Skip to content
Sign in
Artwork for Strangely
Strangely · Today · 31 min

The American Idol Killer

Poppy shares the story of pastor, and one time American Idol contestant, Caleb Flynn. In 2013 he went on national US television to boast of his pretty wife and devotion to the Lord, 11 years later he was on trial for her murder. Plus Luke shares a piece of lost Oscar awards history that may have been rediscovered. Get in touch at strangely@alwaystruecrime.com New episodes every Tuesday. Got 5 mins? Fill in the Always True Crime survey for a chance to win a £100 restaurant voucher https://podcastsurvey.typeform.com/to/MMk0718T Closes 31st Oct 2026 Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

0:00-31:42
Play in

transcript

No transcript — this publisher did not publish one.

show notes

Poppy shares the story of pastor, and one time American Idol contestant, Caleb Flynn. In 2013 he went on national US television to boast of his pretty wife and devotion to the Lord, 11 years later he was on trial for her murder.


Plus Luke shares a piece of lost Oscar awards history that may have been rediscovered.


Get in touch at strangely@alwaystruecrime.com


New episodes every Tuesday.

Got 5 mins? Fill in the Always True Crime survey for a chance to win a £100 restaurant voucher https://podcastsurvey.typeform.com/to/MMk0718T Closes 31st Oct 2026

Hosted on Acast. See acast.com/privacy for more information.

links1

more episodes

All episodes