Skip to content
Artwork for The Mark Casto Program
The Mark Casto Program · September 16 · 1 hr 24 min

When Did Disagreement Become Disowning | Ryan Johnson

A three-letter label is changing how Christians treat each other, and it is bleeding from social media straight into local church life. Mark Casto sits down with itinerant minister and author Ryan Johnson to talk about the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR) narrative, why “lists” and guilt by association are so corrosive, and how pastors can lead with clarity when people are afraid and angry. We are not interested in defending a movement or launching an attack. We are trying to let Scripture, context, and truth set the pace. Ryan explains where the term came from, why critics often describe NAR as an organisation even while admitting it is hard to define, and how that confusion turns normal biblical beliefs into “red flags”. We dig into what often gets lumped into the NAR bucket: healing, prophecy, deliverance, revival, spiritual warfare, apostles and prophets, and the idea that the Church should influence culture through faithful gospel presence. The conversation keeps circling back to one question: are we building a Berean culture that tests teaching by the word of God, or a cancel culture that reacts emotionally and calls it discernment? We also talk about Ephesians 4 and why fivefold ministry gifts are meant to equip the saints and move the body toward unity and maturity, not toward celebrity, control, or suspicion. For leaders facing NAR accusations, Ryan offers practical next steps: slow down, respond rather than react, ask for evidence, open the Bible together, and refuse to let preference become “truth”. If you want to connect with Ryan, find his books, and join his Tuesday email, visit RyanJohnson.us. Subscribe, share this with a pastor or ministry friend, and leave a review with your biggest takeaway. Support the show Renew card: https://markcasto.co/renew Shepherd’s Tent and the Weekly Leader Call: https://connect.theshepherdstent.com/leaders-call The Lion Was Always the Lamb tee: https://markcasto.myshopify.com/products/the-lion-was-always-the-lamb-tee UNVEILED ebook (free): https://markcasto.co/unveiled Become a Partner: https://markcasto.co/donate/ Care line (a phone number, not a link): Focus on the Family 1-855-771-HELP (4357); in crisis, call or text 988.

0:00 · Charged Topic And Leadership Stakes-1:24:17

transcript

No transcript — this publisher did not publish one.

show notes

A three-letter label is changing how Christians treat each other, and it is bleeding from social media straight into local church life. Mark Casto sits down with itinerant minister and author Ryan Johnson to talk about the New Apostolic Reformation (NAR) narrative, why “lists” and guilt by association are so corrosive, and how pastors can lead with clarity when people are afraid and angry. We are not interested in defending a movement or launching an attack. We are trying to let Scripture, context, and truth set the pace.

Ryan explains where the term came from, why critics often describe NAR as an organisation even while admitting it is hard to define, and how that confusion turns normal biblical beliefs into “red flags”. We dig into what often gets lumped into the NAR bucket: healing, prophecy, deliverance, revival, spiritual warfare, apostles and prophets, and the idea that the Church should influence culture through faithful gospel presence. The conversation keeps circling back to one question: are we building a Berean culture that tests teaching by the word of God, or a cancel culture that reacts emotionally and calls it discernment?

We also talk about Ephesians 4 and why fivefold ministry gifts are meant to equip the saints and move the body toward unity and maturity, not toward celebrity, control, or suspicion. For leaders facing NAR accusations, Ryan offers practical next steps: slow down, respond rather than react, ask for evidence, open the Bible together, and refuse to let preference become “truth”. If you want to connect with Ryan, find his books, and join his Tuesday email, visit RyanJohnson.us. Subscribe, share this with a pastor or ministry friend, and leave a review with your biggest takeaway.

Support the show

Renew card: https://markcasto.co/renew


Shepherd’s Tent and the Weekly Leader Call: https://connect.theshepherdstent.com/leaders-call


The Lion Was Always the Lamb tee: https://markcasto.myshopify.com/products/the-lion-was-always-the-lamb-tee


UNVEILED ebook (free): https://markcasto.co/unveiled


Become a Partner: https://markcasto.co/donate/


Care line (a phone number, not a link): Focus on the Family 1-855-771-HELP (4357); in crisis, call or text 988.

links6

chapters

15 chapters