Skip to content
Artwork for The Mythcreant Podcast
The Mythcreant Podcast · September 27

607 – Flawed Protagonists

We’ve all heard advice about creating flaws for our characters, but what does that mean in practice? This week, we’re talking about flawed protagonists! We discuss the factors that make some flawed characters compelling while others are reduced to being unpleasant. We also get into the ways flaws can be tricky to manage and why we believe adding a laundry list of them is a little excessive. Show Notes Pluribus Why Literary Fiction is a genre How to Make Your Hero Guilty – but Still Lovable Understanding Character Karma 587 – Revenge and Forgiveness in Fiction Characters Don’t Need Flaws The Best Characters Eat Their Spinach — and Their Candy Frodo Baggins Othello Writing Character Arcs Stay for a Spell Do Characters Need to Be Likable? Save The Cat Katniss Everdeen Authorial Endorsement 101 Tom Loftis Eleanor Shellstrop Five Ways to Make a Selfish Character Likable Chidi Anagonye The Tainted Cup Rick Sanchez Transcript Generously transcribed by Albert Gallego. Volunteer to transcribe a podcast. Chris: Welcome to the Mythcreant Podcast. I’m Chris. Oren: And I’m Oren. Chris: Now, we might seem like nice people on the podcast, but maybe as soon as we stop recording, we rant about how our podcast is trash and everyone who listens to it has terrible taste. And then when we get fan mail, we write back telling that person to get a life. Also, I should say I’m secretly writing a literary genre novel. That’s my true passion, despite what I tell everyone. Oren: It’s funny because, normally, the trope of doing that is writers do that with books that make them tons of money, but they hate ’cause, you know, making money is bad, actually. But our podcast doesn’t make us any money. [Chris laughs] That would be extra funny if we had a character who’s like, “Yeah, I’m writing these completely unsuccessful books that nobody buys, and they’re secretly trash… and everyone who reads them is stupid.” We should do that. Some people insist that you can’t ever have too many flaws, so I think we should do that, have a character whose flaw here is both that they’re really judgmental and also just incredibly bad at deciding what they should spend their time on. Chris: I’m also addicted to podcasting. That’s why I do it, even though I don’t like it, and also it’s not very popular and not earning me very much money. I said that because we’re watching Pluribus right now. Oren: Yeah. Plur- [they both mumble]. Chris: Plur- whatever. It’s Pluribus. Oren: It’s hard to look up posts about that because pluribus is a very commonly used Latin phrase, and it’s in an important U.S. motto. And so whenever I look it up, that’s what comes up. So it’s been hard to find actual commentary on that show, despite how popular it was. Chris: That’s a naming mistake, for sure. Gotta have a trademark-able, extra unique name. No, that’s a bad idea. So any case, this time we’re covering flawed protagonists because sometimes writers wanna write about people who are messed up. There’s lots to say about people who are messed up, and some people find them very novel and interesting or just find them relatable or empathize with their flaws. There are lots of reasons to wanna do this, even though it is tricky and can create problems. Oren: My favorite is when the flaw is only kind of a flaw. It’s like a little wink to the audience. We’ve been referencing the first episode of Pluribus in which our author main character thinks everyone who reads her books is a brain-dead walnut, and has no respect for them. And yeah we could say that’s a flaw, and maybe that’s part of a character arc. I’ve only seen the first three episodes, I don’t know. Fans tell me it’s part of a character arc, so we’ll see. But regardless of whether it is or not, a lot of people also feel that way, and the show is kind of winking at them, and they’re like, “Yeah, romantasy fans are brain-dead walnuts and are total trash.” So it validates them, and then we can do a little bit of an arc later if we want, and it’s no big deal. Chris: Turns out the flawed protagonist was the audience all along. Oren: Yeah, exactly. And so it works really well that way. I don’t really love that it does, but it does. You know, it would’ve worked on me if she had been writing a literary novel that everyone loved, and then she’d been like, “Uh, actually, literary fans are all snobs and, you know, don’t actually know what a good story is and can be tricked by just being told that the story is deep and meaningful.” That would work on me. I’d be like, “Yeah, okay, that’s a flaw, but also that’s- she’s so right.” [Chris laughs] So it’s just a matter of knowing who you’re appealing to, you know? Chris: I mean, that is one strategy for dealing with frustration. This is one of the issues that can happen with a flawed protagonist is, if they’re flawed in a way that makes it so they create problems for themselves or others or are bad at dealing with problems and you’ve got the audience invested in those problems and solving those problems as usually you would want to… it can be very frustrating. But one way to get around that is to just make them do bad things or sabotage themselves or others in ways that the audience can actually root for, and this would be kind of an example of that technique. It’s kind of a niche technique, but especially if this is something like getting revenge, maybe getting revenge isn’t productive, but if you make a villain hated enough, the audience is gonna be like, “Yeah, but it would be really nice just to see this person gets what’s coming to them.” So even though this is self-destructive, I can probably root for it anyway ’cause I get something out of it. You could have something like that happen. Oren: Of course, when it comes to flaws, we should acknowledge that there is a lot of misconception about them. That’s why if you go into any writing space, you will find a bunch of posts about how characters need flaws and how if a character doesn’t have flaws, that’s bad. You will hear the term Mary Sue thrown around a lot. And of course, in reality, many heroes do not have anything that would be realistically considered a flaw. What that discourse is usually actually getting at is whether or not they have too much candy, which is different. Like, Frodo doesn’t have too much candy, but he’s not really flawed in any meaningful way, not in a dramatic way. And I don’t think he would be a better character if he was. Someone like Othello is flawed, but Frodo’s not. Frodo’s just doing his best. Chris: And again, character arcs don’t require flaws either because… if a character, for instance, is grieving, I would not call that a flaw. That would be weird and judgmental. But they’re, of course they’re grieving, so it’s natural that they’re unhappy and having problems, and as part of their character arc, they can heal. But I certainly wouldn’t say they have a flaw that they have to overcome. Again, flaws, not really necessary, but writers like them for a variety of reasons. We can talk about what we would classify as a flaw, which is something that this person would be better if they did not have this trait. Oren: This would be a better person, and I mean that in the real-life sense, if they did not have that. Something like greedy or selfish or cowardly or judgemental. You know, these are things where they go beyond what might be a healthy version of that feeling. Like, there’s actually a place for judging people. You don’t wanna just completely take everything you see at face value. At that point, you might have a flaw of being too credulous. But obviously you can be too much of that, at which point we start calling them judgemental, and at that point it becomes a flaw. With cowardly, it’s like, okay, if your character is scared of something that is dangerous, that’s not cowardly. Or if they run away from something that they can’t possibly defeat, that’s also not cowardly. But if they run away from something that they could probably have overcome if they had actually stayed to fight, you could say that’s cowardice, and you could say that’s a flaw to overcome. Chris: And again, it doesn’t have to be something that makes them a jerk. I was just reading Stay for a Spell, and the character’s flaw is supposed to be that she’s too nice, and it’s a problem because she ends up doing what other people want instead of doing what she wants. Those kinds of meek characters… I like them, but again, with any flaw, it can turn people against a character. So that is one that could create frustration, right? If you have a character who is nice and lets other people walk all over them, that’s a situation where the reader could be invested in them solving their problems, and get frustrated when they just let people walk over them instead. As opposed to a quirk, which is what we call it when they have a trait that sometimes benefits them and sometimes disadvantages them. Quirks are great ’cause they tend to add a lot of interest. But you don’t feel like the quirk has to be eliminated. You don’t feel like it’s something that has to be a problem that has to be solved. It’s just a permanent interesting feature of the character that can create setbacks and advantages. Oren: And we usually find it works best to focus on one flaw, especially at a time. ‘Cause if your character has a bunch of flaws, actual flaws as we’re describing them, that increases the chance significantly that your readers are just going to hate them and not want to read about them. But also it de-emphasizes the impact of any one flaw because you got all of them, so they just kind of become noise after a while. I’ll never forget frigging “Save the Cat! Writes a Novel” recommending a laundry list of flaws, and… what are you talking about? Chris: That’s a bad idea. Oren: It’s especially funny after using Katniss Everdeen as an example in the beginning of Hunger Games. Like, she’s supposed to be flawed, and by flawed, you mean she’s a little grouchy? Is that a flaw? Wow, that’s, like, such a shallow definition of a flaw. Chris: I won’t say that you can never do more than one flaw because sometimes they can be kind of related to each other or connected together. But what does happen, and I’ve seen this in many works, is that when you have too many, it really muddies the waters when it comes to the character arc. It just becomes really unclear what their problem is, and what they need to learn, and then what the solution is, and when they have actually made progress… because we’re juggling too many things, and they tend to blur together. There’s just so much subjectivity, when it comes to a character’s personality and their emotional state, that we do have to focus on “Okay, what exactly is the issue here?” And if we have, like, five flaws, it’s really easy for those to blend into each other, and it just becomes, “wait, I don’t understand. What, what is their flaw? What do they need to learn?” And also, we’re not gonna be able to follow up on that many character arcs in the same book. That’s gonna be too much. Similarly, we don’t want a flaw that’s super broad. Like immaturity, for instance, or selfishness are both flaws that can mean any number of behaviors. Oren: Yeah, you’d wanna zoom in a little bit. Chris: And that also just makes it really hard to deal with, whereas if we can pinpoint more specifically in what situations is this character immature, and how exactly do they act, or in what ways is this person selfish, and in what situations, and in what ways do they behave in a way that is self-centered, then it’s easier to address that and give that clarity, etcetera. Oren: Say what we want about Pluribus, I do think it’s pretty impressive, especially in the early episodes, which is again, that’s what I’ve seen. They manage to give the protagonist, Carol, three pretty distinct flaws that so far haven’t really blurred together, which is always the concern. ‘Cause the first thing is that she is really disdainful of her readers, and again, that’s like a secret wink to the audience flaw, where a lot of the audience feels the same way, so you know, the impact is lessened. Then she has serious anger problems, and then she’s also an alcoholic. And part of the way that they balance that is that her being an alcoholic doesn’t play a big role in these early episodes. It’s there, you can see it in the background, but it’s not brought to the fore the way her other flaws are. And then in the second and third episode, we focus much more on the anger problem because now if she gets too mad at the uwu murder virus hive mind, a bunch of people will die, so that’s a struggle that she has to try to keep it in check. And that one’s very sympathetic because the evil uwu murder virus hive mind is the most annoying thing anyone has ever invented. [Chris laughs] So when she gets mad at it, I’m like, “Yes, it deserves for you to be mad at it. It’s the worst.” But she has to try not to because she doesn’t want to be responsible for people dying. Chris: I do have a little bit of frustration when she thinks of it as her fault when people die. Yes, you should learn to control your temper. That’s a good idea, but they’re the ones who decided to infect the entire planet with a virus where people would die if you got mad at them. That was their choice. That was their doing. Also, in doing that, they killed far more people than she does when she gets angry at them. So I don’t know… I get annoyed with that because when somebody brings up that it’s her fault and then she just accepts that, definitely feels like there’s authorial endorsement at that point, that we’re supposed to believe that it’s her fault that people get hurt when she gets angry. But it’s, it’s not her fault. Oren: Yeah, I mean, it’s hard for me to say at this point, ’cause again, this is a show that likes to keep its cards close to its chest, and at only three episodes I don’t really know where it’s going, and I don’t trust anything anyone says about this show. [Chris Laughs] Because I’ve seen how unhinged the discourse about it is. Chris: Yeah. We’ve had so many instances where we’ll say something on our blog, and then somebody will be like, “Oh, but this book,…” in the comments. And if we have actually read that book, it is very often misrepresenting the story. And so now we just don’t trust what anybody says about any story ever until we go read it ourselves. Oren: I will say, I don’t like Pluribus. I find it really boring most of the time. But I do find it believable that she thinks that it’s her fault, because she’s basically being constantly gaslit by everyone around her, both the hive mind and the other humans. To me it’s believable that she thinks that because she’s been bludgeoned into it. I don’t enjoy that. It’s not a show I would watch if I didn’t have a blog to talk about it on, but it’s interesting. It’s kind of neat to see. Chris: Yeah, I do think, find it very hard when you have an unpleasant protagonist who bad things are happening to them. That is typically something that I do not enjoy seeing. At the same time, and we should talk about this more, we can talk about Widow’s Bay, one of the strategies for dealing with a protagonist who audiences just find them unpleasant and don’t really like them is to just have bad things happen to them because we get schadenfreude. We get satisfaction at seeing them punished for their bad karma. And I will say with Pluribus, Carol is, as far as I can tell, just a very unpleasant person, and the Pluribus hive mind is a very unpleasant being. And so I’m just watching them make each other miserable Oren: Yep. Chris: And also in many of these cases, the stakes seem relatively low, right? If there was another innocent person for them to hurt while they were going back and forth with each other, but I do get some amusement from that. Oren: Oh man, Widow’s Bay. This is so… Such a cool thing. I hope you could do this in book form. So in Widow’s Bay we have the mayor, Tom, I think is his name, and he’s basically the mayor from Jaws, where he’s super obsessed with having the town make money, and the beaches are staying open despite all the spooky foreshadowing, and he is really disdainful of anyone else’s problems, ’cause he only cares about himself. And man, what a surprisingly interesting character, because so many bad things happen to him, and it’s just fun to watch. Chris: Yeah, that can happen. I definitely think, again, there’s a number of tactics that people use. So bad things happen to him, and we can kind of enjoy that because he’s not a very good person. Humor tends to help. I think a lot of stories that have really flawed protagonists use humor as an important tactic to sort of diffuse the unpleasantness of the situation. Because again, if you just have bad things happening to a bad person, and that’s your story, it can just be really miserable. But if it’s funny, then it adds a much lighter mood, and I think really helps. Widow’s Bay in particular is often pretty funny. We do the whole thing where we’ve got a small town full of very quirky people who are themselves often very flawed, but it’s intended to be funny, and it works pretty well. That is quite an amusing show. Oren: And then of course, “Widow’s Bay” also balances out Loftis [Tom Loftis, main character in Widow’s Bay] a little bit because at the end of the day, despite how dismissive and snooty he is, his goal is actually important for everybody. Town infrastructure doesn’t pay for itself. The town needs revenue. So, you can sympathize with him, and then of course he starts trying to save the town once he realizes that the spooky magic is real. At that point he becomes a lot more likable. But even before that, once he’s taken enough lumps, then you’re like, “Okay, yeah, I mean, you’re a jerk, but you kind of paid for it, and also you do have a goal that I sort of sympathize with. Yeah, all right, Loftis, I guess you’re okay. You’re okay in my book, Loftis.” And then, of course, you could go the Eleanor Shellstrop route from The Good Place, which is a whole elaborate song and dance number to make it okay that this main character who abused old people is actually your favorite. And I admire them, honestly. Hats off that they managed to do that. Chris: Again, we have unnamed old people who are off-screen that she was defrauding. We see the call center that she worked at, but we don’t see any of the actual people that she harmed. The one time we see a person that she harmed, we make sure that this person is also somebody that we hate. So she has a roommate who is just the worst, and therefore when she does a bad thing to her roommate, we don’t get frustrated because we kind of wanna see her do the bad thing to the roommate that we hate, and we can cheer for that even though it’s bad. The other tactic. All of the tools are used here. The fact that in The Good Place she is actually being punished, even in the very beginning she’s like, “Oh no, something bad could happen to me,” and she’s really stressed out about facing the consequences for her bad life. So when we see her backed into a corner and in a really bad place, that kind of mitigates, we’re kind of balancing that bad karma that she’s gotten and generating some sympathy for her, and be like, “Okay, yeah, she’s already been punished, so we don’t have to resent her anymore.” All of those tactics are what helps make Eleanor just a really character that we can root for despite the fact that she’s kind of an awful person at first. Oren: And so far we’ve been looking at characters whose flaws are, for the most part, pretty loud and proud, but there are also ways you can have characters who have more sympathetic flaws. Like, also from The Good Place, Chidi has really bad indecision. He’s so bad at making choices. And this isn’t a problem at first because we’re much more focused on Eleanor, and Chidi is trying to teach her ethics, and we don’t discover just how bad Chidi is at choosing things and how that hurts people around him until much later in the show when we like Chidi a lot by then, but, like, this is also a more sympathetic flaw because we know that he’s trying to fix it and he just can’t. So that is another option of course. Chris: And again, the way that you frame it, so if it’s something that we’re really invested in a certain outcome and Chidi’s indecisiveness is blocking that, we could always get frustrated. But when we have a flashback to when he was alive, and he hurt a friend through his bad Kantian ethics, that’s not a situation that we’re particularly invested in, so we don’t have the same level of emotional response to that. Whereas if you have, we talked about the character that’s too nice, or somebody who’s reckless or irresponsible, if we’re really invested in their success and they just completely drop the ball in a really obvious way, that’s gonna be much harder to deal with. Another thing that I wanna mention, ’cause you asked about, “could we do this in writing versus can we doing it when we have a charismatic actor?” Obviously, it’s nice when there’s a charismatic actor to add some nuance to dialogue lines, whereas in text we kind of have to set the tone, and it’s hard to take that balance there. But one thing that you can watch out for is sometimes when you have a really unpleasant protagonist, you just wanna minimize how much internal narration you have. That would be the narration that reflects their thoughts and feelings. This is not a tactic that you would want to normally use. Most of the time we want our audience to be as close to our protagonist as possible and get really familiar with them, because that tends to build attachment to them and build emotional investment. But if you have a protagonist who’s just really unpleasant, or it can happen if your protagonist tends to pontificate a lot inside, or beat themself up, or has a very negative viewpoint, who’s judging people, complaining, thinking about how much they hate themself, any lots of negativity, if you have a lot of internal narration where you’re reflecting that negativity, that becomes much more unpleasant. So sometimes with a character like that, it’s helpful to just draw back and try to put less of their thoughts in. That’s one thing that you can look out for. Oren: It’s been interesting to read The Tainted Cup books because, you know, that’s a Sherlock and Watson concept. Ana is the Sherlock stand-in, and she’s doing the thing that’s very popular for Sherlock and has been to a certain extent since the original stories where Sherlock is really mean to everybody, but it’s okay because he’s smarter than everyone. And I for one just think it’s cool that women are allowed to do that now. It used to be only male characters could get away with that, so #feminism. Chris: That’s one thing I wanted to bring up earlier is, like, right now we’re assuming- That we’ve got a thorough endorsement for the fact that this character is flawed and should be better, and is kind of a miserable person. Whereas in some stories, it’s like the character is a jerk, but it’s meant for empowerment, where the audience is meant to be like, “Yeah, because I actually would like to be a jerk to people. I would like the freedom to be a jerk, and so I will like this character who’s a jerk.” And that one is kind of a different case. This is the Rick and Morty thing. Oren: Is that a flaw exactly? I don’t know. The story’s not really treating it like one, but of course in real life would be a flaw. And so you get all kinds of people who are very confused who are like, “You’re not supposed to want to be like Rick.” I’m like, “Am I not? The show’s doing a weird thing if I’m not supposed to wanna be like Rick.” Chris: But I think Ana in the Ana-Din books are kind of similar, where we’re kind of doing the winky thing where, yeah, she’s technically she’s flawed, but she’s not. She’s never wrong about anything, always gets everything right. She solves Din’s problems for him. I’m have not gotten to the third book yet. I’m going to soon, but in the first two books… I hope it changes for the third book, I really like this series, but in the first two books she always solves all of Din’s problems for him. And so even though she says things like, “Oh, you know, you don’t want a, a super cool superhuman person to be ruling over the rest of us,” what we’re shown is actually that would be good because she’s always perfect, even if she eats gross oysters Oren: She does like to eat gross oysters. That is true. Chris: One other thing you can think about in terms of managing a protagonist people might not like and who is really flawed is what is the right level of stakes to have? So if you have really high stakes, that does make it easier to care about a plot even if the protagonist is a jerk. We may not care if, for instance, Carol in Pluribus was miserable. I mean, I don’t care that much if she’s miserable. But if she was trying to save humanity and we felt like she has an actual chance of her doing so, then we could still be invested in that even if she’s kind of a bad person. On the other hand, if this is a character who’s gonna bumble their problem-solving and could be very frustrating, then it’s usually better to have lower stakes and kind of lower investment in those plot outcomes so that people are less frustrated when the character just doesn’t do very well. So Carol so far has been… We’ve definitely seen scenes where she is self-sabotaging. She gets together to meet other people who are like her, the few other people on Earth, and she’s extremely bad at talking to them. Oren: Yeah, that’s probably my most hated scene in the show so far. Not for Carol reasons. I just don’t believe that everyone else is so blasé about this. Chris: It’s definitely contrived, yeah. Oren: Yeah. I, I find that extremely unlikely. But anyway, that’s not about Carol. Chris: I don’t actually think it’s possible for her to save humanity from this hive mind, if she messes that up, it’s not as frustrating as it would be because we don’t really have much in the way of stakes. It’s more does she have other human beings that she can connect to? So that’s just one thing to think about in terms of when you have a character who’s unpleasant. Are they gonna be frustrating? Is it better to have higher stakes and more plot investment, or lower stakes so that we’re not as frustrated? Oren: All right. Well, now we will finally resolve our flaw of keeping the podcast going for too long. Aha! Chris: I know we seem like bad people, but if you just hang in there, you can change us. Just become a patron. Go to patreon.com/mythcreants. Oren: Twist: any form of success makes us even worse. So now I wanna thank a couple of our existing patrons. First, there’s Ayman Jaber. He’s an urban fantasy writer and a connoisseur of Marvel. Then there’s Kathy Ferguson, who’s a professor of political theory in Star Trek. We will talk to you next week.

0:00Duration unknown

transcript

No transcript — this publisher did not publish one.

show notes

We’ve all heard advice about creating flaws for our characters, but what does that mean in practice? This week, we’re talking about flawed protagonists! We discuss the factors that make some flawed characters compelling while others are reduced to being unpleasant. We also get into the ways flaws can be tricky to manage and why we believe adding a laundry list of them is a little excessive.

Show Notes

Transcript

Generously transcribed by Albert Gallego. Volunteer to transcribe a podcast.

Chris: Welcome to the Mythcreant Podcast. I’m Chris. 

Oren: And I’m Oren. 

Chris: Now, we might seem like nice people on the podcast, but maybe as soon as we stop recording, we rant about how our podcast is trash and everyone who listens to it has terrible taste. And then when we get fan mail, we write back telling that person to get a life. Also, I should say I’m secretly writing a literary genre novel. That’s my true passion, despite what I tell everyone. 

Oren: It’s funny because, normally, the trope of doing that is writers do that with books that make them tons of money, but they hate ’cause, you know, making money is bad, actually. But our podcast doesn’t make us any money. [Chris laughs]

That would be extra funny if we had a character who’s like, “Yeah, I’m writing these completely unsuccessful books that nobody buys, and they’re secretly trash… and everyone who reads them is stupid.” We should do that. Some people insist that you can’t ever have too many flaws, so I think we should do that, have a character whose flaw here is both that they’re really judgmental and also just incredibly bad at deciding what they should spend their time on.

Chris: I’m also addicted to podcasting. That’s why I do it, even though I don’t like it, and also it’s not very popular and not earning me very much money. I said that because we’re watching Pluribus right now. 

Oren: Yeah. Plur- [they both mumble]. 

Chris: Plur- whatever. It’s Pluribus. 

Oren: It’s hard to look up posts about that because pluribus is a very commonly used Latin phrase, and it’s in an important U.S. motto. And so whenever I look it up, that’s what comes up. So it’s been hard to find actual commentary on that show, despite how popular it was. 

Chris: That’s a naming mistake, for sure. Gotta have a trademark-able, extra unique name. No, that’s a bad idea. So any case, this time we’re covering flawed protagonists because sometimes writers wanna write about people who are messed up. There’s lots to say about people who are messed up, and some people find them very novel and interesting or just find them relatable or empathize with their flaws. There are lots of reasons to wanna do this, even though it is tricky and can create problems. 

Oren: My favorite is when the flaw is only kind of a flaw. It’s like a little wink to the audience. We’ve been referencing the first episode of Pluribus in which our author main character thinks everyone who reads her books is a brain-dead walnut, and has no respect for them. And yeah we could say that’s a flaw, and maybe that’s part of a character arc. I’ve only seen the first three episodes, I don’t know. Fans tell me it’s part of a character arc, so we’ll see. But regardless of whether it is or not, a lot of people also feel that way, and the show is kind of winking at them, and they’re like, “Yeah, romantasy fans are brain-dead walnuts and are total trash.” So it validates them, and then we can do a little bit of an arc later if we want, and it’s no big deal. 

Chris: Turns out the flawed protagonist was the audience all along. 

Oren: Yeah, exactly. And so it works really well that way. I don’t really love that it does, but it does. You know, it would’ve worked on me if she had been writing a literary novel that everyone loved, and then she’d been like, “Uh, actually, literary fans are all snobs and, you know, don’t actually know what a good story is and can be tricked by just being told that the story is deep and meaningful.” That would work on me. I’d be like, “Yeah, okay, that’s a flaw, but also that’s- she’s so right.” [Chris laughs] So it’s just a matter of knowing who you’re appealing to, you know? 

Chris: I mean, that is one strategy for dealing with frustration. This is one of the issues that can happen with a flawed protagonist is, if they’re flawed in a way that makes it so they create problems for themselves or others or are bad at dealing with problems and you’ve got the audience invested in those problems and solving those problems as usually you would want to… it can be very frustrating. But one way to get around that is to just make them do bad things or sabotage themselves or others in ways that the audience can actually root for, and this would be kind of an example of that technique. It’s kind of a niche technique, but especially if this is something like getting revenge, maybe getting revenge isn’t productive, but if you make a villain hated enough, the audience is gonna be like, “Yeah, but it would be really nice just to see this person gets what’s coming to them.” So even though this is self-destructive, I can probably root for it anyway ’cause I get something out of it. You could have something like that happen. 

Oren: Of course, when it comes to flaws, we should acknowledge that there is a lot of misconception about them. That’s why if you go into any writing space, you will find a bunch of posts about how characters need flaws and how if a character doesn’t have flaws, that’s bad. You will hear the term Mary Sue thrown around a lot. And of course, in reality, many heroes do not have anything that would be realistically considered a flaw. What that discourse is usually actually getting at is whether or not they have too much candy, which is different. Like, Frodo doesn’t have too much candy, but he’s not really flawed in any meaningful way, not in a dramatic way. And I don’t think he would be a better character if he was. Someone like Othello is flawed, but Frodo’s not. Frodo’s just doing his best. 

Chris: And again, character arcs don’t require flaws either because… if a character, for instance, is grieving, I would not call that a flaw. That would be weird and judgmental. But they’re, of course they’re grieving, so it’s natural that they’re unhappy and having problems, and as part of their character arc, they can heal. But I certainly wouldn’t say they have a flaw that they have to overcome. 

Again, flaws, not really necessary, but writers like them for a variety of reasons. We can talk about what we would classify as a flaw, which is something that this person would be better if they did not have this trait. 

Oren: This would be a better person, and I mean that in the real-life sense, if they did not have that. Something like greedy or selfish or cowardly or judgemental. You know, these are things where they go beyond what might be a healthy version of that feeling. Like, there’s actually a place for judging people. You don’t wanna just completely take everything you see at face value. At that point, you might have a flaw of being too credulous. But obviously you can be too much of that, at which point we start calling them judgemental, and at that point it becomes a flaw.

With cowardly, it’s like, okay, if your character is scared of something that is dangerous, that’s not cowardly. Or if they run away from something that they can’t possibly defeat, that’s also not cowardly. But if they run away from something that they could probably have overcome if they had actually stayed to fight, you could say that’s cowardice, and you could say that’s a flaw to overcome.

Chris: And again, it doesn’t have to be something that makes them a jerk. I was just reading Stay for a Spell, and the character’s flaw is supposed to be that she’s too nice, and it’s a problem because she ends up doing what other people want instead of doing what she wants. Those kinds of meek characters… I like them, but again, with any flaw, it can turn people against a character. So that is one that could create frustration, right? If you have a character who is nice and lets other people walk all over them, that’s a situation where the reader could be invested in them solving their problems, and get frustrated when they just let people walk over them instead. 

As opposed to a quirk, which is what we call it when they have a trait that sometimes benefits them and sometimes disadvantages them. Quirks are great ’cause they tend to add a lot of interest. But you don’t feel like the quirk has to be eliminated. You don’t feel like it’s something that has to be a problem that has to be solved. It’s just a permanent interesting feature of the character that can create setbacks and advantages.

Oren: And we usually find it works best to focus on one flaw, especially at a time. ‘Cause if your character has a bunch of flaws, actual flaws as we’re describing them, that increases the chance significantly that your readers are just going to hate them and not want to read about them. But also it de-emphasizes the impact of any one flaw because you got all of them, so they just kind of become noise after a while.

I’ll never forget frigging “Save the Cat! Writes a Novel” recommending a laundry list of flaws, and… what are you talking about? 

Chris: That’s a bad idea. 

Oren: It’s especially funny after using Katniss Everdeen as an example in the beginning of Hunger Games. Like, she’s supposed to be flawed, and by flawed, you mean she’s a little grouchy? Is that a flaw? Wow, that’s, like, such a shallow definition of a flaw. 

Chris: I won’t say that you can never do more than one flaw because sometimes they can be kind of related to each other or connected together. But what does happen, and I’ve seen this in many works, is that when you have too many, it really muddies the waters when it comes to the character arc. It just becomes really unclear what their problem is, and what they need to learn, and then what the solution is, and when they have actually made progress… because we’re juggling too many things, and they tend to blur together. 

There’s just so much subjectivity, when it comes to a character’s personality and their emotional state, that we do have to focus on “Okay, what exactly is the issue here?” And if we have, like, five flaws, it’s really easy for those to blend into each other, and it just becomes, “wait, I don’t understand. What, what is their flaw? What do they need to learn?” And also, we’re not gonna be able to follow up on that many character arcs in the same book. That’s gonna be too much.

Similarly, we don’t want a flaw that’s super broad. Like immaturity, for instance, or selfishness are both flaws that can mean any number of behaviors. 

Oren: Yeah, you’d wanna zoom in a little bit. 

Chris: And that also just makes it really hard to deal with, whereas if we can pinpoint more specifically in what situations is this character immature, and how exactly do they act, or in what ways is this person selfish, and in what situations, and in what ways do they behave in a way that is self-centered, then it’s easier to address that and give that clarity, etcetera.

Oren: Say what we want about Pluribus, I do think it’s pretty impressive, especially in the early episodes, which is again, that’s what I’ve seen. They manage to give the protagonist, Carol, three pretty distinct flaws that so far haven’t really blurred together, which is always the concern. ‘Cause the first thing is that she is really disdainful of her readers, and again, that’s like a secret wink to the audience flaw, where a lot of the audience feels the same way, so you know, the impact is lessened.

Then she has serious anger problems, and then she’s also an alcoholic. And part of the way that they balance that is that her being an alcoholic doesn’t play a big role in these early episodes. It’s there, you can see it in the background, but it’s not brought to the fore the way her other flaws are. And then in the second and third episode, we focus much more on the anger problem because now if she gets too mad at the uwu murder virus hive mind, a bunch of people will die, so that’s a struggle that she has to try to keep it in check. And that one’s very sympathetic because the evil uwu murder virus hive mind is the most annoying thing anyone has ever invented. [Chris laughs]

So when she gets mad at it, I’m like, “Yes, it deserves for you to be mad at it. It’s the worst.” But she has to try not to because she doesn’t want to be responsible for people dying. 

Chris: I do have a little bit of frustration when she thinks of it as her fault when people die. Yes, you should learn to control your temper. That’s a good idea, but they’re the ones who decided to infect the entire planet with a virus where people would die if you got mad at them. That was their choice. That was their doing. Also, in doing that, they killed far more people than she does when she gets angry at them. So I don’t know… I get annoyed with that because when somebody brings up that it’s her fault and then she just accepts that, definitely feels like there’s authorial endorsement at that point, that we’re supposed to believe that it’s her fault that people get hurt when she gets angry. But it’s, it’s not her fault. 

Oren: Yeah, I mean, it’s hard for me to say at this point, ’cause again, this is a show that likes to keep its cards close to its chest, and at only three episodes I don’t really know where it’s going, and I don’t trust anything anyone says about this show. [Chris Laughs] Because I’ve seen how unhinged the discourse about it is.

Chris: Yeah. We’ve had so many instances where we’ll say something on our blog, and then somebody will be like, “Oh, but this book,…” in the comments. And if we have actually read that book, it is very often misrepresenting the story. And so now we just don’t trust what anybody says about any story ever until we go read it ourselves.

Oren: I will say, I don’t like Pluribus. I find it really boring most of the time. But I do find it believable that she thinks that it’s her fault, because she’s basically being constantly gaslit by everyone around her, both the hive mind and the other humans. To me it’s believable that she thinks that because she’s been bludgeoned into it. I don’t enjoy that. It’s not a show I would watch if I didn’t have a blog to talk about it on, but  it’s interesting. It’s kind of neat to see. 

Chris: Yeah, I do think, find it very hard when you have an unpleasant protagonist who bad things are happening to them. That is typically something that I do not enjoy seeing. At the same time, and we should talk about this more, we can talk about Widow’s Bay, one of the strategies for dealing with a protagonist who audiences just find them unpleasant and don’t really like them is to just have bad things happen to them because we get schadenfreude. We get satisfaction at seeing them punished for their bad karma.

And I will say with Pluribus, Carol is, as far as I can tell, just a very unpleasant person, and the Pluribus hive mind is a very unpleasant being. And so I’m just watching them make each other miserable

Oren: Yep. 

Chris: And also in many of these cases, the stakes seem relatively low, right? If there was another innocent person for them to hurt while they were going back and forth with each other, but I do get some amusement from that.

Oren: Oh man, Widow’s Bay. This is so… Such a cool thing. I hope you could do this in book form. So in Widow’s Bay we have the mayor, Tom, I think is his name, and he’s basically the mayor from Jaws, where he’s super obsessed with having the town make money, and the beaches are staying open despite all the spooky foreshadowing, and he is really disdainful of anyone else’s problems, ’cause he only cares about himself. And man, what a surprisingly interesting character, because so many bad things happen to him, and it’s just fun to watch. 

Chris: Yeah, that can happen. I definitely think, again, there’s a number of tactics that people use. So bad things happen to him, and we can kind of enjoy that because he’s not a very good person. Humor tends to help. I think a lot of stories that have really flawed protagonists use humor as an important tactic to sort of diffuse the unpleasantness of the situation. Because again, if you just have bad things happening to a bad person, and that’s your story, it can just be really miserable. But if it’s funny, then it adds a much lighter mood, and I think really helps.

Widow’s Bay in particular is often pretty funny. We do the whole thing where we’ve got a small town full of very quirky people who are themselves often very flawed, but it’s intended to be funny, and it works pretty well. That is quite an amusing show. 

Oren: And then of course, “Widow’s Bay” also balances out Loftis [Tom Loftis, main character in Widow’s Bay] a little bit because at the end of the day, despite how dismissive and snooty he is, his goal is actually important for everybody. Town infrastructure doesn’t pay for itself. The town needs revenue. So, you can sympathize with him, and then of course he starts trying to save the town once he realizes that the spooky magic is real. At that point he becomes a lot more likable. But even before that, once he’s taken enough lumps, then you’re like, “Okay, yeah, I mean, you’re a jerk, but you kind of paid for it, and also you do have a goal that I sort of sympathize with. Yeah, all right, Loftis, I guess you’re okay. You’re okay in my book, Loftis.” And then, of course, you could go the Eleanor Shellstrop route from The Good Place, which is a whole elaborate song and dance number to make it okay that this main character who abused old people is actually your favorite. And I admire them, honestly. Hats off that they managed to do that. 

Chris: Again, we have unnamed old people who are off-screen that she was defrauding. We see the call center that she worked at, but we don’t see any of the actual people that she harmed. The one time we see a person that she harmed, we make sure that this person is also somebody that we hate. So she has a roommate who is just the worst, and therefore when she does a bad thing to her roommate, we don’t get frustrated because we kind of wanna see her do the bad thing to the roommate that we hate, and we can cheer for that even though it’s bad. The other tactic. All of the tools are used here.

The fact that in The Good Place she is actually being punished, even in the very beginning she’s like, “Oh no, something bad could happen to me,” and she’s really stressed out about facing the consequences for her bad life. So when we see her backed into a corner and in a really bad place, that kind of mitigates, we’re kind of balancing that bad karma that she’s gotten and generating some sympathy for her, and be like, “Okay, yeah, she’s already been punished, so we don’t have to resent her anymore.” All of those tactics are what helps make Eleanor just a really character that we can root for despite the fact that she’s kind of an awful person at first. 

Oren: And so far we’ve been looking at characters whose flaws are, for the most part, pretty loud and proud, but there are also ways you can have characters who have more sympathetic flaws. Like, also from The Good Place, Chidi has really bad indecision. He’s so bad at making choices. And this isn’t a problem at first because we’re much more focused on Eleanor, and Chidi is trying to teach her ethics, and we don’t discover just how bad Chidi is at choosing things and how that hurts people around him until much later in the show when we like Chidi a lot by then, but, like, this is also a more sympathetic flaw because we know that he’s trying to fix it and he just can’t. So that is another option of course. 

Chris: And again, the way that you frame it, so if it’s something that we’re really invested in a certain outcome and Chidi’s indecisiveness is blocking that, we could always get frustrated. But when we have a flashback to when he was alive, and he hurt a friend through his bad Kantian ethics, that’s not a situation that we’re particularly invested in, so we don’t have the same level of emotional response to that. Whereas if you have, we talked about the character that’s too nice, or somebody who’s reckless or irresponsible, if we’re really invested in their success and they just completely drop the ball in a really obvious way, that’s gonna be much harder to deal with.

Another thing that I wanna mention, ’cause you asked about, “could we do this in writing versus can we doing it when we have a charismatic actor?” Obviously, it’s nice when there’s a charismatic actor to add some nuance to dialogue lines, whereas in text we kind of have to set the tone, and it’s hard to take that balance there. But one thing that you can watch out for is sometimes when you have a really unpleasant protagonist, you just wanna minimize how much internal narration you have. That would be the narration that reflects their thoughts and feelings. This is not a tactic that you would want to normally use. Most of the time we want our audience to be as close to our protagonist as possible and get really familiar with them, because that tends to build attachment to them and build emotional investment.

But if you have a protagonist who’s just really unpleasant, or it can happen if your protagonist tends to pontificate a lot inside, or beat themself up, or has a very negative viewpoint, who’s judging people, complaining, thinking about how much they hate themself, any lots of negativity, if you have a lot of internal narration where you’re reflecting that negativity, that becomes much more unpleasant. So sometimes with a character like that, it’s helpful to just draw back and try to put less of their thoughts in. That’s one thing that you can look out for. 

Oren: It’s been interesting to read The Tainted Cup books because, you know, that’s a Sherlock and Watson concept. Ana is the Sherlock stand-in, and she’s doing the thing that’s very popular for Sherlock and has been to a certain extent since the original stories where Sherlock is really mean to everybody, but it’s okay because he’s smarter than everyone.

And I for one just think it’s cool that women are allowed to do that now. It used to be only male characters could get away with that, so #feminism. 

Chris: That’s one thing I wanted to bring up earlier is, like, right now we’re assuming- That we’ve got a thorough endorsement for the fact that this character is flawed and should be better, and is kind of a miserable person. Whereas in some stories, it’s like the character is a jerk, but it’s meant for empowerment, where the audience is meant to be like, “Yeah, because I actually would like to be a jerk to people. I would like the freedom to be a jerk, and so I will like this character who’s a jerk.” And that one is kind of a different case. This is the Rick and Morty thing.

Oren: Is that a flaw exactly? I don’t know. The story’s not really treating it like one, but of course in real life would be a flaw. And so you get all kinds of people who are very confused who are like, “You’re not supposed to want to be like Rick.” I’m like, “Am I not? The show’s doing a weird thing if I’m not supposed to wanna be like Rick.” 

Chris: But I think Ana in the Ana-Din books are kind of similar, where we’re kind of doing the winky thing where, yeah, she’s technically she’s flawed, but she’s not. She’s never wrong about anything, always gets everything right. She solves Din’s problems for him.

I’m have not gotten to the third book yet. I’m going to soon, but in the first two books… I hope it changes for the third book, I really like this series, but in the first two books she always solves all of Din’s problems for him. And so even though she says things like, “Oh, you know, you don’t want a, a super cool superhuman person to be ruling over the rest of us,” what we’re shown is actually that would be good because she’s always perfect, even if she eats gross oysters 

Oren: She does like to eat gross oysters. That is true. 

Chris: One other thing you can think about in terms of managing a protagonist people might not like and who is really flawed is what is the right level of stakes to have? So if you have really high stakes, that does make it easier to care about a plot even if the protagonist is a jerk. We may not care if, for instance, Carol in Pluribus was miserable. I mean, I don’t care that much if she’s miserable. But if she was trying to save humanity and we felt like she has an actual chance of her doing so, then we could still be invested in that even if she’s kind of a bad person. On the other hand, if this is a character who’s gonna bumble their problem-solving and could be very frustrating, then it’s usually better to have lower stakes and kind of lower investment in those plot outcomes so that people are less frustrated when the character just doesn’t do very well.

So Carol so far has been… We’ve definitely seen scenes where she is self-sabotaging. She gets together to meet other people who are like her, the few other people on Earth, and she’s extremely bad at talking to them. 

Oren: Yeah, that’s probably my most hated scene in the show so far. Not for Carol reasons. I just don’t believe that everyone else is so blasé about this.

Chris: It’s definitely contrived, yeah.

Oren: Yeah. I, I find that extremely unlikely. But anyway, that’s not about Carol. 

Chris: I don’t actually think it’s possible for her to save humanity from this hive mind, if she messes that up, it’s not as frustrating as it would be because we don’t really have much in the way of stakes. It’s more does she have other human beings that she can connect to? So that’s just one thing to think about in terms of when you have a character who’s unpleasant. Are they gonna be frustrating? Is it better to have higher stakes and more plot investment, or lower stakes so that we’re not as frustrated?

Oren: All right. Well, now we will finally resolve our flaw of keeping the podcast going for too long. Aha!

Chris: I know we seem like bad people, but if you just hang in there, you can change us. Just become a patron. Go to patreon.com/mythcreants. 

Oren: Twist: any form of success makes us even worse. 

So now I wanna thank a couple of our existing patrons.

First, there’s Ayman Jaber. He’s an urban fantasy writer and a connoisseur of Marvel. Then there’s Kathy Ferguson, who’s a professor of political theory in Star Trek. We will talk to you next week.

links22