The (climate) case against (AI) data centers

This is a free preview of a paid episode. To hear more, visit www.volts.wtf Volts guests have argued that data centers can be good for the grid if they’re built right. Here I hear the case against, from Ketan Joshi, a former wind-industry analyst who now tracks Big Tech’s climate claims. He sees data centers as the wrong kind of demand growth: lumpy, concentrated, unwanted by neighbors, and largely met with gas. Underneath it all is the worry that the backlash against data centers will become a backlash against electrification itself. Chapters: 00:00 – Introduction 02:14 – How Ketan became a big tech critic 06:01 – The case against data centers 07:39 – What data centers add to emissions 11:57 – Isn’t more electricity demand good? 20:12 – Backlash and the NEXTDC power-pole protest 24:21 – AI claims 1: will AI help the climate? 27:53 – AI claims 2: machine learning vs. generative AI 33:47 – AI claims 3: inflated climate wins 36:51 – The gas rush: how much gets built? 44:49 – Would easier renewables fix it? 49:14 – Can data centers be flexible load? 55:41 – Do we actually want AI data centers? 59:39 – What should data centers do to plug in? 1:05:31 – Fake crackdowns and the risk to renewables 1:09:24 – What if AI is a bubble?