Skip to content
Artwork for Another Not Guilty
Another Not Guilty · Today · 41 min

From The Archives: A Child's Right

Public defender Annie took over a juvenile case she thought should never have been filed. Her client was 11 years old. His adoptive mother testified that she “popped him in the mouth.” He said she hit him with a closed fist, that his nose was pouring blood, and that he thought it was broken. When she came back toward him, he kicked at her from his bed, then swung and knocked her glasses off. The state charged him with felony assault with force likely to produce great bodily injury. He spent over 100 days in custody while the case was pending. At trial, he said he was scared she was going to hit him again. The commissioner sustained the petition, finding that the danger had ended when his mother left the room to get paper towels. About a year and a half later, the appellate court reversed, finding that the prosecution had not proved beyond a reasonable doubt that he wasn’t acting in self-defense. David, Nikhil, and Annie discuss the case and the challenges of defending children in juvenile court. Stay Connected & Support the Show: · Website: anothernotguiltypod.com · Apple Podcasts: Another Not Guilty · Spotify: Another Not Guilty · Follow us on Instagram: @anothernotguilty · Find us on Facebook: Another Not Guilty · Support the show (potential bonus content): Patreon

0:00-41:31

transcript

No transcript — this publisher did not publish one.

show notes

Public defender Annie took over a juvenile case she thought should never have been filed. Her client was 11 years old. His adoptive mother testified that she “popped him in the mouth.” He said she hit him with a closed fist, that his nose was pouring blood, and that he thought it was broken. When she came back toward him, he kicked at her from his bed, then swung and knocked her glasses off.

The state charged him with felony assault with force likely to produce great bodily injury. He spent over 100 days in custody while the case was pending.

At trial, he said he was scared she was going to hit him again. The commissioner sustained the petition, finding that the danger had ended when his mother left the room to get paper towels. About a year and a half later, the appellate court reversed, finding that the prosecution had not proved beyond a reasonable doubt that he wasn’t acting in self-defense.

David, Nikhil, and Annie discuss the case and the challenges of defending children in juvenile court.

Stay Connected & Support the Show:

· Website: anothernotguiltypod.com

· Apple Podcasts: Another Not Guilty

· Spotify: Another Not Guilty

· Follow us on Instagram: @anothernotguilty

· Find us on Facebook: Another Not Guilty

· Support the show (potential bonus content): Patreon

links6