First eBay Sports Card Consign Review 🤔 The Good, The Bad & The $2,700 Truth

In this episode, I sent two massive boxes of sports cards to eBay consigner DC Sports87 (not sponsored, just honest). Did I cash in or crash out? Let’s break down my full experience — from shipping costs to which cards flopped and which surprisingly popped. I also dive into Arena Club vs Fanatics Collect and talk about the underrated power of Magic: The Gathering cards. Spoiler alert: I made $2,700, but it didn’t come easy.

Timestamps:

• 0:00 — Intro & why I used a consigner
• 1:30 — Shipping cost realities
• 2:50 — What types of cards I sent
• 4:10 — Auction process breakdown
• 5:45 — Why some sales stung 💸
• 7:00 — What actually sold well (spoiler: Magic cards!)
• 8:20 — Final profit & reflections
• 9:30 — Would I do it again?

Thanks to our monthly supporters

• Rob Hefley
• Klendathu
• Tatershed
• Justin Burch
• Always_Eaton
• Ryan Bruder
• Kevin Quiles
• Evan Hastie
• Donut
• Josh Stewart

★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★