
Are Deepfakes Legal? AI Likeness Laws and Fair Use
Can someone copy your face and your voice, put them in a film and never ask you? Deepfakes and AI likeness laws are moving fast, and whether a deepfake is legal depends on where you are. In the United States, entertainment attorney Anne B. Easton explains, the question is whether the person gave permission to use their face and voice. In Europe, the question is whether the audience knows it is looking at AI. For documentaries, fair use and archival footage raise a version of the same problem: when can you use something you didn't make? In Episode 290, Christian sits down with Anne B. Easton, an entertainment attorney with Blakemore Law and Entertainment Law Partners, for the first of a two-part conversation. Anne, back on Documentary First after Episodes 248 and 250, joins from Paris after the International Association of Entertainment Lawyers' legal summit at the Amsterdam Dance Event. She follows up on the Blake Lively and Justin Baldoni case and explains why, in her reading, Lively's harassment claims never reached a jury: the judge found she was an independent contractor, not an employee. FREE GUIDE: Lessons from Anne B. Easton on AI likeness, fair use and archival footage. Sign up and we'll email it to you. Anne walks through the AI copies of the "Storm" music video by GENER8ION and Yung Lean, moral rights in France, US publicity rights and the NO FAKES Act, AI disclosure labels in Europe, and Denmark's bill to let people control their own face. Christian brings in Phil Maher from Episode 287 on telling audiences when footage is AI created, and James L. Freedman from Episode 288 on fair use as a gray area. Then Anne breaks down the four factors of fair use, why a $125 license can cost less than a lawsuit, and how the court in the Tiger King case changed its mind about a funeral video Netflix used in the series. In this episode, you'll learn: Anne's advice: go to the conferences and the film festivals CHAPTERS 0:00 Lively v. Baldoni Explained 6:55 Inside a Legal Summit 10:08 Are Deepfakes Legal? 14:30 Publicity Rights and NO FAKES 16:42 Should Documentaries Disclose Reenactments? 20:42 Europe's Labels and Denmark's Bill 25:55 Four Factors of Fair Use 29:34 The Tiger King Ruling 33:16 DocuView Deja View Pick 36:52 Blackmail, Shutdowns and Claude FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS Are deepfakes legal? It depends on where you are. Entertainment attorney Anne B. Easton explains that US law treats an AI copy of a person mainly through publicity rights: did the person give permission to use their face or voice? In Europe, she says, the focus is on the audience and whether people know the material was created with AI. The law is still catching up, with the proposed NO FAKES Act in the United States and a Danish bill on deepfakes. Do documentaries need to label AI reenactments? In France, yes, according to entertainment attorney Anne B. Easton. She says European rules focus on disclosure, so a film with an AI reenactment that plays in France needs a label telling viewers what is AI. In her view, AI-created images and voices must be disclosed; AI used to polish a script probably needn't be. Phil Maher says filmmakers should tell the audience when footage is AI created, and Christian Taylor agrees, saying it builds the audience's trust. What are the four factors of fair use? Courts weigh four factors: the purpose of the use, the nature of the original work, how much of it is taken, and the harm to the original work's market. Entertainment attorney Anne B. Easton says no single factor decides a case, so no clip length is automatically safe. She tells clients they can take the risk on a short clip, but a $125 license can cost far less than a lawsuit, attorneys' fees and court fees. What happened in the Tiger King fair use case? Netflix used about a minute of Timothy Sepi's funeral video in Tiger King. A Tenth Circuit panel first found the use wasn't fair because it commented on Joe Exotic rather than on the video itself. On rehearing in 2026, the court reversed course and found fair use. Anne B. Easton reads the ruling as accepting that footage used as historical evidence can serve a new purpose. The court also said documentaries get no automatic presumption of fair use. DOCUVIEW DEJA VIEW PICK Anne's pick is The AI Doc: Or How I Became an Apocaloptimist (2026), directed by Daniel Roher and Charlie Tyrell. Roher, who won the Oscar for Navalny, asks AI founders and researchers, Sam Altman among them, whether we should bring children into a world shaped by AI. It is streaming on Netflix and Peacock in the US, and every guest pick is on the DocuView Deja View page. SPONSORED BY VIRGIL FILMS ENTERTAINMENT This episode is brought to you by Virgil Films Entertainment, distributor of Super Size Me and the Oscar-nominated Restrepo, with over 25 years of distribution experience: virgilfilms.com LISTEN AND FOLLOW Listen and subscribe wherever you get podcasts Watch on YouTube SUPPORT THE SHOW Join the Documentary First community on Patreon CONNECT WITH DOCUMENTARY FIRST All platforms Christian Taylor on LinkedIn ABOUT THE GUEST Anne B. Easton Entertainment attorney, Blakemore Law; Of Counsel, Entertainment Law Partners Anne B. Easton is an entertainment attorney based in Los Angeles and Paris. She advises on film and television development, production, distribution, financing and intellectual property. She left Sheppard Mullin and founded Blakemore Law in 2025, and she co-hosts My Lawyer Friend Podcast. Blakemore Law | Entertainment Law Partners MY LAWYER FRIEND PODCAST Anne's own podcast breaks down legal and lifestyle topics "with your friend (if your friend was also a lawyer)." Website | Instagram ABOUT DOCUMENTARY FIRST For people who make documentaries and people who love them. Discover how documentaries actually get made, paid for and seen with filmmaker Christian Taylor. Plus DocuView Deja View, where every guest recommends a documentary worth watching. One week, a long-form conversation about a guest's journey, projects and lessons; the next, The Deep Dive, Christian's short solo reflection on one idea from that conversation. Guests have included Ken Burns and PBS American Masters creator Susan Lacy. Christian directed the award-winning documentary The Girl Who Wore Freedom. Nearly 300 conversations. Listen Notes top 3% worldwide. 4.8 on Apple Podcasts. New episodes every week. RESOURCES MENTIONED International Association of Entertainment Lawyers Romain Gavras on the AI copies of the "Storm" video (Stereogum) NO FAKES Act of 2026, S.4591 Denmark's deepfake bill (Euronews) U.S. Copyright Office Fair Use Index The Tiger King fair use ruling (Authors Alliance) Agentic Misalignment, the AI blackmail safety test (Anthropic)
