Skip to content
Artwork for Evan & Tiki

Evan & Tiki

Audacy

Evan & Tiki brings balance, brains and edge to New York sports talk. Evan Roberts’ fan-first intensity pairs with Tiki Barber’s perspective from inside the game to create debate that’s informed, passionate and rarely predictable. Whether it’s Giants and Jets analysis, Yankees and Mets arguments, or Knicks, Nets and league-wide storylines, the conversation goes deeper than hot takes. Throw in Shaun Morash, who stirs the pot with unfiltered opinions and the raw pulse of the fanbase, and you have Evan & Tiki, a show where New York sports get talked through — not talked over.

Play
  • 1,088 episodes
  • Avg 33 min
  • English

Episodes 1,088

Counted on this page — what you have heard stays on this device, so it is not something the list can be paged by.
  • October 5 · 16 min

    Aaron Glenn Steals Harbaugh’s Gimmick After Jets Disaster

    Aaron Glenn’s response to another Jets embarrassment only creates more frustration. After John Harbaugh pushed a “1-0” mentality with the Giants, Glenn delivers essentially the same message days later, leaving Evan unimpressed and reinforcing the growing belief that the Jets desperately need an established, successful head coach. The coaching conversation expands to Jim Harbaugh, Sean McDermott and Nick Sirianni as potential options if the Jets eventually move on from Glenn. Meanwhile, the Giants sit alone atop the NFC East, the Eagles suffer a costly collapse, and the NFL’s biggest Week 4 developments include the Patriots upsetting Buffalo, the 49ers rolling and surprising starts from the Raiders and Browns.

  • October 5 · 19 min

    Joe Benigno Warns Jet Fans Have Reached Breaking Point

    Aaron Glenn is running out of answers, and Joe Benigno believes the Jets coach could be fighting for his job. After another brutal performance filled with penalties, defensive breakdowns and an ineffective offense, Joe unloads on the state of the franchise and warns that a loss to Cleveland could push an already furious fan base over the edge. The conversation turns to what comes next if Glenn cannot stop the collapse. Joe makes the case for bringing Rex Ryan back, while Mike Tomlin, Jon Gruden and other experienced coaches emerge as potential answers. The biggest concern goes beyond the record: the Jets appear to be getting worse, and Garrett Wilson's frustration only adds to the fear that Glenn is losing control.

  • October 5 · 15 min

    Giants Could Make a Stunning Tony Pollard Trade

    Jameis Winston’s mistakes are inevitable, but his ability to immediately bounce back may be exactly what the Giants need. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate whether Winston actually played well against Arizona and why the good, bad and ugly of his game can still produce winning football. The Giants also have a major question developing at running back. Tiki explains why Tyrone Tracy still needs to regain the coaching staff’s trust, while the crowded rotation suggests their long-term bell cow may not currently be on the roster. Evan then delivers a bold prediction: Tony Pollard will become a Giant before the trade deadline.

  • October 5 · 11 min

    Giants Running Back Rotation Is Getting Complicated

    John Harbaugh’s decision to chase two points before halftime sparks a debate over whether the Giants got unnecessarily aggressive against Arizona. The gamble ultimately didn’t cost them, but Evan Roberts questions why Harbaugh was chasing points so early while Tiki Barber sees the logic behind the decision. Then the Giants’ crowded backfield takes center stage. Najee Harris went from converting a crucial two-point attempt to fumbling on the next possession, and Harbaugh responded by giving Cam Skattebo the final seven carries. With Tyrone Tracy and Devin Singletary also fighting for roles, the Giants suddenly have some difficult decisions to make at running back.

  • October 5 · 21 min

    John Harbaugh Has Completely Changed the Giants

    Jameis Winston gave the Giants everything that comes with the Jameis Winston experience, throwing costly interceptions before delivering the huge plays they needed to beat Arizona 36-24. His response after the Cardinals retook the lead proved critical, while Deonte Banks sealed the win with a pick-six for his second straight game-changing defensive play. Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash credit John Harbaugh and his staff for a Giants team that keeps finding ways to win despite not playing its best football. At 3-1 and alone in first place, the Giants have restored belief at MetLife, and their ability to adjust defensively has Evan convinced once again that coaching is the difference between winning and losing.

  • October 5 · 8 min

    Woody Johnson Must Finally Hire a Proven Winner

    The Jets’ humiliation continued after the final whistle when Bears linebacker Devin Bush called the game one of the easiest he’s ever played and admitted he was actually bored. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber say the comments weren’t even trash talk, which only makes them more damning after the Jets barely kept Chicago’s defense on the field. The conversation turns to Woody Johnson and the Jets’ endless cycle of failed coaching hires. Evan argues Johnson needs to stop searching for the next unproven answer and spend whatever it takes to land an established, successful NFL head coach. The Giants provide the painful comparison, with Tiki pointing to their disciplined defense and Evan crediting John Harbaugh for transforming what competent coaching looks like in New York.

  • October 5 · 12 min

    Garrett Wilson Is Being Wasted by Frank Reich

    Jets fans are officially losing hope. Evan Roberts says he’s done believing Aaron Glenn can turn this around after another humiliating loss, but he strongly pushes back on firing Glenn during the season. With Frank Reich struggling to generate offense, Evan sees no benefit to another desperate midseason coaching change. The frustration extends to Garrett Wilson, who once again wasn’t maximized despite being the Jets’ biggest offensive weapon. Tiki Barber explains why the offense needs to manufacture touches for Wilson instead of waiting for opportunities to develop. As callers abandon their preseason optimism and the schedule threatens to make things even uglier, Evan believes the Jets are headed toward another brutal three or four-win season and, eventually, another search for a head coach.

  • October 5 · 11 min

    Aaron Glenn Is Already a Dead Man Walking

    The Jets look completely hopeless after an embarrassing performance in Chicago. Evan Roberts declares Aaron Glenn a “dead man walking” after watching the Jets get pushed around, miss tackles, commit costly penalties and barely possess the football. Tiki Barber’s film review only confirms how badly Chicago dominated Glenn’s defense. The offense was just as alarming. Garrett Wilson disappeared, Frank Reich’s game plan produced almost nothing, and the Jets ran only 29 offensive plays excluding sacks. Evan and Tiki also hammer Glenn for answering “I don’t know” when asked why Wilson wasn’t more involved, as another ugly loss raises serious questions about whether this season is already spiraling beyond repair.

  • October 3 · 1 hr

    Best of the Giants on WFAN: J.J. McCarthy in, OBJ out

    The Giants released Odell Beckham Jr. after barely using him for three games. Our hosts react to the news and debate if there was ever any point of reuniting with OBJ in the first place. Plus, Evan and Tiki discuss the team's chances in the NFC East without Jaxson Dart, and if J.J. McCarthy has any chance of pushing Jameis Winston for the starting job. Phil Simms joins Boomer and Gio to talk all things Big Blue, including McCarthy and how he may be used the rest of this season.

  • October 3 · 53 min

    Best of the Yankees on WFAN: Bring on the Rays

    The Yankees steamrolled the hated Red Sox in a two-game Wild Card Series sweep, and we have full reactions from all of our hosts, who were pleasantly surprised at how efficient the Yankee lineup was from top to bottom. Plus, debating whether or not Aaron Judge will play in the ALDS, how the Yankees will set up their rotation, and if the Bombers should be favored against the Rays. Meanwhile, Evan and Tiki feel like the Yanks were a little over the top in celebrating a Wild Card Series win, and Boomer and Gio debate which Yankee is likeliest to carry the team and be their new "Mr. October."

  • October 3 · 1 hr

    Yanks sweep Boston; ALDS Preview | 'NYYST'

    From 'NYYST' (subscribe here): The Fellas are back to discuss the recent sweep of the Red Sox in the WC series. A look ahead to preview the upcoming ALDS against the Tampa Bay Rays.

  • October 2 · 36 min

    Hour 1: Jameis Winston Is Officially Out of Excuses

    Jameis Winston is entering put-up-or-shut-up territory for the Giants. After weather and circumstances limited what could be learned from his first two appearances, Sunday against Arizona is viewed as the game that should finally reveal what Winston has left. If his arm and accuracy remain concerns, the conversation around J.J. McCarthy and when he could realistically take over will only get louder. The Jets also face what Evan calls the most important game of the Aaron Glenn era, with a loss to a Bears team starting a backup quarterback threatening to wipe away the optimism from last week. Plus, the Yankees face a major Aaron Judge decision, including whether he should return directly to right field rather than disrupt a lineup featuring Ben Rice and Luis Garcia.

  • October 2 · 46 min

    Hour 2: Aaron Judge Must Play, Even If He’s Compromised

    Aaron Judge may not be 100 percent, but Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber see no justification for keeping him out of the Yankees lineup against Tampa Bay. They debate how Aaron Boone should handle Judge, why Ben Rice has emerged as a legitimate star, and how the Yankees’ ability to develop young players has separated them from the Mets. Gerrit Cole’s Game 1 start and the rest of the ALDS rotation also come into focus. The hour also hits the Giants’ challenge of winning with Jameis Winston and whether J.J. McCarthy could eventually fit Matt Nagy’s offense. Plus, Evan and Tiki react to Jack Hughes’ painfully awkward in-game interview, the Jets reach the point where encouraging signs need to become wins, and Shaun Morash deals with the possibility that his UPS driver saw far more than expected.

  • October 2 · 41 min

    Hour 3: Yankees-Rays Prediction Sparks a Major Evan-Tiki Split

    The Yankees’ ALDS matchup with the Rays has Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber going in opposite directions. Tiki sees New York’s starting pitching and postseason experience carrying the Yankees in four, while Evan predicts Tampa Bay in four and warns that Gerrit Cole could put the Yankees in an immediate hole in Game 1. Shaun Morash lands on Yankees in five as the debate heats up over Cole versus Carlos Rodon. Aaron Judge’s role also looms over the series, with the guys weighing whether his presence alone makes the Yankees better and how carefully he should be used coming off injury. Plus, Tony Romo and CBS part ways, the Giants’ J.J. McCarthy gamble gets another look, and the Jets’ offensive line comes under fire.

  • October 2 · 45 min

    Hour 4: Bench Aaron Judge? Evan and Tiki Blast a "Ridiculous" Fan Take

    Tiki Barber and Evan Roberts debate the validity of the current MLB playoff format and the logic behind a caller's demand to bench Aaron Judge for the division series. They analyze the Yankees' travel issues heading to Tampa and share their favorite moments from the movie Major League. Finally, they make their official Week 4 NFL picks for the Jets, Giants, and key national matchups. (00:01:52) MLB Playoff Bracket Debate (00:05:35) Yankees Playoff Series Benefits (00:09:23) Yankees Travel Plane Trouble (00:12:54) Selecting Your Playoff Opponent (00:19:21) Major League Movie Appreciation (00:22:54) NFL Week 4 Analysis (00:28:51) Benching Aaron Judge Debate (00:35:24) Idiots With Idioms Segment (00:39:52) Official NFL Week 4 Picks

  • October 2 · 19 min

    Yankees Could Benefit From MLB’s Broken Bracket

    MLB’s playoff format is under fire, with the Yankees’ path exposing why the bracket system and lack of reseeding can create frustrating matchups. Evan Roberts and Tiki Barber debate the flaws in the setup, why facing the Rays in a best-of-five could actually benefit the Yankees, and whether MLB could overhaul the postseason under a new CBA. The conversation turns to an even wilder possibility: letting the best teams choose their playoff opponents. Evan and Tiki imagine the drama, insults and incredible television that could follow from a live selection show. Plus, they discuss the Yankees’ pitching plans, Gerrit Cole’s importance and the team’s travel trouble getting to Tampa.

  • October 2 · 8 min

    Aaron Judge’s ALDS Role Could Change by Game 3

    Aaron Judge’s ALDS role remains a major question as Evan Roberts, Tiki Barber and Shaun Morash debate how the Yankees should protect him coming off injury. One possibility is keeping Judge out of right field on Tampa Bay’s turf, using him as a dangerous bat off the bench before potentially returning him to the field at Yankee Stadium in Game 3. The Giants also face an interesting quarterback dynamic with Jameis Winston starting and J.J. McCarthy waiting behind him. Evan believes the crowd could turn quickly if Winston struggles. Plus, Shaun unveils his “Cinco de Ronco” list of the opponents New York fans could despise by the end of the weekend, including Ben Johnson, Trey McBride and Rays pitcher Drew Rasmussen.

Showing 521–540 of 1,088 episodes