Skip to content
Sign in
Artwork for 2 Twisted Sisters
True Crime

2 Twisted Sisters

Shawna Blackburn & Kelley DeWitt

Two sisters. A questionable fascination with true crime. And way too many stories about the craziest serial killers in history.

Each episode, Kelley and Shawna battle it out, taking turns sharing their most twisted true-crime stories.

There will be murder, mayhem, and plenty of opinions.

And since I’m writing this bio, I’ll just say it: Shawna wins. Every time.

Play
Open in
  • 13 episodes
  • Avg 48 min
  • English

Episodes 13

NewestOldestLongest
All13Unplayed13In progress0Played0
  • S2 · E5
    Monday · 45 min

    Who Murdered Rachel Barber?

    Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note. Shawna tells us the story of Rachel Barber. What happened to her, and why? Does this compete with the boy in the walls? Let's see who win's this round!

  • S3 · E1
    Monday · 31 min

    The Man with No Face

    Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note. Shawna takes us to India, where things are not what they seem! It's another spooky story with all of the craziness we usually have - we hope you enjoy!

  • S2 · E4
    Monday · 36 min

    The Boy in the Walls

    Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note. Spooooky time! Kelley tells us about the crazy case of the boy in the walls!

  • S2 · E3
    Monday · 49 min

    Special Episode - Nature V Nurture

    Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note. Are serial killers born or made? Join us as we introduce a special guest, future psychologist Kellen Blackburn, and talk about the man with no face!

  • S2 · E1
    Monday · 50 min

    The Case of the Holistic Killer

    Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note. Olalla has some secrets - and Kelley is going to spill them. Have you ever been to a spa that you felt like wasn't quite right? You may crave a burger after this one. Kelley tells you about Starvation Heights! Come and join!

  • S1 · E5
    Monday · 31 min

    Dumb & Dumber Part 1

    Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note. Kelley is telling us about Dolly - the housewife with a secret - It's part one of the Dumb and Dumber competition - let's see whose story is the dumbest!

  • S3 · E3
    Monday · 37 min

    The Lafferty Case

    Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note. What drives someone to do the unthinkable? Is it pride? Hubris? Koolaid? Join us as we continue season 3 with a case comparison of three families who went from normal to nutty, and murder was the result.

  • S1 · E3
    October 2 · 55 min

    The Soap Maker of Correggio v Villisca Axe Murders part 1

    Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note. Join us for part one of this segment as Shawna takes us to Italy to tell us about the chilling story of the Soap Maker of Correggio. It's going to be "sweet"!

  • S1 · E2
    October 2 · 1 hr 5 min

    Burke & Hare v Bloody Benders part 2

    Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note. What do you do when the only place to stay on a lonely road in the middle of nowhere is super sketch? You drive on friend. Unfortunately, too many people didn't follow that little rule and suffered the ultimate consequence. It’s the first family of serial killers documented in the US and Shawna is going to win this round by telling you alllll about it. Come and hang while we talk about the Bloody Benders!

  • S1 · E1
    October 2 · 1 hr 16 min

    Burke & Hare v Bloody Benders part 1

    Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note. Join us as we cover the famous Burke and Hare Murders! Also commonly known as the anatomy murders, we are transported back to the early 1800’s in Edinburgh, Scotland where grave robbing is running rampant and anatomy research in the medical community is booming. In comes Burke and Hare who single handedly revolutionize the art of murder for profit. It’s a doozy and we’re excited to share it with you!

  • S2 · E7
    October 2 · 47 min

    Ghosts V Demons - Part 2

    Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note. It's part two of the Halloween episodes! Join us as we learn more about the first ever court case in America where the defense cited demon possession as the reason for murder. A historic case - but can it beat the ghost story? Only you can tell!

  • S2 · E6
    October 2 · 48 min

    Ghosts V Demons Part 1

    Hey! I'd love to hear your thoughts, send me a voice note. It’s spooky season, so naturally we’re going to talk about ghosts and everything spooky! You should definitely be thankful for this mother/daughter duo who just wouldn’t quit till justice was served! Join us as Kelley tells us about the only case in us history where a tale from beyond the grave was admitted as evidence on a court document. Will it trump Shawna’s demon murder case?! Only YOU can DECIDE!

Showing 1–13 of 13 episodes