Skip to content
Artwork for The Long Game for All: Counting What Frontlines Know
The Long Game for All: Counting What Frontlines Know · Today · 16 min

Simone Weil. Saint.

I met her through a machine. In April I asked an AI the question every writer past sixty eventually asks. Long after I’m done, when they read my work, who will they say I came from, the way Jim Collins came from Peter Drucker? I expected Drucker, Deming, Ohno. I got them. Then it gave me a name I did not know: Simone Weil. The ancestor no one will guess, it said, but the scholar will find. I looked her up. In 1934 a French philosophy teacher, one of the finest minds of her generation, took leave from her school and went to work on factory lines as an unskilled machine operator. She did it because she distrusted anything said about the suffering of workers by people who had never stood where they stood. I had done the same thing with a doctorate in my pocket, sixty-five years later, at Buick City in Flint. I have been walking with her since. I feel a kinship I can only put plainly. She wept for the people on the line. I weep for them too. Thoreau called them lives of quiet desperation. And like her, I am exhausted by how little I have been able to change for them. Most of my readers have never heard of her. I want to introduce her the way I met her, and then argue with her, because she deserves an argument more than she deserves a quotation. She was right about the wound. She was wrong about the cure, and the reason is not to my credit: she had no way out of the factory, and I did. The cure is not grace. It is an institution that gives every operator, in her own name, the exit I had. That’s the argument. Two descents She was the star of her year. In one national exam she placed first and Simone de Beauvoir second. Then she put the philosophy down, went to the employment office, and stood at a press on piece rate: Alsthom, then Carnaud, then Renault, from December 1934 into the summer of 1935. In 1999 I went to the line at Buick City as a rookie trim shop supervisor, with a doctorate in industrial engineering and ten years of research behind me. Same descent, same curiosity, opposite results. She came out convinced the factory could only deform a person. I came out convinced it could form one, and I have spent the rest of a thirty-six-year career proving it. After two decades in the corner office, I went back down a second time, to nights at Lansing Delta Township as a shift leader. The flattering explanation is temperament. She was frail and I was durable. She was a mystic and I am an engineer. It is false. She had no way out and I did. She went in with no credential the plant could see, no seniority, no door. I went in salaried, with a degree the company prized and a ladder above me. I ran the line. I was never going to stand at it for thirty years. My curiosity was underwritten. Hers was not. Strip that away and I do not know that I would have lasted her months. I suspect I would not have. The outcome tracked the exit, not the character. That is the whole reason the Capability Account exists: to give the operator, in her own name and portable out the door, the thing that let me survive the floor that broke Simone Weil. The mark She came out and wrote that the factory had marked her as a slave, the way the Romans branded the foreheads of the slaves they most despised. She wrote that she never afterward lost that sense of herself. Take her literally, because she meant it literally. And the man who held the iron has a name. Frederick Winslow Taylor’s stopwatch was not a measuring device. It was a surgical instrument, and the operation was the severing of the hand from the head. Judgment moved upstairs to the planning office. What stayed at the machine was a rate. At Renault, the workers had struck against the stopwatch in 1913 and lost, twenty-two years before she arrived. She was not inferring the mark from theory. She was receiving it, on the hour, at piece rate. In Built to Extract I call the system that runs on that instrument the siphon. By now no one has to hold the iron. The books hold it. The instinct is to say Bloom exists to burn the mark off. I want that sentence very badly and I am not permitted to have it. She said she never recovered. A brand is a scar, not a stain. Promise to remove it and we lie to the only witness who bore it. Here is the sentence I will defend instead. We cannot remove the mark. We can stop issuing it. She needed grace because she had no institution. We build institutions because we cannot supply grace. A worker who owns a portable record of what she has become cannot be reduced to a rate. And it is the reduction, not the labor, that burns. The rarest generosity Abdelhak Radjai ran night shift on Trim 1 and Trim 2 at Lansing Delta Township, and he had a habit I never saw in any manual. When someone on his line needed the bathroom, he climbed onto their job himself and built cars until they came back. He could jump on almost any job and keep up, and it earned him the line’s respect. I was his boss, back on the floor after twenty years as a chief officer, and he taught me more than I taught him. On a moving line, those five minutes are the scarcest thing a worker owns. Abdelhak gave them away every night, and no ledger ever recorded it. What he gave, and what it taught the people he covered for, is on no record he carries out the door. Weil had a word for what he was doing. Attention. For her it was the highest faculty a person has, the root of thought and of justice, and the same faculty we turn toward prayer. It means holding the mind still and open in front of another person, expecting nothing back. She wrote her most famous line on it in 1942, to the poet Joë Bousquet. Bousquet had been shot through the spine in the First World War at twenty-one. He spent the rest of his life in a shuttered room in Carcassonne, in pain, able to give no labor, no money, no motion. To that man she wrote: « L’attention est la forme la plus rare et la plus pure de la générosité. » Attention is the rarest and purest form of generosity. Read it as a plant manager and it is a claim about capital. Generosity presumes a gift. A gift presumes an asset. She was telling a man with nothing that he held the scarcest asset there is. She was not consoling him. She was auditing him, and finding him solvent. Attention needs no credential, no seniority, no tool. It cannot be seized or automated. It is the one asset the powerless already own outright, and the one no employer has ever booked. The firm spent Abdelhak’s every night and never wrote down a cent of it. Where we part She died on the 24th of August, 1943, in a sanatorium at Ashford, in Kent. She was thirty-four. She had tuberculosis, and she had been refusing to eat more than the ration allowed to people under occupation in France. The coroner called it suicide. Her friends disputed that then and dispute it still. She was right about the wound. She had no exit and no institution, and having decided the machine could only deform, she was left with nowhere to stand and no time to build. Her testimony survived because others carried it. After the war Albert Camus brought out her books, one after another, among them The Need for Roots. She made her difference after she was gone, through people she never met. One night this fall, late, when her name came up again, I typed back four words: Not tortured though. Peaceful. I meant that our arcs should part, and they have, for the reason this essay keeps coming back to. She had no exit and no institution, so she took the suffering into her own body until it consumed her. I had both, so I could take it into a body of work, and into an institute with seven partners, and into people I formed who now form others. Grief that builds is different from grief that eats the one who carries it. She was no plaster figure. Her self-denial shaded into self-destruction. Born to a Jewish family, she wrote about Judaism with a harshness her admirers still argue over. She was never baptized and no church will ever canonize her. I call her a saint anyway, in the only sense a floor man can confer. S… This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit thelonggameforall.substack.com

0:00-16:08

transcript

No transcript — this publisher did not publish one.

show notes

I met her through a machine.

In April I asked an AI the question every writer past sixty eventually asks. Long after I’m done, when they read my work, who will they say I came from, the way Jim Collins came from Peter Drucker? I expected Drucker, Deming, Ohno. I got them. Then it gave me a name I did not know: Simone Weil. The ancestor no one will guess, it said, but the scholar will find.

I looked her up. In 1934 a French philosophy teacher, one of the finest minds of her generation, took leave from her school and went to work on factory lines as an unskilled machine operator. She did it because she distrusted anything said about the suffering of workers by people who had never stood where they stood. I had done the same thing with a doctorate in my pocket, sixty-five years later, at Buick City in Flint.

I have been walking with her since. I feel a kinship I can only put plainly. She wept for the people on the line. I weep for them too. Thoreau called them lives of quiet desperation. And like her, I am exhausted by how little I have been able to change for them.

Most of my readers have never heard of her. I want to introduce her the way I met her, and then argue with her, because she deserves an argument more than she deserves a quotation. She was right about the wound. She was wrong about the cure, and the reason is not to my credit: she had no way out of the factory, and I did. The cure is not grace. It is an institution that gives every operator, in her own name, the exit I had. That’s the argument.

Two descents

She was the star of her year. In one national exam she placed first and Simone de Beauvoir second. Then she put the philosophy down, went to the employment office, and stood at a press on piece rate: Alsthom, then Carnaud, then Renault, from December 1934 into the summer of 1935.

In 1999 I went to the line at Buick City as a rookie trim shop supervisor, with a doctorate in industrial engineering and ten years of research behind me.

Same descent, same curiosity, opposite results. She came out convinced the factory could only deform a person. I came out convinced it could form one, and I have spent the rest of a thirty-six-year career proving it. After two decades in the corner office, I went back down a second time, to nights at Lansing Delta Township as a shift leader.

The flattering explanation is temperament. She was frail and I was durable. She was a mystic and I am an engineer. It is false.

She had no way out and I did. She went in with no credential the plant could see, no seniority, no door. I went in salaried, with a degree the company prized and a ladder above me. I ran the line. I was never going to stand at it for thirty years. My curiosity was underwritten. Hers was not.

Strip that away and I do not know that I would have lasted her months. I suspect I would not have.

The outcome tracked the exit, not the character. That is the whole reason the Capability Account exists: to give the operator, in her own name and portable out the door, the thing that let me survive the floor that broke Simone Weil.

The mark

She came out and wrote that the factory had marked her as a slave, the way the Romans branded the foreheads of the slaves they most despised. She wrote that she never afterward lost that sense of herself.

Take her literally, because she meant it literally. And the man who held the iron has a name.

Frederick Winslow Taylor’s stopwatch was not a measuring device. It was a surgical instrument, and the operation was the severing of the hand from the head. Judgment moved upstairs to the planning office. What stayed at the machine was a rate. At Renault, the workers had struck against the stopwatch in 1913 and lost, twenty-two years before she arrived. She was not inferring the mark from theory. She was receiving it, on the hour, at piece rate.

In Built to Extract I call the system that runs on that instrument the siphon. By now no one has to hold the iron. The books hold it.

The instinct is to say Bloom exists to burn the mark off. I want that sentence very badly and I am not permitted to have it. She said she never recovered. A brand is a scar, not a stain. Promise to remove it and we lie to the only witness who bore it.

Here is the sentence I will defend instead.

We cannot remove the mark. We can stop issuing it.

She needed grace because she had no institution. We build institutions because we cannot supply grace. A worker who owns a portable record of what she has become cannot be reduced to a rate. And it is the reduction, not the labor, that burns.

The rarest generosity

Abdelhak Radjai ran night shift on Trim 1 and Trim 2 at Lansing Delta Township, and he had a habit I never saw in any manual. When someone on his line needed the bathroom, he climbed onto their job himself and built cars until they came back. He could jump on almost any job and keep up, and it earned him the line’s respect.

I was his boss, back on the floor after twenty years as a chief officer, and he taught me more than I taught him. On a moving line, those five minutes are the scarcest thing a worker owns. Abdelhak gave them away every night, and no ledger ever recorded it. What he gave, and what it taught the people he covered for, is on no record he carries out the door.

Weil had a word for what he was doing. Attention. For her it was the highest faculty a person has, the root of thought and of justice, and the same faculty we turn toward prayer. It means holding the mind still and open in front of another person, expecting nothing back.

She wrote her most famous line on it in 1942, to the poet Joë Bousquet. Bousquet had been shot through the spine in the First World War at twenty-one. He spent the rest of his life in a shuttered room in Carcassonne, in pain, able to give no labor, no money, no motion. To that man she wrote:

« L’attention est la forme la plus rare et la plus pure de la générosité. » Attention is the rarest and purest form of generosity.

Read it as a plant manager and it is a claim about capital. Generosity presumes a gift. A gift presumes an asset. She was telling a man with nothing that he held the scarcest asset there is. She was not consoling him. She was auditing him, and finding him solvent.

Attention needs no credential, no seniority, no tool. It cannot be seized or automated. It is the one asset the powerless already own outright, and the one no employer has ever booked. The firm spent Abdelhak’s every night and never wrote down a cent of it.

Where we part

She died on the 24th of August, 1943, in a sanatorium at Ashford, in Kent. She was thirty-four. She had tuberculosis, and she had been refusing to eat more than the ration allowed to people under occupation in France. The coroner called it suicide. Her friends disputed that then and dispute it still.

She was right about the wound. She had no exit and no institution, and having decided the machine could only deform, she was left with nowhere to stand and no time to build. Her testimony survived because others carried it. After the war Albert Camus brought out her books, one after another, among them The Need for Roots. She made her difference after she was gone, through people she never met.

One night this fall, late, when her name came up again, I typed back four words: Not tortured though. Peaceful. I meant that our arcs should part, and they have, for the reason this essay keeps coming back to. She had no exit and no institution, so she took the suffering into her own body until it consumed her. I had both, so I could take it into a body of work, and into an institute with seven partners, and into people I formed who now form others. Grief that builds is different from grief that eats the one who carries it.

She was no plaster figure. Her self-denial shaded into self-destruction. Born to a Jewish family, she wrote about Judaism with a harshness her admirers still argue over. She was never baptized and no church will ever canonize her.

I call her a saint anyway, in the only sense a floor man can confer. S…



This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit thelonggameforall.substack.com
links1

more episodes

All episodes