
The Wild History of Eggnog: Medieval posset, Christmas tradition, colonial America & one very real eggnog riot
Eggnog feels like one of those drinks that has always just… been there. Creamy. Spiced. Very Christmas. Sitting quietly in the grocery store like it does not have a whole chaotic backstory. Girl. It does. In Episode 11 of True Mocktails, we’re going down the holiday rabbit hole to figure out how eggnog became one of the most recognizable Christmas drinks in America. We’re tracing its roots back to posset, a warm milk-based drink enjoyed in medieval Britain, where ingredients like milk, eggs, spices, and alcohol were often associated with wealth, celebration, and good health. Then the idea made its way across the Atlantic. And America, being America, said: “What if we add rum?” From there, eggnog evolved into the rich holiday drink we know today and eventually became deeply tied to Christmas traditions. But then… We get to the Eggnog Riot of 1826. Yes. An actual riot. At West Point. Over eggnog. Cadets were told they could not have alcohol at their Christmas celebration, and apparently that information was not received with grace. What followed involved smuggled liquor, very strong eggnog, damaged barracks, fights, and disciplinary hearings. And baby… I thought we were just here for nutmeg. This is exactly why I love drink history. You start with one simple question like, “Why do we drink eggnog at Christmas?” and somehow end up in medieval Britain, colonial America, and a military academy full of people tearing up the building over a holiday drink. I’m your digital home bartender, Princess, and this is True Mocktails. Salu. Let me take a sip. If you enjoyed this episode, follow True Mocktails, leave the show a five-star rating, and share this episode with the same person you’d share a drink with. Come hang out with us: Instagram: www.instagram.com/thirstyhomebody TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@thirstyhomebody Threads: www.threads.com/@thirstyhomebody Facebook: www.facebook.com/thirstyhomebody YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@ThirstyHomebody We keep the convos going and live life outside of the house too. See y’all next time for another round of True Mocktails.