
transcript
show notes
On the evening of May 8th, 2008, Sharon Randolph and her husband went out for dinner and a movie. Mother's Day was that Sunday. She was forty-seven years old and she loved going to the theatre.
Just after 9:30 that night, her husband called 911 and told the dispatcher that a masked intruder had shot his wife in the hallway of their home, and that he had shot the intruder five times.
When Las Vegas Metro arrived, the scene read cleanly. A dead woman. A dead man in a ski mask with a bag of jewellery beside him. A husband who had reached his gun a moment too late.
The dead man was not a stranger. He was the family handyman.
This week we go through the case of Thomas Randolph, the man the press would eventually call the Black Widower. He was married six times. Four of those wives are dead. He has been convicted of killing exactly one of them and the story of how the law handled the other three is, in some ways, more interesting than the murder.
In this episode:
- The 1986 death of Becky Gault in Utah, the half-million-dollar insurance payout, and the handyman who went to the police
- The felony Randolph pleaded guilty to while awaiting trial for her murder, and the acquittal he sealed afterwards
- Glen Morrison, who was asked to kill one of the wives and stage it as a robbery, and the reason he said no
- The forensic details that broke the 2008 story apart: the shell casings in the wrong place, the ski mask with no blood on it, and a neighbour who heard gunshots twenty minutes before anyone called
- The video walkthrough Randolph volunteered to make, and the sixteen years he has spent trying to take it back
- Why the Nevada Supreme Court threw out his conviction and death sentence in 2020, and why we think that ruling was correct
- The 2023 retrial that convicted him anyway, on much less
- The appeal the court rejected this September
Follow us on Patreon, Instagram & Facebook!


