Gary Hilton

This week on Crimes We Didn't Commit, we're heading into the woods with Gary Hilton—a man who somehow thought hiking trails were the perfect place to become one of America's most terrifying serial killers. Spoiler: they weren't. We'll unpack the crimes, the investigation, and how Hilton managed to evade capture far longer than he should have, leaving devastation across multiple states. It's a case filled with twists, evidence, and decisions that will have you asking, "Seriously...how did this happen?" Grab your coffee, lock your doors (even if you don't live near a forest), and join us as we tell the story of a killer who proved that not every trail leads somewhere beautiful. As always, we'll bring the facts, a little sarcasm to keep ourselves sane, and zero sympathy for the murderer. Listener discretion is strongly advised.