of 4th grade blow up, and it felt like half the class was mad at me. I thought, “Oh well, I’ll probably move soon anyway, I can tolerate everyone being mad at me for a month or two.” Then I stopped short. There would be no more moves. Many of these same kids would be my classmates through high school! This was the first, but definitely not last, time I had to learn to be accountable (ughhhhhhhhhhhhhhh) Accountability, I’ve since realized, is the secret ingredient that makes relationships viable. More on that next week… What do you think? Are you good at staying in touch? Do you have routines or rhythms for how often you’re in contact with old friends? Please share your stories, tips, and questions in the comments. Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit heretichereafter.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • S3 · E19
    July 15 · 5 min

    A Post for When You Hate Everyone

    Do you ever have one of those days where you fantasize about throwing someone out a window? Not that you would ever actually want to hurt someone, but there’s just that “leave me the fuck alone” feeling? Part of living in families and communities that doesn’t get a lot of airtime are the low-level irritations and resentments that can build up in long-term relationships. During this “Stuck Together Summer” we’ve gotta talk about feeling pissed off at the people you, ostensibly, love. Bruh, Why You Mad? I’m not immune from petty annoyances. When my husband was home with me for two weeks after a recent shoulder surgery, I might have, at one point, complained about how loudly he was breathing. When I find myself angry at people for doing things like breathing or behaving in ways that are intrinsic to them (such as my kids for being loud and argumentative) usually the problem is…me. In situations like this, some people like to use the acronym HALT (Am I Hungry, Angry, Lonely or Tired?) to check on themselves, I prefer the acronym SWaTHS: is the sun in my eyes? Do I have a wedgie (or other uncomfortable clothing situation)? Am I thirsty? Hangry? Sleepy? If SWaTHS doesn’t reveal a culprit, the problem is often boundary related. Many of us raised in high-control religions were taught to ignore our needs. The trouble is needs don’t magically disappear because you’re ignoring them! They just fester into irritation and resentment. Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. What Boundaries Are (and Aren’t!) “Boundaries,” like a lot of therapy speak, is a term being widely misused across social media. People say “boundaries” to try and control others, to set ultimatums, and to generally say “this is a thing I don’t want to do and so I won’t because: therapy!” Boundaries, sadly, aren’t magic words that get other people to do whatever we want. Boundaries are decisions people make for themselves about what kind of behavior they will tolerate in order to protect their own mental and physical health. For example: Say your Aunt Bertha constantly brings up your bald spot and it drives you absolutely crazy. Not boundaries: You say “Aunt Bertha stop laughing at my bald spot or I’ll throw you the window!” Boundaries: You decide to mention to Aunt Bertha that her comments bother you. You decide that if she keeps bringing it up, you’ll have to cut your phone call or visit short. Notice here that your decision is about what you will do. You can’t control whether Aunt Bertha makes a crack about your appearance. You can control your response. Why Some People Hate Boundaries In my experience, most people are very respectful of boundaries if they’re framed in a gently, such as “I wish I could help you with your tuba solo, but I’m at capacity.” Some people, though, take boundaries EXTREMELY PERSONALLY because: * it triggers their guilt: were their previous actions hurtful and they didn’t know? * they have rejection sensitivity (common in ADHD) or other trauma related to boundaries * the previous arrangement (you being a doormat) worked well for them. When you set boundaries it threatens the status quo I’ve dealt with a fair amount of drama regarding pretty straight-forward boundaries around my kids’ needs for regular meals and bedtimes. It sucks to feel like you have to choose between good parenting and keeping the peace. But, regardless of how people feel about our boundaries, it’s important to stick to them. Their feelings are their issue, not yours. There are, however, more complex boundary situations. Boundaries with People Who Have Power Over You Boundaries are more complicated with people whom you depend on for housing, a salary, or other needs. It’s a lot easier to set boundaries with Aunt Bertha when she’s not the one paying your rent or watching your kids on the reg. For instance, if you have reason to believe that your boss will punish you for setting boundaries, you might have to take a different tack, such as lowering your expectations (“Bob always microwaves tuna, that’s just how it is”) or, if the situation is really bad, looking for a different job. Boundaries with People You Have Power Over For many of us, setting boundaries with people we have power over can be equally difficult. Having been on the receiving end of abusive bosses, I’ve been reluctant to do things like tell my babysitter to put her phone away and, you know, watch my kids. (We all want to be liked, right?) I have to remind myself there’s a difference between being clear about expectations and being a bad boss. Similarly, I’ve noticed how hard it is for many parents to set reasonable boundaries with their own kids. It feels easy to veer into being either over-controlling or too lenient. Newborns train us to respond to their every cry, but as kids get older, they need increasing amounts of what I’ve termed “brick wall parenting”: firm limits they can’t argue their way out of. Yes, you have to do your homework. No, you can’t play with fireworks. Setting boundaries isn’t being mean; it’s us acting as our kids’ frontal lobes until theirs have a chance to develop. Difficult But Worth It Most people do not enjoy conflict. For those of us who were raised to be doormats, setting boundaries can be especially anxiety-provoking. But being clear about boundaries actually improves our relationships—it teaches people how we prefer to be treated and shows us who is capable of honoring that and who isn’t. Failing to set and enforce boundaries often leads to resentment, which can poison a relationship. If you need a little boost for setting boundaries, here are a couple of mantras I employ regularly: * “Choose discomfort over resentment.” -Brene Brown * “Clarity is kindness.” -probably also Brene Brown? For further reading, I can heartily recommend therapist Nedra Tawwab, who offers down-to-earth, practical wisdom about boundaries in her book, Set Boundaries, Find Peace. She’s also a solid Instagram follow. How are you when it comes to setting boundaries? Do you agree or disagree that feeling “pissed off at the world” is usually the result of a boundary issue? Do you have any tips or tricks for setting and enforcing boundaries? As always, I love to hear feedback from y’all in the comments or via DM or email! Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. BONUS MATERIALS: * more about the importance of limits * this boundary-related humorous vid * and this one’s just for LOLs This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit heretichereafter.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • S3 · E18
    July 8 · 6 min

    WE'RE DOOMED: Great Card Game, Terrible Outlook on Life

    Summer started off with a bang in the Strange household—one of our kiddos pulled some epically bad behavior and, as a result, lost screentime privileges for two weeks! The one upshot of this arrangement is that he was B-O-R-E-D and willing to indulge in more boardgames than usual. Our new family favorite? A cheery little card game called WE’RE DOOMED! Why WE’RE DOOMED! Is So Compelling WE’RE DOOMED! imagines that the world is ending in 15 minutes, and only those who get a seat on an escape rocket will survive. The trick is, the rocket isn’t finished yet. The main choice on each turn is whether to contribute to the (shared) rocket project, or to perform actions which make it more likely that you, yourself, will get a seat on said rocket. Along the way there are fun complications like opportunities to steal or even “nuke” other players (thus eliminating them from the game.) Since the game is timed, all of this is all done with much shouting and rushing. I’ve played WE’RE DOOMED! a few dozen times now and have only succeeded in getting on the rocket once. Generally, everyone dies, but a few times we’ve managed to pull together and build a big enough rocket for all the (still-living) players. Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This game is the right level of fun, challenging, and silly. But the secret, nerdy reason that I like it? It’s a perfect illustration of the “tragedy of the commons.” Our Most Common Problem? The tragedy of the commons is an idea borrowed from economics describing a situation in which a group shares a common, scarce resource. Any one individual can try to hoard this resource for themselves at a cost to the community. Think overfishing, deforestation, or climate change. Once you understand the tragedy of the commons, you start to see it everywhere: it’s corporations putting short-term profits ahead of long-term financial stability (the financial crisis), it’s countries wanting to industrialize (and pollute) to gain an economic edge in the short-term while contributing to climate crisis in the long-term. What makes the tragedy of the commons so interesting is that it taps into that eternal tension between the individual and the community. What is fair? Who gets to decide? And should I take my “fair share,” or do I try to get one over on everyone else? The term “tragedy of the commons” was popularized by the economist Garrett Hardin, who wrote (of overgrazed “commons” or communal land): “Therein is the tragedy. Each man is locked into a system that compels him to increase his herd without limit – in a world that is limited. Ruin is the destination toward which all men rush, each pursuing his own best interest in a society that believes in the freedom of the commons. Freedom in a commons brings ruin to all.” — Garrett Hardin, The Tragedy of the Commons Hardin’s view, it seems, is that all people are inherently selfish and that we are, in fact, doomed to ruin all shared resources. The only solutions, in his estimation, are privatization and top-down government management. But is that actually the case? Crabbing Lessons We were on a big group camping trip this weekend, playing WE’RE DOOMED! in the evening and crabbing by day, which provided an interesting view into the tragedy of the commons. When you crab in Washington, you must buy a $35 license. You’re limited to a certain number of crabs per day, of certain species, and you may not collect crabs that are too small, molting, or the wrong gender. This is top-down government regulation meant to prevent over-harvesting of crabs, enforced by park rangers. Due to a broken boat, we were mostly limited to crabbing off the dock this year. We were not the only ones doing so—the space was fairly crowded with a diverse group of people: immigrants speaking a variety of languages, experienced crabbers, newbie tourists, a precocious 12-year-old crustacean expert, and a very nice guy wearing a very obnoxious Trump t-shirt. The crabs were pretty scarce this year. Following Hardin’s logic, you’d expect that competition would be fierce and the strangers wouldn’t be very friendly towards each other. But you’d be wrong. While my crew only managed to catch 6 crabs over 2 days, we were given many more by folks who were doing better than us. Folks who preferred bigger crabs, or Dungeness versus Rock Crab, were giving us crustaceans left and right. Folks shared tools and tips and repeatedly helped each other. A sort of gift economy developed on the dock, partly enabled by those government limits. Ronald Reagan Was Wrong If you grew up like I did, learning that Reaganism was next to godliness, you probably learned that the best way to deal with the tragedy of the commons was to privatize everything. In this view, government regulation is inefficient, unresponsive to the market, and likely to spawn cancerous bureaucracies. Yes, according to economists, government regulation or privatization were the only choices. Then Elinor Ostrom came along. She studied rural, traditional economies from around the world and found that these groups were perfectly capable of managing their own shared resources without privatization or state intervention. In order for these systems to work, Ostrom found that certain conditions needed to be met, including systems for monitoring and enforcing rules. This research won her the Nobel Prize and opened a whole new area of study in economics. Like the tragedy of the commons, once you recognize this shared resource optimization, you can see it everywhere. It’s why Wikipedia went from being something you should never cite (according to my high school English teacher) to a pretty reliable source. How to Win at WE’RE DOOMED! Solutions are possible. Problems like climate change, while complex and large-scale, are not unsolvable. What’s required, whether we’re governing global CO2 levels or a small neighborhood park, is pretty simple: we need to agree on a set of limits, and we need to have folks monitoring and enforcing those limits. Above all, we, like the crabbers on the dock, need to talk to each other. So, if you want to win WE’RE DOOMED! I’d recommend you don’t start playing when the timer flips. Instead, you should talk amongst the players and come up with quotas of how many resources each player must contribute. You should appoint a monitor, and that monitor should have an enforcement mechanism, such as “if you fail to meet your quota, you will be nuked and removed from the game.” Would we actually play this way? Absolutely not, it would be no fun at all! But it does give me hope, in a world full of naysayers and cynics, that we know how to solve big problems. We don’t have to settle for a WE’RE DOOMED! mentality. Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit heretichereafter.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • S3 · E19
    July 1 · 6 min

    Stop Threatening to Move to Canada

    I hear it all the time: America is doomed! It’s a dumpster fire! Democracy is over, etcetera, etcetera! Let’s all move to Europe! Oh wait, they have far-right, anti-immigrant leaders, too? Okay…New Zealand? Or there’s always our good old friendly neighbor to the north, right?!?! Lefties have been threatening to move to Canada, off and on, since George W. Bush was elected in 2000. The cries grew significantly louder after Trump’s first and second elections. And I get it—these are two administrations that were elected despite losing the popular vote; two administrations who have launched unnecessary foreign wars while simultaneously chipping away at American civil liberties. And let’s be real, Trump’s greed, narcissism, and lust for power makes Bush look like a thoughtful elder statesman in comparison. Of course, we despair when it felt like our votes didn’t matter and as we’ve watched congress and the courts cede more and more of their duty to act as checks and balances. But I’m not ready to give up on America, and neither should you. Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. America is Not Nazi Germany World War Two looms large in the American imagination, and with good reason. There’s been plenty of scholarship devoted to recording and sharing the stories of those Hitler persecuted, particularly Jewish people. Who upon hearing these stories of lucky escapes, doesn’t imagine themselves in their shoes, fleeing the Nazi death machine? Who among us doesn’t scan the headlines from time to time, wondering about our country’s own descent towards fascism? And yet, thankfully, we are not there. Yes, there has been persecution of certain groups, particularly Brown and Black immigrants. This is awful, disgusting behavior that we should not tolerate. And the good news is, most Americans (60%) don’t. We saw the power of resistance in the fight for Minneapolis last January. We’ve seen it in the national outcry against Trump’s thuggish policies. And we’ve seen it in Trump’s cratering approval ratings. Yes, there is a core of MAGA followers who, it seems, will follow their dear leader to the gates of Hell, but most Americans won’t. Using Our Privilege Wisely It’s one thing to stand in solidarity with those who are persecuted, it’s another to imagine ourselves persecuted when we are not. As I wrote about last month, we must always check our fears against evidence. And when I look at the evidence I see that I, a middle-class white woman living in Seattle, am not being persecuted. What to do with all this privilege, then? Move to Canada out of some fear of what could, hypothetically, happen? Moving would be a lot easier for me than for most of the folks reading this. Immigration is always—bare minimum—a huge pain in the ass, but I’ve lived in Canada before. Both my kids were born there. (Thanks for the c-sections, British Columbia!) But when I think about the people I admire, such as Martin Luther King and Dietrich Bonhoeffer, these were people who stayed and fought. Bonhoeffer came to America during the Third Reich to learn from American Civil Rights leaders. He could’ve stayed, but instead he wrote to Reinhold Niebuhr (author of the Serenity Prayer): “I have made the mistake in coming to America. I must live through this difficult period of our national history with the Christian people of Germany. I will have no right to participate in the reconstruction of Christian life in Germany after the war if I do not share the trials of this time with my people” Bonhoeffer was eventually killed for his acts of resistance against Hitler. And, of course, King was assassinated for his activism. Do I undermine my own argument by holding them up as examples? I must concede: resistance is never a safe road. For reminders of this, we need look no further than the murders of Alex Pretti and Renee Good in Minneapolis. And yet, I keep coming back to Kant’s Categorical Imperative. What in the What Now? Don’t be scared, I’m not going to pummel you with philosophical jargon. Basically, the Categorical Imperative is a way of asking if an action is morally permissible by imagining that everyone is allowed to do this action and then asking whether the resulting world would be better or worse. Take stealing. If I want to know whether stealing a pack of gum from the 7-11 is moral, I can imagine a world where everyone is allowed to steal packs of gum from 7-11. I imagine gum shelves gone bare and gum companies going out of business because no one pays for their products anymore. Probably there would be chewed gum stuck everywhere. Clearly this is a worse world; therefore, stealing gum is unethical. So what if I make the rule that every time a president comes to power whom you didn’t vote for who enacts policies you find unjust, you are allowed to move to Canada? In our current polarized situation, wouldn’t that mean half the country emigrating every 4-8 years? Who would be left to push back? Who would hold wannabe dictators accountable? Wouldn’t we just be ceding our country to extremists? Introducing “Stuck Together Summer” This question goes beyond where we live. I think our culture is one in which it is very easy to leave. We are people who move frequently, who can quit clubs, groups, or friends with few repercussions. We’ve seen this in the decline in religiosity and civic groups and the rise of going no-contact with family members. In some ways this is good and necessary—no-fault divorce saves lives. No one should be forced to stay in a relationship or a community that’s abusive. And yet, I do wonder if this era of The Big Sort has shortchanged us in some ways. If we’re always eying the exit, do we miss opportunities to repair and build deeper relationships? Are we becoming too thin-skinned and individualistic? So this summer, I want to look at the idea of Commitment, or what I’m cheekily calling “Stuck Together Summer.” Here are some questions I have: * when is commitment helpful vs. harmful? * how do you know when to quit a relationship or community? * how do various communities work through conflict? * how do groups set up rules and norms? * what about the Tragedy of the Commons and things like climate change? * should Liberals reclaim patriotism? * what role do progressive Christians have to play in fighting Christian Nationalism? (i.e. can we save the church in America?) * when is it a good idea to reach out to others with different beliefs vs. to stay in our own bubbles? What comes to mind when you think of commitment? (Fun fact: this word eliminated roughly half of the 7th grade during my middle school spelling bee.) Do you have communities or relationships where you glad you stuck it out? Or the opposite: times when you stayed too long? As always, I love to hear your thoughts (seriously, this group is the smartest comments section on the internet!) Feel free to comment publicly, or DM or email me if you’d like to share something more privately. Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit heretichereafter.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • S3 · E18
    June 24 · 3 min

    The Scariest Thing I Have Ever Done

    My Secret Fear For someone with an anxiety disorder, I have managed to do a lot of scary stuff. Things like: moving away from my family, getting married when I was a dumb 22-year-old, moving to another country without a job or a place to live—twice! having kids, and telling a deeply personal story onstage at The Moth. But the actual Scariest Thing I’ve Ever Done was none of those things. It was self-publishing my novel last year. Maybe that sounds like not a big deal, but honestly, during the entire 6-month process I was WRECKED, mainly because I have a giant fear of other people thinking I am stupid. Yes, I was the 6th grader who toted around a leather-bound volume of The Complete Works of William Shakespeare like it was a magical talisman that could protect me from porny 90s culture which treated all femme girls like complete bimbos. Yes, despite all evidence to the contrary, there’s still a part of me that fears being reduced to my reproductive organs. This fear stockpiles my shortcomings and whispers them back to me in the middle of the night. Waiting for my novel to publish, it fed me nightmares of all my Super Smart Literary Friends reading my book and thinking, “I can’t believe she thought this was good enough to publish, she must be delusional.” The fear was strong, so much so that I SERIOUSLY CONSIDERED not publishing my book at all. Like, I announced it and then thought maybe I ought to just take it back?! Lessons from a Border Collie When I was growing up in rural Montana, we had a border collie named Mickey who, in accordance with his breeding, liked to herd other animals. Sometimes this was cute, like on hikes when he would nudge laggards onward. (Nothing like a border collie snout to the backside to make you pick up the pace.) But it was a problem when Mickey started chasing our neighbors’ horses. My dad installed one of those invisible fences around our property and put a shock collar on Mickey. When Mickey got too close to the perimeter, he’d hear a buzz, and if he kept going and crossed the fence line, he’d get a small electric shock. The trouble was, Mickey soon decided that a small, short shock was worth the price of freedom. He’d take the charge and keep right on running. Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Fear is a Fence Mickey’s shock collar came to me as I was reflecting back on fear and the scary decisions I’ve made. These past two months, we’ve been looking at the Problem of Fear—what is it? How do we learn to live with it? So far we’ve covered: -Being a Scaredy Cat -Fear of Being a Laughingstock -Sorting Out Rational vs. Irrational Fear -Fear of Travel -“Faith Over Fear” (and why I hate it) -Fear of Strangers -Fear of Hell I think fear is like that invisible fence, it keeps us close to home, stops us from exploring. Like with Mickey and the horses, that can be a good thing. But many times, our fears are a fence that is far too small, a rigid boundary that keeps us from growing. Don’t Forget: You Have Survived Worse Fear wants us to play it small, to never try. But we, like Mickey, can learn to take the shock and keep going. This is the biggest gift I’ve gotten from having an anxiety disorder: I now know that (most of) my fears are irrational and that I will survive doing the Big Scary Thing. I’ve done it before and I’ll do it again. So when I get scared, I try to imagine what my life would be like if I had listened to fear and “stayed inside the fence” so to speak. Would I have ever left my hometown? Met my husband? Had my kids? Had any sort of career in writing or activism? Once you decide to take the charge and keep running, you know you can do it again. And so, if fear is holding you back from something you want to do, something that would be meaningful to your life, that’s my advice to you. Embrace some corny Millennial #YOLO energy or your nearest Nike slogan and go for it. Remember that you have survived worse! Let each new feat pave the way towards a bold life. BONUS MATERIALS: -MY BOOK, in case you’re curious -want to learn more about how bad the 90s were for women? Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit heretichereafter.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • S3 · E17
    June 17 · 7 min

    Relax, Hell isn't Real!

    Welcome new subscribers! This week, we’re continuing our series on FEAR. There’s a bit on parenting here, but if you’re looking for a more parenting-specific article, I can recommend The Extreme Weirdness of Trying to Buy a Bible for My Kids. You can also search “parenting” in the archive. Obsessing Over the Afterlife Growing up Evangelical, there were a lot of things to be afraid of, including but not limited to: * being “left behind” at the rapture * demons * tarnishing one’s purity Simultaneously, we were shamed for being afraid and told that our fear was due to a lack of faith. By far though, my biggest fear was Hell. Would I forget to confess a sin and be cast into eternal damnation? Could I “backslide” and lose my salvation? I worried about friends and loved ones and even strangers on the street. It seemed to me that no one else was taking Hell seriously enough—it was ETERNAL, after all. I wondered how my fellow churchgoers could believe in this vision of Hell and not spend every waking moment obnoxiously evangelizing every single person they met? God was love, I was often told, but God was also perfect and He demanded perfection. Trying to be perfect was the only way of ensuring I wouldn’t be condemned. God was the Big Angry Man in the Sky who was just waiting to drop the hammer on all of us. Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. A Change of Heart It took a lot of life experience, theological study, and therapy for me to admit the truth: Hell makes no sense. Penal Substitutionary Atonement (the predominant way of looking at Jesus’ crucifixion in most American churches) makes no sense, either. Once I became a parent, I could not imagine God (who is supposed to be the perfect parent) subjecting any of his children to eternal punishment or coercing them into loving him by threatening to torture them forever. I can imagine hackles rising even as I write this. If you are a believer in Hell and PSA, you probably want to stop reading right here. But I want to challenge you to consider the alternative—can you imagine how your faith and your life would be different if you let go of these beliefs? If, at the end of my article, you’re unconvinced, that’s fine. Just give me five minutes, if you please. Do All Dogs Go to Heaven? I’m not alone in doubting Hell’s existence. Christian Universalism (the idea that all people will eventually be saved) dates back at least 300 years, if not longer. (For reference, the modern belief of a Pre-Tribulation Rapture is only about 200 years old.) Author and Methodist minister, Derek Ryan Kubilus, explores the arguments for and against Hell in his book, Holy Hell: A Case Against Eternal Damnation. Kubilus examines the Bible verses commonly cited as evidence for Hell, pointing out that many English translations put a thumb on the scale. For example, certain words are sometimes translated as “Hell” and sometimes simply as “pit” or “grave.” He also points out that our modern understanding of Hell comes more from Dante’s Inferno rather than the Bible. The Ancient Jews and Greeks who were writing and reading the Bible had very different schemas of the afterlife. In Kubilus’ telling, even the Bible’s allusions to fire and brimstone aren’t about torture, they’re part of a series of metallurgical metaphors, speaking to the process of refining ore into gold rather than punishing baddies. Wait, What About Hitler? Kubilus, like some Universalists, believes in Purgatory—that is, that based on our sins, we will all be subject to some process of “refinement.” For someone like Hitler, it might take 5 million years, but eventually even he could be saved. I was surprised to find a Protestant version of Purgatory. Is it necessary? Couldn’t God just choose to forgive, like we humans do? But I admit, it does deal with the problem of justice: we don’t want people like Hitler to go to straight to Heaven, do we? It just doesn’t feel right. When You Punch Your Friend in the Face for No Reason This question of justice became real for me recently, when my 11-year-old, T, got in trouble at school for punching his friend in the face for no reason. (Ironic, given that this is the first ethical example used in Michael Schur’s How to Be Perfect, which we read last year.) T was experiencing test anxiety and he took it out on his friend. T felt horrible afterwards, and his friend forgave him, but it still felt like something was missing from the process, like the scales needed to be rebalanced—we needed… justice??? Given that T couldn’t un-punch his friend, was there a way of making things right? After talking with T, his friend, and his friend’s mom, we decided that making amends would look like a three-day screentime ban, an apology letter, and a Roblox gift card, purchased by T with his allowance. I also stressed to him that the biggest part of making amends was not repeating this behavior. This justice isn’t perfect, but I hope it does three things: * emphasize that this behavior was not okay and is out of bounds for our family & community * give T meaningful consequences that will help him not make this choice in the future * attempt to repair the relationship and reestablish trust between friends But these attempts at justice are for an ongoing relationship during, well…life. What would afterlife justice look like? I have no idea! Nobody Knows Anything Let’s be real, neither me, nor Derek Kubilus, nor the most obnoxious street preacher you’ve ever met actually knows what happens after we die. We won’t until it happens. It’s incumbent on us to be humble about our beliefs, no matter how strongly held they are—we could always be wrong! Maybe the afterlife is closer to The Good Place. Maybe we’re reincarnated. Maybe we just stop existing or maybe we rejoin the universal life force. I didn’t believe in any sort of afterlife when my brother, Karl, two years ago. Then I had a weird experience with a bald eagle that made me less certain. What Can We Know? What I do know is that there are people living in Hell right now. Addiction is Hell. War is Hell. Divorce is Hell. Serious disease is Hell. I wish the church would triage the suffering people are currently experiencing rather than some far-off Hell that probably won’t happen. What I know is that all “right” beliefs must lead to increasing love of others and ourselves. When I believed in Hell and that I needed to “save” people from it, I saw them as numbers, not full humans with rich inner lives, not equals who could teach me as much as I could teach them. Not people I ought to get to know and form relationships with. And yes, #NotAllEvangelists, but I gotta say, most evangelism efforts I’ve been part of have felt more transactional rather than relational. Christianity Without Hell When I was an Evangelical, avoiding Hell was the whole point. I was a Christian because of my fear. You may think that without the threat of Hell, most people will stop being Christian. You may be right. But is believing in Jesus solely for purposes of Hell avoidance really the kind of spirituality we want to encourage? For me, letting go of the fear of Hell has opened a whole new world. I can choose to run towards rather than away from something. I am learning more about my interconnectedness with others, with the natural world, and with God. I am more open to learning from people whose beliefs differ from my own. And that’s a journey I can recommend to anyone. Do you believe in Hell? An afterlife? Why/why not? Have you ever had any FREAKY WOO-WOO EXPERIENCES after a loved one’s passing? As always, I love to hear your thoughts. questions, rants, and ramblings in the comments, via DM, or email. BONUS MATERIALS: * ughhhh this article about YET ANOTHER scammy Seattle megachurch * Happy Pride Y’all (slightly NSFW) * Where my Love Island fans at? Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, conside… This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit heretichereafter.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • S3 · E16
    June 10 · 8 min

    'Stranger Danger' is Bullshit

    I was out with a group of mom friends recently when the conversation turned to how much we have to schlep our kids around—driving/walking them to school, to sports practice, to lessons and day camps. There was broad consensus that: * we hate it * it feels mandatory as “good moms” AND * we wonder whether our kids could…just maybe…be a little more independent? This last point was uttered cautiously, as if everyone was reading the room, terrified of being judged. And with good reason. All too often maternal suffering feels like a competition; if you’re not having a bad time, you must not be doing enough. And don’t your precious little babies deserve EVERYTHING? Moms are expected to make sacrifices to our careers, personal interests, and even our health in order to ensure that our offspring are protected from every imaginable risk AND maintain dominance in the extracurricular arms race. The end goal of this is… unclear. Harvard, I guess? Some magical career that will guarantee a comfortable, middle-class life with zero upheaval? Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Arrested for Leaving Her Kid Alone in a Car Author Kim Brooks knows firsthand the consequences of being judged a “bad mom”—after leaving her preschooler in the car for 5 minutes while she ran into a store, Virginia police put out a warrant for her arrest. This led to a two-year legal tussle, which she admits, could’ve been much worse if she weren’t white and middle-class. At first, Brooks kept her legal problems a secret. She felt weirdly ashamed even as she recognized, logically, that her son had been perfectly safe. It was a cool day; she’d cracked the windows. She could see the car from the checkout counter, for crying out loud! But when she began sharing the issue with friends, the mommy judgment machine went into high gear. Again and again, people told her she should never have left her son alone, not even for a minute, because of the risk of STRANGER DANGER, “anything could have happened” was a common refrain. Reality Check Brooks chronicles this saga and the wider panic around American childhood in her book, Small Animals: Parenthood in the Age of Fear. In it, Brooks interrogates many of our modern parenting fears, including the obsession with Stranger Danger. She notes that stranger abductions make up a mere 3% of all child disappearances (many of which are parental abductions, runaways, or simply kids who are lost for a few hours.) American historian Steven Mintz has called Stranger Danger a moral panic, saying that, following economic upheaval in the 70s, “Focusing concern on threats to children may have provided a solution to this psychological dilemma [of job insecurity and growing wealth inequality.] Anxiety about the future could be expressed in terms of concerns for children’s safety.” Brooks adds that focusing all one’s energy on children’s safety rather than an uncertain economy, “feels more manageable.” How Stranger Danger Harms Kids The practical effects of the Stranger Danger moral panic were a vast reduction in childhood independence. Whereas kids in previous generations often walked or biked themselves places and organized their own games and pastimes with other neighborhood kids, nowadays there seem to be two options available to children: overscheduling hell or screen zombiedom. Case in point: my 11-year-old wants to learn to skateboard. If he were living in a different country or a different era, I’d drop him off at the local skatepark (or, even better, tell him to bus there himself) and let him hang out with older kids who could show him the ropes. But the skateparks near us sit empty most of the time, unless someone is being directly supervised (and, let’s be honest, nitpicked) by a parent or there’s a skateboard day camp ($$$) in session. Today’s kids are rarely unsupervised. This lack of independence hurts kids. It makes them more anxious and worse at handling interpersonal conflicts. And having adults hovering nearby prevents kids from gaining self-efficacy (a feeling that they can handle challenges and influence their environment.) And self-efficacy, it turns out, is one of the biggest preventive factors for kids developing drug and alcohol addiction. How Stranger Danger Harms Adults It’s not just kids who suffer the effects of this moral panic, I think it’s a huge contributor to what I call the “Parenting Misery Spiral”: the more that parents must do for their kids, the less time they have for basic self-care, hobbies, and maintaining romantic and friend relationships. Children act out because no one likes feeling controlled, and parents are exhausted and miserable. Is it any wonder why so many people are opting out of having kids when parenting looks like such an awful slog? And the fewer people who have kids, the more having kids becomes seen as a “lifestyle choice” like pet ownership or an expensive hobby, rather than something necessary for a functioning society. In many largely child-free cities like Seattle, parents and kids feel unwelcome in public spaces (or even in apartment buildings) leading to further isolation. How We Fight Unnecessary Panic I know all this, and yet I’m not immune from the fearmongering. My 13-year-old son is one of the few kids in his school who doesn’t have a phone, something I feel great about until he gets lost riding the city bus, which has happened several times this year. In a city with multiple open-air drug markets and a large number of unhoused, mentally ill people, it’s easy to panic when my son is not home on time. Luckily, my husband talks me down when I start frantically researching tracking devices. I’m glad because my son’s confidence has really grown since he’s been able to get himself where he needs to be. He’s even started having more spontaneous, after-school hangouts with friends, which is a huge win for all of us! A Caveat I don’t teach my kids about Stranger Danger. I tell them that 95% of strangers are kind people who would help them if they got lost. The one exception to that is that I think kids need to know how to spot someone who’s not in their right mind. Big city kids learn: we do not make eye contact or talk with folks who are tweaking, muttering to themselves, or otherwise seem off. But that dude staring at his cellphone? He’s fine. That mom with a stroller? Great choice. The bus driver? Helping is part of his job! My own lived experience (including several pre-smart phone years getting lost on transit) has shown me that most strangers are kind and willing to help, especially if it’s a kid. Advice For Setting Your Kids Free What if you want your kid to be more independent but you’re scared of judgment or, God forbid, someone calling the cops? Here are a few tips: * Resist fearmongering. Bone up on a couple of stats and reassure your friends. Remind them about what used to be normal! * Scaffold independence. Kids don’t walk themselves to school overnight. Teach them how to cross the street safely, practice walking with them, then practice hanging back a block or two, until it’s enough to wave them goodbye. * Observe neighborhood norms. Is there a particular age where free-ranging kids are generally accepted? If your neighbor kids are going to the store independently at 12, can you work backwards and figure out some appropriate milestones like walking to a friend’s house or playing without grownups at the park? This will also depend on your kid’s personality and abilities. I emphasize to my kids that being dependable = a longer leash. * Get a group together. If your kid walking alone makes you nervous, can you draft a buddy? A group of kids? Can younger siblings tag along with older ones? * Know your rights. If you’re harassed by police or “well meaning” citizens (as Kim Brooks was) groups like Let Grow and Lenore Skenazy’s Free-Range Kids can offer advice. They also have other great resources on their sites! A Final Thought I’ve spent the … This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit heretichereafter.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
  • S3 · E17
    June 3 · 5 min

    Why "Faith Over Fear" T-Shirts Creep Me Out

    I think it happened a few months into the pandemic: I started seeing the phrase “faith over fear” popping up everywhere. It was in social media bios, on protest signs, and emblazoned across t-shirts. The phrase’s ubiquity seemed to correlate with anti-lockdown and anti-vaccine protests. While the phrase in itself could mean many things, to this day if I happen to see a person wearing this tee, I tend to assume “they are probably not vaccinated.” It’s like the inverse of one of those “In this house we believe” yard signs that sprung up all over Seattle after Trump was first elected. Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. The Merging of Political Party & Religion It’s tragic that COVID safety measures became so quickly polarized. I wonder how many lives were unnecessarily lost because wearing masks and getting vaccinated became associated with being liberal. I still believe that if we’d been able to have productive dialogue, we might have reached a middle ground on things like school reopenings. Instead, each side dug in their heels, painting the other as completely unreasonable. “Faith over fear” feels of a piece with the Christian Nationalism that is ascendant in our current administration. It feels untethered to reality, as if magical thinking can protect us from bad things happening. It’s like those unsympathetic church ladies who tell you that your cancer or car accident is “part of God’s will” and that your dead grandma is “in a better place.” Or maybe the phrase is a justification to do whatever you want wrapped in bad theology: people will die, but probably not me, so who cares? The Two Types of Freedom I remember learning in high school government class that there are two types of freedom: freedom to and freedom from. i.e. if any rando has the freedom to own an assault rifle that means some of us won’t have the freedom from being shot. Freedom from masking might mean others don’t have the freedom to survive COVID. I’m not saying it’s an easy calculus. Life is packed with risks that we as both a society and as individuals choose to mitigate or ignore. The same CDC that pushed masking also strongly suggests you never consume raw cookie dough. Riding in a car is one of the most dangerous things many of us do every day and never think about. Is there a spiritual yardstick we can use to assess risk? Are there some lessons from the Bible that can help us determine when fear is a reasonable response? The Bible on Fear… The Bible talks about fear often. “Fear not!” is one of its most-repeated commands, often uttered by some kind of angel/supernatural being to apparently terrified mortals. Yet this reassurance is contrasted with oft-quoted Proverbs 9:10, “Fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom.” So which is it? Fear God or fear not? Should we just have faith that everything will work the way we want it to just because we’re Christians? (And obviously bad things never happen to Christians!) …Is Profoundly Misunderstood As I set out to explore fear as a topic, reader Darla recommended the book How Not to Be Afraid: Seven Ways to Live When Life Feels Terrifying, by Gareth Higgins. Higgins knows fear well, having grown up queer in Belfast during The Troubles. In this wise little book he covers a gamut of fears from rejection to death. I really enjoyed this book (the audio version is read by the author, in a beautiful lilting accent.) I’ll probably buy a hardcopy so I can vigorously highlight and reread, but what struck me on first listen were two points: * The verse “Fear of God is the beginning of wisdom” is profoundly misunderstood. Higgins writes: “It doesn’t mean that there’s a scary, bearded guy in the sky who loves you so much that he will kill you if you don’t agree with him. It means that becoming wise begins with honoring reality. There’s a healthy way to be afraid that helps us live better and an unhealthy one that makes us sick. There’s a well-worn, but sometimes hidden, path that can help us discern the difference.” (emphasis mine.) As someone who grew up with alcoholics and saw first-hand the destruction of denial, this idea of “honoring reality” strikes me as wise. We can’t get anywhere unless we are willing to face things as they are, even when it is scary or hard. And having discarded my own ideas of God as a “scary bearded guy” I like thinking of God in these more abstract terms: God is ultimate reality, God is the love that underpins the universe. God as the source of all creation. * That “Our fears are reactions to the stories we believe.” Higgins is a big believer in examining our stories. Why do we fear this thing? What are we telling ourselves about it? Is it possible another story is true? It’s not that we should never be afraid of anything, rather, we have to hold the hand of fear and bring it to reality, asking ourselves: is this thing I’m afraid of actually that scary? On Discerning the Difference Yet all this wisdom is often easier to hear than implement. In the case of COVID, it was difficult to figure out what reality actually was. Was COVID “just another flu”? Or was it a catastrophic, world-altering event? Much of peoples’ individual responses hinged on how they answered that question. To make a play on a George Carlin quote, “Have you ever noticed that anybody who masks more than you is an idiot, and everyone who masks less is a lunatic?” Much of the trouble with COVID was its novelty. Scientists were doing their best to give us good information, some of which proved useful (social distancing, masks) and some of which didn’t (wiping down groceries, zoom school.) Perhaps in situations where we don’t have the full information, all we can do is give each other grace and try our best. Yes, grace. Even for those wearing “faith over fear” tees. What do you think of “faith over fear”? Am I alone in thinking this is an antivax shirt? Looking back on COVID, what do you think we should’ve/could’ve done differently? As always, I love to hear feedback from readers in the comments, via email, or DM. Heretic Hereafter is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. This is a public episode. If you'd like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit heretichereafter.substack.com/subscribe

    • Transcript
Showing 1–20 of 28 episodes