
Razor Blades in Apples, Candy Corn Conundrum & Pumpkin Spice Everything
Has anyone ever actually found a razor blade in a Halloween apple? George Duran and food and wellness writer Karla Walsh dig into America's favorite Halloween scare: where the razor-blade apple hoax stories came from and why an apple is a terrible place to hide a blade anyway. Plus the cases that were real: a California dentist who handed out candy-coated laxatives, and a Long Island woman who gave dog biscuits and ant poison to teens she thought were too old to trick-or-treat. Then it's "Treat or Trash?" : Sour candy in a toy toilet with a plunger? (Real.) Candy scabs inside a fake bandage? (Real.) Liquid candy in a urine-sample cup? (Sadly, real.) Pickled eyeballs and used-tissue chews? (George made those up.) After the break: candy corn. Karla is fully Team Candy Corn; George thinks it's sweet, chewy wax and has receipts. They cover how it started as "Chicken Feed," the wax and glaze that give it that shine, Brach's new candy corn perfume, and a candy corn round of Treat or Trash where hot dog, hamburger, green bean and roasted turkey flavors all turn out to be real. In the second half, creative director and Creative Briefs host Jon Racinskas explains how pumpkin spice went from spice trade to pumpkin pie to Starbucks' 2003 latte, why "manufactured scarcity" keeps us coming back every fall, and which pumpkin spice products, from Spam to scented trash bags, have gone too far. Plus his pick for the next seasonal obsession. Key Takeaways The razor-blade apple is mostly myth. Sociologist Joel Best (University of Delaware) has tracked "Halloween sadism" reports since the 1980s and found no substantiated case of a child killed or seriously injured by a stranger's tampered treat. Most reports he followed up were hoaxes. The scare had a paper trail. Razor-blade reports spread in the late 1960s, and a 1970 New York Times piece, "Those Treats May Be Tricks," warned that the apple from a kindly neighbor might hide a blade. Apples are a bad hiding place. George's case: a cut apple browns fast, a slit big enough for a blade can't be hidden, and the fruit would be visibly off by the time it got home. Real tampering was rare and strange. In 1959 a California dentist, Dr. William Shyne, handed out about 450 candy-coated laxatives; around 30 kids got sick. In 1964, Helen Pfeil of Long Island gave out steel wool, dog biscuits and ant poison to teens she considered too old for trick-or-treating. George hands out instant ramen as a Halloween treat. He says he's the most popular house on the block. Gross candy is a real category. Kidsmania's Sour Flush (sour powder in a toy toilet with a candy plunger), Flix Candy's Box of Boogers and Lick Your Wounds candy scabs are all real. Candy corn started as "Chicken Feed." It's credited to George Renninger of Philadelphia's Wunderle Candy Company in the 1880s; the Goelitz company, now Jelly Belly, began making it in 1898. Yes, it's waxy. Candy corn gets its shine from a confectioner's glaze (shellac), and some recipes use carnauba wax. Candy corn now comes as perfume. Brach's released Ode to Candy Corn, a $22 limited-edition fragrance with vanilla, spun sugar and honey notes, in fall 2026. It sold out fast. Yes, these flavors are real. Brach's Turkey Dinner mix (2020) had roasted turkey, stuffing, green beans, cranberry sauce, ginger glazed carrot and sweet potato pie; its Tailgate mix (2022) added hot dog and hamburger. Pumpkin spice is four spices. Cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger and cloves. McCormick sold the blend as pumpkin pie spice in 1934; Starbucks launched the pumpkin spice latte in 2003. Scarcity is the strategy for seasonal pumpkin spiced flavors. Jon's take: a PSL in June wouldn't sell, because the appeal is nostalgia tied to a season. Warmth matters. Jon thinks pumpkin spice products that last are warm and multisensory, which is why he doesn't expect the Slurpee version to stick. Pumpkin spice has gone everywhere. Spam (2019), Nissin Cup Noodles (2021), Hatfield bacon, Pringles (2012), Kraft Mac & Cheese (2020), 7-Eleven's Slurpee (2024), Hefty trash bags, cat litter, deodorant, Dawn dish spray and Trader Joe's hummus. What's next? Jon's bets: a spring lavender latte, and "deep fried" as a flavor, pointing to Oreo's new Deep Fried cookie. People & Companies Mentioned George Duran — Host, Always Hangry; chef and TV personality Karla Walsh — Food and wellness writer, Level One Sommelier; recurring Always Hangry co-host Jon Racinskas — Creative director and filmmaker; host of the YouTube channel Creative Briefs Joel Best — Sociologist, University of Delaware; leading researcher on Halloween candy-tampering myths The New York Times — Published "Those Treats May Be Tricks" (October 1970) Dr. William Shyne — California dentist who handed out laxatives to trick-or-treaters in 1959 Helen Pfeil — Long Island woman behind the 1964 steel wool and ant poison incident Jelly Belly — Maker of the vomit-flavored jelly bean (formerly the Goelitz Confectionery Company) Kidsmania — Sour Flush candy Flix Candy — Box of Boogers Lick Your Wounds — Candy scabs in refillable bandages Bon Appétit — Cited by George for a 2013 gross-candy roundup (unverified — see checklist) Wunderle Candy Company / George Renninger — Credited with inventing candy corn Brach's (Ferrara) — Candy corn maker; Ode to Candy Corn perfume, Turkey Dinner and Tailgate candy corn Walgreens — Exclusive retailer of Brach's novelty candy corn mixes American Chemical Society — Source George cites on candy corn's glaze McCormick — Released pumpkin pie spice in 1934 Starbucks — Pumpkin spice latte (2003) Hormel (Spam), Nissin (Cup Noodles), Hatfield, Pringles, Kraft, 7-Eleven — Pumpkin spice food products Hefty, Special Kitty, Native, Dawn — Pumpkin spice trash bags, cat litter, deodorant and dish spray Trader Joe's — Pumpkin spice hummus Oreo — Chicken & Waffles and Deep Fried limited-edition cookies Links Guests Jon Racinskas — jonracinskas.com , https://www.instagram.com/jonracinskas/, Creative Briefs on https://www.youtube.com/@Creative_Briefs Always Hangry Website — https://alwayshangrypodcast.com Instagram — https://www.instagram.com/AlwaysHangryPodcast YouTube — https://www.youtube.com/@AlwaysHangryPodcast TikTok — https://www.tiktok.com/@AlwaysHangryPodcast
- Transcript
- Chapters